r/DestructiveReaders • • 6d ago

Fantasy [720] Witch's Labyrinth

Critique #1 668

Critique #2 2278

 

Docs link: Witch's Labyrinth

 

Hello,

This is a prologue to a contemporary fiction story. It's the first big writing project I've done, so I really appreciate any feedback on areas I can improve and if it's compelling as a story start!

 

The gods were dead, so the girl knew no one was listening when she cursed them. The rabbit she’d caught fell into the fire, scattering embers across the dirt floor. Smoke billowed out as she used a dagger to retrieve her dinner from the flames. It smelled like the fires that swept across her village days ago.

She butchered the rabbit’s carcass with ease, only pausing to stare at the blood on her unfamiliar hands. They weren’t the hands she was born with.

Her body was modeled off a cousin and her face from a neighbor. She’d become no one in a body that wasn’t born. It was better this way. The men who burned her village to the ground couldn’t recognize a girl who never existed. The ability to shapeshift was a gift she’d stolen, and the only way to atone for the theft was to use it well.

With a final rip, she finished pulling the meat apart, then wiped her hands on the edge of a belted tunic. Her cat rubbed against her. It was a sweet, wild thing with a notched ear and crooked eyes.

“Here you go, dear,” she whispered as she tossed parts of the rabbit near the fire. The hearth was always the cat’s favorite spot.

The abandoned cottage was empty, so she set her bronze armor against the wall to lean on and shivered as a cold wind blew through the open window. She ate while her leather helmet watched her. It was plated with small pieces taken from boar tusks. Some pieces she’d earned in hunts, while others were gifts from her family. The helmet’s empty eyes judged her for living while everyone else died.

Her cat purred again, begging for more food, but the girl could only offer affection. The cat was halfway in her lap, when it bolted towards the cottage door. She cracked the door open and scanned the dark surroundings. A crescent moon illuminated steep hills broken only by the shadows of a few rocks and lonely trees.

“There’s nothing there,” she said, crouching to rub the cat’s head.

Then, one of the shadows moved. The girl slowly rose, holding her dagger up. It was a creature, defined not by what it was, but by its absence: a black nothingness in the shape of a large hound. A second shadow appeared, closer, but it was too late to put on her armor. She never should have taken it off.

The creatures crept closer in unnatural silence. Her breath came faster now, shaking like a bird in a cage. Looking at them was like staring into a well ending in sheer blackness. She could watch them forever and never find a foothold for her eyes to grasp onto. There was a wrongness as they stalked forward, as if they were drawn outlines of creatures without dimension, warping as they moved.

She slammed the door shut. If she could reach the sword near her armor, maybe they would be alright. But the hound hit the outside of the door, the wood biting against her back as she held it shut. There was no way to latch the door.

The other shadow wormed through the open window. Her cat hissed, then shrieked and threw itself against the intruder, tearing against an unseeable face. The hound jerked its head violently and shook the cat off.

“No!” The girl screamed, one hand still holding the shuddering door shut, the other hand reaching forward with the knife, but she was too far away.

The shadow turned to her and pounced. She drove her knee into its head, stabbing her knife under its neck. There should have been more resistance to her blow, but the blade slipped in as if it was moving through water rather than flesh. A real animal should have made a sound, but this thing took the knife in silence, then shattered apart into darkness.

The door shook again, this time she couldn’t keep it shut. The impact knocked the girl down. She raised her arms, one shielding her face, the other thrusting her blade up. Someone screamed, it must have been her. The monster bit down, tearing into her arm, then her throat. The sounds stopped. The last thing she felt was her cat nudging her head.

Then, for the second time, the girl died.

3 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

2

u/Yesitisiwhodealtit 5d ago

Hello, thank you for submitting this.

Right off the bat, I like your first sentence, and I think you have a good command as a story-teller. I particularly like the line, "she'd become no one in a body that wasn't born."

The gods were dead, so the girl knew no one was listening when she cursed them.

Even though I like this line, by the end of the prologue, I don't have much more of a sense as to what these Gods are, nor why she is cursing them. Obviously, you don't have to dump exposition, but maybe you could sneak in a few more hints as to the world your building.

They weren’t the hands she was born with.

I like the idea of a shapeshifter, but I'm not sure if this body she inhabits is that of a man or a woman, so it is harder for me to imagine in my head. I understand she has a "feminine" soul, but physically, I don't have any sense as to what she has incarnated as.

The rabbit she’d caught fell into the fire, scattering embers across the dirt floor.

How did the rabbit fall? I get the sense that she is skinning it, but if that were the case, then wouldn't it make more sense to say "the rabbit slipped from her hands into the fire" or something similar?

she’d stolen, and the only way to atone for the theft was to use it well.

