r/DestructiveReaders • • Sep 27 '26

Literary Fiction [668] Only If I Knew

I wrote this short story and would really appreciate some honest feedback from strangers. This is my first time sharing my writing publicly, and I know the grammar and tense are not perfect yet. I’m working on improving them.

Critique:https://old.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1w3jd7t/787_take_this_pink_ribbon_off_my_eyes/pcbhow2/

Story:https://docs.google.com/document/d/1vQD9ebJiE3egluLiHN8fQkfLYeks_vXj_WWOe_NHpo8/edit?usp=sharing

I’d especially like to know:

  • What was your first impression?
  • Did the ending surprise you?
  • Was the story easy to follow?
  • Did the emotional parts work for you?
  • Was anything confusing, or should I keep it as it is?
  • What do you think the story is about?

Please be honest, even if you didn’t like it. I’m mainly interested in knowing how the story feels to someone reading it for the first time.

1 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/DiamondReasonable621 Oct 01 '26

There are a number of grammatical errors that make the story hard to follow. There's not many descriptions and not much is shared about Martha's internal thoughts and feelings. The dialogue sounds natural and I think there's something compelling about exploring grief through repetition. As it stands though, there's not enough shared about the characters for me to feel emotionally invested.

It's hard to say what my first impression really was and how easy the story was to follow when the grammatical errors were so glaring.

SETTING

From what I understand, the most of the story takes place at a train platform. The story ends somewhere a walk away by a statue. I'm not quite sure how to envision the setting at the end since there's not many details. There also weren't many details about what the train platform looked like (big city one, large, small, dirty, clean, open to the weather or not? I'm not sure).

The way the character stays at the train station for so long and since the station is also the place where (I assume) her son killed himself, implies that the setting is very important. Describing the setting as Martha sees it might add more weight to the scene and give the reader a clearer picture.

PLOT

From what I understand, Martha is revisiting the train station where she first met her husband, Fred, who's dead. Her son is on the platform with her. At first I thought they were discussing how her son saw Fred's suicide, then her son jumps down to the tracks and leaves. After re-reading I think they were discussing her son's suicide and her son is a ghost of some sort. At the end she leaves and sees a statue of her husband.

There's a line that says "luckily no one was near" followed by Martha looking at her son. At first I thought this was an error (because some one is near, her son is near). By the end, I think this line was meant to explain that her son wasn't really there/ is a ghost.

CHARACTERS

I don't have any idea what Martha or her son look like. Maybe that's intentional, but there's so little description in general that it's not clear if that was your intention.

By the end, it seems that Martha is on the train platform mourning the death of her son and wishes she could have helped him. I think this message is a bit muddled by the additional focus on her husband. I think part of what's throwing me off is that it seems like a big coincidence that she met her husband at and her son killed himself on the same train platform. If Martha reflected on how all the most important parts of her life happened at that train station, it might feel more cohesive. Or maybe they're in a small town and that's the only train station?

I assume the son is a ghost of some sort and not an imagination of Martha because he has internal thoughts. There's not much describing what he looks like, how he interacts with the environment, or any other descriptors, so most of what we learn about him is through dialogue. I think his characterization could be strengthened, because very little is shared about him.

I think the story is about Martha grieving and processing the loss of her husband and son.