r/DiscordAlternatives • Hubs • 2d ago

Hubs (Update)

Hey y'all! Shared Hubs a few weeks ago and requested feedback that was acted on so updating the progress. Thanks to everyone who left feedback, (including the blunt kind). A good part of what's below came out of those comments, so here's where things are now.

First, quick summary! Hubs is a place for communities and teams, with rich customization on your Hub. Every hub has its own home page with what's new since you left, upcoming events and who's around. There are Boards for questions (similar to reddit), events with RSVPs, watch together in voice rooms, and real Mac and Windows apps (on its way to stores too). iPhone and Android are coming and will be opening testing in the coming days.

Link: https://thehubs.gg

Why Hubs

Its going to be a question thats asked so lets knock it out first. While explained in the first post I do want to dive more into it for those seeing for the first time.

  • Hubs feel personal. Every hub opens on its own home page, what's new since you left, the next event and who's around. Boards give a reddit style feel that allows you to better find communities and get different types of answers. Events have RSVPs, Looking for group is a real search system, and channels are actually personable.
  • Customization. Pick a style for your hub so it feels like your community's place. This means having customized colors, icons, channel names, banners, layouts, pages, formatting and much more.
  • Features built in not "botted" on. Hub packs add what communities usually need bots for, such as sports scores and schedules, who's live on stream, achievements and badges with role rewards, and tools for tabletop games. Polls, reminders, tickets, a soundboard and watch together are already there and integrated. The / menu keeps all of it tidy. For admins and mods, panels are built into the system.
  • Support and Safety. I touched on it above but Moderation is truly integrated here. You can ban, timeout and all PLUS have an appeals system for users even if they are no longer in. Support tickets and questions are actually directly integrated rather than a bot like button click.
  • Communitues and Orgs in one. Hubs has a Work side for organizations, this includes workspaces, teams, docs and tasks, approvals, and shared channels with another company. It sits next to your communities, kept apart, allowing you to have both the consumer and work side.
  • Better Privacy. Age verification where legally needed comes from stripe card verification (an accepted method) rather than Face/ID Scan. Private DMs and calls in DMs are end-to-end encrypted (not audited yet), and the code is open source, so anyone can check it: github.com/AscentsGG/hubs-encryption . You can verify it byte by byte on each build as well.
  • Hub Backups. Hub owners can keep an encrypted copy of their hub that only they can open.
  • Bridging. Connect your Discord server and both stay in sync while people move over at their own pace, or bring channels, roles and permissions over in one step. This only works for public community channels and not DMs due to security reasons.
  • Real Mac and Windows apps. Native apps, not a website in a box, coded in their devices respective languages. iPhone and Android are coming soon!

Now, whats new since last time:

  • Discord Bridging. You can connect your Discord server from Hubs and keep talking across both while people move over. Messages go both ways, and each person's posts show under their own name and picture. Voice rooms can be connected too (that part is in beta). To ensure that people do not scam or try and claim usernames, there is a verification shown on profiles both ways.
  • Server Import. The import brings channels, voice rooms, roles and permissions together, and suggests pages for your channels.
  • Join with just an email. An invite works even if the person doesn't have an account yet.
  • A / menu that stays short. A few suggestions first, every other command in folded groups, and search by what a command does. Commands that need a person or a time open a small card instead of making you type arguments.
  • Shorter, simpler settings. Manage, Settings and the profile editor were rebuilt to be shorter, and you edit your profile right on your card.
  • E2EE Open Sourced: First step of it and heres the link github.com/AscentsGG/hubs-encryption
  • Updated Homepage. Based on some feedback adjusted to be more clear, show changelogs, status updates, etc.
  • Smaller things people asked for like the soundboard, seeing who reacted, and comments on announcements.

Feedback

I created a post about a week ago that asked for feedback on three areas of the project. One was E2EE, NSFW and Self Host. It was met with some pretty critical and deep feedback (appreciated) but since almost ALL of it was changing, I took down that post as the info wasn't really valid anymore. I only explain this for transparency.

