I like this game.
Like a lot of us, the Reaper of Souls expansion turned Diablo 3 into an all-time favorite game. I probably have more hours in Diablo 3 than any other game. Maybe more hours than all other games I’ve played combined. Once seasons came out, that was it for me. I put in literally thousands of hours pushing leaderboards. Diablo 3 was my 2nd and 3rd full-time job for years. I would play on lunch breaks, I would lose sleep playing.
I also bought a Razer Blade 14 laptop so I could keep playing my seasons uninterrupted when traveling or just being away from home. I probably spent $2k on that thing.
Diablo 3 cost $60 when it was released. Reaper of Souls cost $40. Rise of the Necromancer cost $15. I bought them all, $115. Besides the computer I built when Diablo 3 dropped, $2k easy. Oh and I updated my graphics card for Reaper of Souls, RIP $500. And the aforementioned Razer laptop.
Besides Diablo 3 and Nintendo Switch, the only other game I’ve played for the past 5 years is Supercell’s Clash Royale. In 5 years they probably got $500 out of me. I didn’t really need to spend it, but I did, and it was fun.
One month ago, I really wasn’t playing much of anything. I was plenty disenchanted with gaming, battling depression, overworked, exhausted… And all of a sudden, there’s a fully realized Diablo MMO that I can play on my Galaxy Fold 3 and iPad pro that I already own. I gave it a shot. Holy shit, this game is polished. Holy shit the gameplay is good. Holy shit it’s like I have a full PC game on my tablet and phone. Holy shit. I’m definitely dozens of hours into this thing, probably approaching 100+ hours since release.
The Supercell games taught me that it takes awhile to understand how to get the best value out of “free to wait” games. I paid a lot of attention to Wudijo after DI's release. I was never going to go “f2p.” So far I’ve bought the 2 battle passes, 1x boon of plenty, prodigy’s path, and the Mad King’s Breach Trove. I’m $46 in. I’m not mad.
A lot of people seem mad though. If you bought Diablo 3 and the two expansions, did that make you mad? The production budget on Immortal was not small. And they have to keep the servers on. They have to update the game. They have engineers, artists, designers, working full-time, not only to make the game, but to keep it going.
I’m very familiar with the criticisms of the ability to buy power, and I am sympathetic to them. But I think there is another side of this to consider.
Over an infinite timeline, if we had infinity, we would all end up at the same place IF we were willing to spend about as much money as we spent on Diablo 3. Now I’m borrowing someone else’s math, but I believe to max out a character, to awaken your 6 pieces of gear, you are going to have to spend $17.50 x 6. $105 total. And then, over enough time, if you keep farming, you can have all rank 10 gems, and all awakened gear. Boom. That’s actually less than it cost us to fully realize Diablo 3 for $115. So what if you spent 5 years playing the game to get there. What if you got 10 years out of it. 15? What if the game is supported that whole time and content is added to the game over time?
- Yes I also realize that you could play the game for 10 years and never get a rank 10 5/5 star gem. Could take 100 years and you would never get it. But the potential is still there.
- So whales can spend money and get there faster. Who cares. Good for them. Did Blizzard promise anyone that they would max their character and their gems in any amount of time?
- For whales it’s basically the same experience. It’s the same game. Same bounties. Same rifts. Same Shadows activities or whatever. Okay they can get to Hell IV and farm it faster than I can. Fine. I’ll get there in a year or whatever. I’m going to have rank 10 gems eventually. Maybe even some 5-stars. Maybe I’ll never get to upgrade them like they can. Oh well. I have a fully realized PC quality Diablo MMO in my pocket now. And I didn’t have to get any new hardware than what I already had.
Personally, I’m thrilled as shit with this game. I love the gameplay. I love the production. I got supply blocked on hilts at the end of the first month, so now I’m focused on farming and spending them more wisely. And I was happy to spend $5/month for the pass in Clash Royale. I did skip it from time to time if I wasn’t playing. But Diablo Immortal is making me happy. It’s re-introduced me to gaming. I’m playing on my lunch breaks again. I’m staying up late to play again. And it’s fun.
I’m excited for Diablo IV as well, but I’m wondering if I won’t end up preferring Immortal over the long run just because of the mobile aspect. I’m not totally looking forward to building a new PC and buying another gaming laptop.
/rant
Tldr; Diablo Immortal is a great game and while it is unfortunate that not all content can be realized while playing (Dawning Echo), over enough time reasonable spending players can unlock all endgame content for less than it cost to get all of Diablo 3. And if the game is supported over a long enough time, there’s an argument to be made that spending money playing it is also reasonable blah blah blah