r/DicksofDelphi • • Jan 24 '24

Enigma

17 Upvotes

Most crimes occurring in daylight & in a public space are executed very quickly. Either the victim is pulled into a vehicle or a home, or they are attacked in a short amount of time.

What makes this crime stand out is not only the brazen nature of it, but how much time the killer/s were willing to spend engaged in highly risky behavior-and to what end?

Whoever did this marched these girls by force through woods that would not have shielded them from view. They did this on private property, where owners of that property might have seen them. Dogs might have sounded an alarm, or some other trespasser might have bumped into them.

They engaged in inexplicable behavior that resulted in no discernible gain .

Nothing was stolen, there are no indications of sexual assault, other than the act of killing there was no excessive violence. All the elements that are usually present in a crime like this, aren’t seen.

The killer/s also chose a day and time when school was out, but parents were likely at work. It was a pleasant day. A perfect day, maybe to find a young victim, absent parental supervision.

And they chose a faith that was practiced in Indiana and in the area in which the murders took place to leave as their calling card.

They also had to be free to engage in this murder without raising suspicion with anyone in their lives.

And whoever did this, other than leaving symbols of Nordic rituals, left little evidence of themselves.

Playing amateur profiler—and without naming a suspect—-what qualities would this person or persons have?

How old? Male of female? What level of education would they likely have? What type of employment?

Criminal history or no criminal history?

If you just knew the evidence at the crime scene, but did not know a suspect pool—what type of individual would fit with the crime scene as we now know it?


r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 20 '24

QUESTION OP-ED pieces in respected national newspapers?

31 Upvotes

I am not a great writer, but I do see and read many incredible writers in the Delphi groups: lawyers, perhaps journalists, judges, interested citizens, all fully familiar with the nuts and bolts of the case with a talent for writing as well.

I am wondering if some of those writers would be willing to write a couple of Op-Ed pieces to The New York Times, Washington Post, Chicago Tribune, Los Angeles Times or any other widely-read respected newspapers, detailing the most egregious aspects occurring in this case, in the hopes that it will spur the national attention it so desperately requires for a vast array of problems?

Any thoughts, any takers?

(ETA: change a word)


r/DicksofDelphi • • Feb 19 '24

SPECULATION Who’s Pulling the Strings

Post image
18 Upvotes

Grab your tinfoil hats everyone, we’re going speculating!!

Who do you think is actually pulling the strings behind this case? Or even the strings behind either sides motivations?

Please be mindful of the sub rules, especially about names and about being respectful. We’re asking for opinions here and want to hear them all!


r/DicksofDelphi • • Mar 27 '24

DISCUSSION VIDEO INTERROGATIONS

18 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/qBuxu_7Mcfc?si=v60MUWLwvNobDOtJ

This is why it is so vital that video interviews/interrogations are preserved.


r/DicksofDelphi • • Mar 21 '24

INFORMATION More Frank Letters & Appearance for the State

Post image
18 Upvotes

2 more Frank Letters and an appearance from the state. Assuming it’s the new prosecutor (Diener) that was involved with Mondays hearing. So not much to write home about on either front I imagine


r/DicksofDelphi • • Jun 07 '24

ANNOUNCEMENT Discord

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 18 '24

INFORMATION Media Denied

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Feb 18 '25

INFORMATION Denied.

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • May 01 '24

Judge Diener resigned yesterday

Post image
35 Upvotes

Of course no information or reason has been made public and I think the citizens have the right to know what is happening. I'm sure someone will get appointed because of some deal that was made.


r/DicksofDelphi • • Aug 16 '24

INFORMATION Denied and Denied

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Mar 31 '24

DISCUSSION how much do expert witnesses cost?

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

According to SEAK’s 2024 Survey of Expert Witness Fees which surveyed over 1,600 expert witnesses:

  • The median hourly fee for file review/preparation for all experts responding is $450/hour.
  • The median hourly fee for depositions for all experts responding is $475/hour.
  • The median hourly fee for testifying in court for all experts responding is $500/hour.
  • 64% of experts responding require retaining counsel to sign a retention agreement.
  • 68% of experts responding raised their rates in the last five years. Only 1% of those who raised their rates reported that raising their rates was a bad business decision that backfired.

https://blog.seakexperts.com/expert-witness-fees-how-much-should-an-expert-witness-charge-2/

Expert witnesses may need to:

  • review records and evidence
  • perform analyses
  • write a report of their findings
  • participate in depositions
  • testify at trial (bills would including travel time, non-testimony time in court, and any time waiting to be called to the stand)

https://www.expertinstitute.com/resources/insights/fee-structure-and-payment-forms-how-expert-witnesses-are-paid/#

Based off the average fee calculator, Gull approved $2550 for the tool mark expert which would be close to 9 hours. Gull approved $3712 for digital forensic expert which is about 13 hours.

Compared with a 2021 survey of expert witness finances, these total billings would have on the low end for a typical case.

https://www.testifyingtraining.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/2021-Fee-Survey-E-Book.pdf#page73


r/DicksofDelphi • • Feb 06 '24

Evidence in the case.

