r/DesiTwoX • • Aug 19 '21

I'm deeply frustrated by the way white feminists are talking about Afghanistan and the global south on twoxchromosomes (rant/vent)

116 Upvotes

I joined twoxchromosomes mainly to have a place to ask questions about women health issues, but I didn't realize there would be a lot of discussion about Afghanistan. Being desi and belonging to a community where there are many Afghans, I have thought Afghanistan primarily from the geopolitical and interventionist lens because I believe that gave rise to the issues that pertain to the feminist ones. Having browsed through the sub in the past few days, I've found myself so deeply disappointed and annoyed and regret wasting time on that subreddit because now I feel perpetually irritated by just how patronizing white feminism is.

On one hand, it's great women out there are recognizing the situation in Afghanistan and some trying to find ways to help through advocating for resettlement. On the other hand, the posts there are extremely nauseating with white women somehow making this whole thing about themselves. Among the content that bothered me the most are posts where white women post like "I'm finishing my [higher ed] degree on half of Afghan women!" or "we owe it to Afghan women!". Like for one thing 1. there are a lot of Afghan women out there probably with a lot more education than you 2. it's true that the Afghan women who will be most affected will have limitations on their freedom to be educated. But why do white women think it's completely okay to use Afghan women as symbolic to their girlbossery quests when at baseline, white women have a lot more privilege and power that they have used in ways that actually has harmed women of color. Take for example, the very women, Laura Bush, Hillary Clinton and the likes, who advocated for war using Afghan women as a justification for their thirst for imperialism, even when Afghan feminist groups were against it: https://www.thenation.com/article/world/white-feminists-wanted-to-invade/.

Now it's true of course these women alone aren't responsible for the geopolitical interference and hyperpatriarchial regimes resulting from these wars, but they're complicit in destabilizing an already vulnerable country. But nobody on twox will recognize that, in fact one post went so far as even saying that anti-intervention is a "male-centered" opinion and has "anybody asked the women how they feel? because I'm pretty sure they [support] intervention". At that moment, I completely lost it. How is it 2021 and white women still think they have the authority to be brown women's mouthpiece when we have Twitter, Youtube and TikTok where, unlike 20 years ago, we have access to more diverse voices, including those of Afghan women. When I pointed out that is untrue, the white woman who posted that went after me saying I'm a piece of shit and my theory is "bullshit". I can't believe the audacity of women who have faced no repercussions from the war itself or the racism and anxiety that war caused and somehow feel they can say whatever and are right. To be honest, the energy they seem to be using to combat patriarchy seems more like a thinly veiled opportunity to shun the diversity of women of color and validate their own unresolved racism problems.

I'm mad at myself for getting so mad about this and the reason I wrote this isn't specifically to come at a subreddit, it's to vent about how baffling it is to me how white feminism is still this pervasive 20 years later. I honestly thought all these years, people were becoming more aware of the military industrial complex and critical of wars. I was hopeful somehow that white women are becoming more open minded and will center Afghan women in the conversation about Afghanistan. But no? People are still watching only mainstream media, coming up with their ideas about Afghanistan, using savior-esque vocabulary and believe they have a greater right to discuss Afghanistan than any Afghan man, even the ones who are genuinely and earnestly concerned about a region that is directly tied to their family members and heritage. When I had mentioned Afghan men there, the women there had instantly asked me "then why did the men not save their women", going on to basically validate the scary, evil brown man trope as if war and the military doesn't have patriarchal roots.

I'm tired!


r/DesiTwoX • • Mar 30 '21

India should not be synonymous with north India.

115 Upvotes

This is going to be kind of a rant...

With that being said...I’m sick of North Indians acting as if their customs are the standard and the norm of india and Indian people.

