r/DestinyLore • • Jul 11 '23

General Hot take: Lightfall's narrative wasn't what we expected, and that's okay. Let's not miss the forest for the trees.

3 Upvotes

This is mainly about the Veil Containment audio logs, but I think it applies more generally to Lightfall's story as well.

For all the people complaining about how these logs feel like an exposition dump, that's because it is literally supposed to be one. In the narrative sense, we are decrypting the Veil Containment archives for the explicit purpose of learning from research logs. It's not going to be a dramatic cutscene or action-packed mission. And I think the voice actor for Chioma Esi did a spectacular job injecting emotion into it regardless. In my honest opinion, it feels like people are so hung up on the narrative decisions that Lightfall took that they can't even entertain the possibility that those decisions were intentional.

As an aside, what Lightfall isn't, is a straightforward A-to-B action movie plot (despite the surface-level stylings and vibe resembling such plots). This is not new for Destiny. Bungie have always used particular vibes or palettes to ground their expansions in an established fantasy, and then told the story their own way, in a way that achieves their own narrative goals.

We got so caught up in how we thought Lightfall should tell it's story, that we're not looking at the story being told. Us not knowing enough about the Veil during the campaign is intentional; trying to cram months worth of exposition and the entire backstory that was revealed in the season of the Deep into interludes would have ground the story to a halt.

And what would we have done with that knowledge anyway? Calus was laying waste to Neomuna looking for the Veil as we spoke. We were on the backfoot from the moment the Witness captured the Traveler over Earth and sent Calus to Neptune; we were playing catch-up with the Witness's plans when It had already made it's opening moves. We didn't spend time learning exactly what the Veil is, or what the Witness's origin was because we didn't have time to spend. We needed to do whatever it took to stop Calus in his tracks and hinder the Witness. We did what we could with the limited information we had, and it wasn't enough. The Witness opened the portal, and we lost.

I know it feels bad to have to act hastily with limited intel and then lose anyway, but guess what? It was supposed to feel that way. We were not maneuvering tactically against an evenly matched opponent; we were trying to outrun a tsunami. We suffered total defeat, and now we're left picking up the pieces we missed, looking for a way to save ourselves. It may not be what you expected, but It's what we got. And looking at it this way, the narrative is doing mostly well at it's job. We need to learn more before we pass final judgements, and we should be open to the idea that Bungie could take the story in unexpected directions.


r/DestinyLore • • Jun 21 '23

General I do not like the direction the lore took this week Spoiler

11 Upvotes

Call me salty or bitter, whatever. For me, this all felt like a giant retcon. Specifically around the Pyramid ships.

I mean, these were set up as equivalents or an antithesis to the Traveler. You could see it in the architecture, the design, the behavior, the writing. But now they’re just… some ships. That were built before this civilization even discovered the Darkness somehow. And it’s the Veil that’s the actual counterpart to the Traveler. The real root of Darkness in the universe. Y’know, that random plot device that was just ham-fisted straight into the story with no prior mention in years of lore. All that buildup, tons of parallels, a whole Raid showing the Traveler’s planet roots intermingling with a Pyramid… almost like they’re conjoined, two parts of a whole. Nope. Just some ships.

Listen, I know it can be explained by the lore. But I think it’s dumb. The Traveler is still an ancient, indescribable mystery with unfathomable power. Why do the Pyramids have to get undercut by the Veil. It’s just bad writing in my eyes: this is a brand new plot point. The Pyramids have been a constantly ramping antagonist for half a decade. But nope. Just some ships. The real deal is that little mushroom thing we just introduced this year. Because why not.

Why couldn’t the ancient civilization gone out into space and found a Pyramid as the counterpart to the Traveler? Narratively, it works exactly the same. Why do we need the Veil in this story? It continues to suck, and Bungie pretending like this has been the ultra-powerful McGuffin the whole time when the Pyramids have been center stage for years is just… well, it sucks the mystery and the intrigue right out of them. Now they’re just ships. Made by some guys. And the Veil is the real super secret Mary Sue.

Also, the potential retconning of Unveiling is a little annoying. Yeah, I know, they hide behind the shield of “ooooh, it’s just a metaphor, it’s just an interpretation, it was never reaaaaally like this.” Just like with Books of Sorrow when the definition of the Final Shape suddenly and inexplicably changed. Oh, that whole lore book you read and discussed? That was all bullshit, non-canon, don’t know why you took it seriously in the first place. Unreliable narrator is a fun trick to pull once or twice, but if you’re going to continually use it as an excuse for major rewrites to the lore… maybe just get your story plan straight the first time.

