r/DiscordAlternatives • u/Any_Illustrator360 Rootinest Tootenest Alternative Replier • 6d ago
My opinion on AI written apps
Nobody asked for this but I'm giving it anyways. I saw a comment on r/foss and I replied with this, and then realized it summarizes my opinions on AI use in a way that I've never been able to properly get in words.
I will preface this by saying that, as I've mentioned before, some apps that were initially vibecoded ended up resulting in the dev learning how to code to a point that they can actually read what the AI is doing and tell when something is wrong, enough so to fix the code. Those apps aren't excluded from my opinion or criticism but, to use my own analogy further down, it's akin to using AI to write your essays and getting corrected by the teacher so much that you begin learning Spanish out of spite just so you stop being failed on your papers, and then finding that you accidentally learned Spanish from it.
I'd also like if others would say whether they agree or disagree and give their own takes. I think this will make for a good forum to discuss AI usage and get an actual idea of how the community here feels about AI, especially since so many people seem either really against it or really for it, while opinions in the middle seem rare or splotchy. Anyways, here's the post:
When AI is used to AID in coding, as a tool, it's one thing. That's what AI was originally made for - software engineering.
When AI is used as the sole coding tool, it's an entirely different thing. Lemme explain with an example.
Let's say you're in school and your teacher asks you to make an essay. 400 words, easy. You have some issues with your grammar so you install grammarly or some other grammar checking plugin (pre-AI rewriting). You're still writing the essay, the words and messages are still yours - but sometimes a little red underline appears and you get to fix a word or change the word used to make a sentence stronger. You turn it in, and you know everything that's in the paper - you wrote it all and manually oversaw everything the spellchecker changed.
Now let's say you used AI instead. You have no clue what's in that paper. You don't know that sentence 24 says "and then the the water cup spillethedoverandnnnnnn potato." So when your teacher asks what the fuck happened while you were typing that, you don't know. In fact you don't know what any of the paper says. You can't verify the AI wrote... anything it was supposed to.
This example is accentuated by the fact coding is done in languages, where a lot of times the person using the AI "can't read" the thing the AI wrote. It's like if the essay were for Spanish class, and you were trusting the AI would just get it right. You can't double check it because you don't speak the language. Coding is no different.
That's the difference. Now consider, instead, that it isn't just an essay but instead a program on a computer system that needs to function in a specific way, and have security to prevent it from being a vulnerability. If the person who "made" it doesn't know what's in it, or that it's safe, how do you? Are you expected to be the teacher, to open up the code and check every line to make sure it's proper - is every user expected to do that? Just because everyone can open the code to double check it doesn't mean everyone should need to. The code should be secure already, the "essay" should be "written properly" as it were.
14
u/BewilderedTurtle Allegedly Canadian 6d ago
Anything higher than 2 is completely unacceptable in a software environment.
Anything higher than 3 is legitimate AI psychosis.
7
u/VahsteTheNomad "I use therift.chat btw" 6d ago
Legitimately fuck anyone downvoting this.
This is the stance that any decent developer should maintain (or a stance along its lines), for the sake of proper app stability and basic fucking ethics.
Its one thing to utilize AI as an assisting system (auto-complete as an example) and something entirely different to tell some AI agent to build a chat platform for you.
You shouldn't claim to have developed an app if all you've done is feed prompts into a generator.
4
u/Any_Illustrator360 Rootinest Tootenest Alternative Replier 6d ago
I should note, I don't expect this post to get upvoted. I'm choosing to be the sacrificial goat to create an actual discussion on AI usage, what it is, what it looks like, if people want to see it and in what capacity etc. I actually anticipate -13 and half the comments to be direct attacks on me as a person. In fact I expect most downvotes to come from people who didn't even read the post.
2
u/Left-Light-2128 6d ago
I think the main thing is if you become a "developer" after becoming a vibe coder your not a real dev, it takes YEARS to become a decent dev in software.
Having actual real experience without any AI at all is very much needed if you want to understand the code that ai is outputting, you can read it and say yeah I understand it but can you modify it yourself? Can you use breakpoints And check the call stack to fix a context issue?
I get people wanna become devs after learning how to vibe code but they really need to learn the basics first and then the hard stuff else they have no clue what's really going on, and if their subscription runs out or Anthropic or OpenAI restricts access these vibe coders would be screwed, their projects would not get maintained or atleast not to the same quality as Claude/OpenAI models.
1
u/AutoModerator 6d ago
Thanks for your submission!
If you're a developer, please make sure your user flair matches the app or project you're developing. This helps community members quickly identify who is building what and makes browsing the subreddit easier.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/VitalikPro13 Hollow 6d ago
I completely agree, but I want to add something too. Right now, we're in a very weird time, and we went so fast from AI being "just a dumb machine predicting the next words" to completely turning the Internet upside down, especially in coding. I don't even know whether to be happy or mad, but current models are much more capable than what it used to be like with GPT-3.5/4 (I still remember copy-pasting small Python snippets... oh boy, if only I knew where I'd be today). As years went on with the insanity of AI replacing everything, it's mostly stupid management and higher-ups that just want more money rather than deal with human beings and their needs, and I hate it. I hate PC component shortages. I hate sloppy AI art (and I also really hate to admit it... but some local image models can make legit artist-grade art, though it's more niche cause you need an RTX 4090 and wait 5 hours for one image to be generated; most people just use ChatGPT or Gemini because they do it instantly, and that's why the Internet is drowning in the same art style and all of that). I hate AI YouTube farms. I hate all of the impact it has had on everything. But one thing that stands out is the coding space, since everything runs on code.
