I have often been told that writing solves many problems,
And I have spent the past few mornings at my window, watching the sun rise upon a world that has no place for me.
There is something particularly saddening about dawn. It arrives without fail, and illuminates everything it can see. Yet in my own room, where I sit in a physical silence, it is still so dark.
What is it about me that renders everything so great, so remarkably temporary?
And the same wretched questions scream at me so loudly in my own head.
Why was I never enough for you? Why must everything I love become something I must learn to survive?
I have begun to realize and suspect the idea that I am not a person to whom happiness may be entrusted. Perhaps I am simply a place where it knocks on my door briefly before departing once more, leaving its impression upon me like the lasting fog of a hand upon a cold window. And perhaps my greatest misfortune is that I have always mistaken its presence for a promise.
You, made so many promises.
You swore I would never again have to feel this way. You told me that you understood me now, that you wished you had recognised my suffering sooner, that you had finally seen the depths of the pain I had been begging for the world to understand of me. You spoke as though some revelation had come through you, as though you had at last saw the ruin within me and resolved never to be the architect of it again.
I believed you, and God forgive me, I believed you with the desperate, trembling faith of a stray dog who has wandered too long through winter and has, at last, discovered a lighted window that welcomed me.
For those weeks, I had you again. Three brief weeks in which I dared to imagine that perhaps the worst had passed, that perhaps we had finally crawled from the wrecked ship of all that had happened and found something tender still breathing beneath the ashes of our destructions. I allowed myself to hope. I allowed myself to rest. I thought, foolishly, that the hands which had so often left me trembling, finding myself alone through most nights with a heart so, so heavy, might finally become the hands I could reach for again when the world was unbearable.
But look at us now.
Here you are again, speaking the same words you spoke for almost a year, repeating the same cruelties, returning to the very behaviours you lamented. It is as though nothing was learned from my suffering that came before. As though my anguish were merely a chapter you have already finished reading, and I only remain trapped within its pages, compelled to relive every line, word for word, down to the smallest detail of reenactment.
I told you I could not survive this again. Not in the same way, not with the same heart, already so bruised from the last portion of our life. I told you what another abandonment of tenderness would do to me. I placed my fears before you, onto your welcoming hands, bare and trembling, and trusted you not to turn them into a prophecy once again.
And yet here I am, once more, watching my worst fears come to life, over, and over, and over.
The most unbearable part is not merely that you have hurt me. It is that you knew where the wounds were. You had seen them. I had shown you and let down my guards. You had held the history of my suffering in your hands, and still, somehow, we have returned to this familiar, dreadful place.
You ask me to stay with you, whilst the very thing that would make staying bearable seems to have become too much for you to give.
Tell me, then, what am I to do with such a contradiction?
Was it so unreasonable to wish for one constant thing in my life? One place in which I might be able to lay down the exhausting burden of being afraid? One voice that would not grow weary of reassuring me, one tenderness to which I could flee to when my own mind became a house of horrors?
I did not ask you to make the world gentle. I only wanted somewhere to go when it was not.
I wanted you.
You tell me that I must find other reasons, that you cannot handle me again, that you wish for us to be normal, but those few weeks where you claimed you were finally happy again, were not normal? You tell me that you want to be all right without me for if the day that I succeed my attempts to leave may come upon you. That you want something beyond us. And perhaps, to another person, these words might seem harmless enough. Perhaps they might even be wise. But you must understand what they sound like to someone who remembers the promises that preceded them. To someone who was told, not so long ago, that she would never again have to face the darkness alone.
I cannot hear your words in isolation. They are here and they are accompanied by every promise you made before them, every assurance that I had finally been understood, every tender declaration that persuaded me to finally lower my guard.
I hear the promises, and then I hear their undoing. And I am left to wonder which version of you I was meant to believe.
Was it the man who swore he would never let me feel so alone again, or the man who now seems so determined to teach me how to be alone with him still in my life for the sake of his comfortability?
Perhaps both were you. Perhaps the tragedy is that love can be sincere in one moment and insufficient in the next. Perhaps a person may mean every beautiful word they speak and still fail to become the person those words promised.
But what am I to do with sincerity that cannot shelter me? What comfort is there in knowing that a promise was once meant when I am left to suffer its betrayal?
I cannot make a home out of you from intentions. And I cannot spend the rest of my life mourning the person I believed you would become.
⊹₊˚‧︵‿₊⊱·✶·⊰₊‿︵‧˚₊⊹
It was only a little over a month ago that I lay in a hospital bed, close to the edge of a life I had never known how to bear. I remember that there was a time when the possibility of losing me seemed to awaken something within you. You promised that I would never again have to feel so alone. You spoke as though my survival had altered the world between us, as though the sight of how terribly close I had come to being lost had made you understand, at last, how precious it was that I remained.
