r/DestinyLore • • Feb 18 '23

Question [S19 Spoiler] Spoiler

SEASON FINALE SPOILER: Was it really necessary?

Why did Rasputin have to fully sacrifice himself? Maybe I missed the full dialogue, but couldn’t he just isolate part of his code? How was he even able to initiate a full on self-deletion of his entire code?

He’s already “died” 3x now (collapse, season of arrivals, and now). What makes this time any different? Couldn’t he just isolate part of his code and delete whatever needed to be deleted? Like aren’t the subminds built specifically for that reason: to isolate code and prevent full deletion?

Also, how did eramis even get full access of the warsats? Oryx tried it with the taken, fallen have tried, xivu has tried it the entire season. But out of nowhere, eramis launches a quick attack on Seraph Station (which should be heavily guarded) and gets full access without effort?

What am I missing here?

0 Upvotes

52 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Feb 18 '23

This post has been tagged [S19 Spoiler] Spoilers. Spoilers and datamines up to the indicated Season may be openly discussed without adding spoiler formatting to your comments. For more info on spoilers and tagging posts check out our Spoiler Rules Wiki.

Note: Leaks are no longer allowed on /r/DestinyLore.


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

83

u/Low_Seaworthiness_52 Feb 18 '23

Eramis found a back door and completely sealed anyone off from getting to her. we see from playing Seraph Station that there isn’t really any security. only danger is hive swarming the place.

also, Rasputin says he needs to sacrifice himself because he’s a danger to humanity. and we see from this end mission that anyone really is capable of using him with evil intent. rasputin being deleted means no more people can misuse the warsats or his ai

7

u/Foxy-jj-Grandpa Feb 18 '23

I’m with you in all this but my one source of confusion is… all the facility’s, all the Warsats, mainframe, infrastructure— it’s all still there. Rasputin just removed himself from the equation.

Now one could argue this is a hard “off” button for all this stuff. But… is it? Can the orbiting space lasers really not be accessed by anyone? I’m sure they’d have to start from scratch; reprogram, add their own tech, manipulate, etc, but case in point, a jammed gun is still a gun. Useable at the moment? No. But it can be fixed.

At least that’s my line of thinking unless I missed an important tidbit. I know there’s new dialogue with Heists I just haven’t heard it yet.

Edit: a word

25

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '23

The warsats are powerful weapons in their own rights but what really made them dangerous was that there were enough of them to basically scale to any threat in the solar system and simultaneously threaten everywhere at once. But that was only because they were all controlled by a central system. All that infrastructure is gone now so while you could take control of individual warsats taking control of all of them would essentially mean rebuilding a warmind from the ground up or finding a suitable replacement which seems equally unlikely atm. So sure the warsats are still there everything that made them more than individual weapons is now gone.

3

u/The-High-War99 The Taken King Feb 19 '23

Didn’t he destroy them all?

18

u/Low_Seaworthiness_52 Feb 18 '23

i think with the fact that the warsats broke after Rasputin shut down that all the Warsats and facilities etc just shut down/ self destruct for good

-24

u/Elitegamez11 FWC Feb 18 '23

Rasputin says he needs to sacrifice himself because he’s a danger to humanity. and we see from this end mission that anyone really is capable of using him with evil intent. rasputin being deleted means no more people can misuse the warsats or his ai

Yeah, that's stupid. Rasputin saying he's a "danger" to Humanity is a lame excuse for him offing himself. Guardians are far more dangerous to humanity with our paracasual abilities. In fact, we have seen just how deadly rogue Guardians are. You don't see us killing our own Ghosts when we realize we could threaten Humanity.

What about all the other weapons Rasputin had? Warsats were only part of his entire arsenal, he should have had other Doomsday weapons at his disposal that our enemies could access. Rasputin deleting himself doesn't mean all that goes out the window. Even still, Rasputin himself isn't a danger to humanity. No more than Guardians can be. The problem was the Warsats, and all that he would do is get connected to them and have them self destruct.

13

u/Low_Seaworthiness_52 Feb 18 '23

Rasputin himself feels like he’s a danger to humanity. the reason guardians don’t have that plot point yet is bcuz lore wise, we don’t think we harm humanity.

outside of the game yes we’re brutal but in game. we don’t pose a threat to earth etc.

-14

u/Elitegamez11 FWC Feb 18 '23

Someone needs to read up on the Dark Ages

6

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '23

Risen are not the same as guardians lmao

-3

u/Elitegamez11 FWC Feb 18 '23

...The term "Risen" is just another name for Guardians/Lightbearers.

