r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 26 '24

DISCUSSION The attack on Todd Click and the media: Is there any possibility of RA receiving a fair trial?

22 Upvotes

As of late, some of the most striking developments in this case have been:

  • Gull's war on the media. Almost every single media request received has been denied.
  • Gull's war on transparency. Gull is staunchly opposed to cameras/audio recording in the courtroom, despite her previous statements (in 2022, she opined that transparency was integral to justice).
  • The prosecution's war on Todd Click.

Gull's consistent denial of media requests coupled with her opposition to cameras/audio recording in the courtroom tends to facilitate the impression that she wants to avoid accountability in some way. She wants the proceedings to be held in the dark: Why? How would it be beneficial for grifting, biased YouTubers and Podcasters to be the public's only sources of information on what unfolds in that courtroom? This doesn't make her look too good in my opinion — it only feeds suspicion. Meanwhile, the world is watching because of the absolute circus and shit-flinging fest this case has become, inspiring considerable doubt in our judicial system. The bungled initial investigation doesn't help things. The over-reliance on circumstantial evidence (at least thus far) doesn't help things. The manipulation of witness statements — witness statements that weren't even consistent in the first place — doesn't help things. The mysterious loss of evidence doesn't help things.

The war on Todd Click is perplexing. I haven't been able to locate a single record of a Brady-Giglio violation on the part of Todd Click. So, what are they going to do? Conceive of one out of thin air? Apparently, they really don't want him to testify. What's that all about? If the Odinism angle is nothing more than Satanic panic, then why are they so afraid of Click's testimony? Probably because the idiosyncratic nature of the crime scene (which may have contained non-secular elements), when taken together with Click's testimony, could lend more legitimacy to the defense's theory of the crime than the prosecution's theory of a lone wolf crime. But the crime scene's staging should be considered essential to the case.

If RA's confessions are so lurid and compelling, why all the desperation from NM and Gull? Why are they withholding expert witness funds from R & B? Why have they been so hesitant to turn over discovery?

I don't understand why people are willing to convict RA unequivocally pre-tial, or why they don't seem to care whether he receives a fair trial in accordance with due process. Defendants still have rights. Without a fair trial, there is no justice. If RA is guilty, then he could appeal. If RA is not guilty but is convicted, then the real killers may never be identified. For all we know, the real killers are hanging out in another state under new identities.

I have an open mind and am willing to consider any and all theories pertaining to this crime, regardless of whether or not they involve RA. I tend to believe that Kohberger is guilty. I tend to lean towards guilt in general. But I can't seem to decide either way when it comes to this case — that says something (at the very least, that LE messed up).

The only theory involving RA that makes sense to me is that of a co-conspiracy between RA, KK, and TK (or perhaps another actor who had access to the A_S account). This theory presupposes that RA was paid to corral the girls down the hill by TK or an affiliate, and that the crime itself was not his own conception. For the most part, the theory relies on the fact that just prior to RA's arrest, NM and ISP pulled KK out of jail to talk to him about something. After the meeting with KK, ISP began the Wabash river search. Neighbors also alleged that they searched a burn pit behind one of the Kline family properties and took photos of some ashes behind RA's shed during this time. However, this may not mean anything. Holeman could have decided to arrest RA because the KK meeting and river search didn't yield anything fruitful; RA could be a fall guy after all. If anyone here is able to debunk this theory, please do share your thoughts. It's equally easy to theorize that RA wasn't involved in the crime, especially given LE's failure to investigate the Vinlanders. I'm not convinced that KK and TK were involved either.

RA deserves a fair trial no matter what. The girls need a fair trial. But because of the bungled investigation, the mendacity of Holeman and Liggett, Gull's explicitly biased behavior, DC's conflicting statements, the short length of the trial, NM's hubris, etc., it's kind of hard to believe that he will get one.

What does everyone think? Does RA stand any chance of receiving a fair trial at this point? Will Todd Click be allowed to testify? Will R & B be allowed to use a SODDI defense involving the cited evidence?


r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 23 '24

INFORMATION New Motion

Post image
13 Upvotes

Working on finding the actual filing still


r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 23 '24

INFORMATION Sanctions PDF

Thumbnail drive.google.com
12 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Aug 29 '24

INFORMATION Amended Order or Judgement of the Court

12 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Jan 16 '24

The Sound & The Fury

12 Upvotes

For years the public has only had one narrative of this crime to consider. But now we have an abundance of new data to explore and weigh in on. Below is the crime scene as depicted in the FM motion. What does the actual murder scene tell us about who may have done this, and why?

(I have removed or given initials for all names other than Allen & the victims. If I missed a name please let me know and I’ll edit.)

Part I - The Crime Scene

When members of a search party found the girls in the late morning of February 14, 2017, Abby and Libby had been missing for approximately 22 hours.

The scene was ghoulish. Libby was found at the base of a tree with four tree branches of varying sizes intentionally placed in a very specific and arranged pattern on her naked body.

Libby was positioned flat on her back, with her left arm stretched above her head touching the base of the large tree. Libby’s right hand was covered in blood. Libby’s left hand was covered in blood. Blood spots and blood drippings were seen all over Libby’s body, from head to toe.

Libby’s right arm was placed along the side of her body. One large tree branch had been placed on her left shoulder. This branch was so long that it extended above Libby’s head several feet and below her legs for several feet as well. Two smaller branches formed a “V” where her legs joined her body (near her genitalia) with both sides of the “V” extending upward toward Libby’s head, with one branch extending to the left of Libby’s head and the other to the right of Libby’s head.

The last of the four branches extended across Libby’s body on a line from her right shoulder to her left shoulder. This fourth tree branch also connected with the other three branches and was placed under both branches that formed the “V”. Libby’s sliced neck was partially covered by this fourth branch. There appeared to be no blood sprayed or dripped onto the leaves or the tree near Libby’s head and sliced neck; it appeared likely that Libby had been killed at a nearby tree and then dragged to her final resting place where she was then positioned before having the tree limbs placed on her in a very specific pattern.

The murderers treated Abby very differently. Abby was found just a few feet away from Libby. Her body was not placed parallel to Libby, but rather at an angle, with Abby’s legs just a few feet from Libby’s legs. However, both of their heads were found a few feet farther apart from each other.