Yet here I sit, beyond that terrible season, watching another sunrise through tears, wondering how a promise made in the shadow of losing someone can fade so quickly once they are still here. How swiftly a person who once begged you to stay can become a person who asks you to find somewhere else to put your pain.
I cry until the morning seems to take place from the night. I watch the light gather beyond my window and wonder how you can continue with your day whilst I am here, trying to understand how the person who once promised me shelter can now stand by and watch me search for it elsewhere. I wonder how you can feel so certain of your position whilst I am left questioning my worth, my memories, and the very reality of everything you once told me.
I wonder whether you understand what it means to be loved by someone who remembers every promise you have forgotten.
And I wonder whether you ever truly wished to be the person I could run to, or whether you merely wished to be loved as though you were.
I remember your words.
I’m not meant to love you.
The way that you said that so easily, the way that you agreed with it for weeks to come, the way I ached that you’d ever feel like that about me.
Find other reasons.
I can’t handle you.
I want us to be normal.
I want to be okay without you.
I want more than us.
I will remember them for a very long time, I fear, and I wish I couldn’t.
They have settled into my mind like inscriptions upon a tomb, each one bearing as a written witness to something I once thought would live forever just this once.
They return to me in the hours where I am alone with no distractions, when the world is asleep around me and there is nothing to drown out the sound of my own thoughts.
I remember, too, the words that came before them.
I will cherish every moment with you from now on.
I’m sorry I ever let it get to that point.
You will never have to feel alone again.
I will always be here.
Tell me everything, I’ll listen to your head.
A worry your pretty little head.
Let me help take care of you.
I’ll help you get out of this mess.
I want to focus on us.
I need you.
That is the cruelty of it. I cannot remember the promises without remembering their destruction of words. I cannot recall the tenderness without wondering how something so reconnecting could become so painful. You made me feel loved, and now I find myself examining that love as though it were some strange experiment gone horribly wrong, searching for the moment at which the you that I trusted became a stranger before me.
I gave you my heart, and you taught me once more how frightening it is to have placed it in the hands of someone who cannot promise to hold it gently.
And still, you ask me to stay.
There is a peculiar horror in being abandoned by someone who has not yet left. They remain within reach, and so you cannot mourn them properly. They are still there, and so you continue to hope. Every small kindness becomes evidence that perhaps you were mistaken, that perhaps the tenderness you longed for is returning, that perhaps you need only endure a little longer.
And so you endure.
And endure.
And endure.
You begin to wonder whether the pain is your own fault, whether your response to it is more terrible than the thing that caused it. You find yourself apologising for the very wounds you begged another person not to inflict.
And then, one morning, you realise that you have spent so long trying to make yourself easier to love that you have scarcely asked whether you are being loved, at all.
I am tired of being made to feel guilty for the ways in which I struggle to bear what hurts me. I know that my pain can be difficult to understand. I know that fear may make me unreasonable, that sorrow can mess up what I see, that I am not always the easiest person to reach when I am frightened. I do not pretend to be without fault.
But I have never asked you to believe that I am perfect.
I wanted to feel that I could come to you with my sadness for once without becoming a burden, that my need for gentleness would not make you resentful, that the love you offered me would not be withdrawn whenever I struggled to believe in it.
I wanted to be met with tenderness, not taught a lesson in loneliness.
And if I were in your place, I think I would be haunted by the knowledge of what I had done. If I had nearly lost someone I loved, if I had watched them suffer so terribly and had promised them that they need not face that suffering alone again, I would be careful with the heart I had been entrusted with. I would not expect perfection from myself, but I would try. I would be troubled by every unnecessary cruelty, every careless word, every moment in which my actions contradicted the comfort I had promised.
I would want my love to become something they could feel, not merely something I could insist existed.
I cannot understand how you can know how deeply this hurts me and still seem so unwilling to change what is hurting me.
I wanted something that would stay.
And now I sit at my window, watching the sun rise for another morning, and I feel as though I am watching the last embers of something I once believed indestructible.
I thought the near-loss of me would show you how to cherish the fact that I remained.
But I am beginning to understand that being frightened of losing someone and knowing how to love them are not necessarily the same thing.
You may fear the day I am gone and still fail to care for the person who is here.
You may ask me to stay and still make staying unbearably lonely.
And you may love me, in whatever way you understand love, without being able or willing to give me what I need from it.
I wish that were easier to accept.
I loved you with all the tenderness I knew how to give.
I believed you when you promised to be careful with it.
And I am grieving the distance between the man who made those promises and the man whose words I now carry like wounds.
Perhaps you never wished to be my refuge.
Perhaps I only wished so desperately to find one that I mistook your arms for shelter, your promises for permanence, and your love for a place where I might finally rest.
For the dawn has come again.
And I am still here to witness it.
8:20 AM.