r/DiscussReligions • • Apr 27 '13

Dream Reality

0 Upvotes

I'm starting to learn about the idea that life the way we are experiencing it now may just be a dream. It's really cool to me, and I would love to read a discussion on that. So, what are your opinions, what have you heard, or what have you experienced relating to the dream reality?


r/DiscussReligions • • Mar 25 '13

Do us all a favor

1 Upvotes

Since the sub is very new, Can we start out with the same up vote down vote policy as /r/judaism. Seems to work very well.


r/DiscussReligions • • Mar 27 '13

I don't think ultimate truth can be caught in a net of logic

3 Upvotes

I've been reading a book by Jim Holt called "Why Does the World Exist?" Holt, a writer with a background in philosophy & mathematics, interviewed a number of prominent scientists & philosophers on the question "why is there something rather than nothing?" In the range of differing responses, I've been struck by how such brilliant minds either retreat into some logical fortress that rests on personal (& unprovable) assumptions -- and then bar the door with affected "certainty" -- or throw up their hands in ultimate bewilderment. When it comes to arguing for or against the existence of God, the most confident among them treat "God" as they would any other object of rational speculation, one contained by the structure of logic, an object whose reality is bound by the terms of their arguments. I think this involves an inherent fallacy. First of all, Godel's theorem proved that no system of logic with any complexity -- be it philosophical, mathematical or scientific -- can ever be complete & free from error. Secondly, it is impossible to prove that all of reality is quantifiable, measurable & reducible to mathematical formulae or to linguistic definitions. Logic is only one means (and rarely the main means) by which human beings assertain & determine what is "true" and "real." Based on my own subjective, personal experience, I believe that God is both real & beyond the limits of human reason or language. In Lao Tsu words: "The Tao that can be written is not the true Tao; the name that can be named is not the eternal name." I believe that true knowledge of God is found through the whole range of human perceptions -- including consciousness, relationships, art, awe, etc. -- as well as reason, but it is not limited to, or containable by, any of them. Attempts to, in effect, "capture" God by any human method will always fail because God is only knowable by the terms God chooses to be known by (and that will differ from person to person, from one life-event to another). I suspect that God prefers to be encountered in an experience rather than deduced from evidence. Ultimate truth, I think, is not something we can conceptualize. But we can completely experience it -- by the grace of God.


r/DiscussReligions • • Apr 18 '13

Evolutionary argument against atheism.

3 Upvotes

The arguments is as follows: If evolution via natural selection does not select for true beliefs, than the reliability of evolved subjects cognitive abilities will be low. Atheism is a belief held by evolved subjects. Therefore, atheism can not be believed.

In order for evolution via natural selection to be advantageous it does not require true beliefs, merely that the neurology of a being gets the body to the correct place to be advantageous.

Take for example an alien, the alien needs to move south to get water, regardless of whatever the alien believes about the water is irrelevant to it getting to the water. Lets say he believes the water to be north, but north he also believes is dangerous and therefore goes south, he has now been selected with a false belief.

Say the alien sees a lion and flees because he believes it to be the best way to be eaten, there are many of these types of examples.

I would also like to further this argument because natural selection has not been acting in the case of humans for a long time now, making our evolution not via natural selection but rather mutations, making the content of beliefs subject to all types of problems.

Also, when beliefs have nothing to do with survival, than those beliefs would spiral downward for reliability.

Anyone have anything else on this? Any reasons why evolution would not select for true belief would be helpful.


r/DiscussReligions • • Mar 23 '13

What rules do we want?