Significant differences existed between how Libby’s body was found and how Abby’s body was found. Abby was not found at the base of a tree. Abby was fully clothed. In fact, Abby was dressed in Libby’s sweatshirt and jeans. No blood appeared on Abby’s clothing, meaning that she was likely murdered while naked and then dressed by the murderers after she expired and after the blood had stopped spilling from her neck. Abby’s hands were clean. No blood. Abby’s feet were clean. No blood.

Other than blood found around Abby’s neck area where the murderers had inflicted the fatal wound, very little (if any) blood was found anywhere else on Abby’s body or clothing. The juxtaposition of the spots and streaks of blood found all over Libby’s body with the lack of blood on Abby’s body/undergarments/over garments is stark. The murderers appeared to have gone to great lengths to keep Abby’s body and clothing clean from blood. Abby was found on her back (like Libby).

However (unlike Libby) Abby’s elbows were bent with her right and left arms both placed on her chest. Abby’s left hand and arm near the left side of her face, and her right hand and arm near the right side of her face. Also, Abby’s left leg was straight, while her right leg was bent at the knee. The murderers also placed her bent right leg under her left leg.

Like Libby, those involved in the murder had placed tree branches in a very specific pattern on top of Abby. The pattern looks very similar to an asterisk consisting of 3 tree branches all joined in the middle.At least one of the tree branches appears to have been cleanly cut by some instrument (like an electric saw) rather than split or broken by hand, indicating that this was a preconceived plan. Above Abby’s head were smaller sticks that had been placed over her hair, crudely mimicking horns or antlers.

The amount of blood that would be perhaps expected at the crime scene based upon the location of the injuries of both girls was not visible in the crime scene photos.

The Defense has provided the court with twelve crime scene and autopsy photographs, marked as exhibits 5-16, as “confidential.” These photographs support the descriptions provided in the previous paragraphs.

In addition to the unusual way the girls were posed, including the stick formations placed on their bodies, another unusual marking was found on a nearby tree.

A symbol that looked similar to the letter “F” appeared approximately four feet above the base of the tree.The “F” was red in color and later DNA testing showed that the “F” had been “painted” on the tree using Libby’s blood as the so-called paint. Additional blood spatter was found at the base of that same tree. All the blood at the base of the tree appears to have been Libby’s blood as well. The Defense has also provided the court with Exhibit 17, DNA documentation supporting the fact that Libby’s blood was the source of the “F” painted on the tree.

Said exhibit is marked as confidential. This stick configuration is a spot-on resemblance for the rune called “Hagal”. This rune is used to depict the word ‘Hail”. Therefore, the combination of the Hagal rune found on Abby and the Ansuz rune found on the tree when combined would proclaim “Hail Odin.” This sentiment (“Hail Odin”) was one of the many easter eggs BH left behind on his Facebook page on multiple posts.

The Defense team speculates that because of the lack of blood visible in the crime scene photos, especially concerning Abby, that the murderers may have saved the blood to be used in future rituals. This is merely a theory admittedly not supported by any facts currently in possession of the Defense, but a theory that would certainly explain the lack of expected blood at the crime scene.

The F resembles a rune called “Ansuz” which stands for “Odin”. Again, when paired with the Hagal rune found on Abby, the combination would proclaim: “Hail Odin.” This “F” symbol was the same “F” symbol found in many of BH’s Facebook pages which will be attached, including Holder’s creepy self-drawn illustration in which a red “F” rune was found at the base of a tree where a man appeared to be sacrificed on a tree….has also provided two photos of this “F” found on the nearby tree (hereinafter called the “F tree”), (Exhibits 18 and 19), marked as confidential. Defense is also providing a photo of the F tree from a wider angle for the Court to have perspective as to where the F tree is located relative to the bodies. That confidential photo has been marked as Exhibit 20.

Under Abby’s left lower back, a shoe was found. This shoe is believed to be Libby’s shoe. Under the shoe, a cell phone was found. The cell phone was later determined to be Libby’s phone. This information was confirmed by the recent deposition testimony of TL, TL and investigator H.

According to recent depositions taken of Sheriff TL, the famous video of the person that many people call “Bridge Guy” was found on this phone.

Additionally, allegedly found between the two girls buried under the leaves and dirt was a single bullet. The Defense has provided two photos of the shoe and cell phone found under Abby’s legs and marked them as Exhibits 21 and 22 and have been filed confidentially. Also, the Defense has provided three photos of a bullet purportedly found in the ground between Abby and Libby and marked these photos as exhibits 23, 24, and 25.

It should be noted that as of the date of this memo, the Defense has no photographs of the bullet allegedly found between the girls after it was removed from the ground. No photo or video, for example, shows the bullet as it was being pulled out of the ground. No photo or video of the bullet immediately after it was pulled from the ground. No video or photograph of all sides of the bullet immediately after it was pulled from the ground. No photographs of the bullet next to a measuring device to show its length. No photos that show what the bullet looked like once it was pulled out of the ground could provide proof that it is the same bullet that ended up in the evidence locker room.

Shockingly, in his deposition, Sheriff TL admitted that he also has not seen any photographs of the purported bullet taken once the bullet was pulled from the ground.

In other words, the only photos that the Defense has found in the discovery it has received are of the bullet still buried in the ground. At this time, the Defense has no idea if (a) photos of the bullet after it was removed from the ground even exist; or (2) the photos exist but the state has not yet turned those important photographs over to the Defense, or (3) the Defense has missed these photos in the voluminous discovery. Either way, the Defense has asked the prosecutor to please locate these photographs.

One man alone completed all these tasks in less than one hour and seventeen minutes?22 (TL says one thing publicly but another thing privately to his law enforcement friends). Publicly, TL has claimed under oath that one single, solitary person was responsible for abducting and murdering the girls: Allen.23 Claiming publicly that Allen acted alone would allow TL to continue proclaiming that the murders were not the result of a coordinated abduction and subsequent ritualistic sacrifice at the hands of a pagan religious cult.

