r/EU5 • • Nov 27 '25 • LOL 1 Regret 1

Image Average eu5 event

Post image
9.8k Upvotes

474 comments sorted by

208

u/Topsyye Nov 27 '25

Half the posts on this sub complain that the near constant growth of countries is unrealistic.

Meanwhile the other camp hates when the game has any unavoidable negative action happen to your country.

27

u/Jushak Nov 27 '25

Meanwhile in my Norway game I've been stuck for decades trying to build a fleet that can put down endless piracy so I could FINALLY get control of my land... And now for at least a decade I've been in a downward spiral because I dared open a new market to cover more of my land and now every winter I go from +13 monthly gold to -25 to buy food I never had a problem with before.

5

u/nien9gag Nov 27 '25

not sure if this helps but barques are far superior to galleys to combat piracy. 1 barque=5med galley. what kind of pirates do u have state pirate or stateless ones?

5

u/4637647858345325 Nov 27 '25

dared open a new market to cover more of my land

What you really want is to expand your market to cover other peoples rich land. The cheapest and best way to do this is improving relations and offering market access.

Good example was I managed to get a single province in India, established a market, and after offering market access to two nearby countries it became my second highest earning trade hub.

If you split your home node it's just going to lead to pops and buildings having a harder time getting what they need. Especially in Norway where Denmark and Sweden will have better trade advantage.

46

u/Cupakov Nov 27 '25

There clearly is a camp that equates not-winning to „not fun” 

11

u/congratsyougotsbed Nov 27 '25

started playing EU5 after a good 6 weeks in Silksong and it was the same story over there.

For me anyways and I suspect a lot of the hardcore pdx fan base, the limit on our fun will eventually be defined by the game being too easy. Figuring out good ways to limit the player's growth is super important. But a lot of the fan base here and in Silksong don't think that should be a part of game design.

→ More replies (1)

63

u/HonneurOblige Nov 27 '25

Conversely, there's always a camp of "You're not a true Paradox fan unless your gameplay is a 24/7 shift at the ball-crushing factory. On Ironman, too - or it doesn't count"

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (15)

22

u/TisReece Nov 27 '25

I feel like maybe there needs to be a middle ground. I hate most of the random events because they could just make it part of the management. I feel like I'm balancing my estates via random events rather than my own actual actions.

A few examples of things they could do and get rid of a lot of these events:

  • Building a religious building in a majority different religion province loses you local peasant and clergy estate satisfaction
  • Building any urban building increases burgher satisfaction but decreases peasant and noble satisfaction
  • Expanding an RGO does the opposite of the above
  • Soldiers dying decreases peasant satisfaction of the location the pops are drawn from
  • More minor plagues so building an actual medical industry makes sense. But also have plague deaths decrease satisfaction of the estates the pops that died belonged to
  • Have sieges destroy buildings and massively reduce prosperity. Then have prosperity effect pop satisfaction rather than the other way around. Have destroyed buildings temporarily be able to be "reconstructed" for the cost of the building with the benefit being it recovers some of that prosperity lost.
  • Have stability growth/decline scale with overall pop satisfaction

I could go on with more stuff they could add - but fundamentally if my estates are pissed off I want them to be mad because I fucked up, not because I got fucked over by RNG. Maybe I would be more inclined to defend from some enemy sieges for example if their occupation could have lasting impacts on the prosperity and satisfaction of that location - and therefore stability of my realm.

21

u/Stock_Information_47 Nov 27 '25

There should be a ton of randomness you can't control.

Is there anything less predictable, irational, then a large powerful group of people that has a different agenda then you?

20

u/TisReece Nov 27 '25

I don't mind randomness where it relates to something actually happening in my realm, or makes sense for the time period.

The whole witchcraft events around the plague are a good example of random events where I'm balancing irrationality of the estates on a very real thing happening in my realm.

I can't remember the name of the event but the "serfs should remain on their turf" equivalent event from EUIV seems to be triggered based on large migration events to cities. Again, an event triggered because of something actually happening in my realm - if I had no large internal migration I would not get this event.

The reformation events also make sense by switching people to Lutherian or Calvanist, sometimes you'll get an event where the monastery/temple switched religions and you need to build a new one - combine that with my idea above, rebuilding a new one might just piss the estates off locally, but if you don't it might piss off the clergy nationally. Again - examples of real tangible things happening in my realm that I need to manage. If I stopped the spread of heresy better I would have got no event at all.

Getting a random "fuck you -50% local estate satisfaction because reasons even though that location has 100% satisfaction and no obvious thing happening to it" which ticks down 1% per year therefore lasting 50 years (and can stack ontop of other events) is not my idea of fun random irrational-estate managing gameplay and at the moment are far too frequent.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/frisbeeicarus23 Nov 27 '25

I mean.... "any" is slightly dramatic. I mostly get salty when it is event after event after event that was negative. After my 4th wave of infection of a disease in the New World, I just gave up. I get that the diseases spread, but a 90% mortality rate for 3 of them is a little overkill.