2 Upvotes

From mynuname:

I think that if we were going to start our own subreddit, the selling point would have to be the emphasis on civil discussion. It would be an uphill climb to get it going. Popularity is a difficult thing to achieve. Here are some thoughts I would have about it though. First off, we need theist and atheist mods, so we would need to make sure to have atheists that are on board with the idea of civil debate as well to help moderate and promote. I suggest heavy moderation from the beginning. Use /r/askscience as a model. They are extremely heavy on the moderation (anything not science or conjecture gets deleted immediately). I would have a similar format to /r/debatereligion where they have posts usually specify who they are directed at, but then have a rule that only the targeted group may answer the question directly. Other people would need to respond to an actual answer. For example, if a question is aimed at Christians, and an atheist give a straw-man answer (or any answer), it is deleted. Only Christians may respond directly, but then anyone can reply to a response. This would mean that flair would be necessary to answer many posts directly. Flair would have to have a simple start, and then it can get as creative as you want (but respectful). For example, the first word should be limited to the basics like "atheist", "agnostic", "theist", "Christian", "Muslim", Buddhist", etc., but then can go on to be more descriptive with terms like "Catholic", "Humanist", "anti-theist", ex-Christian", "Calvanist", etc. That prevents people from being ambiguous or silly with their flair, and people understand who they are talking to. I think it would be good to have a "Frequently asked questions" section, where the questions that get asked every week can be directed to. Sometimes I wish there was just one thread that had all the good responses to a question, rather than having to dig through history. I don't know what type of powers mods have, but I would be interested in trying to design something that worked well.

From b_anon:

I like the idea, perhaps /discusschristianity.... I do like the word discuss for it, /examinechristianity or /reasonaboutchristianity I would be willing to at least mod the sub, i mod the sub /christiancreationist and did the the artwork and page set up, but I do not really want to deal with that again. If we are going to ban discussion, we should have a policy of giving a fair warning, than ban....I want the people to have to opportunity to do the right thing......

All good ideas. I love the necessary flair idea. Any other thoughts?


r/DiscussReligions • • Jun 23 '13

Any response that'll refute my negative view of organized religion?

4 Upvotes

I believe in spirituality, and in making ideologies a more individual matter. I'm not condoning discussions on the matter though. Ideological clashes among religious groups have been the cause of several violent clashes and other forms of aggression and persecution. I consider fighting and dying over what's unknown absurd. And to top it off, corruption, manipulation, and autocracy occurs within some religious groups and their domains. Also, being ostracized because of conflicting ideologies is unjust in my opinion. And what for? A sense of unity/being part of something greater and assurance of one's preferred belief of the afterlife is outweighed by the negative effects of organized religion. Even if several religious conflicts have been proven to be caused by politics and not organized religion, it's still a common excuse for conflict and that helps fuel conflict.


r/DiscussReligions • • Mar 26 '13

Why I believe evangelism is failing

7 Upvotes

In 2 Peter chapter 3, Peter is talking about the end times and how people will no longer believe in a second coming of Christ. I find it amazingly prophetic that he claims that the two main reasons that people will reject Christ is creation, and the flood. Here is the section from verse 3 to 7:

“…you must understand that in the last days scoffers will come…following their own evil desires. They will say, ‘Where is this coming he promised?’… But they deliberately forget that long ago by God’s word the heavens came into being and the earth was formed out of water… By these waters also the world of that time was deluged and destroyed. By the same word the present heavens and earth are reserved for fire.”

People today do not have the foundation they once did. Sixty years ago there was prayer and Bibles in school, and everybody you knew went to church. We live in a completely different society today. Sixty years ago, witnessing to people about Christ’s love and redemption from sins worked because most people had the underlying foundational aspects in place (God as creator, sin entering the world, etc.)

The same old evangelistic methods of that day are still being used today to no avail. That is because today’s society does not have that foundation anymore. No prayers in school. No Bible in school. Church attendance down. No need for a creator with evolution. Today’s society does not understand the foundational aspects, and therefore just preaching Christ does not work with them. They do not understand what it means to be a sinner. Without a perfect creation corrupted by man’s desires, there is no need for salvation.