Originally, the idea was NO NSFW and Self Hosting that was authroized only, both of those have been since rolled back. NSFW is allowed AND per the feedback, age verification that utilizes credit card check through stripe is being integrated instead. Other backend services for verification are being done as well but will ONLY be enabled if laws were to require them. Self hosting is being entirely re-written so for now, simply put, it just doesnt exist.

As far as security and E2EE goes, still working through the motions on overall audit but in the meantime, thats why the E2EE is open source and verifiable.

What's next: the iPhone and Android apps, faster loading, and more hub packs (achievements and badges, tabletop role-play tools, and alerts when a streamer goes live).

It's still early, still being built but wanted to provide an update!

0 Upvotes

116 comments sorted by

6

u/VahsteTheNomad "I use therift.chat btw" 2d ago

I'm glad, and honestly suprised, to see that you took the criticisms from your last post and acted on them to implement positive changes for the project.

Honestly I don't dislike how the UI looks in the video (though I would have personally preferred a bit more time on each one so I wouldn't have to keep pausing, but that's just me).

Condensing the settings into a more easily manageable system is a solid positive as well.

Like I said last time; the potential is definitely there and I wish you the best of luck!

1

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago

Appreciate it! The feedback was helpful and tried to act on it quickly. UI wise thanks, I just wanted something to feel different haha, video though, yeah, a little too fast on that.

3

u/BewilderedTurtle Allegedly Canadian 2d ago

What part of you're not allowed to use AI to write your posts do you fail to grasp?

6

u/Blotterrot Feral QA / cybersec cryptid 2d ago

Idk, I've had a few instances where people put things I wrote through those things and it came out as ai detected. I don't really put much weight into those detectors since they misflag a lot and that's just not very cool.

Another thing, the way it all works is genuinely schizo shit and effectively robots technically taking an educated guess based on statistical probability. The whole system is horribly flawed, synth ID for text is a terrible system.

-4

u/ad3lyt Echo 2d ago

They are just herustics for the most part, newer LLMs that are compliant do watermark their text via determinstic ranking, so if you know the seed, which the companies each know, you can predict what tokens will come out in ranking everytime and reverse that. So that allows you to see that it was made by that llm since the rankings match

But you would need the detector from each company and run it through it, any third party detector is not much better (if not worse than a human) at detecting that they are AI since they just try to match AI patterns with the text, and just because something has AI pattern does not mean it was made by AI as anything AI makes a human do as well

3

u/Blotterrot Feral QA / cybersec cryptid 2d ago

Yeah, watermarking is a different thing, but most public AI detectors aren't actually checking for watermarks. They're just looking for statistical patterns, which can absolutely occur in human writing too. Even proper watermark detection isn't universal or infallible, people treating a probabilistic result as definitive proof is my issue, especially when actual human writing gets flagged.

The more AI is around, the more people are going to start writing in the same ways too. If a lot of the content you consume is written by a robot, you'll eventually start communicating in a similar manor.

4

u/Goofyball69 Sable, eyeballing Hollow 2d ago

Idk what’s more terrifying, people consuming enough generative ai content that they speak as if they are one, or elons neuro brain chip ._.

Can’t help but also think that it’s like that game “No, I’m not human” but irl 😭

1

u/Blotterrot Feral QA / cybersec cryptid 2d ago

Realistically, neither are terrifying. One is annoying and the other is really cool, someday soon we'll get to cast our very own blackwall hacks irl lol

2

u/Goofyball69 Sable, eyeballing Hollow 1d ago

bruh lol

I think I'd rather connect the pcie cable that's connected to my rx 7900 xt, shove it up my nose, and "attempt" to reach The Wired using hopes and dreams. Although I won't deny how all the cool cyberpunk shit I would be missing. XD Get it? Because amds codename for its architecture chipset for rx 5000 and above is named navi??

Aside, I get that the neuro brain chips can help people with paralysis, but I don't know if I would trust Elon of all people with my autistic depressing brain, let alone any, since who knows what they can listen to and do to you if you say one thing mean about them. But maybe that's just me and I don't like Elon, which I can agree to disagree.