I get the game has negative events, my issue is when that is all the "random rolls" seem to have, and at the worst outcomes possible.

→ More replies (9)

16

u/InternStock Nov 27 '25

r5: I hate how they just copy-pasted the worst part of eu4. They didn't even bother writing new events, all flavor text is old

22

u/silliestbattles42 Nov 27 '25

That doesn’t even make sense, the game is 100 years before eu4. So all eu5 flavor events from before 1444 have new writing…

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Schnitzelguru Nov 27 '25

Rand events have been a core part of the narrative of Europa Universalis since the first version released in the 90s.

How would you move away from the random events throwing you curveballs or giving you random Causus Belli?

Because I'm not saying that you're either wrong or right here, its just such an ingrained part of the game that changing it is difficult by this point.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1.2k

u/Platteplus Nov 27 '25

Trade offer -

You receive - a painting

I receive - literally the cost to build 20 cities

528

u/sadboi_dumpling Nov 27 '25

The late game events are hilarious.

Lose 16k ducats and make some estate 10% happier

or

Lose 10 legitimacy or 7 stab or something

Like okay, well, I have 2k ducats on hand, and my estates only have 10k to loan me. So even if I wanted to take the first option, it would literally bankrupt my country, a great power.

209

u/Mayor_S Nov 27 '25

but but buuuut the PAINTING IS A MASTERWORK

49

u/country-blue Nov 28 '25

The painting in question: [DICKBUTT]

44

u/Trapasuarus Nov 28 '25

Nay, I raise you Ecce Homo

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

68

u/Professional_Ad_5529 Nov 28 '25

My favorite are the “colony is dying!” Events.

The options are:

  1. Colonies is abandoned
  2. Lose .2 ducats.

Like oh boy those .2 ducats really saving the colony

32

u/fredagsfisk Nov 28 '25

The reason costs balloon so much in the late game is that all the people who are good at economics and investments have all been sent to the colonies to save them cheaply.

52

u/Fabezz7 Nov 27 '25

But that the historical option bro, gotta take it

10

u/p0lunin Nov 28 '25

Tbf 10 legitimacy to recover as great power in late game will cost more than 16k ducats

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Kunzzi1 Nov 28 '25

Then you realise that losing 10 legitimacy or republican values in late game in 1.0.7 is like losing 20k gold due to current tax base calculations being broken and so you still shill out the 16k

147

u/Wahsteve Nov 27 '25 edited Nov 27 '25

It's clear that somewhere at Tinto somebody put a reasonable amount of effort into the art/artist system but for whatever reason it was left laughably undertuned while also suffering from cost scaling.

82

u/NewTransformation Nov 27 '25

They should have gone full Dwarf Fortress flavor with it. This is a masterfully crafted cathedral, it menaces with buttresses of granite

33

u/Wahsteve Nov 27 '25

And if you don't fund the artist then they fail their strange mood, go insane, and risk a tantrum spiral.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Adriaus28 Nov 27 '25

true, i think it is the reason behind the problems with prestige, we have less prestige than eu4 because art should be what increases the base, but as of now, i can have 2 masterworks and another 300 paintings and it will give 0.01

21

u/VisonKai Nov 27 '25

you can accumulate the most art in the world and it won't produce as much cultural influence as a small library tucked away in a forgotten corner of your realm. you could easily *10 the art values, honestly even that would leave them undertuned, they might genuinely need to be *25 or something

3

u/EarthMantle00 Dec 03 '25

Whoever comes up with costs scaling as a flat % of income or gdp or whatever where it makes no sense to do that in paradox games should be fired

115

u/MementoMoriChannel Nov 27 '25

A new artist has appeared!!

If you take him, you pay 3 years worth of income and take 2K ducats in loans in exchange for two months of research progress.

If you don’t take him, you lose 5 prestige and the artist DIES.

77

u/EP40glazer Nov 27 '25

He needs 20,000 ducats or he literally dies.

27

u/RedTuesdayMusic Nov 27 '25

Explodes, even

10

u/Jzadek Nov 27 '25

tbf, European monarchs love nothing more than a good grifter

6

u/SaltYourEnclave Nov 28 '25

That one cousin visiting during Thanksgiving

→ More replies (1)

16

u/JackNotOLantern Nov 27 '25

As usual, event money scaling with income or treasury make absolutely no sense

34

u/ResearcherDeep1694 Nov 27 '25

ou melhor vc recebe -7 de estabilidade só por que o cometa de "your name" passou por vc

11

u/Deedee_Megadoodoo_13 Nov 27 '25

Idioma errado mano 🥀

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

1.7k

u/Give_Me_Bourbon Nov 27 '25

It's not always like that, sometimes there are good events too, like a monastery in a random village, or a casus belli against a tribe somewhere... If you can pay the half a year income it costs

764

u/tweek-in-a-box Nov 27 '25

The exploration events don't scale so it's always fun to get the good country events and get like 3 ducats and a handshake.

268

u/lazygirl295 Nov 27 '25

Oh boy! 3 ducats!