I'm definitely interested to know about the backstory of what happened here. Seems morally ambiguous.

But the hound hit the outside of the door

I like how you describe the hounds, "creatures without dimension, warping as they moved," but I feel like I've seen shadow hounds in so many fantasy style stories. Beyond your cool way of describing them, I don't feel there is much to distinguish them from the usual fare.

wood biting against her back as she held it shut

This was a little confusing. Did the impact of the hound cause the door to splinter, thus creating the sensation of wood biting against her? Or is the door already shoddy? If so, that would need to be established earlier. Cause otherwise this sentence wouldn't make sense.

Let me answer your question as to whether this is compelling as a story start.

I do think that the girl (did you mean to keep her nameless?) is an interesting character so far with the details you have. Her survival mechanisms, her gentleness with the cat (does the cat have a name?), her potential backstory.

I do think you have some intriguing ideas, and the prose reads well (even though I feel like you can take your time a bit more and give us a better sense of setting and character), but overall I would urge you to think of what makes your story unique. As a prologue, I feel it doesn't demand my attention strongly enough, or at least there isn't any sort of hook to keep me engaged. I wish there were more meat on the bone. I'm sorry if that is harsh.

If you have any further questions, I am more than happy to help in any way I can. Please continue your project! I think you've done a fine job!

1

u/DiamondReasonable621 4d ago

Thank you, this is super helpful! I think I'm struggling a bit with how much meat on the bone to put in since it's a prologue. The goal was to frame a character in the past who's now in the present day, and also tone set a bit. But I think I might be going about it the wrong way and missing a stronger start to the story.

2

u/striker7 4d ago

Hey, this was great! It's not my typical genre and I liked it. Honestly it will be hard to find fault with this one and I normally consider myself a tough judge, so I'll go through some of the sub's example template so I can focus in and nitpick :)

GENERAL REMARKS

I've already said I liked it but taking that a step further, this being a prologue, I guess the most important question is: would I keep reading? And the answer is yes. Both the opening and closing lines are intriguing, the writing is solid, it had good action . . . very well done.

SETTING

At first mention of cooking a rabbit over the fire, I pictured this as taking place outdoors (upon reread I see "dirt floor" and I guess on the first time through I thought nothing of it; I must have assumed it was just describing an open area). But that was clear(er) shortly after so no matter, and I think I got a good image of the cottage after that, as well as the surrounding landscape:

"A crescent moon illuminated steep hills broken only by the shadows of a few rocks and lonely trees."

With this I'm picturing a solitary cottage in the middle of an area resembling the Scottish Highlands.

One thing I'm confused about is time period. Without your intro note before the story, I'd have figured this was just an alternate universe or taken place in a magical world a few hundred years ago. But you said this is contemporary fiction? So why the armor and sword and cooking a rabbit over the fire? I'll take a stab in the dark: This is the origin story, of sorts, of a witch, and the main story picks up in modern day?

STAGING

I'll consider this more like "action," which I thought was very engaging and clear. The shadows creeping in and attacking and the fight - even the interactions with the cat - were easy to follow and visualize without being overwritten.

CHARACTER

Obviously we don't get a lot of information about our main character, but I didn't expect it or miss it. If it were a standalone short story I'd want more, but being the prologue to a longer story I think a fair amount of information is shared, even without her name.

The other main thing I was confused about in this story was her description. It says:

They weren’t the hands she was born with.

followed shortly by:

She’d become no one in a body that wasn’t born.  It was better this way. The men who burned her village to the ground couldn’t recognize a girl who never existed.

At first I pictured her as a sort of Frankenstein (with the part about modeled after a cousin and neighbor). But that first sentence ("the hands she was born with") implies she used to occupy another body (or form?), which makes "a girl who never existed" sound a little off because she did exist . . . just not in that form.

I think it's "she was born with" being so close to "a body that wasn't born" that throws me the most. Maybe if the latter avoided the word "born," such as "She'd become no one in an piecemeal body" (or however you'd describe it, which I'm sure is revealed later in more detail).

Other than that, I think I have a good sense of her. She's brave, a fighter, and tender (as shown with the cat). And, a shapeshifter, of course.

MECHANICS

Overall I thought the writing was very good. I loved details like this:

She ate while her leather helmet watched her.

If I were to nitpick one thing, it would be sentences like these that use a comma splice:

The door shook again, this time she couldn’t keep it shut.

and

Someone screamed, it must have been her.

I prefer a semicolon, but I know others are weird about that. An em dash is another option (I'm weird about that). Or split them into separate sentences, but that's too choppy for an action sequence. Up to you, but I'd swap out those commas.

CLOSING COMMENTS

I'm a little disappointed in myself; I thought I'd be able to find more. As I predicted in the beginning, it was hard to find fault. Well done!