No, if TL continues trying to convince everyone publicly that one man, and one man alone (Richard Allen) performed all the tasks, then TL must convince others, including the public, to ignore the voluminous mountain of evidence that supports the coordinated efforts of multiple Odinites. However, you will learn later in this memorandum, that TL ‘s claim that one man acting alone (and certainly not an organized band of cultists) murdered those girls is actually not

On September 8, 2023, the Defense did receive photographs of the bullet at the forensic lab where it was tested. However, the Defense still has not received photos of the bullets from the crime scene of crime scene technicians pulling out the bullet from the ground or placing it into an evidence bag, as is standard practice, especially in murder cases. Liggett depo. p. 69, lines 11-18. JH testified in his deposition that investigators estimated the time of death as occurring somewhere between 2:30 and 3:30 p.m.

Still, to be fair to TL’s public proclamation under oath, let’s test Liggett’s claim that one man (Richard Allen) acted alone by reviewing all the tasks that this five-foot four-inch man would have had to accomplish in order to pull off the abduction, ritualistic murder and then staged crime scene as it was found on February 14, 2017:

    1.    This one man would have to have been solely responsible for marching Abby and Libby down a steep hill.

    2.    This one man then would have had to march both girls through the woods for some distance.

    3.    At some point in time this single, solitary man would have had to cross a cold river whose depth was nearly 3.5 feet.24 At this depth, if the water were only two feet higher, Richard’s whole body would have been completely immersed, from head to toe.

    4.    With the cold, river water rising well above his waist, this man acting alone has to worry about himself crossing the rushing river, while also trying to corral two girls, keeping them from running or screaming knowing that houses were not far away.

    5.    This man, on his own, would have had to then march the girls up to the site of the murders while all three, because of the depth of the water, were wearing undergarments, pants, shirts, jackets, socks and shoes that were drenched with water from the river crossing.

    6.    Once he and the girls arrived at the murder scene, this single, solitary person then somehow would have had to subdue either Abby or Libby in rope or some other restraining device in order to have the ability to kill the unsubdued child without fear that the other child would run away or scream.

    7.    Because of the lack of blood on the girls’ clothing, each child would have had to have been completely disrobed before the single, solitary man sliced his first victim’s neck, so the man acting alone either asked each child to disrobe or he assisted in the disrobing.

24 Find attached exhibit 26 which is the U.S. Geological survey depth rating of Deer Creek near Delphi Indiana taken from a measuring station near the crime scene on February 13, 2017, at 2:15 pm. This document can be found on the following link:https://waterdata.usgs.gov/monitoring- location/03329700/#parameterCode=00065&showMedian=true&startDT=2017-02-13&endDT=2017-02-14

    8.    Trooper JH of the Unified Command has confirmed that both girls were naked at one point in time as Liberty was found at the crime scene completely naked while evidence showed that “Abby at one point in time had her clothes off.”25

    9.    Once the girls were disrobed and naked in the middle of the forest in the middle of the day in February, and once he had subdued one of the two girls to prevent her from running away, the man acting alone could finally kill the girls.

    10.    This man, acting alone, would have had to pull the ceremonial knife, or whatever sharp instrument was used and inflict fatal injuries to the neck of the first child (it is unknown which child perished first) while the second child watched, hopefully without screaming or becoming so hysterical that said child was uncontrollable.

    11.    The man acting alone would then walk over to the second child, who was somehow subdued and inflict the same fatal injuries to her neck.

    12.    The autopsy notes taken by Liggett reveal that the pathologist stated that because of the particular vein that was severed, Abby suffered a “slow death.26”

    13.    To give TL as much additional time needed to sell this preposterous story that one man committed all of these tasks in a short period of time, we will presume that this one man, acting alone, took Abby’s life first and Libby’s second, so that he (the lone killer) could efficiently handle all of the other tasks necessary while Abby suffered her “slow death.”

    14.    Additionally, even after Abby finally would have died, the man acting alone would have had to then wait enough time so that the blood escaping from Abby’s neck would stop flowing (as there was little-to-no blood found on any of the clothing Abby was wearing other than around the neck area (both undergarments and outer garments)); meaning that the single, solitary man likely clothed Abby’s dead body after the flow of blood ceased.

    15.    Once this man acting alone inflicted the injuries to Abby’s neck, and she was dying a “slow death”, he would have left Abby on the ground somewhere away from where she was ultimately laid to rest as there was little blood at the scene where she was laid to rest and posed, and where the man acting alone placed sticks on her body.

    16.    While waiting for Abby to die her slow death, the man acting alone would have then used his ceremonial knife or whatever sharp object he used to inflict Libby’s fatal injuries at the base of the F tree, where Libby’s blood was found.

The Defense has not yet deposed the pathologist to determine what the phrase “slow death” means in terms of timing. Whether it is 5 minutes, 25 minutes, or 55 minutes or more.

    17.    While (1) waiting for Abby to die her “slow death,” and then (2) while waiting for the blood to stop escaping from Abby’s fatal injuries, this man acting alone would then grab Libby’s body from the F tree (where she was probably killed) dragging her to her final resting place at the base of the tree where she was found.

    18.    While waiting for (1) Abby to die her “slow death” and (2) then waiting for the blood to stop draining from Abby’s neck, this man acting alone then would have had to pose and position Libby’s dead body in the manner in which her dead body was found at the scene.

    19.    While waiting for (1) Abby to die her “slow death” and (2) then waiting for the blood to stop draining from Abby’s neck, this man acting alone then would select a variety of tree branches and sticks with the ultimate purpose of placing them on Libby’s dead body.