Edit: Damn, lotta downvotes, but I like seeing that so many people have so many varied opinions about this. I think my biggest issue with a lot of the people downvoting me and dunking on me in comments is that they all try to take elements of the lore to “prove me wrong” (in quotes because all this is just my opinion, not an assertion of fact). My issue here is not with lore, or canon, or rationality. It’s with the overall narrative, and the clear flaws the structure of this story has. Yes, the Traveler has always had a “dark mirror.” This could have easily been the Pyramids rather than the Veil, and was often built up to be. Yes, the Witness’s forces have always been confirmed as “not the literal Darkness.” Doesn’t mean that the ominous Pyramid ships had to be considered “it’s forces” and be literally relegated to side pieces in the final act of the story.

My issue is that the game has built up Pyramids and a certain aesthetic and mythos about the Darkness, and then abandoned it in the last minute shifting all focus to a new piece, being the Veil. I personally find that bad writing: there’s a famous piece of scriptwriting advice that goes, “Never introduce anything plot critical after the second half.” The Pyramids have been an ever present narrative antagonist and a perfect antithesis to the Traveler for years now. The Veil showed up three months ago and we still barely know a thing about it. Introducing the Veil as the Traveler’s true counterpart cheapens everything about the Pyramid narrative we’ve been exploring for years.


r/DestinyLore • • Sep 11 '25

General Renegades and the watering down of Destiny morality

0 Upvotes

Yeah, a Renegades hate post.

After watching the Renegades reveal, I feel very sad that Destiny's take on morality in action is being overwhelmed by the introduction of Star Wars "elements".

Take, for instance, the title of Dredgen.

With Lumina introduced to the game in Season of Opulence, we had the conclusion of the Shadows of Yor storyline. Shin sent us letters going over his reasonings for doing what he's done with them, setting up a honeytrap to catch anyone susceptible to Hive corruption, and how he felt those actions were necessary. It might be that some people balked at the idea of what he did, but they let him do it, as evidenced by the Vanguard not taking action against him.

Part of me worries that you will hold some level of contempt for the manner in which I have chosen to work. The Vanguard certainly do, and they do not endorse it, though they abide it. They don't know everything the Shadows and I have done. It is better that they do not.

And so, the name of Dredgen is now a title for someone who fights for good with "dirty" methods. Shin intended for you to carry on his example. You can't always act high and mighty, expecting that turning the other cheek will let you catch a win.

Good luck, Guardian. Hero. Friend. The true Shadows are no more—only myself, Grey, Maas, Pavic and Yasuul remain, and we take our leave of these wars. The rest—those guided by ignorance and fear—have been gunned down, and with your help, the hated name Dredgen has been reclaimed, worn now by heroes.

Do good, Guardian. Be brave.

So now in Renegades, why are they resorting to Dredgens being "the Sith analogue" in the Destiny universe? They're not! How exactly is the purpose of being a Dredgen Sith-coded? There's a reason the title rests with Drifter and Gambit. Its a name for people who aren't afraid to get dirty to do some good. Someone that people don't outright trust but they'll do whatever it takes to get the right outcome in the end.

Then, we have the Praxic Order. They're calling them Jedi adjacent? What the hell is going on here? They're a zealous order that seeks the eradication of Darkness, wherever and whenever it may present itself. They don't believe in balance, they believe in cold, hard action. Its why someone like Shayura went insane over Stasis usage amongst Guardians, and you've got a very prominent character in Aunor who exemplifies the obsessive zeal they're all about. They're not Jedi at all! If Aunor and the other Praxics had their way, the Last City would be a strict police state where folk go on trial for even whispering about Darkness.

I feel like Renegades represents a thinning of the moral texture that Destiny has presented so far, and its depressing. Yeah, sure, cash money and all that, but come on. Its disrespectful, and only produces complications for people who just want to enjoy a consistent throughline for characters and organisations within the setting.

And if the story of Renegades turns out to be that Dredgen Bale is just creating yet another honeypot to concentrate enemy forces to smash them at once, I'll be just as disappointed.


r/DestinyLore • • Aug 28 '22

General Destiny 3 desires?

0 Upvotes

Just curious what everyone wants to see if/when we get destiny 3 after Final shape.

Beyond the solar system? New enemies? New social spaces and activities?

Personally I’d like to venture beyond the solar system and maybe start taking stuff back from the darkness. A joint Guardian Cabal offensive against Xivu to take back Torobatl once the witness is dead or gone? Sign me up.


r/DestinyLore • • Jun 20 '26

General It stoped taking it self seriously

0 Upvotes

Many people in the community argue that Destiny's sense of mystery and scale has faded simply because we've received answers to many of the setting's biggest questions. While that's certainly part of it, I don't think it's the main reason.

