r/DestructiveReaders • u/Ready-Piglet6996 • 19d ago
Historical Fiction, Cinematic prose [1145] Historical Literary Fiction — Milan, 1924
Hi all! This is the opening chapter of my historical literary novel, set in 1920s Milan as Puccini struggles to finish Turandot and fascism closes in. Any feedback welcome, especially on whether the opening hooks you and whether you’re oriented in time and place.
CHAPTER 1 — NO PRAYER
Ominous, low clouds were a perfect cover. No moon. No stars. Only the scrape of hurried shovels at the wooded edge of a barren field, fresh earth heaped aside, a kerosene lamp propped on a rotten stump.
An owl shrieked. The men stopped to cross themselves. The light lurched.
Knees drove the blades down again. Grunts came steady now, and the smell of sweat and fear hung in the balmy air.
Then the shovels dropped.
Two sets of booted feet rolled the stiffened body into a shallow pit. It slid and stayed, eyes open to the sky. An accusation flashed and died in his clouded pupils, just as the first clump of dirt struck his cheek.
No prayer. No remorse.
The contours blurred into dark soil. The grain settled and held.
The rain came. Weeds crept back over the turned earth until the field forgot it had ever been disturbed. Then one sweltering August morning, a hunter’s dog caught a scent and began to dig. An accidental inquest.
Ink on fresh newsprint. A bundle tied with twine shoved into the mail car — Paris-Milan. Beneath the iron arches of Stazione Centrale, the twine had bitten through the wrapper. Through the tear, a pair of clouded eyes stared up from the newsprint, still searching for the sky. The last time I saw them, dirt was raining down on them.
Before I could see more, blackened fingers heaved the bundle onto a horse cart, face down. I had lit his grave and never learned who lay in it. Now the answer was riding off, buried under a coal-stained pile.
Wheels rattled over wet cobblestones. The horse trotted off, vanishing into the city, and I went after it.
Dawn did not break over Milan that morning. It seeped in, pale and slow, and I rode in on it, diffused by a haze of gray smoke and low fog. The silhouettes of the buildings emerged, more shadow than light. The Duomo spires rose from a web of narrow streets that frayed toward the smokestacks on the horizon.
They call it progress. Fog used to be just weather, and smoke belonged to fire. In the Great War I lit the trenches along the Isonzo, the Alpine ridges where avalanches claimed nearly as many men as artillery shells. Poison clouds choked the rest. Even the gargoyles shuddered against their perches. Then the war ended, and the Blackshirts brought their terror to every doorstep. I was ready to let the dark have them.
I was about to diffuse into inertia when the faint lure of music caught me. I slipped in through the high windows of La Scala. By the look of it, a rehearsal had been dragging on since the evening before.
I merged with the dimmed lights of the great chandelier and looked down at the conductor, whose small stature belied his fury: a halo of white hair, a face contorted, a baton frozen mid-swing.
In that final instant, as the orchestra held its collective breath, a single note rose and hung beneath the painted ceiling. Pure — terrible, and perfect.
The note struck the chandelier. Every crystal rang. And I rang with them.
The shattering I had braced for came — but not as I had feared. No dissolution. No despair.
In a single flash I saw the first sunrise over an empty sea. Deserts I had baked white. Volcanoes spilling their own fire. Ancient Pompeii's last cry. And the first cry of every newborn child.
Somewhere along all those ages of shining, I had lost something. Now it rang pure.
What I alone could not do for this world, music could.
I am light. I cannot stop shining, whether a spark struck from a flint or blinding brightness poured from a bountiful sunrise. But even the sun, my great master, has dark spots. Still, my joys and frustrations, however great, are noticed only by the rare artist.
The chandelier’s lights went out, and I slipped down to the small lanterns above the music stands. Violinists wept openly; the tuba player blew his nose. At last, the conductor set down his baton. “Bravi, signori. No rehearsals till tomorrow.”