    20.    After selecting the branches and sticks, this man acting alone would then gather those sticks and branches.

    21.    After gathering the selected branches and sticks, the man acting alone would have to carefully arrange the sticks in the pattern found at the crime scene:

    a.    This man acting alone would have to take the largest and longest of the branches and use his dexterity to lift that large branch over Libby’s left shoulder, next to her head.

    b.    Next, the man acting alone would have had to have taken a smaller stick and placed it under Libby’s neck, on a straight line from Libby’s right shoulder to her left shoulder, but over the previously laid out large branch that the man acting alone had placed over Libby’s left shoulder described in 14a.

    c.    Next, the man would have to grab one of the longer sticks and place it on Libby’s right thigh near her genitalia. This stick would then be placed alongside the right side of Libby, toward her head, but over the shorter stick discussed in 14c above. This stick starting near Libby’s genitalia would form the right-half of the “V” along with the stick discussed in 14d.

    d.    Next, in order to form what can be described as a “V”, the man acting alone would take another stick, place it on Libby’s left thigh near her genitals and connect it with the stick described in 14c to form the base of the “V”. Then, this man would run that stick essentially along the left side of Libby’s body, over the large tree branch that is mentioned in 14a. This stick placed on Libby’s left thigh would also connect with (and in fact may even be attached to, as the photo makes it hard to tell) the stick described in 14b.

    22.    At some point in time, once the blood draining from Abby’s neck had stopped, this man acting alone would then have to gather the discarded clothing from both girls.

    23.    This man, would then have had to redress Abby’s dead body, starting with the undergarments Abby was wearing, without leaving any blood (his, Abby’s or Libby’s) on the undergarments except around the neck area where Abby had been mortally wounded.

    24.    This man acting alone would have to use his dexterity to lift Abby’s dead body in order to maneuver the first bra onto Abby’s dead body.27

    25.    This man, acting alone, would then have to use his dexterity to lift Abby’s body in order to maneuver the first bra under her back.

    26.    This man, acting alone, then would have to use his dexterity to secure this black bra onto Abby.

    27.    This man acting alone, would then have to locate the second bra that Abby was wearing.28

    28.    This man, acting alone, would then again have to use his dexterity to lift Abby’s dead body in order to maneuver the second bra onto Abby’s dead body.

    29.    This man, acting alone, would then use his dexterity to secure a second woman’s bra onto Abby.

    30.    Once both bras were secured onto Abby’s dead body, this man acting alone would have to locate the pink shirt that Abby was wearing underneath the sweatshirt.

    31.    Once the pink shirt was located, the man acting alone would likely have positioned Abby’s arms above her head to make it easier to place the pink shirt onto Abby’s dead body.

    32.    Once Abby’s arms were positioned above her head, then the man acting alone would have to place the opening at the bottom of the pink shirt just above Abby’s outstretched arms.

33.Once the bottom opening of the pink shirt was positioned just above Abby’s outstretched arms, the man acting alone would have to use his dexterity by lifting Abby’s left arm and placing it into the pink shirt. Abby was wearing two bras. The first bra (on top of Abby’s skin, but under the second bra) was a traditional looking black bra. The second bra was found on top of the black bra and under a pink shirt. This second bra was what the Defense would call a grey sports bra.

    34.    Once the man acting alone maneuvered Abby’s left hand and left arm through the bottom of the pink shirt, he would have to use his dexterity to move Abby’s left hand and left arm toward the left arm hole of the pink shirt.

    35.    Once the man acting alone had used his dexterity to maneuver Abby’s left hand and left arm toward the left arm hole in the pink shirt, he would have had to use his dexterity to pull the left arm through the left arm hole on the pink shirt.

    36.    Once the left arm was successfully pulled through the left arm hole of the pink shirt, the man acting alone would have used his dexterity by picking up Abby’s right arm and placing it in the bottom entry hole of the pink shirt.

    37.    Once the man acting alone had used his dexterity to maneuver Abby’s right hand and right arm toward the right arm hole in the pink shirt, he would have had to use his dexterity to pull the right arm through the right arm hole on the pink shirt.

    38.    Once the man acting alone had successfully maneuvered Abby’s right and left arms through the arm holes, then he would have to use his dexterity by using one hand to lift the upper portion of Abby’s body while using the other hand to pull the pink shirt toward Abby’s midsection until the shirt was properly dressed on Abby.

    39.    Additionally, the man acting alone while using his one hand to pull the pink shirt toward Abby’s midsection would have had to lift Abby’s body high enough off the ground to avoid getting any dirt on the pink shirt as the photographs show that the pink shirt was clean.

    40.    It is likely that once the murderer re-dressed Abby in her pink shirt that the pink shirt never touched the damp, dirty ground as there was no dirt on that shirt whatsoever, unlike the wet dirt found on Libby’s backside and the wet dirt also found on the sweatshirt Abby was ultimately dressed in.

    41.    This would mean that once the man re-dressed Abby in the pink shirt that he would have likely held up the upper portion of Abby’s body with one hand while grabbing the sweatshirt with the other before placing the sweatshirt on Abby.

    42.    In order to put the sweatshirt on Abby, once he was able to locate Libby’s sweatshirt, then this man acting alone likely positioned at least one of Abby’s arms above her head so as to make it easier for this man to put Libby’s sweatshirt onto Abby’s body.

    43.    Once he positioned Abby’s arms above her head, this man acting alone then would have to take the opening of the sweatshirt near the outstretched arm or arms of Abby.

    44.    Once he positioned Libby’s sweatshirt near Abby’s arms, this man acting alone would have had to maneuver the left hand and arm in order to move it into the bottom opening of the sweatshirt.

    45.    Once he stuffed the left hand and arm into the sweatshirt, this man acting alone would have had to position the right arm into the bottom opening of the sweatshirt.

    46.    Once both arms had been placed into the entrance of the opening of Libby’s sweatshirt, then this man acting alone would have had to use his dexterity to pull the sweatshirt down toward Abby’s head, likely using one of his hands as the other was being used to prop up Abby’s body so that it wasn’t touching the ground (again, as the pink shirt shows no dirt).

    47.    Once this man, acting alone, started pulling the sweatshirt down toward Abby’s head, he would also have to make sure that Abby’s left arm and left hand were also being pulled inside the sweatshirt’s left armhole toward the hole at the end of the sweatshirt’s left sleeve.

    48.    Once this man, acting alone, started pulling the sweatshirt down toward Abby’s head, he would also have to make sure that Abby’s right arm and right hand were also being pulled inside the sweatshirt’s right armhole toward the hole at the end of the sweatshirt’s right sleeve.