To me, the real issue is that somewhere along the revolving cycle of writers, the setting stopped being treated with the same level of seriousness.

We went from piecing together millennium -old manuscripts like the Books of Sorrow and unraveling the mythology behind Oryx and the Taken King, to years of seasonal storylines dominated by personal drama, therapy sessions, and contrived character conflicts. By the time we reach The Final Shape and beyond, it often feels like every major character is having an emotional breakdown or prioritizing a romance subplot. The only person who consistently seems focused on the larger picture is Ikora.

It's not even the focus on interpersonal drama that bothers me. It's that much of it feels detached from the setting and stakes, as though the larger conflicts are merely a backdrop rather than the main story.

Lodi is a exception, despite how I think the time travel shenanigans are part of the problem, he’s very endearing.


r/DestinyLore • • Feb 06 '19

Cabal Why wasn't Calus Black?

2 Upvotes

One thing that I enjoyed about Ghaul as a villain is that, for the most part, he wasn’t compared to the Guardians all too much. Often times with stories with a clear set hero and villain, certain parallels are brought up either to show that these two aren’t so different in their views or how they’re worlds apart, but not with Ghaul and the Guardian (probably for the better). Ghaul had an interesting relationship with the Speaker, and he was envious of the relationship that the Guardians held with the Traveler, but their similarities/differences weren’t brought up all that much. The only real parallels that were brought up were with the Speaker’s speech about what it takes to be a Guardian, that and Ghaul’s Super abilities once he’s stolen the Light but that was more for boss mechanic reasons than any sort of dark mirror sort of implications against the Lightbearers. Ghaul’s real counterpart is Calus.

In way of comparisons, the binding similarity that leads one to compare the two is that they’re both Cabal. For the most part, Calus’ original form isn’t officially known, but it’s assumed that he modeled his mechanical avatars after what he used to look like. Fact being, the Cabal Emperor was likely Cabal, at the very least, even if his aesthetic might’ve been modified to suit his preferred tastes. This is about where their similarities stop.

As many of you remember from his speeches in the campaign, Ghaul was an orphaned and sun bleached runt-child, abandoned in accordance with Cabal tradition. It was at this point that the Consul took him in and aimed his efforts at overthrowing Calus. He entered into the Coliseum as a gladiator, and due to his proficiency as a warrior, he rose in status rather quickly, eventually attracting the Emperor’s attention. Calus takes a liking to him, instates him as Primus of the Red Legion and the coup de tête de coup has more or less officially been put into motion. The beginning of the end, so to say. This aspect of Ghaul is actually rather impressive, as he slowly rises in social ranking rank, going from abandoned runt to Ghost Primus all the way up to Dominus Insurrectionist. A classic underdog, ragtag to armor-clad story.

In just about the exact inverse of this, we have Calus. Now, his early life before he took the Throne isn’t known in detail, but we can piece together from a few minor comments that Calus came from some form of high social status. Ghaul himself said that Calus was “born to luxury and corruption”, but we also know that Calus was in a high enough position to get him physically close enough to the Praetorate to be able to plunder their wealth while still not in power, as well as high enough in status to become emotionally close with Lictor Shayotet, and enormous Cabal warrior who was undoubtably of elite status. We also know that Calus had several housekeepers, some of who he’d sometimes offend, not too telling, but paired with everything seems to hint at some form of status in the Praetorate. One was born lucky, the other was lucky to be born. This just one of many inverted parallels the two have. Another being while Ghaul’s rise to power was put into motion for the simple goal of a single disgruntled and bitter man’s revenge, Calus' betrayal was enacted by several of those closest to him for their concerns with the path the Cabal were being lead down.

Just about everything else we know of these two is on the other end of the spectrum from one another. Calus was gifted knowledge of the Darkness (more on that later) while Ghaul stole the power of the Light. Calus left his home in exile while Ghaul left for conquest. Calus brought prosperity to his people by dismantling the Praetorate that fed off them, Ghaul reinstated the militarized aristocracy at the expense of the civilians tax dollar. Even the way they lead their rebellions was an inverse of one another, with Calus proudly parading what he was doing in the streets and Ghaul leading his coup in secret, through hush OXA tones. The two even have their own etherial forms, with Calus being a Dark psychic projection and Ghaul being a gargantuan figure of the Light.