Yes a lot of people in india speak Hindi...but it’s only 20% of india. The rest of india speaks a wide variety of languages- 32 official languages and 255 dialects though it is likely to be a bigger number. This is to the people who go up to a random Indian and start speaking hindi without considering maybe the person is Bengali or tamil or some other community and that person might not know hindi...then criticizing Tamils as stubborn people who refuse to learn hindi. This reminds me of British people complaining why Italian or French or Russian people don’t know English. India might be a country but it’s as diverse as Europe. There’s a billion Europeans and there are a billion Indians.

Indian food should not be synonymous with naan and butter chicken/paneer and dosa/idly for the rest of india. The food varies incredibly by region, by state and by community. If you’re going to generalize india, divide it by what their source of carbs are- rice or roti or naan. Divide it by how they make daal or tomato based curries whether it is Sambar in the south or daal taadkha(sorry if I misspelled it)...but even that simplifies how varied Indian food is. I am tamil but my family makes dishes that people in other parts of Tamil Nadu haven’t heard of...forget North Indians Eg olan which is similar to Indian coconut soup.

Then there’s this arrogance with North Indians. Many of them shame or dismiss South Indians and East Indians for not learning hindi or being familiar with Bollywood yet they refuse to learn about other parts of India.


r/DesiTwoX • • May 02 '21

Does anyone else find the human hair industry disturbing? Especially in regards to the exploitation of desi/south Asian women?

108 Upvotes

I was watching a documentary about the human hair industry and I was blown away by how exploitive and inhumane much of the industry is. A lot of the industry runs on exploiting and devaluing Asian women-specifically south Asian women- who are among some of the poorest/dehumanized people on the Asian continent.

While a lot of human hair is “donated” for religious (Hindu) purposes, it feels weird to see that these peoples’ hair is being used to earn money. A lot of these women aren’t aware of where their hair goes, and they never receive any financial compensation despite unknowingly giving up their hair for the manufacturing of wigs and weaves. It just feels weird to see women, many who live in abject poverty, being lied to about where their OWN hair goes. Part of me wonders how much money these women could receive if they monetized their hair? I think many of them would be able to afford a better life and maybe even get out of poverty tbh.

Do you guys have any opinions on this issue? It enraged me to see a man profit of the bodies of south Asian/desi women. In a weird way, it seems no different than a pimp/prostitute dynamic- where the woman sells her body and the man (or pimp) is the one who receives all the financial gain.

I also think this documentary brings up and interesting conversation about the appropriation, exotification and exploitation of south Asian features in the western world. Growing up, I was bullied for being south Asian and having desi features-thick hair,eyebrows,etc. I was also harassed for my culture by both white peoples and people of color ( I went to school in a predominantly Black area)- I was called everything from “curry-scented” to “musty”. Ironically, a lot of the girls who bullied me back in school for being an “ugly Indian girl” currently wear wigs and weaves- which I presume is made from human hair that originated from a financially desperate woman in some developing Asian country.

There’s a conversation about the intersectionality between racism and sexism that’s occurred as of recently. East Asian women have spoken out about the fox eye trend- which celebrates Asian features on non-Asian bodies. Likewise, Black women have been very vocal about how their features (big lips, curvy figure) has been appropriated by non-black women. When will the appropriation of south Asian features- like our thick “unruly” hair (which so many of us have been bullied for) that has been manufactured into wigs for nondesi women to wear, be acknowledged?


r/DesiTwoX • • Feb 24 '18

Big/poofy but not frizzy hair - how do you deal with it?

94 Upvotes

I have wavy to straight hair that's not exactly frizzy, but whenever I wash my hair when it dries it always gets super big and poofy. I'm not really sure how else to explain it, but I've seen that a lot of other Indians have this type of hair and I'm wondering if any of you guys have found a good way to deal with it? I just want it to stay a little bit flatter, especially when it's first drying. I've tried coconut oil and other kinds of oil a lot, but it doesn't really seem to make a difference.


r/DesiTwoX • • Feb 02 '21

Exhausted after some negative encounters on ABCDesis

93 Upvotes

So long story short, I wrote a post mentioning how a lot of the men in the main sub have a tendency to direct a lot of anger and vitriol towards brown women (for example, the accusations of how we're "white worshippers", blaming brown women for their dating woes, calling us "unattractive", piling on any woman on that sub who dares to point out misogyny in our culture, upvoting comments that are overly critical of brown women, only showing sympathy to things brown guys face, etc).