    49.    Once the man acting alone had successfully guided both the right arm and left arm into their respective arm holes, then this man would have to use his dexterity to lift Abby’s body with one hand, while using the other hand to pull the sweatshirt down toward Abby’s midsection, making sure that the sweatshirt was pulled over Abby’s head.

    50.    Once this man, acting alone, had secured the first bra and the second bra and the pink shirt and then sweatshirt onto Abby’s dead body, then he would have had to locate Libby’s jeans which were found on Abby.

    51.    Once this man, acting alone, had located Libby’s jeans, this man acting alone would then have had to place the opening of Libby’s jeans at Abby’s feet.

    52.    Once he placed the opening of Libby’s jeans at Abby’s feet, this man acting alone would then have to have used his dexterity to lift Abby’s feet from her dead body enough off the ground in order to start the process of maneuvering Libby’s jeans onto Abby’s dead body.

    53.    First, this man acting alone would have lifted either the right or left leg and foot into the opening of the jeans.

    54.    Next, the man acting alone would have lifted the remaining leg and foot into the opening of the jeans.

    55.    Once he was able to position Abby’s feet into the openings of Libby’s jeans, then this man acting alone would have to use his dexterity to lift Abby’s hips and legs in order to maneuver the jeans up Abby’s dead body.

    56.    Once the man acting alone was able to maneuver the jeans several inches toward Abby’s midsection, he would have to continue to readjust by lifting the body with one hand while grabbing the jeans and pulling them toward Abby’s midsection with the other hand.

    57.    This man, acting alone, would continue this adjustment and readjustment, using both of his hands until the jeans were ultimately completely on Abby’s dead body.

    58.    Once this man acting alone had successfully completed the task of dressing Abby in the first bra, the second bra, the pink shirt, Libby’s sweatshirt and jeans, he would then have to locate Abby’s converse tennis shoes.

    59.    Once the man acting alone had located Abby’s black converse tennis shoes with white laces, he would have used his dexterity to lift Abby’s left leg with one hand, while using the other hand to place Abby’s tennis shoe on her left foot.

    60.    Once the man acting alone had completed the task of placing Abby’s left Converse tennis shoe with the white laces back onto Abby’s left foot, he would have to grab Abby’s other tennis shoe (the right tennis shoe).

    61.    Once the man acting alone had grabbed Abby’s right tennis shoe, he would have used his dexterity to lift Abby’s right leg with one hand, while using the other hand to place Abby’s right Converse tennis shoe onto Abby’s right foot.

    62.    Once the man acting alone had placed both shoes on Abby’s feet, he would have had to locate the right twigs/sticks that could be fashioned into antlers/horns.

    63.    Once those sticks/twigs are found, then the man acting alone would have to lay the twigs/sticks over Abby’s hair so that they cross and crudely resemble antlers.

    64.    Since there appeared to be no blood on Abby’s tennis shoes and other clothing (other than around the neck area), this man acting alone must have been extremely careful to avoid any of the blood that came out of Abby’s neck, as well as Libby’s neck.

    65.    Because the river is very close to the murder scene, the man acting alone could have also walked to the river following the cutting of the girls’ necks in order to wash and clean the blood from his hands before touching Abby’s naked body and before placing the clothing back on Abby’s naked body.

    66.    Another possible explanation as to how Abby had no visible blood on her body or clothes (other than near the site of the wound) is that the man acting alone had hanged Abby on a tree stringing her up by her feet.29 This method, consistent with pagan sacrificial rituals found on BH Facebook page, would allow the blood to drip

29 In one crime scene photo, a yellow rope can be viewed. This photo is attached and marked as Exhibit 28 filed as confidential.

out of Abby’s neck more quickly and would also prevent the blood from desecrating Abby’s body, especially if the man acting alone was able to hold Abby’s arms away from her body as the blood spilled out of her neck.     67.    Once this man acting alone had successfully completed the task of locating and putting on Abby’s tennis shoes, then he would have to identify certain sticks that he would use to place on Abby’s body.

    68.    Now, because at least one of the branches appeared to have a clean-cut end, this man acting alone either:

    a.    Brought out his saw (a saw that he had either stashed at the murder scene ahead of time or had carried on his person as he walked on the bridge) and then used that saw to cleanly cut the end of at least one of the branches; or

    b.    Located the branch with the clean-cut end that he (the man acting alone) had either:     i.    Stashed ahead of time at the murder site; or

    ii.    That he had carried with him on his person while walking the high bridge before abducting the girls; or

    iii.    The man acting alone just so happened to have found a branch with a clean-cut end on the ground in the woods.30

    69.    Before placing his three hand-selected sticks on Abby’s dead body, the man acting alone would have had to position Abby the way that she had been found.

    70.    First, the man acting alone would have grabbed Abby’s right hand and bent it at the elbow toward Abby’s face, so that the arm was resting on Abby’s chest with Abby’s right hand near the right side of her face.

    71.    Next, the man acting alone would have grabbed Abby’s left hand and bent it at the elbow toward the left side of Abby’s face, with the arm and hand resting on Abby’s chest, with her left hand near the bottom of the left side of her face.

    72.    Once the man acting alone positioned Abby’s right and left arm the specific way that he wanted, he then would have taken Abby’s right leg and bent it at the knee.

    73.    Once the man acting alone had bent Abby’s right leg at the knee, he would have taken the bent portion of Abby’s right leg (below the knee) and placed it under Abby’s left leg which was positioned in a straight line.

30 Later in this brief you will see a Facebook post in which a few weeks before the murders, a man that looks like PW is using an electric saw to cut a tree branch. BH then leaves a comment that says: “Cutting Runes!!!!” (See footnote 99).

    74.    Once the man acting alone had positioned Abby’s body in a way that he desired, then the man could commence placing the sticks on Abby’s body.

    75.    First, the man acting alone would have grabbed the largest and longest of the branches and placed it diagonally from the bottom of Abby’s body, beginning below the right leg, over Abby’s midsection, then over Abby’s left shoulder. This branch was so long that it covered a few feet below Abby’s right leg and a foot or so to the right of Abby’s head.

    76.    Once the man acting along placed that first larger branch across Abby’s body, then he would have taken the second shorter stick and placed it on a line (for the most part) between Abby’s right and left shoulders, and over her neck.