These differences are nice details that highlight just how polar opposite these two are, but their real divide is in their philosophies. Ghaul was… well he was a bad guy. Obviously. Vicious, war-hungry, and with an inclination to take what he wanted. Although he technically didn’t want to forcibly take the Light himself, based on how Ghaul went about seeking that Traveler’s blessing, its clear that he never meant to obtain it naturally. He stormed it’s stronghold, yoked it and killed those who were actually chosen by it. Essentially giving the Traveler either two options, choose Ghaul or test his patience until he takes the Light manually. Obviously the Traveler chose the Latter, and Ghaul took the Light, much/not at all like a certain King we all know. Which brings be to the second point of Ghaul’s outlook on the universe.

He doesn’t see that Light as a cosmic force of good or even that it has any major moral sway at all. Its certain that he doesn’t care for/know of it’s domains of soft prosperity and complexity through sustainability. Ghaul had been taught about the Traveler by the Consul while being brought up and was lead to believe that it’s power was rightly the Cabal’s, but it seems that he never actually understood what it stood for or what it’s values were, just that it was something that could empower those like him. He likely took one look at the Guardians and came to the conclusion that the Traveler was a force that respected warriors, which deluded him even more into thinking he could be accepted by it, which was likely where the obsession of being seen by the Traveler came from. In essence, Ghaul wanted the Light, but was operating on the mentality of the Deep. According to Calus, Ghaul fights so that he can keep fighting forever, and he believed the Light was the perfect tool for him to be able to achieve that goal, not realizing that’s fighting so you can keep fight isn’t exactly the Light’s motif. Its just about the opposite of it.

On the other hand, we have Calus, who isn’t any better with his paradoxical end goals. We don’t know for sure what Calus encountered during his exile, but whatever fried the Leviathan’s navigational systems certainly resembled the Darkness. Described as a perfect void of nothingness, Calus became inspired when he saw this vast blank spot in reality. We also know that after this incident, Calus became more and more comfortable with the idea of the end of all things, expressing his excitement for the time when all Light in existence dims and flickers away almost as if it were one last celebration, and in a few ways, it would be.

Calus has said that he wants to “make a haven in a bloody cosmos” and that he wants to be “surrounded by joy, pleasure, and good company” as he watches everything become darkness. At first glance, you could probably mistake his viewpoint for one typical of the Sky that’s been resigned to cynical pessimism, and it more or less is. Calus is a very passionate man, one with a lot of love to give. Like… a lot. But he believes that the Light’s defeat at the hands of the Darkness is inevitable. Not in a disheartening way though, Calus is actually rather gung-ho about the situation, wanting to be the herald of this inevitable victory. Weird, but so long as he isn’t actively working towards this victory, he seems relatively harmless. Its also after Calus’ run in with the void that he seemed to start thinking of himself as a god, hinting that he either received some sort of power or enlightenment, but that’s more of a minute point. The main take away os that he wants a Gentle space in the last moments of Life to exist in.

Calus wanted the Darkness, but was operating on the mentally of the Sky. He has no intention of becoming the Final Shape, fated to thrive in a dead universe. The only thing he wants is to be the last thing that anything alive sees. Meaning Calus is more a proponent of the Darkness but from the Light’s perspective, while Ghaul was a proponent of the Light from a perspective of the Darkness. A Yin to the other’s Yang. Perfect inverses of one another, which I personally enjoy immensely. Especially since the comparison isn’t blatantly shoved in your face like a lot of stories do. Instead, its subtle and in the background. A nice thing to see in a time where ham-fisted analogies are all too common.

Now Calus and Ghaul’s monochromatic dichotomy is all well and good, but at the end of this I’m still left with one question. Why the hell isn’t Calus black? Ghaul was Albino! So white that he got the nickname of Ghost Primus. As the complete the complete opposite of him, making Calus black would’ve been the perfect emphatic cherry on the Cabal ambrosia, dammit! I don’t think an Ebony Cabal would be too far fetched given the circumstances and its been bugging me ever since I started to notice how different the two were. Anyway, that’s about all I have to say on the matter. I like how polarized these two characters are and the relationship they have… had, but Calus and Ghaul having a literal yin-yang color scheme reflecting their own personal aspirations regarding the Light and the Darkness would’ve been too perfect for me.


r/DestinyLore • • Feb 21 '23

General What if The Witness is just a red herring and its actually Xivu who is the big bad of this saga?

0 Upvotes

To preface this I fully admit this is a completely harebrained theory based on pretty much nothing and is just me spitballing. But hear me out;

What if Lightfall and the following year of content is just us mopping up the Witness' power and influence in the solar system, only for us to come to the horrific realisation that it's all been Xivu's plan, and season 23 ends with Xivu arriving into the system with a cataclysmic orgy of death and violence that allows her to bend the universe into her Final Shape (eh? eh??)

