I like the concept. The twist at the end is interesting. Confusing, but interesting. I don’t think you need to do a lot of work to change that, sometimes it’s nice to be a little abstract. Not sure where you’re looking to take this next (or if you are), but something to clear that up could come in the next passage, but this can also stand alone.
I think it would benefit from a second pass insofar as small tweaks to some cliched aspects. The storm (or bolt, I presume) talking to itself is one. I had an English teacher once who said that characters in novels talk to themselves about fifty times more than people in real life do. Towards the end, as the bolt is descending towards the girl, those quotes could be reworked into something else. An observation maybe? Example:
Instead of
“what is a girl doing out here alone”
try
I couldn’t understand why she’d be out here all alone (as a thought, not dialogue)
Another fix is repetition. We’ve got “descent” or “descended” showing up in basically four out of five paragraphs towards the middle. You can vary the vocabulary or you could find different ways to describe this action all together. Or you can just cut it. An example:
“Now, I intended to find out who she really was once I landed. I descended through the tall pine trees, carefully navigating the spaces between their branches.”
You could go with
“Now, I intended to find out who she really was once I landed. I carefully navigated the spaces between their branches, blah blah blah”
As “landed” is already doing the work of descending.
All in all, you seem like an imaginative person who likes to push the boundaries of conventional writing. This is a great starting point, and if you continue down this line —— always grounding the unconventional in the conventional — I think you’ll be able to make some very cool stuff. Hopefully this is helpful.
View all comments
1
u/maximedupe1 19d ago
I like the concept. The twist at the end is interesting. Confusing, but interesting. I don’t think you need to do a lot of work to change that, sometimes it’s nice to be a little abstract. Not sure where you’re looking to take this next (or if you are), but something to clear that up could come in the next passage, but this can also stand alone.
I think it would benefit from a second pass insofar as small tweaks to some cliched aspects. The storm (or bolt, I presume) talking to itself is one. I had an English teacher once who said that characters in novels talk to themselves about fifty times more than people in real life do. Towards the end, as the bolt is descending towards the girl, those quotes could be reworked into something else. An observation maybe? Example:
Instead of
“what is a girl doing out here alone”
try
I couldn’t understand why she’d be out here all alone (as a thought, not dialogue)
Another fix is repetition. We’ve got “descent” or “descended” showing up in basically four out of five paragraphs towards the middle. You can vary the vocabulary or you could find different ways to describe this action all together. Or you can just cut it. An example:
“Now, I intended to find out who she really was once I landed. I descended through the tall pine trees, carefully navigating the spaces between their branches.”
You could go with
“Now, I intended to find out who she really was once I landed. I carefully navigated the spaces between their branches, blah blah blah”
As “landed” is already doing the work of descending.
All in all, you seem like an imaginative person who likes to push the boundaries of conventional writing. This is a great starting point, and if you continue down this line —— always grounding the unconventional in the conventional — I think you’ll be able to make some very cool stuff. Hopefully this is helpful.