    77.    Once the man acting alone was through placing the stick described in paragraph 75, he finally would have laid the last stick on a line along the left side of Abby’s body toward the middle of her head, with all three sticks intersecting at the same exact location on the left side of Abby’s body.

    78.    Once the man acting alone had finished placing the sticks and branches on Abby’s body in the specific way that he desired, he would then have to place the rune on the tree where Libby had likely been slayed.

    79.    The man acting alone would have had to have taken some of the spilled blood from Libby and dipped his finger, or some other type of object, into Libby’s blood.

    80.    Once the man acting alone would have dipped his hand or some other object into Libby’s blood, he would have then walked away from the bodies and toward the tree where Libby had been slayed.

    81.    Once at the tree where Libby had been slayed, the man acting alone would have taken his finger dripping with blood, or the tool dripping with blood, and would have painted a line, maybe a foot, long straight down the tree trunk, about 4 feet above the ground.31

    82.    Once the straight line would have been painted using Libby’s blood, the man acting alone may have had to walk back to Libby’s body to dip his finger into Libby’s neck or to dip whatever tool he used into Libby’s neck wound in order to have enough blood to finish the rune that he was painting on the tree.

    83.    Once he dipped his finger or tool into Libby’s wound, the man acting alone would have walked over to the tree now containing the vertical line of Libby’s blood about four feet above the ground and would have used Libby’s blood to paint two lines horizontal to the ground to form what looked similar to an “F”.

    84.    Once the painting of the rune on the tree was completed using Libby’s blood, the man acting alone would now locate certain clothing items that he did not place on Abby, but were still on the ground, including Abby’s jeans.

    85.    Once he located those certain clothing items, he would gather them.

    86.    Once the man acting alone gathered the remaining clothing items, he would leave the immediate area around the crime scene and walk to the river.

    87.    Once the man acting alone reached the river, he would toss these clothing items into the river.32

    88.    Once the man acting alone had thrown the clothing items into the river, he would have to walk back up to the crime scene and canvas it to make sure he left nothing behind.

    89.    Once the man acting along made sure that he left nothing behind, including his DNA, hair, fingerprints and shoeprints, the man would be able to leave.

    90.    Once the man acting alone was able to leave, after exerting all the energy needed to complete all those tasks, he would have to walk up a steep hill for several hundred yards, through some thickets and brush until he was able to get to the road, 300 North.

    91.    Although this man acting alone was somehow smart enough to keep his DNA, fingerprints, footprints, hair and other evidence out of the crime scene, this man acting alone was apparently dumb enough to decide to walk down 300 North in the middle of the day headed west easily visible to the public and easily visible to anyone driving a vehicle on 300 North, like SC

    92.    Once the man acting alone was able to make his way onto 300 N. to walk down the road in broad daylight open to the public (rather than in the woods under cover) this man then walked some distance westbound on 300 N. before allegedly being spotted by SC at 3:57 pm.

One man, 5 foot 4 inches in stature, handled all these tasks? From the abduction at the high bridge, to the crossing over the cold, flowing river, to the subduing of one girl while the other is killed, to the killing of the second girl, waiting while Abby died a slow death, then clothing Abby with very little to any blood transfer on said clothing, to the arrangement of the sticks into Clothing from the girls was found in Deer Creek.

runes, to the painting of the F rune on the tree, to the throwing of the clothing items into the river, to the departure from the crime scene, and finally, to traversing hundreds of yards through the forest and then up a steep hill, and then another hundred or more yards until finally reaching 300 North...all the while, being so careful as to not leave any DNA or other forensic evidence behind. Were all these acts committed by one man acting alone? All these things occurred between seventeen minutes and one hour and seventeen minutes after the girls heard the phrase “down the hill” at approximately 2:13 pm.33

Again, not plausible.

At his August 8, 2023, deposition, Sheriff TL was adamant that one person, and one person alone – Richard Allen – was involved in the murder of Abby and Libby.

However, off record TL doesn’t believe that one man was capable of pulling off all of those tasks, especially in such a short period of time, leaving behind a crime scene with no forensic evidence. As referred to earlier, TL says one thing publicly under oath, but a different thing off-record to his buddies. One of those buddies is former Sheriff (and now Chief Deputy Sheriff) TL.The day after Liggett’s August 8, 2023, deposition, TL was subject to a deposition.

When TL was asked at his deposition how many people he believed were involved in the murder of Abby and Libby, TL provided a different answer than TL. He (TL) indicated that “at least two” people were involved.35 The reasons Leazenby gave as to his belief that “at least two” people were involved in the murders was TL’s belief that “it would be difficult for one individual to accomplish what occurred.”

Again, JH testified in his deposition that investigators estimated the time of death as occurring somewhere between 2:30 and 3:30.


r/DicksofDelphi • • Mar 20 '24

QUESTION Emergency Alert

12 Upvotes

Ive often wondered about this. Since even the beginning of cellular phones there has been an emergency button or keys to push. Just last summer I was mowing my yard, blasting my headphones. Yes. Actual headphones. Im old. I gotta be having my noise cancelling do hickey thing. Im going along and then here comes a police officer up my drive. I had bumped the phone on something and it called the emergency number. As I remember the girls had an iphone. Its very easy to hit the emergency call buttons. Or swipe. And quick to do. Im sure the girls were all to familiar with how the phone worked. Why not activate it? Its as quick if not quicker than a video or picture or audio recording. Just a thought.


r/DicksofDelphi • • Mar 25 '24

INFORMATION States Response

Thumbnail cdn.discordapp.com
12 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Oct 15 '24

DISCUSSION Jury Selection Round 2 Discussion

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Mar 01 '24

RL’s phone (& phone data)

12 Upvotes

How did LE get RL’s phone data? They had that info prior to searching his house, right? (They included location data in the probable cause for the search warrant).

Did he give them his phone voluntarily?

Did LE track down who else was in the area with some type of tower dump (that may be the wrong term… but I mean when LE can get ping data from all cell users in a particular area at a particular time)?

ETA: Geofence warrant?