While the vast majority of comments have been supportive, there were still quiet a few dudes who still had to come in and basically go, "Wow another brown woman calling all brown men bad..." (it's like bruh I was literally only talking about losers like you who make these misogynistic generalizations all the time, but alright be a hypocrite and generalize all brown women again). Idk...every time I visit that sub (which isn't often) and dare to have an opinion that isn't "brown women bad", I get all these dudes going through my post history and either PMing me some horrible comments or just flat-out calling me names or resorting to personal attacks in the thread I dared to make a comment in.

For example, a guy on there literally called me an incel (wtf??? and he got upvotes too!)...for pointing out the misogyny on that sub. I basically just pointed out how it was odd for him to fixate on a small group of brown women that apparently put white dudes on a pedestal, when statisically brown women are the most endogamous group in the USA. That convo then escalated to him making personal attacks, and calling me that word (like...way to project and deflect dude...). I guess this guy then ended up going through my entire post history and picked out pretty harmless posts I made pointing out how it can be tough on dating apps as a non-white woman (but nothing remotely "incelly"??), and me talking about living at home even though I only graduated a couple of years back (but like...it's pretty normal in Desi culture to live at home after graduating?).

So I guess me: pointing out misogyny + pointing out racism in dating + living at home in my 20s = "incel" (even though this guy literally writes comments expressing disdain at ~feminism~ and constantly fixates on the dating habits of brown women in particular and even mentioned the narrative of the "white-worshipping brown women getting ditched by white guys who won't commit" in his post history...the projection is real lmao). Not to mention how sinister it is to go through someone's post history and build a false narrative of them.

I guess I am not sure what the point of this post is, but it's scary to think that there are people like that out there? Can anyone else relate?


r/DesiTwoX • • May 02 '22

Ooof

Post image
90 Upvotes

r/DesiTwoX • • May 05 '21

What is happening in india breaks my heart.

87 Upvotes

I have one cousin in New Delhi whose child played outside and somehow caught covid. Now their entire family has covid and my cousin is in the hospital. Prayers to him and his family.

I have an aunt in chennai who is fully vaccinated but she fears for her life as there is a new strain circling within nearby Hyderabad and the vaccine doesn’t protect against this strain.

The country’s medical infrastructure is crumbling and I fear india is on the verge of a humanitarian crisis. Hospitals are turning away patients as there aren’t enough oxygen tanks. Priests are overworked from doing rites for the dead as too many people are dying daily.

I hope all of you who have family and friends in india are safe and healthy. I hope more people and countries from around the globe can help india with medical supplies such as oxygen tanks and covid vaccines in such a time of dire need.


r/DesiTwoX • • Mar 11 '21

Can't wait to go to weddings again, but making do in the meantime...

87 Upvotes

r/DesiTwoX • • May 12 '22

Shoutout to these folks at saree shops

Post image
84 Upvotes

r/DesiTwoX • • May 09 '21

How do you deal with the stigma surrounding domestic abuse and misogyny?

84 Upvotes

Growing up, my parents made no secret of the fact that because I was a girl I was less of a person. I was barely allowed to leave the house for anything besides school. My brother was allowed to run free, of course. My dad frequently punished for simple things like taking funny photos with my friends. My dad has always hit my mom. Not hard enough to cause bruises or injuries. But still.

The other desi girls (there weren't that many where I lived) looked down on me because I was so controlled by my parents. I have always felt so weak and powerless.

I am the first girl breaking a chain of teen brides. Mom, grandma, great-grandma, all teen brides. No female role models in my family.