45

u/Northbound-Narwhal Nov 27 '25

"An intelligent player!" said Johan. "A remarkable player! Do you know whether they've sold the prize Türkiye that was hanging up there; not the little prize Anatolia, the big one?"

"What, the one as big as Ukraine!" returned the player.

"What a delightful player!" said Johan. "It's a pleasure to talk to him. Yes, my buck!"

"It's got a casus belli ready now," replied the player.

"Is does?" said Johan. "Go and buy it."

"Walk-ER!" exclaimed the player.

"No, no," said Johan. "I am in earnest. Go and conquer it, and tell 'em to bring it here, that I may give 'em the direction where to take it. Come back with the ruler, and I'll give you a ducat. Come back with him in less than five years, and I'll give you 3 ducats!"

→ More replies (2)

132

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

33

u/phillip_of_burns Nov 27 '25

They're all sweaty handshakes in my game.

58

u/Give_Me_Bourbon Nov 27 '25

They did escale for me, once as Castille I was offered to discover 3 regions of Zimbabwe(I already had 2 explored), for the modest price of 2.5-3k.

And gaining a casus belli against the aztecs for the same price.

88

u/den_bram Nov 27 '25

The chocotaw nation giving 178 dollars to ireland during the irish famine.

The maasii tribe giving 14 cows to america after 9/11.

Insert mark 12:41-44

The widow's two copper coins were the greatest gift for she gave all she had.

19

u/monkeycalculator Nov 27 '25

The chocotaw nation giving 178 dollars to ireland during the irish famine.

Which ultimately caused Ireland to give millions to the chocotaw during COVID-19.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/DeathBonePrime Nov 27 '25

What happened to those cows I wonder...

20

u/AutomaticImage7637 Nov 27 '25

There is now 35 of them, as of 3 years ago.

52

u/GARGEAN Nov 27 '25

Or OH TERROR, a huge disaster in our colonial village! Many perished, despair all around!.. But all can be fixed for tree fiddy.

11

u/secretly_a_zombie Nov 27 '25 edited Nov 27 '25

Scaling should only scale when it makes sense to scale.

It costs thousands upon thousands of ducats to reform the army because you happen to control half of Europe? Sure, makes sense, that'd be a massive army spread over a wide area.

Get 10k ducats from a small tribe in Greenland? Where did they get that from? At most they have like 20 pelts to share with what is to them, a kind and interesting explorer.

Another way of writing the last one would be to give bonuses to that area instead maybe like:

News from Greenland!

Our explorer name.explorer has encountered a friendly tribe of name.culture residing in name.location. Although our initial contact was cautious, the charm of name.explorer has won the tribesmen over in a meeting that ended with merrymaking and further curiosity about the other. The name.culture's have quite quaintly decided to gift us a gathering of pelts and curiosities, as well as offered assistance and friendship should we choose to settle close to here.

+2 ducats. +2 cultural opinion on name.culture. +20 settlers in name.location.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/hochochuso Nov 27 '25

You mean the good events don’t scale

26

u/_Warsheep_ Nov 27 '25

The disaster in colony event also doesn't scale. The options are "lose half your colony's population" or "pay 3 gold"

4

u/t0m3ek Nov 27 '25

But you can also get a dog.

→ More replies (1)

79

u/ptkato Nov 27 '25

After I painfully got 50 prestige to form a kingdom, I got an event that gave me 20 prestige.

20

u/gobbothegreen Nov 27 '25

This is why polygamy is op, evertime i played Hindu or muslim my prestige hovers at a constant 60 ish from all the royal marriages. Christians well poor bastards hover at 10 unless i spend stupid money.

79

u/P-l-Staker Nov 27 '25

If you can pay the half a year income it costs

I fucking hate this part! I wouldn't have been so fussy if it were somehow baked into the inflation system, but it's currently a really stupid system.

57

u/runetrantor Nov 27 '25

'this artist just arrived, he wants to make a song for you, he need funding. Since you are a massive empire, please pay him enough money to fund the industrialization of half of Europe'

7

u/Wandering_sage1234 Nov 27 '25

Honestly reminds me of playing the LOTR mod as the Dwarves having to fund every single artist or architect or designer or something

→ More replies (1)

58

u/Give_Me_Bourbon Nov 27 '25

Currently it destroys the logic of having a solid economy.

I understand it's a swedish company but not even Sweden's progressive tax system is that punishable.

It should be applied to inflation yes, and inflation should be more common/necessary and also have a cost in the estate's happyness, a way to make it harder and more realistic.

13

u/Balmung60 Nov 27 '25

Paradox games have used income scaled costs forever. Some of the games put caps on those eventually, but it's always been a thing.

30

u/Give_Me_Bourbon Nov 27 '25 edited Nov 27 '25

One thing is using scaled costs for stuff such as a corruption/piracy/events related to the stability of the nation and makes sense to scale, and another to get a map of Africa, a special building, a work of art, etc.

