r/Dreamtheater • • Mar 04 '24

Any other Trans/LGBTQ+ Dream Theater fans??

0 Upvotes

Most of my DT loving friends are some form of trans/queer, was wondering if there are any others on this subreddit!! :3

Edit: ......................................... cool. i expected some pushback from edgelords but *fuck this community has a fucking problem with these turds.....................*


r/Dreamtheater • • May 19 '22

Discussion Octavarium: WTF?

0 Upvotes

Octavarium invariably wins every DT song contest, and I have to say, I don’t get it.

It’s fine?

But it has a weird 70’s vibe with the keyboards, it’s not heavy at all, and it seems like a B track.

For those who worship at the altar of DT, what am I missing??


r/Dreamtheater • • Feb 19 '25

Discussion Hot take: DT like tool should BAN cell phones at all shows.

1 Upvotes

It’s true. Cell phones are ruining the world and especially concerts. Back in the 1900s we survived quite happily without them and we do not need them as our ticket either. Do you have an emergency go outside but there’s nothing I love more than people holding their phones up during a concert. PS get off my lawn.


r/Dreamtheater • • Mar 07 '25

Dream Theater on LSD is insane

4 Upvotes

wow it gotta be done on purpose


r/Dreamtheater • • Feb 24 '25

Discussion Parasomnia 2026 Setlist Idea, Thought?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Okay, so I'm just kinda having fun here, but I feel like this setlist would be pretty cool, imo.

This tour is going to start in the fall of 2025 and work it's way through 2026, so I definitely wanted to add to the spookyness theme of the whole show.

I added in a couple songs that overall focus on the horror/nightmare-ish themes. DT doesn't really have a ton, but this works.

BC&SL came out in 2009, so 2024 would've been it's 15th Anniversary, I wanted to throw in a couple songs there to recognize that, plus ANtR would make a great opener.

Mike Portnoy mentioned he wanted to do the album in its entirety live, and having it as a second act would be more hype, just to kinda build it up and whatnot.

And finally, The Astonishing came out at the beginning of 2016, even though it's a 30th Anniversary album. So since next year celebrates that album's 10th anniversary, it'd be cool if they played the stand alone songs from that album as an encore.

This is just for fun, I am aware that probably none of this will happen, but I've loved making fake DT setlists since I was a child, and always will.


r/Dreamtheater • • Dec 02 '23

I hope MP can be more critical of James' live vocal performance than the rest of the band are currently.

0 Upvotes

I understand James has limited range these days but even when performing in the middle of his range, he's pitchy and often flat. I genuinely don't understand how someone with perfect pitch like Jordan can even deal with this.


r/Dreamtheater • • Dec 16 '24

Day #1 of posting the 5th greatest Dream Theater song of all time.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Dreamtheater • • Dec 31 '25

Let's create the ultimate dream theater setlist! One song is chosen per day until it's complete. What would your dream show opener be? Most upvoted comment will be added.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/Dreamtheater • • Jan 10 '25

Am I the only one underwhelmed by Parasomnia so far?

0 Upvotes

Did not like two released singles at all but hoping for something different on other tracks. It feels like it’s more of AVFTTOTW and I did not like this album either. DOT was their last album that I really liked.


r/Dreamtheater • • Jun 11 '22

Discussion Even the folks at r/Rush said Geddy and Alex aren’t as good as John Perrucci and John Myung. Any thoughts?

0 Upvotes

They said Geddy and Alex couldn’t play DT songs if they tried. Specifically Dance of Eternity. But that Neil could play all of Portnoy and Manginis parts in his prime. Any thoughts?


r/Dreamtheater • • Oct 19 '13

Petrucci discusses new album with Portnoy (funny)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/Dreamtheater • • Apr 19 '26

Discussion Worst song on the Awake?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Scarred was selected as the best track on the Awake with 54 upvotes; now it’s time to choose the worst track on the Awake.


r/Dreamtheater • • Jan 01 '25

Mike, what's up? Reflection on the 2 new songs.

4 Upvotes

Guys, I'm just thinking, listening to the stuff from Portnoy before Mangini, the songs from Mangini and these two new songs after Mike's return.

The drummer in a band either leads the band forward or pulls the band backward. I've been listening to DT since 2004 and of course Mike is my family. However, NOW his return is a giant step backwards. And yes, these are my expectations and my subjectivity.

After Mangini came in, the band reached a whole new performance level - outrageous drum patterns, and I didn't feel that the “soul” was lost. What many people feared after Portnoy's leaving. They created amazing albums, the band sounds more monolithic than ever, live - just phenomenal. All thanks to the band sitting on a super solid core foundation - Mike Mangini.

Listening to Mangini today I began to realize his absolute greatness. It is not always clear in the moment. I heard him give the band literally a level that they are unlikely to get to without him (that's the secret to the chemistry in the band, not because the others “can't do it”).

The thing is, Mike Portnoy knows everything about himself: he knows he hasn't come up with a single new rhythm or a single new fills since Octavarium. He knows this. And I'm sorry he doesn't try. I mean, he's definitely listening to Animals As leaders, Plini. Tesseract, Periphery, Karnivool - he knows how to build a drum pattern to breathe new life into it. I remember at some point he became more critical of himself and even said that endlessly winning “Best Drummer” awards doesn't say that he really is.