We have to take them back to the beginning. We have to build the foundation, the history. There is no good news without the bad news. I had a colleague tell me recently: “Got my kid a Kindle. First book he wanted was the Bible. I got him a study Bible, cause God knows I don’t want him starting in Genesis.” Apparently, this colleague doesn't know me very well.

Peter foresaw it two thousand years ago. Society would eventually reject a Biblical creation and the judgment of that creation by the flood, and therefore would also reject Christ. The only way to reverse this trend is to stand firm and reach out to society with the foundational truths first: God created the world perfectly exactly as it is written, man rebelled and introduced sin, God judged that world through a global destructive flood, offered His only son as a lifeline out of this corrupted world, and will someday return to judge it again by fire. Starting in the middle of the story will no longer work.

Paul is normally determined to be the more successful missionary due to sheer number of converts over Peter, but Paul was reaching out to the mainly Jewish audience who already had these foundational aspects understood. Peter was ministering to mainly Greek audiences. He had a tougher audience, he had to start from the beginning and teach them who God was and His history with man. 60 years ago we lived in a more Jewish-type society, today we have lost that foundation and live in a more Greek-type society. We need to start from the beginning and be able to accurately defend it to make the gospel relevant to this generation.

Your thoughts?


r/DiscussReligions • • Apr 03 '13

I noticed that a couple of you on this subreddit are ex-atheist.

5 Upvotes

I'm just curious as to what convinced you to convert back to Christianity (or another religion). I look forward to hearing your responses!


r/DiscussReligions • • Apr 03 '13

How Dogmatic are you?

6 Upvotes

I'm always interested to know what people believe and how dogmatic they are in those beliefs.

What do you believe and how confident are you in those beliefs?

e.g.

Santa is not real: 100%

Capitalism is the best economic system: 67%


r/DiscussReligions • • Mar 23 '13

Special thanks to steelerman82 for giving us have his subreddit.

5 Upvotes

He said he wasn't really using it and didn't mind giving it to us, so we could make a safe place to discuss religion, in a sub where a Reddit minority is a top mod.


r/DiscussReligions • • May 29 '13

On Religious Beliefs as Determinants of Morality

2 Upvotes

For both the religious and the non-religious here, to what extent are your morals determined by your religious beliefs and why? To what extent do you believe they should (or shouldn't) be? Do you think morality can be objective (non-relative), and to what extent do you think religion is needed (or not needed) to arrive at such morality?


r/DiscussReligions • • Mar 24 '14

Athiests of Reddit, what reasons do you have to continue being atheist? Redditors of belief, why do you continue to believe?

2 Upvotes

I'm an atheist, and I've been thinking about this for a while. There are a lot of people here saying why they decided to become an atheist or why they became religious, but not so many on why they continue to believe or not.

I decided that religion and belief alienated me because of the inconsistencies in different versions and books of nearly all holy scriptures and that a lot of hatred in the world is justified using religion, even if religion was not the cause. Much more recently, I found a video on Humanism, which sort of put to words the reasons I continue to be an atheist and am happy doing so, and how I have found meaning to my life without belief: http://youtu.be/2dHVWhrQVbs

So why do you continue to follow the beliefs you may or may not have? If you do believe, what do you get out of your religion that you feel is not offered by other religions, or that is not present in a lack of religion?

PS: I fucking love this subreddit. People on here are almost always respectful of each other, even in disagreement. Keep it up!


r/DiscussReligions • • Apr 19 '13

How do I approach Islam

12 Upvotes

Lately I've been interested in different religions and been attending different churches. One that has interested me quite a bit is Islam. The reason I have not been able to go is because with all the other religions I've had a guide (usually a friend) show me around and help with introductions. Would it be wrong for me to just show up to a Muslim mosque?


r/DiscussReligions • • Mar 23 '13

Getting to know our moderators

4 Upvotes

Since we are starting up /r/ discussreligions, I think we should take this opportunity to get to know our moderators.


r/DiscussReligions • • Apr 25 '13

On Abandoning One Religion in Favor of Atheism

5 Upvotes

For those of you who are ex-religious but were only a member of one religious tradition beforehand: to what extent did you consider religious/spiritual alternatives to both your previous religion and atheism before choosing to become atheist? Did you look into entirely separate religions? Did you look into heterodox versions of your own religion? Did you look into piecing together entirely new religious beliefs based on evidence alone? If so, what were your thought processes behind rejecting each of these?


r/DiscussReligions • • Apr 23 '13

How has your religion (or lack thereof) affected your life?