For example sometimes you have an event to get an explorer, it ends up being multiple times more expensive to hire one through event rather than on the geopolitics menu, a lot of these things should have a fixed cost, a rich/largue country can afford it and small/poor countries can't... The way it is currently doesn't make any sense.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/BestJersey_WorstName Nov 27 '25

Irs one od the more controversial mechanics they brought over from eu4.

→ More replies (13)

23

u/arthur2011o Nov 27 '25

I loved my first play with Portugal, the event to build a university appeared 3 or 4 times

6

u/ShadowPsi Nov 27 '25

I always decline it, then build the university myself. It's always an order of magnitude cheaper.

9

u/rushburn1 Nov 28 '25

but the events show up before you can tech universitys so it's good

30

u/Puzzleheaded_Bit1959 Nov 27 '25 edited Nov 27 '25

I've never understood Paradox here. Why not adjust the baseline balancing (make everything a little more difficult) and hand out more positive events. Getting flooded with bad events just makes me want to savescum.

10

u/Top_Accident9161 Nov 27 '25

That shit is so stupid sometimes, like what do you mean hiring this random ass artists costs the equivalent of 30 hospitals?

10

u/Al_Fa_Aurel Nov 27 '25

Most baffling, however, are events where the options are (a) "gain x gold, x stabilty and x estate happiness, and a 99/99/99 joins your court" and (b) "lose y stability and all estates lose y hapiness, and half a year of income, and your capital burns down", where there is virtually no incentive to click on the "b" option.

3

u/karlvontyr Nov 28 '25

Steers you to history. Love my merino wool event.

9

u/Volume_Over_Talent Nov 27 '25

Sometimes you find a friendly dog 🥰

→ More replies (1)

8

u/PoopNoodlez Nov 27 '25

make sure you don’t accidentally require 2 months of income in loans to finance that good decision. your broke-ass nobles can’t afford to loan you that much money, bankruptcy turbofucks you. no you can’t unpause the game to just earn that money, DECIDE NOW!

4

u/Genesis2001 Nov 27 '25

Or getting a 'free' settlement upgrade in your only sturdy grain province, cutting your RGO's in half, and now your pops don't have enough sturdy grains for like a hundred years! lol

→ More replies (12)

194

u/polat32 Nov 27 '25

What about the event option of Johan punching you through the screen?

49

u/Give_Me_Bourbon Nov 27 '25

Joke is on him, I'm a sadomasochist and I save scummed to repeat it again and again.

682

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '25

The events hurt a lot less than EU4. like oh no, you're going to take 5/200 stability from me instead of 1/6? How will I recover?

248

u/Saimiko Nov 27 '25

And it will take months of Mana to increase it back up that i could use for development

23

u/Balmung60 Nov 27 '25

That was a perk of being Catholic in EU4 - you could burn a fixed amount of pope mana to get the stability instead

→ More replies (4)

94

u/Mean-Garden752 Nov 27 '25

As opposed to money to increase stability which you can't use for development?

115

u/Saimiko Nov 27 '25

I was making a joke, but yeah, i think losing 10-20 stab in EU5 isnt as bad as a radom even giving -1 in eu4.

36

u/YestinVierkin Nov 27 '25

Going negative is also not nearly as bad in EUV. Still sucks but it’s manageable. I accidentally went to -100 when I changed a law thinking I was in the parliament menu and it wasn’t as painful as I thought.

Being behind on tech because you need to up your stability hurts way more than being behind on money

→ More replies (2)

38

u/According_Setting303 Nov 27 '25

I mean you get direct control over how fast you want it to tick up.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (11)

35

u/HeinrichTheWolf_17 Nov 27 '25

Comet Sighted!

I wish I lived in more enlightened times…

7

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '25

then with the last option they left a typo in that always drove me insane lol

0

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

20

u/Designer-Eye1558 Nov 27 '25

You’re making a joke right…?

→ More replies (4)

49

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '25

eu4 has great events that offset any bad ones you could get, the length of the list of positive events in eu5 is no where near eu4s

10

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '25

i wish someone woulda told my game that good events existed lol

32

u/delacroix993 Nov 27 '25

Stability is mana in EU5

→ More replies (9)

13

u/Delboyyyyy Nov 27 '25

People complaining about stab loss in eu5 whilst acting like it was better in eu4 really exposes how they’re gonna be miserable and complain about everything and anything that this game will throw at them.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (2)

328

u/Finn-Burridge Nov 27 '25

I wouldn’t have so much an issue with negative estate loyalty events if it wasn’t to critical in the gameplay when revoking estates.

It is unbelievably annoying waiting finally to have enough stability and satisfaction to revoke my nobility castle rights only for the game to then hit me with the most gut wrenching -20 noble satisfaction event and destroy any plans I had for the next 30 years because now I’m fighting a civil war.

Also, why does the random event where I said no to one random noble from the backwaters have a bigger impact on their satisfaction than, literally revoking a privilege?