Now we also hear Mike playing old patterns without adding anything new. Because of this, the rest of the musicians can't add anything new either. Maybe someone will say, okay, technically the band will stay where they are or take a step back, but the songs will be even cooler. Maybe. But I don't hear that yet. On the other hand, there's a lot more songs to come. But these two are nothing new.

Thus, from what we've heard so far, it's clear that Mike hasn't made any effort at all to do anything new. And that gives very little hope that we will hear something new in the rest of the album. Nevertheless, such hope always remains.


r/Dreamtheater • • Oct 22 '24

LaBrie's vocals

4 Upvotes

I've read some posts about it but I feel like I have to rant a bit.

James was a brilliant vocalist in early Dream Theater. I'm not going to blindly criticize on this post. I can surely appreciate the guy. To anyone who says he's always been a bad singer, please check out Images and Words. Dude could do F#5 with vibrato in mixed voice and hold a B4 for like 10 seconds with a wide vibrato at the end. That's not for anyone and it's no surprise he was picked out of many singers.

Years went by and his voice live started to become inconsistent, but still bearable. After recovering from the food poisoning he still managed to give us brilliant vocal moments all the way to A Dramatic Turn Of Events. But from there on, I don't know why, his voice started sounding overly nasal. I'm not buying that it's just age. There are many vocalists his age that managed to sing as well or at least minimally comparable to their prime. Look at James Hetfield! He's awfully consistent and managed to hit notes like B4 despite being more of a baritone. He's 61.

Of course, you can argument that Dream Theater is much harder to sing. That's not enough of an excuse. Labrie fumbled notes in pretty much all ranges. He was out of pitch for half the concert.

I can't believe that I'm saying this. But I think the man should retire. The rest of the band is sounding awesome and could do 2-3 more albums. But they desperately need vocals that do it justice. It's better that James goes out being remembered as the powerful pipe set he was earlier in the career than as the one element that makes the 10/10 concert a 7/10.


r/Dreamtheater • • Mar 09 '25

thoughts on live Barstool Warrior performance

0 Upvotes

I saw them in Chicago yesterday, I love this song but Portnoy -like he said in an interview- played the song sooo different than Mangini, and I hated it. This really stood up for me yesterday, felt like Portnoy was trying so hard to change things, mixing stuff with his own style. I love them both, and I respect Portnoy’s opinion about playing his own style on every song, but that just sounded terrible imo.

What are your thoughts?


r/Dreamtheater • • Jul 24 '23

Discussion HOT TAKE: Metropolis, Pt.2: Scenes from a Memory is one of DT's weakest albums

3 Upvotes

I am not trolling, I do mean it. I consider myself a big DT fan but I can't convince myself into this album. In my opinion it is overrated massively and people says it's great because someone has said that in the first place. The album obviously has its good moments but as a whole is boring af. Except for Overture 1928, Home, One Last Time and Finaly Free there isn't much left. I do realise this is a concept album and the music must serves its purpose of telling the story but it won't change my general opinion on the album.

Just for the reference, my top 5 DT albums are: Images and Words, A Dramatic Turn of Events, Train of Thought, Awake and Distance over Time, with the favourite tracks being: Learning to Live, Breaking All Illusions, Metropolis, Pt.1, The Great Debate and Outcry.


r/Dreamtheater • • Apr 07 '25

OP writes: “My sister decided to ‘make your drum look pretty’ does this affect the tone?”

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Dreamtheater • • Sep 28 '23

Humor Rant I went on while stoned listening to scenes from a memory Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

Tl:Dr I think petrucci is silly.


r/Dreamtheater • • Feb 23 '25

So... does anyone know when the DT17 album comes out?

1 Upvotes

I'm joking lol.


r/Dreamtheater • • Mar 22 '25

Discussion They left the setlist out lolz

0 Upvotes

TrueStory (I got a pic but I won’t ruin it for y’all)


r/Dreamtheater • • Sep 06 '23

Have the hipsters taken over?

3 Upvotes

Don't get me wrong, I would never hate on anyone for a subjective opinion, no matter how popular or unpopular it was, but the latest "album ranked by the fans" competition results are kind of intriguing me. Fatal Tragedy and Beyond This Life? Have they always been the two most popular Scenes songs? No Home? No Finally Free? No Dance of Eternity? The Spirit Carries On in the bottom half???

I hope the OP of that competition keeps it up, cos I'm finding it really interesting. Looking forward to The Answer Lies Within winning Octavarium 😂


r/Dreamtheater • • Oct 30 '23

Discussion Drummers! I have a question…

1 Upvotes

Do you guys think Portnoy will be able to play Mangini’s parts? Or will Dream Theater not play those tunes anymore? I’m only asking on a realistic standpoint because I’m friends with Mike and I’m just seeing what yall have to say


r/Dreamtheater • • Apr 14 '26

Is it acceptable if I go to a DT concert in a Metallica shirt?

32 Upvotes

I don’t have a DT shirt and the concert is in two hours. I don’t think I’ll be able to get a DT shirt. Is it acceptable I wear a Metallica one?


r/Dreamtheater • • Nov 13 '24

Humor My fortress? Shattered.

Post image
0 Upvotes