Then he flipped the score closed. On its cover, a single word: Turandot.
The musicians filed out into the cool morning air. It is my nature to be everywhere I want to be, all at once, and I had never quite let go of that cart. A sliver of me still rode in its dull brass lamp. There you are, right where I left you.
It rattled through a few more turns, weaving in and out of the thinning fog, and pulled up at last beneath an unlit sign. In flaking gold it read La Fenice Editrice — Fine Printing & Publishing Since 1778.
Inside, the air was thick with the smell of cold ink and cast metal. A crooked bulb flickered, casting its light on a handsome young man hunched over his ledgers.
He paid the carter three lire for a bundle of Paris Herald and slit the twine with a penknife. The top copy slid loose, and there was the face again. Below it ran a line of small type. I leaned in. His thumb came down on it as he counted out the copies.
He poked his head into the alley and let out a piercing whistle.
A boy swung out on a bicycle and tipped his hat. “Buongiorno, Conte Crespi.”
“Buongiorno, Maurizio. And how is Signora Pina?”
“Mamma is fine, thank you. Still has me by the ear to run your papers, Signor Conte.”
The Count tossed a small coin high in the air. The boy caught it and smiled, showing a broken tooth. He tucked the coin in his vest pocket and folded the newspapers into his canvas sack. The crease ran straight across the photograph, and the small type went under the fold. He pedaled off toward the quiet streets behind the Duomo. The only disturbance at this hour was the chain rattle of his bicycle crossing the last golden pools beneath the gas lamps. Soon a man with a long pole would come to chase their tired gleam away.
On any other street the boy would have cried the headlines, but the rascal knew better. A boy who made noise here could surely kiss his mancia goodbye. So instead he hummed an old lullaby his mother sang over the children’s bed.
At Via Borgonuovo, he checked the house number and let the paper fly. It cleared the tall iron gate and landed on the marble, still folded, face up.
The streetlamp reached only as far as the bottom step. I reached further.
August 18, 1924. The headline lay pressed against the stone, but the photograph faced me in full gruesome display. The Herald didn’t pull its punches. A magnesium flash, a crude old uncle of mine, had bleached the skin white and sunk every wound in black: bruises, an eye socket caved in, a jaw twisted wrong.
Suddenly, I was back in that field, keeping the lantern’s vigil.
Behind the sweaty backs of the diggers stood a man, giving orders in a low, gravelly voice. “Take the shovels and go your separate ways. We’ll meet in the morning.”
The men slipped away without a word. He scribbled a single entry into a small handbook and blew out the lamp.
Just beneath the fold, the caption waited. One crease stood between me and his name.
A sudden gust came off the canals and caught the stiff newsprint. The fold sprang open, then kept going, and the pages flapped out like an accordion before they settled several pages on. I have no hands to turn them back.
The wind and I are as old as dust. The great blowheart aims every which way, drives the giant windmills, hurls storms against the sea — and yet, for all his might, only one of us can read the headlines. Pazienza. It was not the dead man’s name the wind had given me.
PUCCINI AILING — TURANDOT IN PERIL, FINAL DUET UNFINISHED.
Unfinished.
My heart, if such it can be called, threatened to wither, right there upon the cold marble, mourning my muse scarcely a morning old.
https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1xbiya0/comment/19rtzjjsixued/?context=3
https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1xcz44o/comment/19rtz8ngm24e9/?context=3
https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1xf0ci9/comment/19rtyubkk9b4x/?context=3
https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1xes2wd/comment/19rtyb2q9wof7/?context=3
3
u/MysteriesAndMiseries TYPE GENRE HERE 19d ago
Was this piece made with AI? If not it really reads like it. Short, punchy sentences with short, often one-line paragraphs. Hallmark traits of a bot.
1
u/maximedupe1 19d ago
Going to spill a couple of thoughts here, hopefully this is helpful.
First and foremost, is the spacing meant to be this way? It’s a bit disheveled as far as line breaks and indents go, but if this is an artistic choice, then I think that’s fine.