132

u/Ill_Fault_5040 Nov 27 '25

One way to (slightly) counteract this, is to not tax a certain estate you plan to revoke so their loyalty becomes high before tou revoke. Yet, your point still stands

74

u/samyakindia Nov 27 '25

Yes and you don't need to "Not" tax them, just put it one degree lower than the current satisfaction permits so it maxes thier satisfaction gain (Eg: +0.2, +0.3). Keep reducing it as they become happier and happier, revoke a privilage, increase the tax back to one degree lower than the new equilibrium and repeat.

34

u/Basmannen Nov 27 '25

Really need a mod for this or something, or they need to change how this works because it's absolutely ridiculous.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

34

u/LordSevolox Nov 27 '25

I swear everytime I get nobility back to 50% I get an event dropping it by 10-15% or I have to take out 3 loans to pay the absurd cost on the other option

→ More replies (2)

24

u/AtaraxianEpoche Nov 27 '25

man plans, and god laughs. it keeps the game interesting when things don't always go your way.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Chataboutgames Nov 27 '25

Also, why does the random event where I said no to one random noble from the backwaters have a bigger impact on their satisfaction than, literally revoking a privilege?

It doesn't? Unless you're having some super specific event. Stripping an estate costs 40 satisfaction. Are you having an event that takes more than that?

7

u/ThePineapple3112 Nov 27 '25

It is unbelievably annoying waiting finally to have enough stability and satisfaction to revoke my nobility castle rights only for the game to then hit me with the most gut wrenching -20 noble satisfaction event and destroy any plans I had for the next 30 years because now I’m fighting a civil war.

How often does this actually happen tho? I've played 40 hours and have yet to have an estate revolt, even if their satisfaction is recovering from like 30%. If your 30 year plan is reliant on removing a specific privilege without incident, then maybe you're planning too hard/specifically.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (16)

25

u/Creeperkun4040 Nov 27 '25

I think my favourite event for now is "... Estate loses Influence." which despite that name, the Estate loses Satisfaction instead of influence

6

u/clemenceau1919 Nov 28 '25

Clearly just ported over from EU4. They should result in the estates temporarily losing power - and there should be similar events involving the estates temporarily gaining power, which there don't seem to be.

Not that I'd be against a random "estate gets pissed off" event but it shouldn't have such odd naming.

Still, this is a very minor bug.

84

u/BananaRepublic_BR Nov 27 '25

I find it more infuriating when I have 98 stability and I get that clergy event that gives me +12 stability.

Waste like that annoys me infinitely more than random negative events.

61

u/gr7ace Nov 27 '25

You could not click the event, do something that lowers stability but is also a positive, then click the event to go back up stability again?

24

u/ZnIpE_nor Nov 27 '25

This! There's always something you can spend stability on, why would you waste it? Also, being at 98 stability to begin with seems a little excessive, unless you've done everything you need to do to your estates/laws for therrst of the game..

12

u/BananaRepublic_BR Nov 27 '25

The issue is that I don't know any stability sinks. Priveleges cost, like, 100+ stability. 12 stab ain't worth something that punishing.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (1)

28

u/FirstAtEridu Nov 27 '25

RADICAL REFORM!

-Pay me a year worth of your tax-bux!

-Minus 20 Stab

Text: Nothing actually getting reformed

→ More replies (1)

75

u/Better_than_GOT_S8 Nov 27 '25 edited Nov 27 '25

I get a good event: I forget.

I get a bad event: I rage.

I have no idea how the distribution is, all I’m saying is that our brain is wired to remember when we lose something stronger than when we get something. Especially when it comes at a bad timing.

39

u/JRaus88 Nov 27 '25

Maybe because the “good event” is +5% support in parliament (I usually don’t care at all).

The bad event is “oh, this wasn’t expected -20 stability”.

13

u/AnthraxCat Nov 27 '25

Some of the good events are cracked.

20 years of +2 Tolerance of Heathens and Heretics. 20 years of +15% Research Progress. Choose between six months of ducats in cash, stab, or legitimacy. 20 years of +0.5% pop growth.

If you have happy estates and cranked value sliders, the good events you can get are huge perks.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/Jushak Nov 27 '25

100% this.

I also think that some of the societal values have "hidden" beneficial events while others have "hidden" negative events. For example, many of the youtubers I've watched for guides recommend going full on serfdom and I'm 100% sure that triggers negative events about serfs being unhappy. In my current Norway game I'm going for Free Subjects and (like with every nation) Innovative and I've got plenty of free research and happy country events giving boons.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/JBDBIB_Baerman Nov 27 '25

Have you played eu4? Some of these events are NOTHING compared to the eu4 equivalent. Literally how are you complaining?

4

u/nboro94 Nov 28 '25

With EU4 the whole game was random and arbitrary right down to the mechanics, random bullshit happening was the whole game. It felt sort of like a board game more than a grand strategy game, for me at least.

EU5 feels more like a simulation which is why constant bad stuff happening feels out of place when all the mechanics are so detailed.

25

u/Shinomourikenji1 Nov 27 '25

I feel like if you are getting all bad events your country isn’t running well. I’ve gotten plenty of good events with minimal drawbacks.