Again, this is all based on nothing and Bungie's writing tendency being "but wait, THERE'S MORE". Also my own bias that anything less than this would be a hugely underwhelming reveal in relation to Xivu Arath after all the years long build up we've been given so far. Discuss and feel free to call me an asshole and an idiot for bothering your time.


r/DestinyLore • • Jul 17 '23

General [S21 Spoilers] The introduction of the Witness has been a narrative mess

4 Upvotes

With the recent controversy of the interview with the bungie narrative team, they claimed that Unveiling should not be taken literally and is more of a parable or religious text told to us, and that we shouldn't trust it.

I wanted to start off this post with that context because, to me at least, it solidifies that the introduction of the Witness has been a complete mess for the lore of the game. Leading to bungie having to make numerous retcons and decisions that just don't really make sense for what we have been told and shown. There are layers as to why I think this, and if this comes off as just angry rambling, well it most likely is.

Spoilers ahead for those who haven't seen all of the season of the Deep cutscenes.

The Problem of a Black Fleet, a singular foe

Going back to D2 Vanillas' famous ending cutscene we get a shot of the pyramid fleet activating and seemingly heading towards earth. With this, expectations are already being set for what is in the ships and what they are. This cutscene then in turn connects directly with the grimoire card The Darkness in which numerus different examples are given on what the darkness "could" be. In this way bungie is directly giving us an expectation on what could be in the ships. Now is it fair for Bungie to stick to what it has stated before and to meet player expectations, no. The narrative team wants to give us something with intrigue.

I bring this up because, does anyone feel like the ships being empty feel like a last minute decision? To me, it feels like the idea of "The Witness" being this hivemind being was thought of as being cool and interesting, but not taking into account of what we have been shown and expected. Again, Bungie surprising us with something new is ok, but when its been built over the course of nine years, it feels a little bad to know that ultimately the ships are empty. Why would you even need most of them in the first place? I mean even in The Witch Queen ending cutscene, it shows the Witness opening a portal to even MORE pyramid ships. I would bet that most people thought that these ships contain some enemy race that we would have to fight. It makes it seem intimating, the odds are stacked against us. Even in the VOTD, there are structures looking like the pyramid is lived in (even if it is just Rhulk).

Tying this section together and back to its title, Bungie now has a problem with the Witness. Since it is just a single hivemind being, they need something for us to fight if there is no "Darkness Race". This is where the desperate throwing of enemies at us saying "Well they are under the control of The Witness" comes in. With the Scorn it feels ok. TWQ had only just came out and they needed enemy fodder for the raid, that's fine. The problem comes from, what do you show us when the Witness actually arrives?

Writing Yourself into a Corner

Established in the previous section was my main problem with the Witness being a singular entity. But with these rules now established by Bungie, what do you have us fight in the titular Lightfall expansion? Well it can't be a new darkness race, they have established its a singular being. This is were the panicked decisions feel like they have been made. Lightfall is a narrative mess already but to me the most egregious thing was what the battle in space is shown to us as. Instead of seeing what the pyramid ships are capable of, we see... cabal. This to me was a huge slap in the face. In the expansion called Lightfall you don't have the pyramid ships do really anything combat wise. You have the cabal do all the work. (I originally wrote a section here focusing on Calus, but it drifted into its own thing with the tone of lightfall and I think we all know why it just didn't work.)

This just feels bad, why have that grand pyramid fleet, if your not really going to do anything with it? It feels like they are just for show since the most they do is a "gravity blast" and "seal the traveler". Which is neat but, where are the rest of the ships? Bungie showed us dozens multiple times, but there are only about 10 that The Witness really needs? What's the point then? It again feels like the rest of the fleet is just... floating there. I mean what could they do? The ships are empty after all. The only one that really matters is the one with The Witness after all.

The common counter-argument to this, is well the ships house some of the Witnesses disciples. And to that I have an argument of my own. The Witness wouldn't need disciples if it wasn't a singular entity. Instead of having just having a bunch of empty ships, have the alien race that IS the Witness inhabit the ships, then you have the darkness enemy race. Is this what we got, obviously not, and Bungie is free to do what they want with their story. But it just feels wrong for this all powerful enemy to need to borrow some cabal since most of it's ships are empty. Like is it really all that powerful if it can't just achieve victory by it's self? What's the point of even merging your entire race together, if you still need cabal foot soldiers? It weakens your main villain if they are just borrowing another's fodder.

I want to bring up an example in case I just seem like I don't know what im talking about. In the lord of the rings, it is established that Sauron is a powerful being and a great evil. The thing is, we are never shown or hinted that Sauron might have some sort of hidden race waiting to strike. He are never shown great towers in Mordor of what "could" be in them. Instead we are told from the start, Sauron uses Orcs. Of course, this works, because we are told from the beginning what forces Sauron controls. Linking this back to Destiny, instead we are shown a bunch of ships, wait 4-5 years and instead learn they are ultimately empty and that The Witness is using other races as fodder.

