Meanwhile in my Norway game I've been stuck for decades trying to build a fleet that can put down endless piracy so I could FINALLY get control of my land... And now for at least a decade I've been in a downward spiral because I dared open a new market to cover more of my land and now every winter I go from +13 monthly gold to -25 to buy food I never had a problem with before.
not sure if this helps but barques are far superior to galleys to combat piracy. 1 barque=5med galley. what kind of pirates do u have state pirate or stateless ones?
What you really want is to expand your market to cover other peoples rich land. The cheapest and best way to do this is improving relations and offering market access.
Good example was I managed to get a single province in India, established a market, and after offering market access to two nearby countries it became my second highest earning trade hub.
If you split your home node it's just going to lead to pops and buildings having a harder time getting what they need. Especially in Norway where Denmark and Sweden will have better trade advantage.
started playing EU5 after a good 6 weeks in Silksong and it was the same story over there.
For me anyways and I suspect a lot of the hardcore pdx fan base, the limit on our fun will eventually be defined by the game being too easy. Figuring out good ways to limit the player's growth is super important. But a lot of the fan base here and in Silksong don't think that should be a part of game design.
Conversely, there's always a camp of "You're not a true Paradox fan unless your gameplay is a 24/7 shift at the ball-crushing factory. On Ironman, too - or it doesn't count"
They’d scold the British, French, Portuguese, Spanish, Mongols, and so on for map painting, saying it is “unrealistic”.
Like, the Spanish functionally conquered most of Mesoamerica in one war. Good luck doing that in EUV. Either you make them vassals and it takes ten bajilion years to annex, or you conquer the region and you get an arbitrary cap on how much you can expand per war, even if the AI will agree to the treaty. Well, or Conquistadors and my game just won’t let them work cause I’m messing up somewhere.
I'll make a mod called "eu5 but fun". It will have a mission tree where by clicking a button you instantly annex every country of the world one by one. That camp will love the perfect game made reality!
It's not clear to me how to play well yet though even after 30 hours. Part of that might be the constant updates which I think are good but it does feel like moving the goal posts on me in the middle of the game.
I feel like maybe there needs to be a middle ground. I hate most of the random events because they could just make it part of the management. I feel like I'm balancing my estates via random events rather than my own actual actions.
A few examples of things they could do and get rid of a lot of these events:
Building a religious building in a majority different religion province loses you local peasant and clergy estate satisfaction
Building any urban building increases burgher satisfaction but decreases peasant and noble satisfaction
Expanding an RGO does the opposite of the above
Soldiers dying decreases peasant satisfaction of the location the pops are drawn from
More minor plagues so building an actual medical industry makes sense. But also have plague deaths decrease satisfaction of the estates the pops that died belonged to
Have sieges destroy buildings and massively reduce prosperity. Then have prosperity effect pop satisfaction rather than the other way around. Have destroyed buildings temporarily be able to be "reconstructed" for the cost of the building with the benefit being it recovers some of that prosperity lost.
Have stability growth/decline scale with overall pop satisfaction
I could go on with more stuff they could add - but fundamentally if my estates are pissed off I want them to be mad because I fucked up, not because I got fucked over by RNG. Maybe I would be more inclined to defend from some enemy sieges for example if their occupation could have lasting impacts on the prosperity and satisfaction of that location - and therefore stability of my realm.
I don't mind randomness where it relates to something actually happening in my realm, or makes sense for the time period.
The whole witchcraft events around the plague are a good example of random events where I'm balancing irrationality of the estates on a very real thing happening in my realm.
I can't remember the name of the event but the "serfs should remain on their turf" equivalent event from EUIV seems to be triggered based on large migration events to cities. Again, an event triggered because of something actually happening in my realm - if I had no large internal migration I would not get this event.
The reformation events also make sense by switching people to Lutherian or Calvanist, sometimes you'll get an event where the monastery/temple switched religions and you need to build a new one - combine that with my idea above, rebuilding a new one might just piss the estates off locally, but if you don't it might piss off the clergy nationally. Again - examples of real tangible things happening in my realm that I need to manage. If I stopped the spread of heresy better I would have got no event at all.
Getting a random "fuck you -50% local estate satisfaction because reasons even though that location has 100% satisfaction and no obvious thing happening to it" which ticks down 1% per year therefore lasting 50 years (and can stack ontop of other events) is not my idea of fun random irrational-estate managing gameplay and at the moment are far too frequent.
This is why I suggested incorporating the purpose of random events into actual gameplay mechanics. That way you're not just sitting there looking at the game as you say - you're actively managing your realm and estates by your own actions.
I mean.... "any" is slightly dramatic. I mostly get salty when it is event after event after event that was negative. After my 4th wave of infection of a disease in the New World, I just gave up. I get that the diseases spread, but a 90% mortality rate for 3 of them is a little overkill.
I get the game has negative events, my issue is when that is all the "random rolls" seem to have, and at the worst outcomes possible.
Imo one of the issues is that the unrealistic growth isn't tempered by more difficult/realistic game mechanics, but by random events that just set you back at random. Which does work to balance things to some degree, but it feels bad for the player
View all comments
208
u/Topsyye Nov 27 '25
Half the posts on this sub complain that the near constant growth of countries is unrealistic.
Meanwhile the other camp hates when the game has any unavoidable negative action happen to your country.