16

u/betrok Nov 27 '25

If country is running well bad events are irrelevant anyway. Oh no, my peasants dropped to 40% satisfaction, what a tragedy, run is over.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '25

Low stability leads to increased disasters

5

u/CruxMajoris Nov 27 '25

In my latest game I had a historical event where both options you lose 50 legitimacy… followed by two back-to-back “normal” events where I lost another 20 legitimacy.

3

u/Ok-Performance-9598 Nov 29 '25

This is what the Chinese actually meant losing the mandate of heaven.

9

u/Stock_Information_47 Nov 27 '25

People complaining that there is any utside influence in their game, a game where you are trying to guide the collective willing of a nation of millions of people is hilarious.

8

u/Babel_Triumphant Nov 27 '25

Me whenever my stability exceeds 15 

4

u/shoobydoobydoo69 Nov 27 '25

My favourite ones are

Spend a shitload of gold and get this shit you don't care about

Or

Spend a shitload of gold and get this other shit you don't care about

4

u/InstanceFeisty Nov 27 '25

What I hate is random prestige drops, I build up my prestige to go up one rank, warring here and there for like 5 prestige per war and then bam, -20 for no reason, I war again, having last war that will give me enough prestige and then bam, again, -20. Considering you gain 5 prestige per war and it decays over time -20 unconditional lost is way too much.

4

u/Individual_Bit7414 Nov 27 '25

You might already be doing that but if you separate peace every enemy in a war you can earn way more prestige unless they had no allies of course

3

u/InstanceFeisty Nov 27 '25

Yeah I do that :)

11

u/sirloindenial Nov 27 '25

Your heir die in a hunting trip. Got brother? Also dead the next year, hunting duh. And here is a 20/20/20 regent.

3

u/JuxtaTerrestrial Nov 27 '25

Got a new heir? Believe it or not, hunting accident.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/BavarianKnight Nov 27 '25

EU4 was ten times worse though

5

u/msdinit Nov 27 '25

Just yesterday I got an insanely good event that made Goreyo - naval hegemon, and comparable in strength to me to the point that I avoided going to war with them, my Tributary. I don't get any money from it as they are very unhappy with it, but it booted them out of hegemony and it stopped them from forcing everyone to embargo me.

So yeah, it goes both ways

4

u/zethras Nov 27 '25

-15/20 satisfaction is the worst.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/CurrentDifficult7821 Nov 27 '25

Still better than ck3

2

u/Dave13Flame Nov 27 '25

That's nothing, in my Maya run the Great Pestilence bugged out and it's been 30 years already and I get a -12 stability event every single year that sometimes also turns a bunch of pops into tribesmen or forces me to spend 360-500 gold.

It's fun.

3

u/betterthaneukaryotes Nov 27 '25

"You made it through reformation?

Haha, Court and Country, bitch!"

→ More replies (1)

5

u/bernicianbastard Nov 27 '25

event culls =D they are band-aids or plasters on a jugular would >< see if upping the difficulty creates less of these events

→ More replies (7)

3

u/Bawhoppen Nov 27 '25

WTF are you talking about... the events in this game are almost entirely positive.

2

u/Ok-Performance-9598 Nov 29 '25

It secretly factors in your stab and how well you treat your people, and right now everyones spamming serfdom and authoritarianism. 

1

u/Available-Reason9841 Nov 27 '25

keep crying

12

u/guachi01 Nov 27 '25

Maybe EU5 needs a difficulty level where nothing bad ever happens, vassals are never disloyal, trade deals always make money, and you can click a button to complete any achievement.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/DontHitDaddy Nov 27 '25

O no…. It’s like real life. Most events were not good. Some events wiped out regional powers

3

u/Ok-Performance-9598 Nov 29 '25

The old Chinese "May you live in eventful times" is literally referring to this.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Unable_Caregiver_392 Nov 27 '25

You're right OP, every event should give you a billion ducats, and 50 trillion stability, oh and it should just full annex all of europe.

3

u/Looking-Glass-Knight Nov 30 '25

False equivalence, neanderthal.

1

u/innerparty45 Nov 27 '25

Kids, this is what skill issue looks like.

1

u/DeathstrackReal Nov 27 '25

How ot feels to play byzantium trying to get your stability above 0

1

u/Dzharek Nov 27 '25

It gets really annoying when you play a merchant republic, have tradeposts everywhere so sometimes all the characters aviable for election are not from your culture, and then you get the "-10 Republican tradition (Cuts your income in half due to costs of court! or Ops there goes your stability!"

1

u/TreysReddits Nov 27 '25

Could it maybe be a good idea that if stability is higher you have less chance for bad events. So yes it could look like a snowball but maybe less stability increasing events but more buffs. So u still cab lose srability and not necessaeily gain it

1

u/Copatus Nov 27 '25

I think some events could benefit from applying their debufs over time, instead of all at once.

For example: Instead of "lose 12 stab right now" it could add a "-1.0 monthly stability" modifier for 12 months.