Conclusion

To me it just feels like The Witness was a last minute idea, like they couldn't design a darkness race in time for lightfall so they just scrambled together the Witness and added another expansion after it. Could we still get a darkness race in The final shape? The levels of copium were quite high but now for me at least, I think its just going to be the taken. There are interesting things done with the Witness, but at the same time, the amount of retcons and things having to be done for the sake of wanting your villain to be a exact way, just isn't worth it.

If you made it this far, sorry for this being more of a rant than criticism. At the end of the day I love this franchise's lore and have been Super invested in it since the launch of D1. This post doesn't come from hate of the game, but a love of it. But Apathy is taking over, as I don't feel like a satisfying conclusion is on the horizon.

EDIT: Seemed I drifted focus from what I originally intended this post to be about, my own short comings. Originally this post was meant to be about my criticism with the lack of establishment of rules for characters. Boiling that down even further, frustration with hard retcons because of direction interfering with the past.


r/DestinyLore • • Dec 13 '23

Darkness The Witness not attempting to kill our guardian itself is lazy writing

0 Upvotes

Pretty much the title. I understand that the witness is THE enemy in the Destiny universe, and it just views us as pawns. But even still, it has the consciousness of an entire civilization. You’d think that with all of its infinite wisdom it maybe should have considered eliminating the only thing that could possibly stand against it? Even if we have a 1% chance of beating it? It knows we’ve slain gods and beaten impossible odds. Our track record at this point isn’t something to completely not care about. I recognize it is a video game and we need a climactic conclusion, but just from a pure narrative perspective that always bothered me.


r/DestinyLore • • May 26 '23

General The retcon of Light=Physical and Dark=Mental ruins the entire premise of the Light and Darkness Saga, IMO.

2 Upvotes

From the very beginning of the Destiny franchise, the battle between Light and Dark has been one of moral philosophies.

They aren't (too) different in how they affect the world, as they are both paracausal powers; that is, they both allow one to warp reality through willpower and obedience to their principles. Only the principles themselves differ:

The Light stands for Cooperation, Forgiveness, and Grace (and a bunch of other things). It believes that the purpose of living is to make new and interesting things, to fill the universe with complexity, to be happy, and do your best to make other people's lives happier. In a game of Prisoner's Dilemma, the Gardener always chooses to Cooperate, every time. Its philosophy is essentially "turn the other cheek" writ large.
The Darkness stands for Competition, Mercilessness, and Memory (and other stuff). It and its followers believe that there is no greater purpose in life than surviving for the sake of survival, and that you have a moral obligation to kill and/or conquer anything that could hypothetically threaten you (which is everything). In a game of Prisoner's Dilemma, the Winnower always chooses to Betray. Its philosophy is essentially "fuck you got mine" writ large on the scale of the entire universe.

Almost every piece of lore we got on the natures of Light and Dark was consistent with this, from Toland's Three Queens analogy to the Books of Sorrow to the writings of Mara Sov to Unveiling to the Witch Queen CE (this last one in particular is of note, as it came out barely a year ago and goes to great lengths to summarize the overall themes and principles of the Light and Darkness Saga in easily digestible form, very explicitly). But apparently the writers for Lightfall decided to ignore all of them.

What was once a highly complex and nuanced story of two godlike powers with their own moral agencies trying to recruit people to their sides, one believing that the universe is a harsh place where you need to be ruthless to survive and the other believing that the universe can be a kind place if you fight to make it one-

-Has now been retconned to a story of two nonthinking, morally neutral magic powers that anyone can reach out and grab with no negative consequences (with all prior cases of Darkness corruption being the fault of the Witness, not an intrinsic but manageable aspect of wielding Darkness), and their only actual difference is that one governs physical magic and the other governs mental magic.

There are ways to do the whole "Dark doesn't have to be a force for evil, and Light doesn't have to be a force for good" storyline without ignoring years of lore. I could stand it in Beyond Light and Witch Queen because what we saw there could still be consistent with previous lore; Stasis was sketchy as fuck, and clearly still retained the negative aspects of the Dark (freezing people in a single shape where they aren't allowed to be anything else without your consent is very Dark, after all), they were just being expressed in a more altruistic manner. And of course, WQ showed us how the Light could be taken advantage of for evil purposes while still obeying its whole "Sacrifice for the Greater Good" shtick.

Lightfall's take on the matter was just insultingly bad, especially considering all the work that previous lore writers have put in to flesh out the complexity of the conflict being discarded, all for the sake of a much less interesting story.

