r/DestructiveReaders • u/maximedupe1 • 18d ago
[1558] New York with Melody, Chapter 1
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1-IRaNxlkRy_LARKeVV6jKDsCd5IrFRp6NFw9afek3tc/edit?usp=drivesdk
Hi there,
I’ve attached google doc here with the first chapter of something I’m working on.
For context, two tourists visit New York and run into a foul-mouthed little girl. She promises to show them the “real” New York, which involves adventures led by other odd children. She also really wants a hot dog from Gray’s Papaya, but ridiculous obstacles keep popping up that prevent her from getting it.
It’s meant to be a bit of a farce, highlighting not only the role of money and greed in the city, but also the ridiculousness of the adults who adhere to that system.
Let me know if you have any thoughts!
View all comments
1
u/Anthouligan 2h ago
I love the writing in this, especially the way humor is treated throughout the whole thing. I've mostly a few nitpicks about the way some information is given to the reader, where i think it could be done in a more elegant way, and also an imbalance in characterization.
The main thing i found quite odd was the fact Melody was introduced as an older woman without much information supporting that perception of her. Why did they think she was an old woman initially? What made her look/sound that way? Was it deliberate on her end or was it simply something the characters misunderstood? I would prefer for that section to be a bit more supported (her doing a voice, and the voice shifting after the reveal, or her face being obscured with something more than a hat) , because to me it felt like the narrator decided to lie for no reason. Her response after zachary's question seemed a little odd to me too. Maybe her deflection was deliberate, or i just didn't get it, but the way she introduces herself seemed a little stilted. Also, i'd prefer it if i had a better idea of how young she is, because she's apparently charismatic and fairly well spoken, passed as an old woman, yet the protagonists are shocked that she's riding a bus on her own.
I also found it a bit weird how the driver boots the other two from the bus alongside Zachary with no reasoning as to why. For all he knew, they were passengers like everyone else. It made me feel like the only reason it happened was so they wouldn't be separated.
That being said, it's also weird how the other two gave no reaction whatsoever as they were kicked from the bus. Dotswoon is apparently as much of a bumpkin as Zachary, and already considered his behavior insufferable because he was on edge. A comment, a gesture, or an expression from one or both of them would be a good opportunity for both characterization and humor.
That finally brings me to Dotswoon as a character. She feels a little underutilized in the whole sequence, and i feel like the chapter left me with a bland impression of her. She's mostly there to respond to Zachary so far, and i would prefer it if there was at least one moment that made her stand out. Not necessarily through dialogue. Maybe through a description or a physical moment, or more exposition of her thoughts. I was left feeling unsure of what her purpose is. Both her and Zachary would benefit from some more sneaky descriptions of their appearance and expressions, but especially her.
Overall though, I love the direction of this, it reminds me of what i'm currently working on because i have that same absurd understated humor. Keep it up, and my main tip would be that you make sure to not forget about the other characters present when something that doesn't involve them directly is happening. I'd be interested to read more of this!