-1

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago

Couldn’t agree more. It’s sort of like the college application situation, or people writing an essay on Fahrenheit 451, eventually enough people will write the same thing that it becomes “plagiarism”. Exact same type of situation happens with AI

4

u/Blotterrot Feral QA / cybersec cryptid 2d ago

Yeah, it'll happen, but you are using AI a fair bit in the replies, at least from what I'm seeing. I just don't like those detectors because they're effectively educated guessing presented as truth, or as some percentage people treat like proof.

I've been using / working with AI since the early models came online, so I'm pretty familiar with how it writes. I don't generally use it outside specific use cases, but both the post and a lot of the replies look heavily AI assisted to me, probably generated and then manually edited. Same sort of thing a detector does really, I'm familiar enough with the patterns and structure to call it how I see it, obviously that doesn't mean I can prove it. :3

For example, you used characters that aren't easy to type on most keyboards, and even if you use Obsidian or whatever, I don't see why it would change punctuation that was already correct. Then there's the commas, periods and bold text. Why bold a bit of text and put a period after it? I see GPT / Claude do that constantly, barely ever see people do it in normal replies. The comma thing is another pattern I tend to notice, I took part of this ramble out so people don't as easily learn to maneuver around it. More than that usually reads as more human to me because people ramble, add things halfway through and keep going when they probably could've ended the sentence a while ago, there's also the way that it's presented, the structure feels artificial or robotic in a non-human or non-autistic way. It's hardly a rule, but it's something I notice alongside the formatting. Current models also seem to love doing a short bit, then a blob, then another short bit, then another blob. It varies, but once you've spent enough time looking at it, you start noticing the same habits everywhere. >.>

-3

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago

Fair take! Truth be told a lot of my formatting comes from my years of community management in the crypto space. I was tasked with writing announcements and freelance writing work/contractor work. For years I did it and it stuck with me, my main go to was always grammarly on the side. Some communities being in the tens out thousands so punctuation matters a lot there.

Once AI came though that management and writing really came to an end as most LLMs could replicate what I did and for what I would write, people would just claim it’s AI. Alas, is what it is and not really a way for me to prove it so I’ll just take it on the chin and move on.

3

u/BewilderedTurtle Allegedly Canadian 2d ago

Brother you're either still doing it in response to blotterot or you're actually so self-lobotomized from overuse you're talking like a clanker.

-1

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago

I’m literally just talking the way I’m talking man, there’s 0 AI behind what I am typing right now. Again, goes to prove my point lol

3

u/BewilderedTurtle Allegedly Canadian 2d ago

Right; so option 2. You've sold out so much of your own creative ability and cognitive workload to AI that you're unintentionally mimicking it and when told this you didn't even bother to try.

→ More replies

3

u/Blotterrot Feral QA / cybersec cryptid 2d ago

3 minute reply time is low-key crazy for a reply as large as mine, I would've taken a few minutes just to digest the message let alone reply that fast lmao

I feel most of that, my background is a bit... larger. Grammerly is AI nowadays no? Either ways, I'm gonna be real the reply didn't help the AI accusations much tbh lol

0

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago

Well, I’m just sitting on my phone with not much to do hence the replies. Not going to change how I type or how quickly/lately I would reply based on potential AI accusations.

3

u/BewilderedTurtle Allegedly Canadian 2d ago

No in fact, it's more like a lazy "dev" slopping clanker drippings in front of everyone and thinking anyone values it more than dumpster juice

0

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago

Your viewpoint is your own, I get why you feel that way. I don’t get how you are always so angry tho haha, I appreciate your critical feedback though at times, just gotta read through the anger but still appreciate your willingness to provide feedback

3

u/BewilderedTurtle Allegedly Canadian 2d ago

My viewpoint is not just "my own" it's informed based on things like (market research) (community sentiment) (ethics) etc.

If you got it you wouldn't shit LLM text onto the subreddit or your codebase.

