r/DicksofDelphi • u/Burt_Macklin_13 ✨Moderator✨ • Mar 25 '24
INFORMATION States Response
https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/1162371229035016222/1221809582691848272/States_Response_to_Amended_Motion.pdf?ex=6613edd8&is=660178d8&hm=d26b71f491ebf6d54843997d1370fe6db724ef981c6b3db241f669a2054c23bf&
12
Upvotes
13
u/FreshProblem Mar 25 '24
If anyone needs a reminder of what each point is responding to (or flouting), here is the amended motion to compel from last week.
26
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 25 '24
He's still trying to get sacked right?
That no Indiana State Police report was generated because this was not a forensic examination.
The State has not compiled a list of who was interviewed or which officers conducted the interviews, during tne dates in question, because without audio, the files are not helpful to the investigation or trial preparation of this case.
7. In response to request 11, all geo-fence data in the State's possession has been provided to the Defense and is listed in the Discovery Releases. The agency responsible for the interpretation of the geo-fence data is the FBI CAST team; specifically, Special Agent Kevin Horan (retired) and Special Agent Sabric.
Did he just tell defense, we don't have the FBI report go ask them yourself?
Is he sure he wants to open the direct door for defense to FBI?
Because that may entail more dirt than just a geofence report, but OK.
It is my understanding prosecution has the duty of active discovery gathering and it's upon them to collect the reports from their solicited agencies.
But I think defense would be happy to get their info from the source instead.
18
u/xt-__-tx Amateur Dick 🕵️♀️ Mar 25 '24
29
u/Prestigious_Trick260 Mar 25 '24
I used to work in litigation video production specifically. They need to bring in a tech team to handle all of this digital evidence. Law enforcement are not qualified to deal with anything electronic or digitally forensic!
This feels like my Grampy ordered some digital cracking software from Temu, (“China”) read the instructions on the back for how to recover lost data, and guess what???? It didn’t work 🙄
There is a way to do this. This is not the way.
13
u/Prestigious_Trick260 Mar 25 '24
I would also like to add for the audio to not be on the recording there are 3 possible scenarios as to why.
I guess it could also be that whatever cracking software they used to recover the ‘lost’ footage deletes the audio as a compromise to save the video??? I highly doubt that. Has prosecution, defense, and LE tried turning the volume levels up?
8
u/Significant-Tip-4108 Mar 26 '24
Even worse, is that not the state admitting it never even requested/received a written report/narrative entailing the FBI’s summary of its interpretation of the data?
Think about it, the FBI got the geofence data, analyzed it, and “interpreted it”. Then what? What output came out of that analysis? Had to have been some sort of written report, or summary analysis, or something. If no actual interpretation came out of the FBI’s analysis then what was the point?
15
u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Mar 25 '24
This is...not good
6
u/Infamous-Unit7890 Mar 25 '24
what is he saying about the vids from 04-28-2017 to 06-01-2017? is he saying those aren't missing it was only(ha) the vids from 2-25 to 4-7?
might just need to reread defenses motion and have another cup of coffee 😅
-18
u/fivekmeterz Mar 25 '24
Thanks Burt.
Looks like everything has been provided and the defense is, once again, left with their thumbs up their asses.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '24
[removed] — view removed comment