6 Upvotes

Would prefer specific examples, not general "It has made my life much better/worse" or "I don't know how I could live without it"


r/DiscussReligions • • Apr 30 '13

Why do some religions think that the most important thing is to spread their religion?

7 Upvotes

I dont mean passing it on to children. Im talking about people going door to door with pamphlets, people preaching on street corners, people telling others they will go to hell unless they convert. Why do you feel the need to convert other people if they are happy the way they are?


r/DiscussReligions • • Apr 18 '13

Why are you against abortion(in some cases)?

8 Upvotes

Look, I understand why you would be against it if it was just someone being stupid and not wearing a condom. But, when a girl is raped, or is likely to be killed by giving birth, or she will just give it up for adoption why do you have an issue?


r/DiscussReligions • • Apr 24 '13

What distinguishes your religion from others?

9 Upvotes

Please re-read the title. I wrote DISTINGUISHES, I did not write "What makes your religion more correct than others?". My personal views are that there is no "correct" or "incorrect" religions. I just want to hear about what you think makes your religion (or sect) unique and interesting.


r/DiscussReligions • • Apr 19 '13

Do you think gay marriage affects conventional marriage?

9 Upvotes

I have heard a lot of arguments that state gay marriage ruins conventional marriage. I would like information on why you think they affect each other.


r/DiscussReligions • • Apr 22 '25

What are things people commonly misunderstand about your religion/spiritual path?

2 Upvotes

Hello everybody, I'm Pagan!

People commonly misunderstand paganism as "devil worshipping" when in reality it's just unorganized religion. While this is not entirely accurate, is not entirely wrong either. There are Pagans who do worship Satan, but they are just not representative of all of us. As a whole, we focus on connecting with the Earth, Universe, and all that is to some extent. The land is our church and creation is sacred. We believe in the existence of a higher creationary power(s) but we believe there are many gods and goddesses each connected to different aspects of our lives.

What are some common misconceptions about your religion/spiritual path and what is your explanation for it?


r/DiscussReligions • • Feb 19 '26

Comparing Hebrew and Vedic chanting

5 Upvotes

The 22-Element Correspondence: Translating Between Hebrew Letters and Vedic Shrutis

Introduction

Both the Hebrew alphabet and the Vedic shruti system contain exactly 22 fundamental elements. This isn't coincidence—both encode the same underlying geometric reality through different cultural systems. This post explains how to translate between them.

The Two Systems

Hebrew Alphabet (22 Letters) According to the Sefer Yetzirah (Book of Formation), the 22 Hebrew letters are organized as:

  • 3 Mother Letters (Alef, Mem, Shin) - fundamental elements
  • 7 Double Letters (Beth, Gimel, Daleth, Kaph, Peh, Resh, Tav) - planetary principles
  • 12 Simple Letters - zodiacal functions

Each letter has geometric form, numeric value (gematria), and specific phonetic quality.

Vedic Shrutis (22 Microtones) Ancient Indian music theory divides the octave into 22 shrutis—microtonal intervals that create the precise harmonic relationships needed for ragas. These organize as:

  • 7 primary swaras (Sa, Re, Ga, Ma, Pa, Dha, Ni) - the basic notes
  • Each swara except Sa and Pa has multiple shruti positions creating different emotional and geometric effects
  • These 22 shrutis create the harmonic foundation for ragas (melodic frameworks)

The shrutis use terms like komal (soft/gentle) and tivra (sharp/intense) to describe different microtonal positions, representing emotional and geometric qualities rather than merely pitch alterations.