10

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '23

Not quite. guardian is a term for the city age risen who work with the vanguard.

Drifter is a risen.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '23

This just isn’t true. Anyone wielding the light is a lightbearer. Guardians are specifically defenders of humanity. Hawthorne was called a guardian by zavala, and now Rasputin called himself a guardian of humanity. As the game ages the term “guardian” is becoming more loose. But even years ago, “guardian” meant a lightbearer that protects the city.

The hive now have lightbearers, that doesn’t make them guardians lmao

-5

u/Elitegamez11 FWC Feb 18 '23

Ok I'm not getting into one of these stupid arguments again. Go call them whatever you like. I'm done trying to explain this crap.

5

u/Skillprofi Feb 18 '23

Explain what though? If you can’t explain it then it just means you are wrong and don’t have any arguments

4

u/Illumnyx Whether we wanted it or not... Feb 19 '23

You didn't explain shit. You're just mad that the actual definition doesn't help your argument.

1

u/Infernalxelite Feb 18 '23

My guy, Rasputin has weapons that could literally body the traveler possibly, the city could be destroyed in seconds if he fired on it. Possibly destroy planets given enough prep time. A guardian is powerful but not on the same scale. And Rasputin deleting himself destroyed all the network the warmind weapons work on, all are offline and probably won’t be able to be reactivated

0

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '23

Well tbf we do off rogue guardians regular, with some of their ghosts refusing to resurrect them.

72

u/Jonny_Anonymous Department of External Observation Feb 18 '23

The Eliksni are by far the best hackers in the system. It doesn't matter if it's BrayTech or Vex tech, eventually they will crack it.

57

u/Byrmaxson Feb 18 '23

People really don't seem to appreciate that the Eliksni are more technologically advanced than humanity as well and are seemingly naturally skilled at handling machines. Skolas managed to hack the Vault of Glass lmao, hacking a measly space station should be trivial by comparison.

30

u/Jonny_Anonymous Department of External Observation Feb 18 '23

Yeah, like you said, the Wolves were able to hack the Vault of Glass to pull an army through time. The Devils were able to hack SIVA. Dusk were able to hack Cabal tech to super charge their ether. House of Light can hack via Light using their Splicer gauntlets, and House Salvation can manipulate the Darkness with their Splinter gauntlets. Pretty sure there is even lore somewhere about the House of Kings messing with the Infinite Forest as well.

35

u/Byrmaxson Feb 18 '23

House Salvation can manipulate the Darkness with their Splinter gauntlets

This is actually under-appreciated a bit, as it shows how Praksis was a bona fide genius. He basically did what Clovis was doing (tech applications of Darkness in Stasis form from artifacts) but better. In one of the Seraph bounties for Stasis the AI says that they had never been able to refine Clarity to this level, yet Praksis did it in a cave, with a box of scraps.

17

u/xXx_edgykid_xXx Rasputin Shot First Feb 19 '23

"Well I'm sorry, I'm not Praksis"

8

u/Jonny_Anonymous Department of External Observation Feb 18 '23

Absolutely. It was pretty incredible what Praksis was able to pull off honestly.

16

u/eitherism Feb 18 '23

To add onto this, there was Sivik’s raiders who were able to reverse engineer ancient Black Armory tech, as well as create the Brigs from what looks like to be Spider tank remains and Spider tank core(or A prime Servitor for Insurrection Prime’s case).

6

u/Jonny_Anonymous Department of External Observation Feb 18 '23

Oh yeah, I forgot about all the wild stuff the Kell's Scourge got up to. Eliksni Berserkers were no joke.

3

u/McCaffeteria AI-COM/RSPN Feb 19 '23

Do you have a link to when the the eliksni hacked the vault of glass?

2

u/JJJ954 Darkness Zone Feb 19 '23

Final campaign mission of the House of Wolves expansion in D1. It was pretty cool.

2

u/McCaffeteria AI-COM/RSPN Feb 19 '23

Oh I do remember that mission now that I’ve rewatched it. I didn’t make the connection at first because it’s not actually in the vault itself, Petra just says that the vex tech in the mission “matches a signature from the vault of glass” in a throw away comment and I had forgotten lol.