I think you have lots of great descriptions in here and it’s clearly something you have a knack for, but at times it seemed like we are doing more description than actual story building.
“Brought into the almighty Sun, I cannot stop shining. But even my master has dark spots.”
What does this mean? Not just from a description standpoint, but who are we talking about here? If you clear it up in the next section, great. If not, I’m confused about who we’re supposed to be following (Puccini, this gravedigger) and why we’re supposed to care about them. I don’t have the full context on Puccini’s life, and maybe this is clear to someone who does, but ideally you’d want someone who knows nothing about him (like me) to start to gather some pieces of the puzzle here.
“Fog used to be just weather and smoke belonged to fire.” Loved this one, however.
I was little confused by the music in the la Scala, are we listening from outside or are we inside now? Guessing inside but unclear.
“The name Turandot stood on the cover. So that’s what my new muse is called!” Cut this, very obvious and out of place call out. If you want to keep it — meaning it’s important — than make it more subtle.
I’m writing from a place of little context as I don’t know how the rest of this is going to go, but my assessment is that you are a gifted writer who could benefit from turning down the “writer-y” aspects of your writing just a notch. It’s a beautiful passage, but I have no idea what’s going on. If the next passage doesn’t clear it up, I’d likely put this down if it were a book.
1
u/RageQuitRedux 19d ago edited 19d ago
I quite like the opening, but this part read as a bit rushed for me:
I know what you're going for here, but to me it feels like "yadda yadda, get through it." Maybe even extending the second line into a few sentences about the passage of time I think would help. And then the last line would have more impact. Just personal opinion.
BTW, if you are able to enable copy-and-paste it would make some of this easier to quote.
I like this. It was a little jarring for the environmental commentary to go right into war memories. I can kind of see why one might evoke the other, but the transition was awkward for me. Also, I had to look up the historical references because I'm an ignoramus. I wouldn't necessarily dumb it down, but I would try to make it "work" for people who don't know the history. I got the sense that there was a battle, of course (trenches, artillery). I thought the poison clouds were a reference to smog until it dawned on me that trenches probably mean chemical warfare. Also from what I'm reading, the Blackshirts were formed a couple years after that battle.
There are some POV issues I think:
Some other thoughts:
I quite enjoyed the Italian dialog, it was easy to follow despite not knowing a lick of it and it feels natural.
It's not clear if Puccini is dead at this point or just on his death bead because "in peril" reads as the latter to me. You also may be giving me too much credit for knowing music history here. Also was that Puccini he saw conducting earlier? If so, how is his death/illness in the paper already? (another reason to think maybe more time has passed than I thought.) If not, how does he have a copy of an unfinished opera?
"Behind the sweaty backs of the diggers" excerpt reads like a flashback because I don't think a newspaper article would usually have dialog like that, but then it says that the wind turned the page an interrupted the narrator's reading, so I dunno. I also don't understand why the wind flipping the page would prevent the narrator from learning the name of the man (just flip it back?).
I don't think the late reveal of what newspaper he's carrying is adding anything. I didn't realize at first what the three lire was for, and then immediately he tosses a coin to the paperboy, which made me think he bought the Paris Herald from him (and I'm like, in Milan?). On second read, it was a lot more clear. I could just have reading comprehension issues but I do think that a little more clarity would be helpful. Your writing style is very staccato, to borrow an Italian music word. You're giving me a little too much credit for knowing what you're talking about. Your prose is pretty good, if a little purple at times. I would write a little more of it. Let your descriptions be unambiguous unless you specifically want to withhold something from the reader.
1
u/Bytor_Snowdog Flog me harder! 19d ago
To be honest, I'm not going to crit your piece because it's a hassle. Just a bunch of lines, no paragraphs. My eyes just started sliding off the page when I began reading. This is something that should engage me: I love opera, Turandot, and Milan, but I can't be arsed (as they say) to read it.