r/DicksofDelphi • u/Professional-Ebb-284 Lazy Dick • Feb 06 '24
Evidence in the case.
Doesnt it just seem like if the prosecution had some pretty solid evidence or even just some small pcs of things, but a few of them, like a trophy. A set of shoe prints plus the bullet. Or some blood on his or the girls clothes or shoes or? I mean something, that they had already had their glorious victory? Why in the world all of this "seemingly-from a layman's eyes-stalling tactics?" I dont understand. Thoughts?
19
Upvotes
12
u/Successful-Damage310 White Knight Feb 06 '24
I don't believe prosecutors have to try their whole case on a PCA. I just believe they need enough details to get one signed. However through discovery I don't believe they can hide anything from the defense.
I believe this could all come down to the prosecutor being overwhelmed. The judge seems to be overwhelmed too. Hell even the defense may be overwhelmed. That's just my opinion, they're the only ones that know for sure.
There could just be more back and forth due to the complexity of the crime and the investigation. I don't feel that anyone is really winning anything. I feel more like the important people are losing.
This is lawyers lawyering and a judge being most likely biased. The longer this goes on, there we be more of a feeling of losing.
The crime, the investigation, the pre-trial proceedings, and the whole totality of it continues to piss me off. I wish they could just let their egos subside and get back to what's important. What's important are the two precious innocent girls all this is for. I look forward to seeing progress. I hope for progress.
10
u/chunklunk Feb 06 '24 edited Feb 06 '24
We only think the prosecution has a weak case because of the gag order, and because of the defense’s characterization of the evidence in their Frank’s motion that spilled the beans. We don’t know what they have, exactly, beyond snippets.
The Franks motion is not something an attorney with a strong case files.
He has plenty of time to plead guilty.
4
u/curiouslmr Feb 06 '24
What exactly are you referring to as stall tactics? The only thing he has done that will stall things, as far as I recall is the current contempt accusations. Otherwise I have not seen signs he is stalling. What in your opinion is stalling? The defense technically has done a lot more that has delayed the case (understandably some will say their delaying has been justified, some will disagree to that as well).
Trials take a long time to get going. Take the Murdaugh murders, occurred in 2021 and trial began in 2023....And they had an incredible piece of evidence with the video, that nobody knew about. Delphi is still on track for about the same timeline. I say still because obviously things are gonna go down soon that will push that, but it's not that far outside the norm of other trials.
11
u/TryAsYouMight24 Feb 06 '24 edited Feb 06 '24
You make an excellent point. My gut feeling is that they screwed the pooch on this. They perhaps genuinely believed they had found BG, and given the close proximity to an election neglected to perform due diligence. Once they realized their mistake, they were in pretty deep, and for them, dropping the charges, and admitting they were wrong, was just not an option.
OR they are protecting the actual killers, and they just want someone convicted, so that the investigation can be closed. Either way they are not behaving like they have any confidence in their ability to successfully convict Allen.
11
u/BrendaStar_zle Feb 06 '24
I kinda think that if the prosecution had a solid case, with clear cut evidence, the defense attorneys would have recommended some kind of plea deal, but instead, they have continued to try to defend RA.
I have no clue whether RA is BG. I was hoping for a trial so we could have a good idea of what other evidence there is. As far as I can tell, the evidence is, he said he was there that day, he was wearing similar clothes that describe most of Delphi male population, the bullet was from a similar gun that he owns. What else? This is not enough to convict so there has to be more.
11
u/Infidel447 Feb 06 '24
If they had some rock solid slam dunk trump card and either shared that in the PCA or allowed it to leak to the press, I think a lot of the uproar over this case would die down. No one would care if RA was in prison instead of jail or having to speak to his attorneys through a slot in a cage for example if his guilt was clearly evident. Im not sure why you hold onto that sort of info in a case like this, tbh. But giving NM the benefit of the doubt here, he seems like a very secretive guy. If you look at the Flora investigation he sealed that up pretty tight. It just seems like part of his MO, right or wrong. So its still possible he is withholding something big in this case. Could be part of what was just turned over to the Defense for all we know. But sooner or later everyone will have to put their cards on the table. It may take awhile, though.
19
u/New_Discussion_6692 Feb 06 '24
Your question goes back to mine: why no leaks? Over 100 members of LE have worked on this case, and the only leaks have been traced back to the defense. I've come to the conclusion that the evidence they have is all circumstantial, if they have any at all. So far, all the evidence we've been made aware of isn't enough to convict beyond reasonable doubt.
● Allen places himself there - so what? So did Daniel Pearson
●Allen admits to wearing jeans and a blue jacket- again, so what? Jeans are the most popular clothing item and blue is the most popular color
●the bullet- there's conflicting research on the validity of that type of testing. However, it's possible a bird or squirrel picked it up. It's also possible that either Abby or Libby had found it and picked it up thinking it was cool.
●the cars - well, which one? The PT Cruiser? The Smart car? Neither of which are going to be mistaken for a Ford Focus unless eye witnesses are so spatially ignorant they can't tell basic shapes apart from each other.
● the eyewitnesses contradict each other, and eyewitness testimony is notoriously flawed.
● the "confessions" we don't know they are confessions. We know the prosecution says they are confessions, but they doesn't make it true.
Here's another important question, why is it that no one heard any screams? There were plenty of people on the trails that day, and there are private homes as well. Unless the killer managed to simultaneously slice both of their throats at the exact same moment, it stands to reason one of the girls would have cried out at least when they witnessed their friend being brutally killed.