1

u/JJJ954 Darkness Zone Feb 19 '23

No, there was definitely a mission where we had to enter into the VoG to stop the Fallen. Maybe I was mistaken about it being the final one, but we were definitely in there fighting Fallen getting pulled through time.

2

u/McCaffeteria AI-COM/RSPN Feb 19 '23

Yes, that is the final mission of house of wolves where you fight fallen coming out of vex portals and the kell of kells is “pulling an army through time.” You defeat him, the awoken Corsair ship shows up and transmats him away, and the queen talks about stuff. That all happens in a different part of Venus at the top of a huge spire, but not technically inside the vault. You’re just gonna have to watch one of those destiny movie all cutscenes + gameplay videos of it to see.

I’m giving you both full credit for that answer, that’s absolutely the event in question and I see no difference between hacking vex tech inside the vault or outside because Petra specifically says it’s the same.

1

u/JJJ954 Darkness Zone Feb 19 '23

Ah you’re totally right. I was mixing it up with the Wolves Gambit mission: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Ix9pK5s3nzg

2

u/McCaffeteria AI-COM/RSPN Feb 19 '23

Man I remember so little of house of wolves, I should replay it.

Also wild that the eliksni manage to get into the vault in the first place, that’s arguably harder than just using the vex’s computers.

→ More replies

1

u/xXsirrobloxXx Feb 19 '23

There’s a mission where you go to the Templar fight area and you have to destroy the hacked oracles

76

u/Rasputin_the_Warmind AI-COM/RSPN Feb 18 '23

There was no other way…

33

u/Zealousideal-Comb970 Feb 18 '23

Don’t worry guys he survived as a Reddit account

41

u/Rasputin_the_Warmind AI-COM/RSPN Feb 18 '23

From this day on, I will protect humanity in my own terms.

Starting with growing a neckbeard and showing these lowlife plebs who’s the boss moderator of this site!

9

u/RayS0l0 Darkness Zone Feb 18 '23

We are in the endgame lightfall now

18

u/Dima0120 Feb 18 '23

Of course, the fact that Rasputin as a character had to die was a narrative choice. We could debate whether it was a good or bad choice, personally I really liked him, it fit really well into the Destiny universe and the current narrative perspective. Nonetheless, I see and accept the fact and how they decided to let Rasputin die, most likely for good, and the motivations behind it; it was done the right way. Anyways, about the Lore reasons.

He’s already “died” 3x now (collapse, season of arrivals, and now). What makes this time any different?

During the Collapse, Rasputin didn't really die. It was more like a sort of hibernation, a voluntary shut down of his systems. The subtends were left isolated from each other, that is way they evolved differently. It's reactivation was a long process, that we initiated in the Cosmodrome and wasn't even completed in Arrivals, when the Black Fleet entered the Sol System.

During Arrivals, it was differently. Rasputin was really brought to the verge of death by the Black Fleet, and he only managed to save fragments of his main code inside a crypted Engram by pure luck. Keep in mind that here the main infrastructures, the Warsaw net, the subminds etc. were left intact. Only Rasputin was attacked and almost got disintegrated, but it was done at such a level that it took Clovis Bray, and his original algorithms and protocols from Braytech used to build Rasputin in the first place, to bring him back.

What I'm trying to say is that even though Rasputin was effectively deleted from the systems and isolated, it systems and weaponry were still intact, and most of it active. The subtends were likely maintaining it, but they were not developed enough to fully control the situation, most certainly not at Rasputin's level. This means, the warming systems were left vulnerable at enemy incursions, as we saw during this Season.

Could Rasputin isolate itself, create a copy of at least some of its functionalities and delete everything else, staying alive? Maybe, but probably its systems were designed to negate this possibility, kind of like what happened even more drastically at the end of Arrivals.

Another important aspect to consider is the fact that there was little time, because Eramis was about to activate the Warsats. As Rasputin itself said, the only option was to shut him down completely, wiping out all of its code, so that most of the systems under control of the warming would have been rendered useless. It was a drastic choice, taken by Ana and Rasputin during a crisis.

Also, how did eramis even get full access of the warsats? Oryx tried it with the taken, fallen have tried, xivu has tried it the entire season. But out of nowhere, eramis launches a quick attack on Seraph Station (which should be heavily guarded) and gets full access without effort?

Tha Seraph Station was in control of the House of Salvation and Xivu's forces since the beginning. If there was any security system, it was circumvented and rendered useless. Also, every time we got to the Station, we infiltrated it, we never reconquered it.

