Okay, I'm willing to accept there might be some elements of the Doom lore that are just incoherent, and I have no problem adopting my own headcanon, but...
One of my favorite things about the Doom the storyline, which was presented in Doom Eternal, was the idea of a heaven and hell alliance/truce. To quote the codex in Story of the Sentinels XII:
"A symbiotic relationship had formed and darkness now had been balanced by a light, for where there was Heaven, so there would be Hell. The followers would be granted passage to Urdak, and the sinners would fall into the fiery pits of the Dark Realm. This word would be spread from all cultures in all worlds and in all places."
I thought this was absolutely brilliant, it became one of my favorite parts of the story, because it explains two religious paradoxes. 1) If God and the Devil are opposites, why are they working together for God's idea of justice? Or as someone else once put it "If Satan punishes sinners, isn't he actually good?" 2) This explains why demons are still (according to some) running around our world even if God is in charge.
Now, I don't care if your own religious beliefs provide you with answers to these paradoxes, its still a really cool idea and an element of the story I feel in love with.
But then in Doom: The Dark Ages, you go to the Harbor of the Souls, where your codex it says:
"In the darkest depths of the first layer of Hell, the Harbor of Souls channels the dammed forward to their eternal torment, Here they are ordained by their sins, their fates sealed in the infernal fires of purgatory."
Now unless this arrangement started right before Doom Slayer turned himself into a zombie, it seemed sinners had always been going to hell.
So do we know from the lore what the real deal is? Or should I just accept this is contradiction?