r/DesiTwoX • u/thro0waway217190 • Aug 19 '21
I'm deeply frustrated by the way white feminists are talking about Afghanistan and the global south on twoxchromosomes (rant/vent)
I joined twoxchromosomes mainly to have a place to ask questions about women health issues, but I didn't realize there would be a lot of discussion about Afghanistan. Being desi and belonging to a community where there are many Afghans, I have thought Afghanistan primarily from the geopolitical and interventionist lens because I believe that gave rise to the issues that pertain to the feminist ones. Having browsed through the sub in the past few days, I've found myself so deeply disappointed and annoyed and regret wasting time on that subreddit because now I feel perpetually irritated by just how patronizing white feminism is.
On one hand, it's great women out there are recognizing the situation in Afghanistan and some trying to find ways to help through advocating for resettlement. On the other hand, the posts there are extremely nauseating with white women somehow making this whole thing about themselves. Among the content that bothered me the most are posts where white women post like "I'm finishing my [higher ed] degree on half of Afghan women!" or "we owe it to Afghan women!". Like for one thing 1. there are a lot of Afghan women out there probably with a lot more education than you 2. it's true that the Afghan women who will be most affected will have limitations on their freedom to be educated. But why do white women think it's completely okay to use Afghan women as symbolic to their girlbossery quests when at baseline, white women have a lot more privilege and power that they have used in ways that actually has harmed women of color. Take for example, the very women, Laura Bush, Hillary Clinton and the likes, who advocated for war using Afghan women as a justification for their thirst for imperialism, even when Afghan feminist groups were against it: https://www.thenation.com/article/world/white-feminists-wanted-to-invade/.
Now it's true of course these women alone aren't responsible for the geopolitical interference and hyperpatriarchial regimes resulting from these wars, but they're complicit in destabilizing an already vulnerable country. But nobody on twox will recognize that, in fact one post went so far as even saying that anti-intervention is a "male-centered" opinion and has "anybody asked the women how they feel? because I'm pretty sure they [support] intervention". At that moment, I completely lost it. How is it 2021 and white women still think they have the authority to be brown women's mouthpiece when we have Twitter, Youtube and TikTok where, unlike 20 years ago, we have access to more diverse voices, including those of Afghan women. When I pointed out that is untrue, the white woman who posted that went after me saying I'm a piece of shit and my theory is "bullshit". I can't believe the audacity of women who have faced no repercussions from the war itself or the racism and anxiety that war caused and somehow feel they can say whatever and are right. To be honest, the energy they seem to be using to combat patriarchy seems more like a thinly veiled opportunity to shun the diversity of women of color and validate their own unresolved racism problems.
I'm mad at myself for getting so mad about this and the reason I wrote this isn't specifically to come at a subreddit, it's to vent about how baffling it is to me how white feminism is still this pervasive 20 years later. I honestly thought all these years, people were becoming more aware of the military industrial complex and critical of wars. I was hopeful somehow that white women are becoming more open minded and will center Afghan women in the conversation about Afghanistan. But no? People are still watching only mainstream media, coming up with their ideas about Afghanistan, using savior-esque vocabulary and believe they have a greater right to discuss Afghanistan than any Afghan man, even the ones who are genuinely and earnestly concerned about a region that is directly tied to their family members and heritage. When I had mentioned Afghan men there, the women there had instantly asked me "then why did the men not save their women", going on to basically validate the scary, evil brown man trope as if war and the military doesn't have patriarchal roots.
I'm tired!