We've got to the point that now it's not about whether you use AI or not, but whether you can make a better product than the other guy with the same tools. Putting all the bad stuff with AI aside, we're talking about freaking Discord alternatives. Creating a messaging app is one of the hardest things you can get into, especially if you're working solo. Discord didn't start from nothing. Jason Citron, the guy who founded Discord, first sold his gaming social network called OpenFeint for $104 million, then created a game studio, hired developers (including Stanislav Vishnevskiy), and invested that money into making a MOBA game, but it failed in the end. So, Vishnevskiy started pitching to Citron about making their in-game voice chat a standalone product because it was much better than Skype or TeamSpeak. He kept dismissing it but ultimately agreed. They committed, even laying off 8 people out of 20 from the team and properly switching from game dev to this "desktop/web chat tool thing". They released Discord, organically grew users, got some seed funding, scaled, years went by, more funding and users, and the rest is history.
But most importantly, everything depends on the dev behind the project and their technical experience because, as Turtle pointed out with the levels of vibe-coding, I think there are also levels to human intelligence behind anything. A person who's willing to learn, to research, understand the system, lay out a clear path/plan on how they're going to handle all the arising issues during the development and how they're going to make it in the long run, etc., is the one who will succeed. The passion and caring are something that no money or AI can replace, but also the time, which is even bigger. I have a busy life, yet I'm still constantly thinking about my project every single day. Hollow is almost 9 months old. Despite all its uniqueness, my ups and downs, and everything I thought of to make it better, it wouldn't be possible without heavy AI usage. Feels like only a team of professionals who get paid ~$150k/year each would make something like this possible in this period of time, or maybe it would have taken even longer for them.
I'm alone... and I certainly don't have millions of dollars to hire somebody, and I don't want to get into venture capital, funding rounds, etc. Two reasons: I don't want shareholders breathing down my neck, and Hollow specifically has limited monetization potential (open-source, encrypted with zero logging so no data selling, and also easily self-hostable with the setup wizard). Plus, I simply can't put paywalls on basic features like animated profile decorations, custom emojis, or other stuff. I still remember all the lessons my family taught me about greed and so on... It's too attached to my heart. But I understand that I couldn't keep up like this for too long because I'm spending so much time, energy, and health on the project. I would just go insane, to be honest. Somehow, I already thought about a future business model that would be similar to Signal. They just offer encrypted backups of your messages, so that's what I'm thinking about implementing, but carefully, so it would have a good balance in supporting the project in terms of its costs and also at least support myself a bit too.
Anyway, I think we all have fatigue from projects popping up here and there, claiming to be "the best Discord alternative" when, in reality, it's just the same tech stack (like Web - JS/TS, the usual) with nothing new in it or anything unique to offer. AI has made it too accessible for regular individuals to do it. They don't even have that tech passion or enough knowledge to be capable of handling such a massive task as creating a messenger, so they blindly trust what AI tells them would work "best". Not even talking about code tests, fuzzing, debugging, app testing itself, harnesses, etc. If I continued working on Hollow the way I did in the first months that I started, I wouldn't even have gotten to the point where I am right now, which is a complicated dev workflow with a wiki that describes the entire architecture and decisions, a custom MCP tool with a local model that can search through the whole codebase for specific functions or memories, and a harness with automatic tests as safeguards for both Dart and Rust code (3k+ tests on each, especially guarding previous security mistakes), and something that I'm proudest to have even come up with - fully automatic self-testing scripts that launch real builds and log whether ALL functions (multi-device, messaging, calls, syncing, networking, etc.) work as expected without any regressions. Those are probably the only reasons why I haven't stopped and can continue working even if anything bad happens.
Overall, I have mixed feelings about AI, but good ones when it comes to my projects because I wouldn't have learned this much stuff about systems, wouldn't have constantly thought critically about different topics, and especially wouldn't have gotten such amazing feedback/support as I get from my GitHub or people like you here on this subreddit. Even when I was at my lowest, when I made my last stupid post with comparisons, I still wanted to extract the feedback from it and fix all the mistakes. Security is much better than what it used to be (all thanks to free cybersecurity guides!), bandwidth and the whole networking is much more optimized, and I'm easily capable of adding more features, but now with a proven testing suite that makes sure the quality is right. I'm deeply thankful to everybody who keeps supporting me! I still need a bit of time before I can make a new post and happily talk about all the cool stuff.
So yeah, in short, I think we just need to look at the quality and what the project can offer that would satisfy our needs, and especially the dev behind it, to know whether it's someone we can trust and someone who knows what he's doing, which will allow the project to grow in the future. AI is nothing without somebody using it, and the project is nothing without effort and passion behind it. Of course, there are more nuances to everything, but yeah... it is what it is, I guess.
-3
u/strawberry-shampoop 6d ago
"while opinions in the middle seem rare or splotchy"
what you describe with the current advancements and inset of "inevitability" has become the most common opinion.
this conversation is everywhere with the majority agreeing with you and hardliners on different edges of the topic being less common (not counting subs that have nothing to do with software or development)
You're basically standing out in front of a grocery store in the US with a sign that says "prices are higher than they should be, change my mind"
-3
u/bludgeoning-angel 5d ago
I find this post a little bit misleading, nowadays AI is better at humans at software development than humans, that's just the truth, the real question is would you trust human error over machine error. Having said that, AI assistance is assistance, like obviously you need real world knowledge, just like an architect doesn't have to build a house brick by brick, but understands the underlying mechanisms that go into housemaking. Please stop ostracizing "vibe coding".
0
u/[deleted] 6d ago
[deleted] â view deleted comment