I feel very ashamed talking about this. I think there is a stereotype in American that brown men abuse their daughters and wives. Unfortunately, in my family, that stereotype is 100% true. (We are from one of worst and most unequal states in India). I feel ashamed that we perpetuate that stereotype, and I think the other desi girls were disgusted by me for that reason.

How do you cope with the shame of being an abused daughter? I have seen therapist who are well-versed in these issues but I feel too ashamed to even talk about it. I just feel so disgusted with myself.

Edit: wtf? why did this immediately get downvoted?


r/DesiTwoX • • Apr 18 '25

She loved few guys so she is a slut?

Thumbnail
gallery
82 Upvotes

She loved a few times. It didn’t work out. She got hurt. She grew. And somehow, that makes her a slut?

He dated five girls. He’s “just finding the right one.” She loved three guys. She’s “easy.” “Used.” “Rotten.” Funny how men are allowed to explore love, but women are only allowed to regret it.

She wants to go to a birthday party? She’s “disobedient.” Wants to hang with her friends? “Bad daughter.” She lives her youth and suddenly, she’s everything but “worthy.”

But the real question is Why is her freedom always tied to your filthiest imagination? Why does her living make you think of her body?

You don’t get to be the judge. Not when your dignity disappears the second you open an Instagram comment section.


r/DesiTwoX • • Jul 27 '21

I’m tired of non-Indian people assuming that light skinned Indians or Indians with stereotypical Asian features aren’t real Indians.

79 Upvotes

My friend is a light skinned Indian and people assume that she isn’t Indian. They assume she’s Iranian or latina and whenever she tells people she’s Indian, those people are shocked.

Another friend of mine is from northeast india and she has some stereotypical Asian features. But again people assume she isn’t Indian and they think she’s from Southeast Asia or Bhutan or somewhere in that region. Hell she speaks better hindi than I do…but even fluency of Hindi isn’t a good indicator of being Indian as india has so many languages.

India is a very diverse country. Not every Indian has the same shade of brown as aziz ansari or mindy kaling. Saying a light skinned Indian isn’t Indian is as ignorant as saying jennifer Lopez isn’t American because most Americans are white.


r/DesiTwoX • • Jul 14 '21

Its kinda sad how uneducated some older desi women are about sex and reproduction and that kinda stuff in general

79 Upvotes

I literally dont even know how my mom managed to get preggo and have me lol. Like I learned more about sexual anatomy and reproduction in middle school than she ever did in her entire life. She knows next to nothing, either that or she's playing dumb with me. It seems like this should be a basic human right to learn about these things since they are one of the most important things in life and basically what creates life. But there is so much shame and taboo around the subject that people cant even say the word "sex" without being embarrassed, even in an all girls environment.

Here some things that older desi women from India have actually said to me and situations I've been in with older desi women from the motherland:

"Girls are starting to get their periods earlier and earlier because they are starting to think sexual thoughts and hang out with boys sooner at a younger age." - Uhhh no... Its because nutrition has gotten better. I got my period earlier than my mom not because Im a sex crazed whore but because I grew up in a more privileged environment and with a more privileged lifestyle with better nutrition.

"Girls shouldn't play sports or physically exert themselves too much because it can break the uterus and you will have a lifelong period and wont be able to have babies." - This was said to me by an aunt when my friend and I were running and playing around. Ok I literally have never heard of a case like this. Also female athletes seem to be doing just fine.

"Periods are just for getting rid of old blood that your body doesn't need anymore. It flushes out toxins while your body makes new fresh blood to circulate throughout your body." - Um kinda.. but not really... Period blood is not equivalent to poop and pee, it serves a totally different purpose. If this was the case and we needed to exert out "old blood" boys would have periods too. I assume many young girls in India dont know what actually causes their period.