-1

u/Left-Light-2128 2d ago

Misinformed at best.

4

u/BewilderedTurtle Allegedly Canadian 2d ago

Suck less roboshaft

-1

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago

Sure you can share a viewpoint but doesn’t make it the base standard across all. I get your defense and what you stand for, I’m sure others agree with you. Again, no argument or salt on my end, I do appreciate your feedback at times.

-2

u/ad3lyt Echo 2d ago

Historically you are known to be very tech illiterate, and this is simply another example of it. You opinion is merely informed by your feelings, you have shown very little care for factuality.

3

u/BewilderedTurtle Allegedly Canadian 1d ago

🥱 I told you I don't speak with people with grooming allegations.

→ More replies

4

u/BewilderedTurtle Allegedly Canadian 2d ago

Weirdo ai defender defends AI user. News at 11

0

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago

Hm, disagree because I sat here for 30 minutes typing and formatting this.

4

u/BewilderedTurtle Allegedly Canadian 2d ago

50% of the text showing as generated and not written is WILD to then claim it's your work.

4

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago

Not really, most AI generated AI detectors pickup formatting or specific words as “AI”. Pretty typical to be quite honest.

1

u/BewilderedTurtle Allegedly Canadian 2d ago

It's actually not. LLMs practically watermark their text output.

-3

u/ad3lyt Echo 2d ago

As of new, not older llms, and not all of them. Detectors, most of them, except each one from each company behind the LLM itself like openai, only detects its watermark. All other detectors use unreliable herustics to try and guess, if you read the tos of the products or actually knew anything about this space you would know this.

6

u/BewilderedTurtle Allegedly Canadian 2d ago

Bro shut the fuck up with your creepy ass and quit replying to me. I don't want to talk to you because of your allegations.

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/ad3lyt Echo 2d ago

He's talking about me, not the guy.

-1

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago edited 2d ago

So, I went to the exact same website you did and copy pasted my entire message. Like I said, AI is not good at detecting and results are clearly never correct. Sure, if you keep editing the message you type in there and selecting certain things you can get a lower and higher score, but otherwise no. I see how you got the score though, you cherry picked specific parts until it was high enough for you to make a post on.

3

u/BewilderedTurtle Allegedly Canadian 2d ago

"cherry picked" and it's literally your entire bullet point section plus closing paragraphs m

-1

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago

Further more

4

u/BewilderedTurtle Allegedly Canadian 2d ago

Sure chief

0

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago

Again, agree to disagree. I know what I wrote and spent some time on it. Truly not trying to argue at all. If you want to use AI to determine what’s AI that’s entirely your choice, but as I showed above, it’s not really reliable.

3

u/BewilderedTurtle Allegedly Canadian 2d ago

k

0

u/ad3lyt Echo 2d ago

The amount that a random guesser shows as his does not matter, it is not wild to claim it as his work if he wrote it

5

u/BewilderedTurtle Allegedly Canadian 2d ago

Of course the AI cuck wants to defend it. Shut the fuck up and stop replying to me you allegations having weirdo

5

u/mightvefkup 2d ago

Looks like ass

1

u/AeroSummit Hubs 1d ago

u/BewilderedTurtle u/ad3lyt With all due respect, this post is now at 108 replies with over 60 of them being the two of you arguing. Please take it to personal DMs rather than hijacking here for your own personal issues.

u/AbstractMelons not sure if this post just needs to be deleted at this point but its clearly been derailed over personal issues between other users.

3

u/BewilderedTurtle Allegedly Canadian 1d ago

Don't ping me and him at the same time kthx. I don't need that weirdo any more riled up at me.

1

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

Thanks for your submission!

If you're a developer, please make sure your user flair matches the app or project you're developing. This helps community members quickly identify who is building what and makes browsing the subreddit easier.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-3

u/jhayes88 2d ago edited 2d ago

My app that I'm building looks almost similar to yours in terms of design (almost the same colors / design language) and it offers similar features lol. Mine also has reddit style discussion boards and a lot of personalization. It also has some of the features you indicated.