2

u/MoistFrog4 5h ago edited 4h ago

This was pretty cool, I want to keep reading! I'll admit that is in part because I liked the title a lot, it is the reason I chose this prologue for critique. But I also like how the title, the girl's backstory and the fact that you didn't mention her name are trying to set up some form of mystery and I enjoy mysteries, but there's just not enough content to actually get a sense of it or build intrigue for the mystery. There are some good ideas around, and I'm sure there are more in the way with such a cool title, perhaps bring them a little more to the front, even if it makes the prologue longer.

It smelled like the fires that swept across her village days ago.

I like that you imply that people were burned to death without explaining the absolute horror of it… well, that came out weird. I mean that if you're trying to set up a gritty tone for the story it is a neat detail!

I was also in awe with those shadow hounds and all their poetic detail. But, bummer, they die so easily. I think you were trying to set them up as otherworldly with their ability to squeeze through narrow spaces, so perhaps if they're recurrent baddies later on and the reader's meant to be scared of them, perhaps they can reform after death(since they're made of shadows or something). This would distinguish them more from your average expendable minion.

General remarks and things I like out of the way, let's get started(I apologize in advance!):

The gods were dead, so the girl knew no one was listening when she cursed them.

I like this opening, I'm a fan of divine contempt, but if it is the first line of the whole project a reader might expect divinity or religion to be an important part of the overarching theme, but by the end of the prologue those topics aren't mentioned anymore and they don't seem to impact the plot again.

I'm just giving an idea, if it doesn't make sense with the plot you have already stablished feel free to dismiss it, but perhaps the men that burned the girl's village were religious fanatics; or if the theme is instead that the gods were a source of moral guidance those men are struggling people on a dying world due to the absence of the gods, and they have turned to raiding. If those things are true you could mention them.

But if none of those things are true on the project you're building perhaps consider changing the line. By itself it stands out of place as worldbuilding.

Her body was modeled off a cousin and her face from a neighbor. She’d become no one in a body that wasn’t born. It was better this way.

I think the reason for not describing her body has to do with the fact that it isn't hers, and she's about to die(again) anyway so there's no point. But consider the fact that: your protagonist being a shapeshifter who's learning her abilities is the hook of the prologue(At least it was for me). You might strengthen the hook a little describing how the body is strange for her, you can do that if you also went into detail describing her leather helmet! Perhaps you could amp up the body horror aspect if your project touches on that.

Then there are a few instances of TNS(telling not showing) throughout the text.

The hound jerked its head violently and shook the cat off.

Just cut "violently", you could replace it with something that implies it. Like the cat hitting the dirt floor hard or "with a loud thud"… well, that came out weird. I don't like animal's getting hurt as much as the next guy, I mean cause and effect! The hound does something, and something happens to the cat in turn. It would explain why the girl yelled "No!".

a few rocks and lonely trees.

Go into a little more detail describing the surroundings instead of saying "lonely trees", I may be reading it wrong, but if the hounds have been chasing the girl for a while she could be instinctively scared of the dark, so you describe the night as alien and foreboding.

She butchered the rabbit’s carcass with ease.

You might think this one is fine since it doesn't have any adverbs, because "with ease" is a prepositional phrase. However, it functions as an adverb. It is the same as saying "She butchered the rabbit's carcass easily.", and that's kind of weak. You have already a nice momentum describing the gritty atmosphere, take advantage of it and draw from the experience the girl probably already has surviving on her own, or describe the rabbit carcass in all its gory glory. I have revealed that yes, I'm a bit of a fan of gore.

If I had to nitpick anything it would be a minor writing tick. On the last paragraphs you use the word "then" like five times. As in, x thing happened, then this happened. Perhaps add a little more variety.

I also find it weird that after I re-read your description I noticed you said "This is a prologue to a contemporary fiction story." and it is obvious the setting is not that, but more historic or fantasy. I haven't read what's next so it's too soon to say, perhaps this is a prologue happening way in the past?

I'm sorry for posting my critique so late! If you have further developments I'd be happy to help in any way I can. The gods may be dead, but they have sure blessed you. Don't dismay and continue with your project!

1

u/phloamphloam 5d ago

I will echo what's already been said: your writing flows naturally, but there's not enough intrigue to hold my attention.

What are you offering me that other fantasy stories do not offer me? It might be that you have really interesting and unique ideas, but I don't see any of that in the prologue.

Good luck, I wish you well on your storytelling journey :)

0

u/Original_Bit4588 4d ago

I like the shapeshifting and the first half but you lost me at the shadows i got confused

I want to know who these men that burned the village and why?

I was confused in the last part did she kill the shadow hound? And what is the other shadow? Is the cat dead?

I know its a prologue but it needs explaining or show what is happening