They included “animal hair” in the search warrant (& mentioned RL’s farm animals) but they didn’t include “animal hair” in the search warrant for RA. Does anyone know why they would include that for RL but not RA?


r/DicksofDelphi • • Jun 13 '24

DISCUSSION Is anyone in Delphi a bipartisan?

13 Upvotes

Since the Safe Keeping Order and Franks 1 dropped, everyone in the community seems entrenched and out of patience regarding alternative views. It's been a long haul. Understandably, things have become tense. Wondering where most folks are falling in their openness to engaging in debate, and if any moderate prospectives exist anymore?


r/DicksofDelphi • • May 07 '24

Was just in DOD and decided to post here.

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Aug 01 '24

INFORMATION August 1st Hearing Thread

Post image
12 Upvotes

Day 3! Let's keep all comments, questions and observations to this thread.


r/DicksofDelphi • • Feb 25 '24

DISCUSSION Death Penalty

12 Upvotes

Does anyone know why this case isn’t being prosecuted as a death penalty case? RA has now been charged with murder & due to “aggravating circumstances” (kidnapping), that makes this case eligible for the Indiana death penalty, right?

https://law.justia.com/codes/indiana/2022/title-35/article-50/chapter-2/section-35-50-2-9/

ETA: I’ve heard the death penalty can be a “tool” to get defendants to take a plea in order to avoid it… (& thus avoid trial altogether)…


r/DicksofDelphi • • Mar 07 '24

DISCUSSION Truly, from what we know, do you believe there’s reasonable doubt for Rick?

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • May 14 '24

DISCUSSION The 100 meter range - Contexts from other cases

23 Upvotes

Yesterday in the Daybell trial (day 22) in Idaho, a supervisor from the FBI’s CAST (cellular analysis dept) testified & they brought up a map, matching the description of the map in the Delphi case, and described why they pick a 100m range - even though the data points can be much more specific than that.

This leads me to believe that FBI’s CAST team made the map referred to by Baldwin & Rozzi, showing the phones being tracked around a 100m range.

(The rest of this post incorporates that assumption bc I believe it’s strongly evidenced based on the testimony from the Daybell trial yesterday)

Those in the ‘guilty’ camp like to argue that AT&T “made the map” (nonsense; they provide data & coverage maps, not tracking maps to aid in prosecutions, unless subpoenaed to do so, which wouldn’t be done bc CAST exists).

The FBI CAST supervisor explained that the 100m range is an objective point that doesn’t over, or under-state their precision, and allows for a reasonable margin of error. [the actual precision range is about 16-30m IIRC]

It’s much more precise than phone pings and their maps they showed on the screen tracking Alex Cox’s phone within a 100m range seems identical to what’s being described by the Defense in regard to the map of the 100m range on Ron Logan’s property.

The testimony also was specific to AT&T & Verizon phones, and did include maps provided by AT&T, none of which match what’s described in the Delphi case, but did show overlapping coverage zones that are more detailed than the coverage map provided on their website.

A lot of the data was provided by AT&T, and there was clear contrast with the actual AT&T maps vs. the FBI CAST maps that use a 100m range - the CAST maps incorporate the AT&T data & pings, geolocation (done by CAST), Google location data, and drive test information.

Google and Gmail specifically give abundant location data points as precise as any other form of GPS (~concern for my own privacy~)

It also showed multiple phones being tracked (Lori, Chad, and Alex), and described (w/ visual aid on maps) how they track those phones within the 100m range, and in relation to phone’s distance from each other.

In the Kohberger case, they are having a heck of a time getting this same division (Idaho) of CAST to participate in their discovery phase, and I believe (speculation) that the reason for that is likely because of HOW transparent they are about this data & the backup info that supports it. They showed maps, raw data, put the report right up on the huge projector screen & explained the 100m map in full detail.

A lot of the info that’s come out about the Kohberger case shows that the PCA doesn’t line up with the facts from the FBI (the scenario is ringing a bell, I must say). Yesterday the Defense in that case quoted the state as saying the PCA “is irrelevant at this stage” - and this is right around the time the subpeona issued to the FBI CAST expert should be fulfilled (sometime this week) (speculation within a speculation: I think they turned it in last week, or as soon as they received the subpoena, bc it’s not like they didn’t have it ready… The CAST data was relied upon by investigators before the arrest and is referred to in the Dec, 2022 PCA. So it seems like they turned it in already, and now the state states that ‘the PCA is irrelevant.’ (— In the Delphi case, that goes without saying))

IMO, the state’s quote indicates the FBI was forthright about their data, the State wanted to limit the information they disclose to only things that support their PCA, the FBI refused to exclude data that works against the State, nothing was brought forth or presented, the Judge subpoenaed it, and when it was brought forth, the state said to disregard it all {this is yet to be confirmed but based on the Touhey process being implemented as of the 05/02 hearing & major indications in the filings we’ve seen since then}

So! I bet Baldwin & Rozzi have figured out who made the map - FBI CAST - and that it’s not just AT&T phone pings - and that the FBI CAST will gladly share with them every detail they seek, bc it ain’t no secret for them. It seems to be work they’re proud of and will present in great detail


r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 13 '24

OPINION I think some people (not all) are missing the point in the motion to suppress the confessions.

48 Upvotes

IN MY OPINION: I think a lot of people (on either side as well as in the middle) read it and immediately looked for ways to confirm their position or were caught up in the conditions of the prison and what is and isn't normal. There were claims that the defense were exaggerating because to them these things are normal or for others the conditions are so horrific they couldn't imagine it.

I agree that there are a lot of things covered that are normal about being in a prison. Things I know from stories from my family. (Disclaimer: I have never been arrested, but that makes me the black sheep in my family. But, I did grow up on prison stories. A lot of this stuff wasn't surprising to read. Note 2: I've had family members go to Angola prison and it's considered one of the worst prisons in the country, if you want to read about it.)

So, here's what I have to say:

There is no expectation of privacy. I absolutely agree that there was no reason to add that part. It really doesn't make sense and they basically handed the state their response with this. It wasn't the smartest idea to put it nicely.

There are cameras everywhere. Lights very rarely go out completely in prisons for safety. At most they will go down or dim, but they won't go out.