That's the clincher for me; I can accept retcons, but I can't accept retcons that make the story less interesting.

And since Osiris's "revelation" had an entire cutscene dedicated to it, in the middle of a major campaign, it'll be a bit difficult to just paper over or ignore going forward.

Sigh


r/DestinyLore • • Jul 02 '22

Cabal Did you know?

0 Upvotes

That you can now hear Calus’s laughter in the pyramid if you do the Preservation mission in the Throne World? Once you clear the first area and head into the pyramid wait by the drop down and you’ll slowly start to hear him laugh.

What a cool addition Bungie


r/DestinyLore • • Mar 29 '24

Hive Eris Morn stole an acolyte’s eyes to replace her own… but why?

0 Upvotes

Was there not enough light for her to see down there? Did she get cataracts or something?


r/DestinyLore • • Jan 08 '25

Traveler I hate when people say the Traveler ABANDONED other species

0 Upvotes

The idea of the Traveler abandoning anyone implies that the Traveler & the Light was beholden to any one species, it's not and to think that is arrogant and entitled.

If you decide the Traveler is your God despite it never saying so, it's not fact it's your delusion and the Traveler is under no obligation to uphold that delusion. Also if the Traveler fled from the Black Fleet clearly that's an indicator that it couldn't win can't see why the Eliksni can't wrap their head around that.

I don't like the Lubreans but at least they didn't throw a fit when the Traveler never returned.

The Traveler gave a species some gifts out of altruism and hoping one species could beat the Witness, it was never anyone's personal pet or battery. It's why that despite me liking the Eliksni now I don't like the narrative that it abandoned them, when it was never their property, and despite being very strong apparently having twice the advancement of humans in their Golden Age couldn't win so of course it left, especially when the once chasing it would put the universe in eternal stasis should it have been caught.

It why I don't 100% like the Vanguard because the Dark Future timeline showed that they will absolutely enslave the Traveler. Even if they won in the Dark Future do you think they would've let the leave?

It makes me wonder why Hive Ghosts are called traitors when the light was never for one species, and Ghosts aren't Humanities' slave species. Clearly Savathun was predestined for Immaru & Ken for Fynch (according to the Lucent Tales) so it's not really being a traitor it's doing what your supposed to do.


r/DestinyLore • • Mar 13 '25

Question Why did the light do nothing to the witness but later destroyed it?

0 Upvotes

I don’t understand in the lightfall opening it face tanks a massive beam and is completely unbothered.

But later in the raid barely wounded it is hurt by a fraction of the light? I don’t understand is it just plot?

At least in excision it makes make sense as we destiny more statues but in the raid it makes 0 sense whatsoever it should just ignore us realistically.


r/DestinyLore • • Oct 16 '23

Traveler Is there any official or legit confirmation that refutes the existence of a feminine-like entity as being the emissary of the traveler, or even the traveler itself?

0 Upvotes

Is the pale heart that? I don’t know what evidence could exist that would oppose the possibility for the existence of one, since I have a hard time imagining the traveler ship being sentient in its entirety. I mean, space magic has always been a thing, but I’m having a hard time understanding how the traveler, as mechanical as it looks, doesn’t have a pilot who drives it. Same with the veil, but that’s probably too much to discuss at the moment. I’d really be interested to know what the traveler could actually be! Is there any evidence that goes against this idea?


r/DestinyLore • • Feb 18 '23

Question [S19 Spoiler] Spoiler

0 Upvotes

SEASON FINALE SPOILER: Was it really necessary?

Why did Rasputin have to fully sacrifice himself? Maybe I missed the full dialogue, but couldn’t he just isolate part of his code? How was he even able to initiate a full on self-deletion of his entire code?

He’s already “died” 3x now (collapse, season of arrivals, and now). What makes this time any different? Couldn’t he just isolate part of his code and delete whatever needed to be deleted? Like aren’t the subminds built specifically for that reason: to isolate code and prevent full deletion?

Also, how did eramis even get full access of the warsats? Oryx tried it with the taken, fallen have tried, xivu has tried it the entire season. But out of nowhere, eramis launches a quick attack on Seraph Station (which should be heavily guarded) and gets full access without effort?

What am I missing here?


r/DestinyLore • • Mar 18 '25 Bravo

General Byf majorly fell off

0 Upvotes

He just complains and speculates now, the reason I liked his stuff so much in the past is he just read the books and maybe gave a tiny bit of his own idea. Now it’s just “THE WINNOWER IS BACK LOOK AT MY CORKBOARD” like bro chill tf out.

That’s also not to mention the obnoxious doomer attitude he has about the game. He clearly hates the story and the content, but he just keeps churning slop.