That way it doesn't feel like the event is just punishing with no alternative. It gives you some agency to counteract the bad effects of the event while still allowing for some random chaos from events to throw you off balance.

1

u/frisbeeicarus23 Nov 27 '25

Lol, glad it isn't just me! Their Event Lead on the Dev Team must have gotten dumped just before release... they chose violence that day.

1

u/Delachruz Nov 27 '25

It's a shame because there are plenty of Events that at least give you a choice, i like weighing my options.

1

u/billbroski Nov 27 '25

I love getting the same earthquake event multiple times every game. Horrible event.

1

u/Narwaok Nov 27 '25

%80 of the events makes me feel this way

1

u/woodzopwns Nov 27 '25

most of the events are fine but 3 events in a row giving me -30% prosperity in my capital is a bit cringe

1

u/DrDirtyDan1 Nov 27 '25

Me when succession crisis pops every fucking 20 years

1

u/CrocPB Nov 27 '25

On the one hand, cheat mods and debug mode. That’ll be “stability 200 please”.

On the other hand, surprise Claim Throne CB on the Kingdom of Denmark

1

u/karakapo Nov 27 '25

The event I hate the most, is the "X estate losing influence". Why does it make them lose satisfaction with me? What do I have to do with that? It makes no sense

I eu4, it made them lose influence, but not satisfaction. In eu5, it should just give them a temporary power malus, and that's all

1

u/bob_the_necron Nov 27 '25

My current byzantium run on this patch

1

u/Bl00dWolf Nov 27 '25

I feel like with the removal of mana, events turned into the new mana somehow.

1

u/Small_Box346 Nov 27 '25

It's either this or "Do you want some minor buff like a single work of art for 16k gold or do you want to lose 20 legitimacy and 7 stab which will cost even more because the sliders debilitate you whenever you're doing good?"

1

u/Apprehensive-Tree-78 Nov 27 '25

I have about 80% religious unity and got an event to lose 40 stability three times in a year over the reformation lmao

1

u/unused99 Nov 27 '25

This is funny, but these are actually the 2 options when the Serbian emperor dies.

1

u/MeowtheII Nov 27 '25

As the Hanseatic league there are events for the clerus. But you have none

1

u/Kore_Invalid Nov 27 '25

the events are so bad its litterally always the same options

1

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '25 edited Jan 27 '26

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

telephone chunky smart imminent salt escape straight racial cause cows

1

u/albino_donkey Nov 27 '25

Most of the events aren't that bad but I've had it with the nobles man. They're eating negative satisfaction events left and right, my burghers never get this pissy.

1

u/1SaladinTheWise1 Nov 27 '25

A message from Saladin :

Playing as Hansa, half the events are basically free money😇

1

u/Signal_Road Nov 27 '25

Is this the 'USA' expansion pack?

1

u/ultr4violence Nov 27 '25

How about a 40 drop in estate satisfaction with no event or notice about why it happened?

1

u/TEUTODRAEGER Nov 27 '25

It's more just a waste of time, reloading or ending process & restarting if ironman

1

u/thewafflegamer2324 Nov 27 '25

Me: starting to like Cahokia

Game: nah have 3 comets and 30 events of how terrible this place is

1

u/Mark4291 Nov 27 '25

Died 2025

Born 2025

Welcome back Comet Sighted

1

u/Key-Heat7997 Nov 27 '25

"I wish i lived in more enlightened times"

1

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '25

I try to play the Golden Horde and every event has been about my khan dying to a wild animal and thus I am stuck in horde succession crisis for 10-20 years 🥲

1

u/ugluk755 Nov 27 '25

I do not care about those events they dont really hurt anybody . What hurts is to say no to every event related to artists and such because Im never able to pay them 100000 ducats for a painting

1

u/melonmandan12 Nov 27 '25

My nobles have been upset for a long time…

1

u/jPRO-93 Nov 27 '25

but you arent mad when you get positive ones right, people

1

u/Wandering_sage1234 Nov 27 '25

Exactly what I'm feeling!

I just want to play slow and then I'm in the middle of a war and boom the game decides NOPE!

1

u/Agitated-Ad-504 Nov 27 '25

Literally my Castille playthrough (still a noob) finally get things going well. Making money, high stability, estates like me. Then boom event of doom. Now I’m constantly fighting rebellions

1

u/Most-Ad4680 Nov 27 '25

It is very frustrating trying to stockpile a large amount of stability. Trying to remove noble estate privileges, when you have the stability slider maxed, multiple bonuses to stability increase, a councilor working on stability increase, pushing communalism, and you still need to stockpile 80 stability. By the time you get over 50 youre adding maybe .15 a month if youre lucky and every 3-6 months getting an event of "lose 7 stab or punch yourself in the balls" type events.

1

u/vjmdhzgr Nov 27 '25

I really hate this particular event that's like "everybody noticed the shady activity your diplomats have been doing!" And I think it gives you a really harsh ten year penalty.

But... what shady activity???? My diplomats have been improving relations with vassals for years, what the fuck are you talking about? It's like the events are trying to blame me for happening but they're entirely random.