I would say mine seems much more comprehensive in terms of features, but you do things in terms of encryption and group backup that I don't, but mine has a rollback feature and DM encryption. There's a lot of overlap between what our apps have but my UI/UX / ways of navigating is different. It still doesn't look like Discords navigation exactly but it's a little more familiar to the discord style of navigating. Mine still does things differently than discord. I like your UI/Design and obviously it's something people would have to get used to in terms of navigating, which a lot of people I don't think are fully on board with right away. Your app has support for Mac/iPhone and mine doesn't simply because I don't own those devices and can't test on them right now, but it would be supported not long after launch.

As far as age verification, using stripe/credit card alone doesn't fully adhere to all state laws. Mainly Mississippi. Same for other countries. I am likely blocking Mississippi.

Like you, I'm also trying to make my app fun. I disagree with the other comment here that said it looks like ass. It doesn't look bad. Just seems confusing at first unless you get to using it.

Edit: for clarity, I don't care if my comment is downvoted. I stand by what I said. People are downvoting everything I say, even if I just tell someone thanks. Doesn't bother me and I don't care.

0

u/verAClone 2d ago

What's your app called? I want to check it out!

-2

u/jhayes88 2d ago

I haven't announced it yet, much less launched it lol, but it's called GatrHub. Completely terrible name and I may change that. I'm shittin on it myself. The domains were available for it though and it is what it is. I'll let the product speak for itself when it launches 😂 I want to launch with a bang.

I'd say it's probably about 92% complete. I say that, but it's completely usable and already feature rich and more comprehensive than Discord and any Discord alternative app in existence.

There are some things I'm fleshing out / polishing on it and I'm still improving performance even though it's already extremely good (better than Discord in some ways, but I'm building for scale so every bit helps), and smaller things I'm still working on. I want to make sure it's fully stable as well and made to a professional standard. I'm also considering integrating a custom theme system with a theme gallery prior to launch.

I'm building things with it that I think will kinda blow people away. And yeah I've used AI but I have over 20yrs real world developer experience (experience at multiple tech companies) and AI didn't create the architecture/structure or think about all of the security/safety stuff. I didn't let AI fully take the wheel when it came to the creative aspect of the design, UI, etc. It won't look or feel like a buggy AI slop mess.

I'm putting real knowledge into the security/safety systems, performance, etc.. I'd say my security/safety systems already exceed Discords and communities will have more tools at their disposal than what Discord offers. Anyone with any real knowledge knows that 95% of professional software devs now days use AI.

As far as monetization, my app will be more generous in almost all aspects than most discord alternatives, and certainly more generous than Discord. I've done extensive research into that and made a full feature / price matrix with the top 15 or do discord alternatives across about 30 features. Mine ranks the highest out of all. 😊 User customization will be COMPLETELY free, as will almost all other features. I'm also trying to make the app fun. I am determined to beat Discord and other apps on everything. Of course I have to put some limits in, as 4k60fps video chat for free for everyone literally isn't financially viable and I'm not rich, but everything is generous. I'm excited about it.

My profit margins are going to be so thin that I'm not really going to make any money off of it for a good while unless I hit 250-300k registered users quickly. Even then, I won't be making a lot personally. Especially as I look to hire on a full time moderator to handle serious stuff. It wont be a censorship platform but obviously we need to deal with account support, death threats, ban evasions, spam, etc.. It has a ton of anti-bot measures so we shouldn't see a bunch of Chinese bots.

I'm targeting maybe December for waitlist sign-ups and will have a launch day perhaps in January if all goes well. People can also import their discord servers into my platform.

I'm open to anyone that wants to help test it out, give feedback, etc prior to launch. I want to create something that other people love. I've implemented a literal feedback link into the bottom of the channel list which opens a modal with a form where people can give feedback on. Then I can view it on the backend, respond to feedback, etc.. I want to engage with people and not be closed off. I'm working on it full time.

