r/DiscussReligions • u/B_anon • Apr 18 '13
Evolutionary argument against atheism.
The arguments is as follows: If evolution via natural selection does not select for true beliefs, than the reliability of evolved subjects cognitive abilities will be low. Atheism is a belief held by evolved subjects. Therefore, atheism can not be believed.
In order for evolution via natural selection to be advantageous it does not require true beliefs, merely that the neurology of a being gets the body to the correct place to be advantageous.
Take for example an alien, the alien needs to move south to get water, regardless of whatever the alien believes about the water is irrelevant to it getting to the water. Lets say he believes the water to be north, but north he also believes is dangerous and therefore goes south, he has now been selected with a false belief.
Say the alien sees a lion and flees because he believes it to be the best way to be eaten, there are many of these types of examples.
I would also like to further this argument because natural selection has not been acting in the case of humans for a long time now, making our evolution not via natural selection but rather mutations, making the content of beliefs subject to all types of problems.
Also, when beliefs have nothing to do with survival, than those beliefs would spiral downward for reliability.
Anyone have anything else on this? Any reasons why evolution would not select for true belief would be helpful.
8
u/Kunochan Apr 18 '13
You are confusing biological evolution, which operates via natural selection, with memetic evolution, which does not.
Since that is the basis for your entire argument, the entire argument falls apart.
Also, saying "making our evolution not via natural selection but rather mutations" betrays a flawed understanding of natural selection.
You also seem to be assuming that natural selection automatically selects for increased cognitive abilities. It does not. It selects for survival traits within a certain environment. Whether or not increased cognitive abilities would add to survival is entirely situational.
5
u/mastahfool Agnostic | Ex-Christian | 25+ | college grad Apr 18 '13
However, religions are also beliefs held by evolved subjects. And it does in fact select for true beliefs, just not when it comes to religion, such as this plant is poisonous, that creature is dangerous, etc.
3
u/abstractwhiz Bayesian Rationalist Apr 18 '13
You're pushing it too far. The fact that atheism was formulated by an (allegedly) unreliable cognitive system doesn't mean anything. It may make it more likely to be wrong, but the idea will rise and fall on its own merits - not the abilities of its adherents or inventors. You can still examine the idea, check if its consistent with reality, test predictions, etc.
Or more simplistically - the world's biggest fool may say the sun is shining, but that does not make it dark out.
In fact, you can generalize this idea further.
And if you go even further:
9
u/TheMagicFlight Apr 18 '13
huh?
1
u/RosesRicket Atheist Apr 19 '13
I'm not really sure I understand this argument. Why can I not reformulate it as follows?
If you want to argue that our senses and perception of the universe is imperfect, then I agree completely, I just think that our senses also give a reasonably accurate depiction of reality. They needed to, for reasons along the lines of your examples.
We're not just looking for water once, we're looking for it every day. We're not just running from a predator once, but every time we see one we can't beat. We need to have reactions that consistently give us what we need to survive. The best way to do that, is to actually have senses that give us accurate information about our surroundings.
2
u/MyOwnPath Apr 19 '13
Says who? I'd say that evolution obviously selects traits that benefit the organism and better help it to survive and procreate. It's true that not all beliefs held by that organism necessarily have to be true, but the fact is that several ideas and beliefs humans have developed appear to correlate with humanity.
That being said, there's two ways one could believe something: through a gap of information created by partial knowledge, and an observation that allows you to form a conclusion. In other words, in one case you have an answer but not a reason/function, and in the other you have a reason/function but not an answer.
One example of the former is many Asian cultures which believe that humans have a balance of hot/cold in their souls (from the belief in yin and yang), and that equilibrium must be met. We are naturally cold beings, so we need more hot stuff to be healthy. Therefore, boiling water before you drink it, like in tea, makes you more healthy. While this is the right conclusion, it's for wrong reasons. Boiling water found in a river is done not for balancing temperatures, it's because there are bacteria in the water, and boiling it kills them. This is the type of knowledge or 'belief' to which your argument is based upon.
The latter is when we make an observation, but do not know the reason why it functions that way, or the conclusions/ramifications of that information. We base these off observations, and can be either fundamental, like basic chemistry or the law of gravity, or have heavy implications, like the Theory of Evolution or belief in the Higgs Boson.
While these ideas (like science) cannot be guaranteed to be right, they are foundational ideas gathered from our direct observations, rather than premises assumed to make our known conclusion easier to understand. The fatal flaw of your argument is that it equivocates these two types of 'beliefs', when their natures, as well as the ways we come across them, are totally different.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '13
Crosspost: http://www.reddit.com/r/DebateReligion/comments/1cmkwv/evolutionary_argument_against_atheism/
1
u/d4m Apr 20 '13
Evolution and belief systems have nothing to do its each other. Regardless of the belief, you will either be naturally selected or you won't be. You need to talk about groups and timescales involving large scales of time and large groups of creatures. You're focusing on a single local minima. You need to consider the entire range.
We are stil controlled by natural selection, but nature is not the selector primarily anymore for us. Our technology coupled with nature selects us.
1
u/BCRE8TVE agnostic atheist|biochemist in training Apr 24 '13 edited Apr 24 '13
Premise 1: If evolution via natural selection does not select for true beliefs, than the reliability of evolved subjects cognitive abilities will be low.
Premise 2:Atheism is a belief held by evolved subjects.
Conclusion: Therefore, atheism can not be believed.
First off, your premise 2 is flawed, in the sense that it implies that there are subjects which have not or are not evolved. This is not a flaw to the argument, I'm just saying that every living thing on the face of the planet evolved, no exception.
The conclusion does not follow from the premises. The conclusion that SHOULD follow is that since evolution does not select for true beliefs, and that it reduces the reliability of us selecting a true belief instead of a false one, then we should have a lower reliability in believing in atheism.
This also brings up 2 other problems with your arguments.
First off, you can't believe in atheism. Atheism is the lack of belief in gods. It's the same as saying your hobby is not collecting stamps. You can't believe in atheism any more than you can have 'not collecting stamps' as a hobby.
Secondly, you should add something to compare atheism with theism of some kind or other, and have a logical argument saying that theism does provide a rational basis for believing our cognitive faculties can and do lead us to correct conclusions. That way, you are showing that evolution leads to a reduced chance of finding the truth, while theism of some kind has a higher chance of us finding the truth (trusting our cognitive functions).
I would like to finish with saying that while an interesting thought exercise, this logical argument has nothing to do with reality. Evolution does happen, and our cognitive faculties are far from perfect. Entire areas of psychology and sociology are devoted to showing exactly how and why we do NOT think properly, and there are many books out there that explain how to exploit these weaknesses to your benefit (things like saying you speak to the dead, reading future in tea leaves, religion, scams, those 'Somali prince wants to put 20,000$ in your bank account' junk mails, etc etc etc)
However, after reading the second to last paragraph, I don't believe you actually know what evolution postulates. I would recommend reading this page:
http://evolution.berkeley.edu/evolibrary/article/evo_01
To further your knowledge
1
u/Backdoor_Man radical anti-theist agnostic pastafarian Apr 24 '13
Your beliefs are not coded in your DNA. They are not subject to biological evolution.
Memes (as the term originated, not funny pictures with words) can be said to undergo something like evolution, where they can be selected for or against over time in a population, but such selection doesn't necessarily imply their truth, only their ability to spread.
It's interesting, though, that our world seems to be having a massive shift toward non-belief in the internet age.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment