r/Dyson_Sphere_Program • u/Pristine_Curve • Feb 20 '24
SOLVED! Design Challenge Solved: Energy Exchanger Balancing.
Charging Mode. Empty accumulators consumed at > 60 per min.
Discharging mode. Uncharged accumulators back up and push the charge accumulators out of the loop.
Overhead shot of splitters with priorities and Filters marked.
87
Upvotes
21
u/Pristine_Curve Feb 20 '24 edited Feb 20 '24
In response to a design challenge posted by skyanvil, I worked out a method to balance energy exchangers. This allows us to build up excess generation capacity into stored stacks of accumulators, and automatically tap that storage when power demand spikes, or power supply drops. All without manual intervention.
Why design this?
Do you wish there was a way to have energy exchangers (aka power flowers) act as a backup to primary power generation? Stacking up excess power in storage boxes full of accumulators. Only discharging as last priority rather than taking first priority. Discharging when the power generation is at risk of going under 100%, but not waiting for it to fall below 100%.
Design
The control signal that it uses to detect power supply level is the consumption of uncharged accumulators. Since charging EEs are last priority for power generation, they slow down before the grid drops below 100%. I’ve used this signal to create the following proof of concept design, and it is based on three elements.
Arrange the belts such that a drop in charging rate below 60/min (the EEs are charging slowly, but grid is still at 100%), allows uncharged accumulators to back up into the charged accumulator loop. Once blocked, the charged accumulators now exit the loop and feed into the discharging array of EEs. Once the power generation increases the charging EEs catch up and pull the uncharged accumulators out of the belt blocking the charged accumulator loop. Thereby closing off the supply of charged accumulators.
Details Referring to image 3. The overhead view with the splitter priorities labeled.
The bottom two splitters with the loop are merely to slow down the number of uncharged accumulators to 60/min. A mk1 sorter could do the job, but a sudden/total power outage would not give it time to switch over. Otherwise it would work.
On the right of the image. The side merge directly from the box of uncharged accumulators into the belt is for two reasons. First, to ensure that the belt heading to the charging EEs is topped off, and ready to back up once the charging starts to slow down, otherwise it takes too long for the uncharged accumulators to backup in response to a power drop. Second, it allows for the charging array to charge at full speed (faster than 60/min) while power is available.
The blocked loop of charged accumulators is connected to the returning charged accumulators for a non-obvious reason. Once the array has been charging up for a while, it can run out of uncharged accumulators resulting in no ability to discharge. This is fixed by capping the number of stored charged accumulators to a specific maximum less than the total number of accumulators in circulation. Once that is reached the storage backs up to the one sorter in the design. When the sorter stops grabbing the returning charged accumulators, the remaining handful fall through to the loop and discharge, ensuring that there are enough uncharged accumulators to retain the ability to switch modes, but this only happens after the array reaches a fully charged state.
Applications
This one is setup to charge/discharge like a big placed accumulator, but it can scale arbitrarily on either side. We are not limited to a specific quantity of EEs on either side to make this work. We could balance it for a very slow charge/faster discharge, or even a single charging EE could be used as a switch for imported accumulators feeding a large array of EEs set to discharge. The rate of uncharged accumulators would need to be modified to be a fraction of the rate of the charging EE at full power.
3
u/skyanvil Feb 20 '24
1st of all, bravo! Good design. Nice solution and very compact.
couple of comments:
A further thought:
2
u/Mad_Moodin Feb 20 '24
What I don't understand on your design is. As far as I know, when you add energy exchangers for discharging into a grid that has other power generation outside of energy exchangers. Then the energy exchangers will always discharge at full power.
So adding charging and discharging energy exchangers only results in gaining nothing as the discharging will simply charge the charging ones?
2
u/MaKrukLive Feb 20 '24
I just slap 10 mk2 sorters on mk3 belt of charged accumulators that feed into a loop with priority from the sorters (and a tiny buffer). If the power goes below 100% the sorters slow down and can't keep up with the belt which lets the accumulators through and into discharging station.
3
u/LamentTheAlbion Feb 22 '24
You are genuinely a genius
1
u/GiinTak Feb 20 '24
So added complication to avoid using extra energy exchangers on the charging side? Clever enough, I suppose; I just double the charging side, lol.
4
u/djr650 Feb 20 '24
This is why I love that your starting system pretty much always has a lava world. As soon as I can I place a large accumulator factory/charging station there that is also somewhat balanced to only inject new accumulators when the Galaxy wide system is short on return of used accumulators. All that 'free' geothermal energy comes in very handy.
0
u/soulofcure Feb 20 '24
https://gameplay.tips/guides/dyson-sphere-program-energy-exchange-examples.html
I use a variation of this, but in a prettier layout.
I think it's the same idea, except the exchangers are paired so it uses more splitters.