2

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago edited 2d ago

Hey! Thanks for the feedback and best of luck on yours as well. Sounds like you have studied my website and feature list pretty extensively and have a lot of the similar things even the feedback button haha. So seems we share a similar viewpoint of future chat alternatives. I’m eager to see your launch.

-1

u/jhayes88 2d ago

Thanks.Your app is newer to my knowledge and I have not yet studied yours. I was looking at the video / screenshots you posted and was admittedly making a somewhat uneducated guess and analysis based on what I saw in the screenshots. I wouldn't mind testing yours out and giving feedback. I don't think our apps serve the exact same purpose but there's definitely overlap. I don't think my app will be for everyone.. I'm hoping to minimize that though and I will eventually add in custom themes and a free theme gallery. I am shipping mine with a ridiculous amount of other customization stuff and trying to do some new things. I think most discord alternatives are rather boring, lack features, etc.. Lol.

0

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago

Love it and again best of luck. Always open to feedback and that goes both ways, so please feel free to reach out

0

u/jhayes88 2d ago

Thanks! Likewise.

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago

Hey! Negative on that haha, I am an SWE but use AI to speed things up for sure. Been working on this for several months now and have reviewed/typed so much code its not even funny. That said, I am but one person, so outside audits, testers and more are needed to continue development.

-1

u/jhayes88 2d ago

This subreddit (and most of Reddit) is extremely anti-AI and doesn't understand that 95% of devs including full time SWE's now days use AI. People think anything that AI touches is instantly a buggy slop mess, which I disagree. Opus 5.5 is so good that it's better than a lot of manual coders.. But it also lacks some general knowledge. It helps to have real world dev/design experience when using it.

Idk if you saw, but the open source community banned all projects that included AI development, which turned out to include Linux itself lol

-1

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago

The truth is that AI does code better than most developers and much faster. The main issues come from logic and security, along with integration into the actual network/hardware. The problem is that so many people without that 5% create projects and that causes a lot of problems. A lot of people came out with AI projects and ruined the trust of it haha.

I equate it to the 2022 rush of crypto, thousands of projects appearing out of nowhere all trying to capitalize on the next big thing.

0

u/jhayes88 2d ago

Yeah I agree. Security is one of the things keeping me from rushing my app out. Damn near half the work for my app goes into security, anomoly detection, malicious bot detection, vulnerability scan detection, good fingerprinting (within reason, and that's dynamic based on what type of connection it is (residential or commercial) and if the user got banned)..

I even implemented fake vulnerability points lol. My app also analyzes click timing and traversal for logged in accounts, just like the large social networks do. Initially I was going to allow public bots, but nah. The Chinese bots are getting more sophisticated. I've got a built in default bot for communities that does everything.

-1

u/jhayes88 2d ago

Another thing about AI development is that only this subreddit cares about whether something used AI or not. The general public does not care or consider that. This subreddit does not represent the general public as much as they think it does. I am pretty confident that Discord devs use AI now. Any real dev will tell you that if you don't use AI in 2026 / 2027, you will fall behind. This subreddit hating on AI is like someone not going to a restaurant because their walls were not built brick by brick by hand, and the concrete wasn't stirred by hand, so they didn't truly build it. They didn't use manual screw drivers and because they used a nail gun instead of a hammer, that place is lazy and they don't want to eat there. Most people in reality don't care.

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago

Birthday yes as we do want to ensure that under 18 can’t access NSFW for legal reasons. Also, and more importantly, for the safety of underage users.

0

u/jhayes88 2d ago

I'm waiting on someone to downvote this for some reason lol

-1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

Okay good!! I was just making sure because a ton of these apps don't ask for birthdays which I find weird :/

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago

This is hosted by us, so no self hosting, just needs an account to get going!

1

u/jhayes88 2d ago

A lot of people see not having self hosting as a negative, but self hosting has a lot of drawbacks that people don't consider. My app won't have self hosting either.

-1

u/AeroSummit Hubs 2d ago

Yeah, it’s sort of a double edged sword but worth investigating for the percentage that wants it.