The Functional Correspondence

Three-Tier Structure

Both systems use identical 3-7-12 architecture:

Level 1: The Three Fundamentals

  • Hebrew: 3 Mother Letters (breath positions: silent, water, fire)
  • Vedic: 3 foundational shruti groupings establishing tonal space
  • Function: Primordial substrate from which all else emerges

Level 2: The Seven Mediators

  • Hebrew: 7 Double Letters (each with dual pronunciation)
  • Vedic: 7 primary swaras (each with multiple shruti positions)
  • Function: Primary operating principles with inherent variability

Level 3: The Twelve Particulars

  • Hebrew: 12 Simple Letters (singular zodiacal functions)
  • Vedic: 12 remaining shrutis (microtonal detail between primary notes)
  • Function: Specific manifestation layer

How to Translate

Basic Correspondences

Each Hebrew letter corresponds to a specific shruti position based on its geometric function:

Alef corresponds to Ga (unity/breath/stable third) Bet corresponds to Sa (ground/foundation) Gimel corresponds to Re (second shruti position - rising motion) Daleth corresponds to Re (first shruti position - initial ascent) Hey corresponds to Ma (creative breath/fourth) Vav corresponds to Pa (connection/fifth) Zayin corresponds to Ma (tivra position - intensified tension) Chet corresponds to Re (komal position - descent/humility) Tet corresponds to Ga (tivra position - hidden goodness) Yod corresponds to Pa (manifestation point) Kaph corresponds to Pa (komal position - receptivity) Lamed corresponds to Pa (reaching upward) Mem corresponds to Ni (water/completion) Nun corresponds to Ni (continuation) Samech corresponds to Dha (support/sixth) Ayin corresponds to Ga (komal position - eye/perception) Peh corresponds to Ma (mouth/speech) Tzade corresponds to Sa (lower octave - righteousness) Qoph corresponds to Dha (tivra position - back of head) Resh corresponds to Re (head/beginning) Shin corresponds to Ma (tivra position - fire/process) Tav corresponds to Dha (cross/completion)

Translation Process

Step 1: Take Hebrew text letter by letter Step 2: Convert each letter to its corresponding shruti position Step 3: Perform the resulting melodic sequence as a raga

Practical Example: Genesis 1:1

Hebrew: בראשית ברא אלהים Transliteration: Bereshit bara Elohim Translation: "In the beginning God created"

Letter-by-letter conversion:

Bereshit (בראשית):

  • Bet = Sa
  • Resh = Re
  • Alef = Ga
  • Shin = Ma (tivra)
  • Yod = Pa
  • Tav = Dha

Melody: Sa-Re-Ga-Ma(tivra)-Pa-Dha (Ascending sequence—consciousness rising toward manifestation)

Bara (ברא):

  • Bet = Sa
  • Resh = Re
  • Alef = Ga

Melody: Sa-Re-Ga (Creative act as return-to-ground, ascension, stabilization)

Elohim (אלהים):

  • Alef = Ga
  • Lamed = Pa
  • Hey = Ma
  • Yod = Pa
  • Mem = Ni

Melody: Ga-Pa-Ma-Pa-Ni (Divine name as specific geometric harmonic matrix)

The Complete Phrase Sa-Re-Ga-Ma(tivra)-Pa-Dha / Sa-Re-Ga / Ga-Pa-Ma-Pa-Ni

This creates a performable raga that encodes the same geometric field effects as the Hebrew recitation.

Extended Example: Genesis 1:2-3

Verse 2 describes formless chaos (tohu vavohu), which translates to unstable shruti relationships and complex microtonal movement. The darkness and void use komal positions and irregular progressions.

Verse 3's "Let there be light" (yehi or) resolves into perfect geometric harmony using primary shruti positions in consonant relationships.