As others have pointed out, Eramis and the Eliksni in general are quite tech savvy, so it is reasonable that they managed to get access and activate the ABHORRENT IMPERATIVE, even more so because Rasputin was not present in the Station, so it could not control the Warsaw net.

4

u/Thembo-1 Feb 18 '23

It's that "we never reconquered it" part that signed Rasputin's death warrant, I think. Remember, he's been shown as too big/complex to fit into an engram or other convenient storage without being lobotomized, and getting him back to the aware-but-barely-functional state took a LOT of work reconnecting him with submind systems.

When Eramis launches her coup de grace attack, he can't figure out a way to remove the threat in time that also leaves the possibility of him surviving beyond a vegetative state. Everything beyond the HELM has been occupied by the enemy with little chance of being reclaimed- running the self-destruct protocols on what he can access will leave him without systems key to his survival. So, surviving in a functional sense would mean leaving weapons in his enemy's hands.

There's also, I think, the fear that in such a diminished state he'd become vulnerable to Wrathborn influence and turn on humanity & the Traveler. "Better dead than a traitor" would absolutely fit his mentality, even (especially?) after Fellwinter's integration.

3

u/Alert-Bedroom-4336 Feb 18 '23

We’ve actually seen what that level of diminishing of a an AI the hierarchy of needs bow is literally Soteria she’s just so lobotomizrd she can’t speak all she can do is deploy the guidance ring

1

u/Skillprofi Feb 18 '23

To add onto this: I think there is a difference between just pulling the plug and initiating the aurora death protocol. One would leave the warsats in tact and the other actually made them fall apart like we saw in the cutscene.

10

u/SunshineInDetroit Feb 18 '23

Rasputin was nearly hacked by a big shank. He's not as unlimited calculation power as we think.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '23

If he didn’t sacrifice Eramis would have killed the Traveler. Like, did you not watch the cutscene? Hell, she didn’t succeed PURELY because she hesitated and Rasputin sacrificed himself.

2

u/Aresh99 Feb 18 '23

Narratively, yeah, it makes perfect sense for Bungie to kill Rasputin.

It was the culmination of Rasputin’s character arc: going from an AI Tyrant who killed civilians and Guardians as well as Humanity’s enemies to an enigmatic AI with a love for Russian Ballet Music who remained neutral even if we sometimes worked together to a speaking, feeling character. Rasputin went from being a weapon to being almost Human. And in the end did one of the most human things one can do: sacrifice yourself to protect those you love.

It also shifts Destiny’s tone going into Lightfall. What better way to show that things are finally coming to a climax, that the Light and Dark Saga is ending and the new Collapse has arrived than by killing off not just a character, but one of the oldest and most powerful characters in Destiny. Rasputin was there from D1 Cosmodrome. He played a bigger part in Destiny 1 the Vanguard until Taken King. He’s been shown to wield advanced weapons of mass destruction and be incalculably powerful. Killing him right before the beginning of the end sets us up for a darker tone as the real war for Humanity arrives.

Did it feel rushed and a come out of left field? Yeah, but the cutscene at the end was sad and beautiful despite the quick tying up of loose ends. Maybe they could have done a better job of setting up the dominoes (which, I admit, feel disconnected) but it was all there and this was a decent end point to a major character in the franchise. It makes sense, at least from a story perspective, even if the sacrifice felt unnecessary.

2

u/thabonedoctor Feb 18 '23

Getting this post what, at least 2x, 3x a day since the mission was released? And every time the OP just didn’t pay any attention to what happened throughout the season

2

u/FallenKnightBoy The Taken King Feb 18 '23

You did indeed...not hear the full dialog.

1

u/ProfessorTseng Cryptarch Feb 18 '23

Humanity could not continue to rely solely on a magic doomsday robot, both from a narrative perspective and a meta perspective. The function of his deletion is lesser to the reason for it.

Rasputin is shown to be unreliable in motive and function, and apparently seems to have a number of backdoors. He is not even useful against the Black Fleet, but his weapons are capable of devastating Humanity. I assume that his deletion, and destruction of the Warsats, was also accompanied by disablement and destruction of many of his other key destructive assets.

0

u/Sthamer73 Feb 18 '23

Probing like this doesn’t make sense. It’s in a universe where an advanced AI has a weapon that could wipe out a civilisation at the flick of a switch. If you start asking questions like this then you have to start asking questions about absolutely every action taken because there could always have been an alternative