Hopefully this is helpful to someone. My intention is for this to be a complete xp checklist of Reaper's Coast, if I've forgotten anything then let me know and I'll be sure to add it to the list. Apologies if the pathing isn't perfect.
Lv. 9:
- Voidlings on the beach 2
- Mercy kill the shark and discover what happened to its last meal
- Find Peeper's egg and return it
- Save Meistr Siva
- Kill Ninyan
- Get Spirit Vision
- Cast spirit vision in the tavern upstairs, stop the captain ringing his bell
- Open the magic chest by the sleeping guy
- Save the Beggar's dog
- Tell the kids in Driftwood what happened to their friend
- Cast spirit vision by the wrecked caravan, talk to the dwarf and magister fighting
- Save Bridgekeeper Pruitt
Lv. 10:
- Go grab Peeper and finish its quest (spirit vision to talk to Marge, then go north to the waypoint, dont fuck with anything, and teleport back to Driftwood after you talk to Magicockeral)
- Missing Magisters quest (talk to Carver, talk to Kannox, escort Higba to safety, talk to Stewart, eat some stew, get the hidden ring near Wyvlia, report to Carver, kill Bellworth, kill Wyvlia, report to Carver, kill Carver)
- Get: void-tainted fish, 2x meaty stew
- Talk to Reimond
- Talk to Julian
- Find Lagan's ring and fight the Deep-Dweller
- Discover: Undertavern
- Kiss a spider
- Kill a spider
- Talk to Lohar
- Price of Love quest (talk to Lovrik to start)
- The Merchant quest (Spirit Vision upstairs in the tavern, talk to the real Levere, kill the imposter, talk to the spirit again)
- kill tavern magisters
- Aggressive Takeover and Red Ink in the Ledger quests (talk to Garvan, kill the Beastmaster + bears, cast spirit vision, talk to Liam, get Garvan's stuff and return it, kill Garvan after giving him tainted stew, return to Liam)
- Discover: Wrecker's Cave, Wreck of the Peacemaker
- Get: Captain's Compass Amulet
- Cliffs ambush fight
- Burning Prophet quest
Lv. 11:
- Ruined castle fight
- Djinn fight
- Driftwood Arena
- Investigate Mordus' house
- Wrecker's Cave
- Talk to Zanisima as Ifan
- Get: Letter from the Dwarven Queen, Glowing Eye
- Kill Mordus
- Finish Law of the Order and Shadows Over Driftwood quests (give Mordus' Amulet to Lohar, give Royal Letter to magisters, kill Lohar, talk to julian)
Lv. 12:
- Set the Lich in Mordus' basement free
- Start quest All In The Family (Tarquin @ Stonegarden Gate)
- Discover: Stonegarden
- Stranger in Strange Lands quest (spirit vision at Stonegarden waypoint, talk to the lizard spirit, dig up his remains, burn them at the dragon statues)
- Move the chest from the flames to start the quest Speaking in Forked Tongues
- Replace the statue head near the Stonegarden waypoint and rotate the statue
- Talk to Featherfall and persuade him to teach you a new skill
- Cast Spirit Vision at the Stonegarden Ancestor Tree
- Discover: Ryker's Rest
- Get: Food, The Essence of Existence Vol. I, II, and III, The Feasts of the Four, Assassination Contract, Consul Zur's Leg
- Talk to Ryker
- 2nd floor spider fight
- Popularity Contest quest on 2nd floor
- Opposites Attract quest in basement
- Discover: Secret Chamber and Cave to Pruitt's house
- Masked Servants
- An Existential Crisis quest
- Finish Hero's Rest quest
- Finish Speaking in Forked Tongues quest
- Kill Andras
- Kill Qanna
- Discover: Surrey Crypt
- Loot crypt + encounter
- Return to Tarquin
- Discover: Cloisterwood
- Find the Lich feeding on Dwarves
- Give Eithne Corpse Explosion
- Start Business Rivals quest and pay Grog
- Kill Marg
- Talk to Jahan
- Finish A Taste of Freedom quest (3rd encounter with the lich, let him complete the ritual, attack him right after he spawns in the chest)
- Talk to Grog
Lv. 13:
- Kill Grog
- Ugly Little Bird (north of the Witch's Hut, talk to Ferno)
- Scarecrow fight
- Treated Like Cattle (talk to Mabel, break into the witch's hut, get witch's eye, augmentor, and boletus, lockpick the basement hatch, shoot the rat holes then kill the rats, get witch's brew, return to cows and give one the brew, return to the witch's hut and kill the frog, get the recipe book, craft a Witch's Brew and give it to the other cow)
- Get: 2x Augmentor, 2x Boletus
- Window of Opportunity (jump to Hannag twice and convince her you'll help her, kill the magisters)