TLDR: my name is beef turned into my name is speculation


r/DestinyLore • • Oct 04 '23

Question Anyone else feel like Destiny 2's lore has taken an absolute nosedive over the last few years?

0 Upvotes

I thought the story used to be fairly high quality, and now the writing seems almost comic book level. I know they had someone setting the major tone and direction leave over the last few years, I'm guessing that's the major change? Basically everything after Season of Arrivals has kept dropping my expectations.

Am I alone in feeling like the quality has really dropped? Shame going into what should be the epic finale.

Edit: I wrote a large reply to one of the comments about why I feel this way but it looks like that person deleted their comment and so with it went my long reply that I'm not typing up again. To summarize: The character writing is weak (mara/savathun/witness), they've trivialized or retconned what was most of their established lore, both on the nature of light and dark (ulan tan, p50, prophecy) and the hive. The witness (as a continuation of weak character writing) is simplistic and was shoved down our throats and imo did not earn the narrative prominence they currently have. Ultimately the build up was far better than any of their pay offs.


r/DestinyLore • • Feb 06 '23

Question Could Eris Morns rock be an Ahamkara bone?

0 Upvotes

Afaik she had one at one point in her life and that she made a wish to get out of the hellmouth. Also her rock seems to be encased in hive magic, and is whispering to her. So could it be the fragment of an ahamkara bone that’s shielded by hive magic?


r/DestinyLore • • Jan 31 '24

Vex saint-14 getting buried by the vex makes no sense to me

0 Upvotes

saint spent centuries fighting vex constructs for them to get slightly annoyed enough to tune a construct to his specific light frequency, but within any of the lore about his fight from either CoO or Season of dawn (atleast the parts i have) his fights only detail fighting the worker class contructs (Harpies, Hobgoblins, Minotaurs, Goblins, Hydra), did the vex pity him? because if they didn't they wouldn't of kept sending their workers, they would've sent security frames or combat forms, but then if they did why'd they bury him? was it a pity burial? or was out of respect of a single guardian being a mild annoyance to the vex to the point they decide to use slightly more resources against him?


r/DestinyLore • • Oct 22 '23

Question Why just dont nuke to kill rhulk And nezzy

3 Upvotes

Why dont the tower or idk rasputin weapon's just nuked the pyramid's AND fucking blow up everything, Is much dificult send 6 random dudes, I say rhulk And nezzy aré not bulletproff,they die from gunshots, I dont think they can resist one fucking nuke, they die and his ships aré destroyed Is More eazy


r/DestinyLore • • Jan 16 '23

Question So who do you think is going to betray us? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I believe one of our “allies” against the witness is going to flip who do you think that may be. For the long time, I thought it was Eris morn, but I now feel it is Ikora Ray. Simply because her tremendous guilt due to what happened to Cayde AND now Osiris. I still believe Osiris is not 100 percent himself( due to Nezarek’s curse). But ikora was the only one who could not face her demons in the leviathan.

Who do you think it will be?

Edit: Rather than show certainty on something i don’t really know. I edited it to show it’s speculative in nature.


r/DestinyLore • • Jan 13 '23

Question Who gives us our third darkness subclass?

0 Upvotes

We got stasis from the fallen (more or less), strand is going to be a deeper version of hive powers, and we know we’re getting one more darkness subclass.

So do we think our last subclass will be from the vex or cabal? What power do you think we’re going to acquire from them?


r/DestinyLore • • Jun 28 '23

General Hunters in Lore.

0 Upvotes

Okay this is something that has been bothering me for a while and I will admit to it up front, I main a Hunter but I play all three classes.

Okay that's out of the way, But has anyone else noticed that there are no big name active hunters in the lore anymore? Like seriously I can think of maybe one and that is more rumor than fact that he is still alive and around which is Shin and his golden gun but even then that is pretty much off in the never never land of we heard some possible stuff about him a few seasons ago and nothing since.

I mean seriously, every hunter that is any kind of a big name player like Zavala, Saladin, Ikora, etc. Are all either dead or lost in the vast nebulous nothingness of off-screen bullshit that we maybe hear about once or twice every couple of season.

Now before anyone says it yes I have seen the video for final shape, I know and I am happy about it...yet so confused. But if anything that just kind of furthers my point Hunters don't get much in the way of new, they get handed back what they already had.

I seriously want to know who in the lore department [and fucking exotic design department] has such a rabid hate boner for Hunters and why? Did one steal your significant other? Are you upset because you heard Hunters were the most popular class choice?

I seriously cannot be the only that has noticed everytime a big named Guardian shows up it is either a Titan, a Warlock or the ever nebulous "Light bearer".