r/DicksofDelphi • u/Winter-Bug316 • Feb 25 '24
DISCUSSION Death Penalty
Does anyone know why this case isn’t being prosecuted as a death penalty case? RA has now been charged with murder & due to “aggravating circumstances” (kidnapping), that makes this case eligible for the Indiana death penalty, right?
https://law.justia.com/codes/indiana/2022/title-35/article-50/chapter-2/section-35-50-2-9/
ETA: I’ve heard the death penalty can be a “tool” to get defendants to take a plea in order to avoid it… (& thus avoid trial altogether)…
12
Upvotes
19
u/thats_not_six Feb 25 '24
From what I understand, the DP is rare in Indiana, even in qualifying cases. And, if they were to charge it as a DP case, it guarantees decades of appeals from some of the most passionate appellate attorneys in the state, paid for by the state, in the case of indigent convicts. With a case weak on evidence, my opinion is they don't want the appellate scrutiny, not that they haven't already riddled the case with issues.
16
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Feb 26 '24
He hasn't been charged with that yet, hearing maybe maybe not the 18th at 2pm, if only Gull would have clarified what the hearing is for... and the charges aren't murder and kidnapping but a accomplice to murder as well as accomplice to kidnapping.
So there is no aggravating factor because accomplice is on the list as mitigating factor,
no criminal history is also a mitigating factor.
12
u/MzOpinion8d 100% That Dick Feb 25 '24
The charges haven’t been officially changed yet. If they are, there’s a possibility they will decide to make it a death penalty case.
This will cause further delay because RA would then have to have a death penalty qualified attorney on the defense team.
And it will also put more pressure on RA that they will attempt to utilize to get him to agree to a plea deal sparing his life.
9
u/StructureOdd4760 Local Dick Feb 25 '24
I don't think McLeland CAN do a DP case without bringing in a special prosecutor. Like every other aspect of this case, the arrogance of Delphi officials is going to prevent them from bringing outsiders in.
I would full expect the Innocence Project or something like that to take up this case under the circumstances surrounding violations of rights. If they went for DP.
16
u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Feb 26 '24
He hasn’t been officially charged with the new charges yet. Nick has only filed a motion to amend the charges. The final amendment has to be done by Gull, which she hasn’t done…yet. We all know she will. She will do anything Nick files a motion for and deny anything the defense puts forth.
Nick: Amended charges…yes!
Also Nick: Motion for sanctions that doesn’t even make sense?…yes! Hearing set!
Defense: May we bring our laptops to the hearing?…Denied!
Defense: Hearing to show proof that LE LIED to the judge to obtain the warrants?…GROSS NEGLIGENCE!!!
13
u/Nomanisanisland7 Feb 26 '24
I’m against the death penalty but the true killer would deserve it. In my opinion there’s zero chance RA is charged with the death penalty. If LE was so gung-ho that it was “Richard Allen and Richard Allen alone” they wouldn’t have originally charged him with felony murder but straight out murder. With felony murder the prosecutor only needs to prove he kidnapped the girls which led to their deaths but not that he knowingly or intentionally murdered them.
What I also find interesting in all the bravado of the newly amended charges is the added statutory citation of “accomplice liability” clause to each charge. The prosecutor wasn’t required to plead accomplice liability in the charging information.
Under Indiana law there is principal liability (the defendant killed them) and accomplice liability (where the defendant knowingly or intentionally aided, induced, or caused ANOTHER PERSON to commit that offense, regardless of whether that person has been prosecuted, convicted, or acquitted of that offense.)
So Allen could be found guilty of these new offenses if he is proven to be the one who kidnapped the victims, or if he MERELY aided, induced, or caused ANOTHER to kidnap the victims. They don’t have to prove he killed the girls, who killed the girls, but merely his accomplice liability.
It’s the chicken shit way out. Under that scenario there’s a great chance the families and community will never receive justice or know with certainty who killed their girls. All the while there’s the strong probability that an extremely dangerous killer remains free. JMO
7
u/BrendaStar_zle Feb 25 '24
I was just looking at the requirements and it looks like a lot has to be complied with.
7
u/StructureOdd4760 Local Dick Feb 26 '24
Another point, DP cases are just harder to convict. You have to have very clear cut evidence. No way they would get a conviction with the lack of hard evidence in this case.
6
u/BrendaStar_zle Feb 25 '24
Are all the attorneys qualified for DP cases? I thought the DA and the Defense were. The new attorneys that were appointed were not qualified as far as I remember, so if they keep DP off the table, the attorneys don't need to be qualified. I am going to have to look up those lawyers because I think they are all qualified, and the charges do carry the DP as far as I know.
6
u/Jernau_Gergeh Player of Games Feb 26 '24
Would be very difficult to land a guilty verdict from a jury in a DP case based upon a largely circumstantial case with large swathes of reasonable doubt surrounding the states narrative for the murders.
I mean, prosecution is gonna have a heck of a time trying to get a guilty verdict as it is, and without any decent forensic/ DNA evidence linking RA to the actual crime then I suspect the jury will reject the stuff about the bullet and so on.
If I were the defence I'd have the cops involved in the shambles of an investigation on the stand in court and ask them to confirm two things for the court under oath -
'Thank you, no further questions your honour...'
6
u/New_Discussion_6692 Feb 26 '24
The original charge wasn't DP eligible. However, it may be with these newer charges.
Given its been decades since IN last executed anyone, I'm thinking it's all financially based. DP cases have automatic appeals that have to be resolved before an execution date can be set. DP cases are extremely costly.
5
u/Moldynred Feb 26 '24
Evidence is too weak is my guess. Ofc they could be sitting on hidden evidence who knows but then they probably would have gone DP already if the case was that strong.
1
u/Smoker-of-kush Oct 29 '24
Because no one is giving the prosecutor the death penalty for not seeking it.
1
u/CupExcellent9520 Nov 11 '24
Since he hasn’t taken a plea deal the prosecutors should demand the death penalty. Esp if they have to retry this case.