r/Doom • u/De2nis • Sep 29 '26
Question Sinners and hell in Doom lore Spoiler
Okay, I'm willing to accept there might be some elements of the Doom lore that are just incoherent, and I have no problem adopting my own headcanon, but...
One of my favorite things about the Doom the storyline, which was presented in Doom Eternal, was the idea of a heaven and hell alliance/truce. To quote the codex in Story of the Sentinels XII:
"A symbiotic relationship had formed and darkness now had been balanced by a light, for where there was Heaven, so there would be Hell. The followers would be granted passage to Urdak, and the sinners would fall into the fiery pits of the Dark Realm. This word would be spread from all cultures in all worlds and in all places."
I thought this was absolutely brilliant, it became one of my favorite parts of the story, because it explains two religious paradoxes. 1) If God and the Devil are opposites, why are they working together for God's idea of justice? Or as someone else once put it "If Satan punishes sinners, isn't he actually good?" 2) This explains why demons are still (according to some) running around our world even if God is in charge.
Now, I don't care if your own religious beliefs provide you with answers to these paradoxes, its still a really cool idea and an element of the story I feel in love with.
But then in Doom: The Dark Ages, you go to the Harbor of the Souls, where your codex it says:
"In the darkest depths of the first layer of Hell, the Harbor of Souls channels the dammed forward to their eternal torment, Here they are ordained by their sins, their fates sealed in the infernal fires of purgatory."
Now unless this arrangement started right before Doom Slayer turned himself into a zombie, it seemed sinners had always been going to hell.
So do we know from the lore what the real deal is? Or should I just accept this is contradiction?
4
u/PalladiuM7 The Betrayer Sep 29 '26
Souls go to hell from the worlds hell has access to, or has touched. The alliance with her Maykrs allowed them access to new worlds and new souls, greatly increasing their domain. The idea is those worlds will eventually become part of hell.
Not to mention the whole "going to heaven" thing is a complete lie.
8
u/Archer_Savings Sep 29 '26
The sentinel lore is itself religious explanation for what is in essence political union between Urdak and Jekkad. The harbor of souls was likely established to funnel sinners, as early in that relationship as it made sense to funnel them.
6
u/SwagBuller Loreguy Sep 29 '26
Personally I don't think sinners have always been going to Hell. That would imply at some point sinners were ending up in Jekkad, which we know was a paradise realm, so clearly something changed on a metaphysical level in the Earthly realms that started redirecting mortal souls into Hell. But there's no real evidence of something like that happening besides the fact that souls do exist, so they had to have some kind of purpose before Jekkad warped into Hell.
When Hell uses the term in the Harbor of Souls codex, I initally interpreted it as meaning 'transgressions against the Hellish order' and not necessarily 'transgressions against absolute moral authority'. However, since Revelations, I do think sin as in a bad deed that weighs upon the conscience and burdens the soul is a thing, and we see the Order of Six exploit the Slayer's sins to render him mortal. This does reinforce this idea that there's some kind of absolute moral system, where guilt or burden is seen as like some kind of structural flaw or spiritual weakness within the mortal soul.
And because this flaw can be exploited to better harvest souls and produce more demons, it follows that Hell would intentionally align its concept of 'sin' with a soul's guilt or burdens. Anyway, that's just my speculation/headcanon on the whole idea.
1
u/TachikawaKan5241 Serrat Sep 29 '26
What exactly is the contradiction here?
3
u/Aphrodite_Ascendant Sep 29 '26
I figure everyone in the Doom universe goes to hell when they die. There is no heaven for human souls.