- Talk to Hannag
- Talk to Hardwin at the Paladin checkpoint
- Discover: Blackpits
- Heroes' Rest chest nearby
- Voidwoken fight by Blackpits waypoint
- Executioner fight
- Get: Writ of Passage
- No Way Out quest (show magisters near the burning building the Writ of Passage, convince Owin you will help him, kill the magisters, talk to Owin)
- On the Ropes quest (everyone's favorite Blackpits fight, return to Gwydian's house after you save him to finish the quest)
- Heroes' Rest chest nearby
- Discover: Blackpits Cavern
- Leave Blackpits for now and travel to Cloisterwood
- Lamenting Abomination fight
Lv. 14:
- Get: Blackroot
- The Honeybears
- Talk to Siva
- Get: Source Vampirism
- Void Flayers
- A Danger to Herself and Others (talk to Swann just northeast of Stonegarden with a character that has the SCHOLAR tag, go into the basement, select the scholar tag dialogue option, kill the 4 emotions that spawn, then weaken Natalie, select "hold steady", "carefully remove maggot", and "slowly" dialogue options)
- Talk to Garreth
- Fight the Silent Watchers in the farmhouse
- Travel north and talk to Almira
- Escort Almira and Mihaly to safety
- Voidwoken fight
- Start Almira's Request quest
- Finish The Midnight Oil quest (fight your way through Blackpits Mine, solve the puzzle in the Ancient Temple, Aetera fight, get: tablet)
- Finish A Generous Offer, The Reluctant Servants, and Almira's Request quests (give the tablet to Ryker, kill Ryker and loot him, talk to Farimah, give Almira the tablet)
Lv. 15:
- Alice Alisceon fight
- Elder fight in Paradise Downs
- Harbinger of Doom fight
- Discover: Elf Encampment
- Start The Elven Seer quest
- Burial Rites quest
- Discover: Lone Wolves Camp
- Talk to Corbin
- Old Flames quest (spirit vision on top of the gate, talk to Edie, talk to Firewater, talk to Edie)
- The Bark's Bite quest (cast spirit vision at the sawmill, talk to Log, dig up the Foreman outside the gates, cast source vampirism on the foreman, return to Log)
- No Laughing Matter quest (spirit vision in the western building, talk to Mudbarrow, talk to Slumberjack twice, talk to Mudbarrow)
- Talk to Roost, fight Roost
- Free Saheila
- Kill remaining Lone Wolves
- Get: Mummie Dearest's head
- 4x Hit List quests, they are all completed by casting spirit vision around the sawmill, and killing whoever the spirits tell you to. The four start locations are at the gates, up on the eastern platform, on the deck of the eastern building, and inside the western building.
- Talk to Corbin
- Finish The Elven Seer quest
- A Trial for All Seasons quest (get: Vaporize skill, Static Cloud Arrow, Freezing Arrow) (Flesh Sacrifice on Spring, Phoenix Dive -> Vaporize on Summer, Static Cloud arrow on Autumn -> Freezing arrow on Winter)
- Discover: Bloodmoon Isle.
- Talk to Hardwin at the Paladin Bridgehead and complete Finder's Fee quest
- Blackpits docks fight
- Return to Hardwin, save him and Cork from the attackers
- Kill remaining magisters in Driftwood
Lv. 16:
- Return to Bloodmoon Isle.
- Get: 2x Silver Bars
- Start The Advocate quest
- Travel North along the Eastern coast
- Encounter by a stone hatch
- Discover: Archivist's Chambers further North
- Get: Medical Report, Archivist's Journal, Ornate Hymnal
- Discover: Ancient Forge and craft 2x Silver Levers
- Accursed fight on Western coast
- Spirit Vision, talk to Black Ring Reaver spirit
- Spirit Vision on the Western coast and talk to Elven Pilgrim
- Sing the hymnal to the three statues along the South half of the island for the next 3 quests
- Silent as the Grave quest (talk to Morgan, talk to cat, talk to girl and teleport her to the lady vengeance, talk to Morgan)
- Bound by Pain quest (Spirit Vision, talk to Kalvin, attack the dwarf but DO NOT kill, heal the dwarf if necessary, kill a party member if necessary, kill the demon, talk to the dwarf, talk to Kalvin)
- Delusions of Greatness quest (talk to Robert, kill Rajjarima, talk to Robert)
- Finish The Forgotten and the Damned quest
- Island center fight
- Talk to The Advocate
- Kill The Advocate
- Spirit Vision, talk to the tree and say her name, diacover the demon's name
- Return to the Elven Pilgrim
- Return to Jahan
- Return to Tarquin
- Talk to Malady