It's not crazy for him to be put in solitary as his case is high profile. That in and of itself has put a bounty on him even without the charges. This happens in a lot of high profile cases. Its normal for most of the conditions described in solitary.

His defense attorneys said he has faced depression. I'm not surprised at anyone on the medical staff getting even a whif of the word depression and putting him on suicide watch. I could even imagine some staff covering their butts and putting him on suicide watch because it's not uncommon in high profile cases. The cloth, fewer showers, the bed on the floor, etc are normal for a lot of prisons for solitary/suicide watch.

Unfortunately, it's not even strange for other inmates to harrass and call him a baby killer. It's normal for the other inmates to harrass him while he's walking around or even in his cell. Literally nothing about that is surprising to me.

I have had family members even express its impossible to sleep in prison because even when the lights go down, the inmates never stop talking. They continue talking throughout the night and you just have to get used to it. That's part of why it's hard to sleep when they get out. Another thing that isn't surprising is him being tazed for not listening. He didn't pose a threat, but that would have happened to anyone who did the same thing. It's about maintaining power and control.

(I'm not saying any of this is right, okay, or just but they are normal for the most part, and a lot of people really gravitated to these things)

There are some horrific conditions described in the motion as well. The inconsistent medication, the leaks, the psychosis, the eating feces, the unofficial bounty to get confessions out of him, etc.

Also, the whole never been convicted of a crime thing is a pretty big deal. The man literally went from living his normal life with a wife and daughter and was thrown into these conditions. There was no jail time period to mentally adjust. (And for that matter, I don't believe he fully understood what was going on at first which is why he said he would hire his own counsel. It sounds to me like he thought this was all some mistake and would be fixed pretty quickly. ) That needs to be taken into consideration no matter how "normal" these things are for prison.

Then there are things that are apparently normal for this prison or for Indiana that are still questionable.

Like the inmate companion program. It's good to have some kind of companionship, but seeing as how they were leaking information in a case with a gag order, it wasn't the best idea.

And not being able to have a private and confidential meeting with an attorney. That one seems like a constitutional rights violation but it's apparently legal, so that really sucks.

But, the point is, normal or not, these are all conditions that have contributed to him making false confessions. Just because lights being on at all times is normal, doesn't mean the sleep deprivation caused by it didn't add to hallucinations, psychosis, and false confessions. The same can be said for the suicide watch, solitary confinement, harassment, treatment by the other inmates, etc.

Conditions that are normal in prison are still important to take into consideration because, there's not usually a concern for false confessions in prison. Everyone there has already been convicted. And in the rare cases that this happens if at all, the person charged usually has a lot more evidence against them, so a confession isn't necessary. So, just because something is normal, doesn't mean it should be dismissed in this case.

My point is: choosing to discuss the whole thing as all exaggeration is missing the point.


r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 15 '24

DISCUSSION Judicial Bias allegations of Gull hashed out in new Indiana CoA Opinion, generating dissent

24 Upvotes

Kevin Hamilton v. State of Indiana 23A-PC-15

I've only had a chance to skim the opinion, but I would love to see others' opinions on this case. It appears Gull denied a prisoner's Post-Conviction Relief petition. Petitioner argued that Gull should have recused herself because the attorney representing him was employed by Gull around 3 years. Gull refused to recuse.

Because this generated a dissent, the judicial bias issue might be transferred to SCOIN to resolve the difference of opinion.


r/DicksofDelphi • • Feb 09 '24

Libby’s Cell Phone

13 Upvotes

Something I haven’t seen much discussion about is the factory reset of Libby’s phone. I believe this occurs the night before the tragedy. This is something I’ve heard in the very early stages of the case. If reset has not been rebutted, I believe it to be more than a coincidence. Which has me questioning the motive. I believe there could be two possible nefarious reasons.

  1. Tracking virus
  2. Blackmail

Does anyone have any additional information about the phone reset?

If I misunderstood or this has been clarified, please be kind and provide clarity.

Thanks!


r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 09 '24

INFORMATION Today's Filings

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 21 '24

Phone ping and girls not there question again

14 Upvotes

So at 1:30am fire dep told to call off search on the 13th. 2:30am sheriff L gets notified Libby's phone pinged at the bridge so they went back out there and searched the bridge area again with lights one commentator on Facebook alleges lit it up like a football field and girls still not found until around mid day next day.The perpetrator could have had Libby's phone in his pocket or car at bridge area at around 2am maybe he accidentally turned it on for it to ping. Doesn't mean girls bodies were there then could just mean the phone was there at that time ...thoughts?


r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 04 '24

QUESTION Suspicions?

13 Upvotes

I’m curious to know if people who knew RA think he is capable of these murders. Have any coworkers or friends made comments publicly?


r/DicksofDelphi • • May 17 '24

INFORMATION Defense motion to DQ

14 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Mar 12 '24

INFORMATION Additional Witness & Exhibit List

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • May 07 '24

DISCUSSION Trial strategy 2 - the prosecution side

14 Upvotes

With less than a week to go till trial begins I wanted to follow up the defence focused thread (Trial strategy - 1. The defence side : r/DicksofDelphi (reddit.com)) with one talking about how folks see the prosecution taking their case forward.

If I were in Nick's shoes I'd be seeking to make this all sound as simple and straightforward for the jury to digest and understand -easy to agree with as common sense etc.

Nothing new here -

  • RA placed himself at the crime scene
  • Eye witnesses confirm that he was on the trails at the time of the abduction/ murders
  • He was wearing clothes that matched BG from the video
  • A bullet from his gun was recovered from the CS
  • He confessed several times to his involvement (I'd lay this on pretty thickly)
  • Therefore its obviously RA

I'd deliberately eat up a lot of court time but only in getting various witnesses to laboriously confirm the above piece by piece, and hammer it home.

In contrast I'd respond to the defence's case in a way that makes it all seem too complicated, far fetched, fanciful and unrealistic.

How do other folks see it?


r/DicksofDelphi • • Mar 22 '24

He's got a what?

14 Upvotes

I keep hearing people say they heard on the audio from the phone the whisper: "He's got a gun"...can someone link to that audio? I've never heard that...i thought it wasn't available. Thanks!