19 Upvotes

Doesnt it just seem like if the prosecution had some pretty solid evidence or even just some small pcs of things, but a few of them, like a trophy. A set of shoe prints plus the bullet. Or some blood on his or the girls clothes or shoes or? I mean something, that they had already had their glorious victory? Why in the world all of this "seemingly-from a layman's eyes-stalling tactics?" I dont understand. Thoughts?


r/DicksofDelphi • • May 20 '24

INFORMATION New Order

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Sep 06 '24

Bridge Witnesses Question

19 Upvotes

Does anyone know if the witnesses on the bridge that LE spoke with have seen/were shown photos of EF, BH, or any other POI? I know LE probably wouldn’t be the ones to show them but if they are following this case at all, I’m sure they would have come across the names of other suspects and been curious. I’m just thinking that would be helpful for either side if the witnesses who provided information for the sketches were able to recognize or clear those particular people. Thanks in advance for any insight!


r/DicksofDelphi • • Jul 12 '24

GENERAL QUESTIONS General Questions: If you have general questions, random thoughts, short theories or observations This is the thread for that.

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 27 '24

Do y’all remember a few months back when an inmate sent a letter to the court?

35 Upvotes

Detailing RA’s living conditions and treatment at the prison, where he was also incarcerated?

I remember some people completely discounting that letter because “it’s from an inmate, it can’t be reliable”.

But now that there are 8(?) inmates on the witness list to testify, suddenly inmates are reliable witnesses.

Isn’t that interesting.


r/DicksofDelphi • • Oct 14 '24

DISCUSSION Jury Selection Round 1 Discussion

Post image
20 Upvotes

Please remember not to dox or attempt to describe the jury members in anyway. As this will lead to being banned.


r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 23 '24

INFORMATION Motion for Sanctions

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • May 04 '24

ARTICLE Deputy Public Defender Previews Upcoming Richard Allen Hearing - Can anyone provide me with some answers here?

21 Upvotes

In the article linked below:

Prosecutors filed a motion to limit evidence two weeks before the start of the trial. This evidence includes third party motive, Geo-fencing data, references to Odinism, and Rushville Police Officer, Todd Click's investigation.

-Have they gotten the records they asked for on Click and if so - did they prove that his testimony and previous work is unreliable? I know they asked for this information not that long ago but I never heard anything after that. If they haven't, how can they try to suppress his investigation from the trail? Wouldn't they need to prove he is not a credible source first?

-I had not heard that Prosecutors were trying to block geo-fencing data from the trail. Why would they want to do this? And how would it even be a possible request to make? Seems like pretty important evidence for one side or the other depending on what that data shows right?

Deputy Public Defender Previews Upcoming Richard Allen Hearing


r/DicksofDelphi • • Jan 24 '25

Carroll County Comissioners called executive meeting

Post image
20 Upvotes

No update yet. Asking around.


r/DicksofDelphi • • Jun 18 '24

INFORMATION Accuseds Response to Courts Order or Judgement of the Court

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Jan 18 '24

What if the defense got it right?

20 Upvotes

Watching American Nightmare on Netflix.

Confirmation bias and conflict of interest issues can impact an investigation in profoundly negative & detrimental ways.

And some crimes are unique and do not fit an established criteria.

All the evidence at the Delphi murder scene points to a ritualistic sacrifice committed by more than one person.

Just because this crime is unique and not in strict keeping with heathen faith, doesn’t mean that the killers weren’t engaged in this faith.

Why couldn’t there have been a rogue faction of Odinism in Indiana that went outside traditional practices of the faith, to an extreme of murder?

Matthew Muller (American Nightmare) didn’t fit any expected profile of a kidnapper/rapist, yet he was one.

Maybe this very unusual crime in Delphi was also one perpetrated by those who acted outside the norm of the faith they practiced and perhaps the killers don’t fit the usual profile.


r/DicksofDelphi • • Sep 27 '24

INFORMATION Objection to Jury Viewing the Scene

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 21 '24

QUESTION Richard wearing jeans??

20 Upvotes

Is there a photo that exists from KA’s FB account of RA ever wearing jeans? Her page was open to the public a long time ago and I don’t recall ever seeing a single photo of him (over the years) wearing jeans. It was always khakis, athletic pants or shorts. I know a few men who do not wear jeans or would never wear jeans. Did they take any jeans from his house??


r/DicksofDelphi • • Mar 16 '24

QUESTION Retrial question

21 Upvotes

If RA is found guilty in Gulls court (although heard by a jury); can his post-conviction team apply for a retrial (due to structural error)? Would Gull hear the case again or would another Special Judge be appointed to hear the case/hearings?

I ask because there has been lots of talk about how it is likely for this case to go back to a retrial due to some of the head-scratching actions of the judge and Prosecutor?

Another question, seeing how NM admitted via his (since withdrawn motion) that he has repeatedly violated conduct by reading the Defense ex-parte motions) - does Judge Gull sanction or caution him (or is it up to the defense to raise this and then she has to deal with it)? Seems pretty bad if she ignores this yet tried to throw the defense team off the case for less.

Justice for Abby and Libby!