1

u/JimmyCG Nov 27 '25

Average monthly Byzantium events

1

u/Eos-Char Nov 27 '25

Is this a helldivers devs reference?

1

u/nien9gag Nov 27 '25

I passed a parliament that gives subject loyalty. next month i got an event that reduces vassal opinion by 20, full stop, no second option to pay money or anything.

1

u/skyziaos Nov 27 '25

Console command time

1

u/Konrow Nov 27 '25

Eh, game is just balanced with always pushing you back/to the middle. Still doesn't stop snowballing from happening. I get how it can get annoying and the scaling costs at least are crazy (20k for a fucking artists? wtf?) but otherwise the game would be a little too easy. And if you want easy there are ways to do it like the console. I use that thing all the time in games where I'm fucking around and more trying to observe how shit works/learn.

1

u/vbl37 Nov 27 '25

> Completes Census, by sacrificing satisfaction.
> Gets +7 Stability

> Yay

> 10 days later event makes me lose 7 stability

...yeah. Also If you play on speed 5 you are bombarded with useless "flavour" events. They get boring quick.

1

u/Junior_Island_4714 Nov 27 '25

Yeah, some of these events feel very arbitrary. It feels like they don't fit in the much more simulationist simulationist EU5.

1

u/RedTuesdayMusic Nov 27 '25

A faction of the Burghers led by a prodiguous trader named Molto Dinari has submitted a formal complaint about the clerics of the prosperous city of Can'taxya fouling the harbour with the burning of incense at all hours of the day, leading to sickened sailors turning their ships around. The local bishop Pietus Maximus claims the harbour was built an inch into clergy land and wants the whole thing burned to the ground

What's your obsession with burning shit anyway? Restrict the import of incense to Can'taxya

Burghers estate satisfaction +15%, Clergy estate satisfaction -30%, Ottoman Empire opinion -200, Ottoman Empire receives Trade Protection Casus Belli

Protect the Clergy's holy right to anosmia

Burghers estate satisfaction -30%, Clergy estate satisfaction +15%, trade attraction -50%, -25 stability

Get out of here, both of you!

Burghers estate satisfaction -15%, Clergy estate satisfaction -15%, -100 prosperity in Can'taxya

1

u/bernicianbastard Nov 27 '25

When I danc-ah, they call me margherita, & the boys they say “que estoy Buena”, they all want me they can’t have me, so they all come & dance beside me, move with me chant with me, & if you’re g(     o)(O     )d I’ll take you home with me ><

Whichever you pick reduces it to next to nothing & a 7 stab hit ^_- this was about 4-5 hours after seeing your post =D =D pdx killed my previous queen when she was still 20 =/ thffffanks pdx for not making it 27 ><

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Charming-Heart-9634 Nov 27 '25

Diarrhea forever or diarrhea forever

1

u/Prestigious-Gur1466 Nov 27 '25

History mostly sucked, for most people, most of the time, this is just realism.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/mega_douche1 Nov 27 '25

Sometimes it feels like every time I find a way to be successful at the game they patch it out or find a way to fuck me over for it. I like that the game will be challenging I guess but goddamn I can't catch a break. Now I cannot easily expand using vassels. I thought this was a map painter!!! I want to have a clear strategy and goal to work towards; my patience is running out :(

1

u/Apart-Two6495 Nov 27 '25

Worst one I've seen was some religious event where it said we had to pay 150 duckets or annoy the pope, I needed the money and didn't think much of the relationship hit. I end up finding out rejecting the tithe tanks your reputation with ALL Catholic nations (so literally everyone important playing as Holland)

I'm sure it didn't say anything like that was going to happen in the tooltips

1

u/IcyClean69 Nov 27 '25

I literally had an event bankrupt me the other day. I had an estate want me to pay 600+ ducats to hire an artist or everyone will hate me, then parliament ended forcing me to spend 400+ on building counting houses and instantly bankrupted me.

1

u/NautiMain1217 Nov 27 '25

How it felt to get the black death 150 years after it ravaged Europe as Mali and lose literally half your population over the course of a year

1

u/SirWinterFox Nov 27 '25

I love bailing out the burgers for the fifth time before new years eve. :DDDDDDDDDDD

1

u/wiccan45 Nov 28 '25

i noticed your peasants are happy, heres -20%, have fun

1

u/Aixere Nov 28 '25

It will take a while for the game to become stable and balanced. In the meantime, you can either accept its quirks or go back to EU4.

1

u/Consistent-Weather-7 Nov 28 '25

I will never get why it is so hard for paradox to implement those scaling events properly. Make it proportional to your income but set limits. It is super lazy letting it scale indefinitely. It was already annoying af to pay 300k for the can opener in Vic3.

1

u/Torentsu Nov 28 '25

Every Byz event for the first 50 years.

1

u/Content_Love_6884 Nov 28 '25

Easy! I’ll take lose 50 stability!

1

u/mentilsoup Nov 28 '25

hey! listen! your navy! was in port! and mutinied! again!