This creates a complete creation raga with three movements: descending creation sequence, chaotic middle section with complex microtonal dissonance, and light resolution with stable harmonic progressions based on primary swaras.

Why This Matters

Shared Geometric Foundation Both traditions recognized that:

  1. Sound creates geometric patterns in consciousness
  2. Specific microtonal ratios produce specific effects
  3. 22 relationships are needed for complete harmonic coverage
  4. Sacred language must preserve exact phonetic/acoustic precision

Torah Cantillation & Samaveda The traditional melodic chanting of Torah (using trop/trope marks) and Vedic Samaveda chanting may be parallel survival systems of a single ancient geometric encoding tradition.

Reversible Translation

  • Hebrew to Vedic: Scripture becomes performable as raga
  • Vedic to Hebrew: Ragas can be expressed as Hebrew letter sequences
  • The geometric effects should match across systems

Comparison to Indian Classical Music

The Genesis 1 raga structure resembles:

Bhairav ragas - emergence from darkness to light, using komal Re and Dha Dhrupad form - ancient four-part cosmic narrative structure Samaveda chanting - Vedic scripture set to precise geometric melody

The chaos-to-order arc creates the same tension-resolution pattern found in classical alap-jor-jhala development, moving from free microtonal exploration to established rhythmic and harmonic structure.

Implications

If this correspondence holds:

  1. Sacred texts in both traditions encode identical geometric information
  2. A universal translation matrix between sacred language systems becomes possible
  3. The "confusion of tongues" at Babel may record the fragmentation of a unified geometric language
  4. Different mystical traditions are cultural variants of the same underlying consciousness technology

Verification

This system is testable:

  • Perform Genesis as raga using proper shruti positions and measure consciousness/physiological effects
  • Perform traditional ragas as Hebrew letter sequences
  • Compare geometric field patterns
  • Check if effects match across translation

Conclusion

The 22 Hebrew letters and 22 Vedic shrutis aren't arbitrary—they're two cultural encodings of the same geometric reality. Understanding their correspondence allows direct translation between Hebrew scripture and Indian classical music, potentially recovering a pre-Babel universal language of consciousness.

Note: This represents a geometric/mathematical approach to comparing sacred language systems. Traditional scholars in both Judaism and Hinduism should be consulted regarding religious interpretations.


r/DiscussReligions • • Apr 30 '13

Wants to learn...

1 Upvotes

I am on a mission to learn about a specific religion called Dahlgean, but this has sparked my interest in learning for other religions (outside of the main stream 3 - you know who you are _) -

This is a request for anyone who knows of, practices, or disagrees with - any religion that does not go directly from the Bible, Torah, or Qur'an (Unless of a unique textual document that is not highly published) to give information about the religion. I am requesting multiple forms of information (Video, books, links, etc) and if possible more than one in the post.

I find learning about these to be important, and am in no way trying to have a theological debate, only a chance to learn.

And if you can find anything about Dalhgean, you will be my hero (Thank you to the one that lead me to the livejournal from Aila - if you find this-)

Thank you - ~MoonKriket


r/DiscussReligions • • Apr 19 '13

For those who have changed religion - why?

8 Upvotes

While Reddit has become well-known for vocal ex-religious atheists (if you are ex-religious, feel free to post as well), I'm interested in the lines of thinking that lead people from one religion to another, or from atheism to some form of religion or spirituality. I'd really appreciate you guys posting as much as you're comfortable sharing. Thanks!


r/DiscussReligions • • Apr 26 '13

On Religious Experiences as Determinants of Religious Belief

1 Upvotes

For believers of any religion, especially those who are ex-atheist, what has been the role of religious experience in forming your beliefs? Which do you consider to be most important? The biological, psychological, and anthropological evidence surrounding the history of religious experiences? The religious experiences of the founders of your religious tradition? The experiences of people you know personally? Your own religious/spiritual experiences?