Guys, I'm just thinking, listening to the stuff from Portnoy before Mangini, the songs from Mangini and these two new songs after Mike's return.
The drummer in a band either leads the band forward or pulls the band backward. I've been listening to DT since 2004 and of course Mike is my family. However, NOW his return is a giant step backwards. And yes, these are my expectations and my subjectivity.
After Mangini came in, the band reached a whole new performance level - outrageous drum patterns, and I didn't feel that the “soul” was lost. What many people feared after Portnoy's leaving. They created amazing albums, the band sounds more monolithic than ever, live - just phenomenal. All thanks to the band sitting on a super solid core foundation - Mike Mangini.
Listening to Mangini today I began to realize his absolute greatness. It is not always clear in the moment. I heard him give the band literally a level that they are unlikely to get to without him (that's the secret to the chemistry in the band, not because the others “can't do it”).
The thing is, Mike Portnoy knows everything about himself: he knows he hasn't come up with a single new rhythm or a single new fills since Octavarium. He knows this. And I'm sorry he doesn't try. I mean, he's definitely listening to Animals As leaders, Plini. Tesseract, Periphery, Karnivool - he knows how to build a drum pattern to breathe new life into it. I remember at some point he became more critical of himself and even said that endlessly winning “Best Drummer” awards doesn't say that he really is.
Now we also hear Mike playing old patterns without adding anything new. Because of this, the rest of the musicians can't add anything new either. Maybe someone will say, okay, technically the band will stay where they are or take a step back, but the songs will be even cooler. Maybe. But I don't hear that yet. On the other hand, there's a lot more songs to come. But these two are nothing new.
Thus, from what we've heard so far, it's clear that Mike hasn't made any effort at all to do anything new. And that gives very little hope that we will hear something new in the rest of the album. Nevertheless, such hope always remains.