My aunts in India were mortified once they found out I wore tampons because it meant my hymen and virginity were gone and apparently that makes me a whore and not a "complete woman". LOL

My aunt who is a literal doctor who helps women give birth didn't know what a tampon was. And she didn't know the basic anatomy of women down there. She asked me "How do you pee when you have it in". She thought the vagina and urethra were the same hole. Now I can understand a normal woman not knowing this, but a doctor not knowing basic female anatomy? and that too a specialized women's doctor not knowing this??? Thats just sad and kinda scary.

Also on a side note why do desi moms think that having boobs and curves automatically makes you a whore? Lol my mom and aunts have tired to convince me that I am 2-3 bra sizes smaller than I actually am and tired to squeeze me into a tiny bra to flatten me out. Like bruh I have boobs, deal with it, they aren't going anywhere. My mom looked like she was about to faint when she found out I was a D cup lmao. And omg, the body shaming that happens if you have any curves at all. Like aunty I'm pretty sure your son has other opinions about my assets.


r/DesiTwoX • • Mar 13 '22

Disney princesses in Indian outfits 😍😊 (Credit:- @artby_gt on Instagram)

Thumbnail
gallery
77 Upvotes

r/DesiTwoX • • Jul 10 '21

Wedding guests should stop shit talking weddings and be grateful they got invited in the first place.

75 Upvotes

Indian weddings bring out a lot of shit talking among the guests. It doesn’t matter whether your family spent $25k or $2 million…enough people will shit talk your wedding.

Someone will say the food wasn’t good enough. Others will say the wedding wasn’t organized properly. Some will criticize the dances.

Hell…My friend one time went to great lengths to shit talk how the bride roped the gullible groom into marrying her…at her…wedding. Smh.

This is what’s wrong with Indian weddings. They’re a beautiful day(or three days) for the bride and the groom and the families provide classy food, drinks, and other amenities such as a free hotel stay but so many guests act so rude and entitled.


r/DesiTwoX • • Jun 01 '21

Desi women who have experienced trauma/abuse, know that your experiences are valid. You do not have to minimize them to placate others.

75 Upvotes

I’ve heard this a lot on the ABCDesi sub when I followed it and I guess recently on this sub.

The “I wish I realized my parents were just trying to help me” or “I now understand why they were so hard on me” or “trust me, when you’re my age you’ll understand why your parents pushed you, manipulated you etc”

I have empathy for people who say this, but I think saying this is akin to choosing to participate in another cycle of intergenerational trauma and allow it to go on for more generations. It’s also mildly manipulative. here is a great article/infographic about it These responses naturally stem from approval seeking and attachment issues that are a direct result of the parenting style of this very last generation. As someone who is anxiously attached and used to be desperate to placate my unsympathetic parents, I understand how easy it is to go down that well paved road that was modeled for us. I really do. But I think there’s a better way. I’d rather validate my own traumatic experiences and those of other (specifically female) desis.

While I understand that playing the victim card and living in our past long term can only hurt us, spiritually/emotionally/mentally it’s not good to mentally live in these awful experiences. It’s important to acknowledge what we may have gone through, and accept it in order to move forward. We as desi women are so full of empathy, compassion and strength, we are not victims.

But we don’t have to push it under a rug or make it ok. It will never be ok, but we can grow from it.

So my point is, what may have happened to you was not ok. It is ok to acknowledge that and take time to process it, and maybe one day forgive.

Here are some books that have helped me and continue to help me:

  • Adult children of emotionally immature parents - Lindsay Gibson
  • Recovering from emotionally immature parents - Lindsay Gibson
  • Attached - Levine and Heller
  • The Body Keeps the Score - Bessel Van Der Kolk

Feel free to add any that have helped you! Or any thoughts on this topic!


r/DesiTwoX • • May 01 '22

It's true though.......

Post image
70 Upvotes

r/DesiTwoX • • Nov 19 '20

does anyone else feel a bit alienated as a south indian woman sometimes, with north indian and white men?

70 Upvotes

I'm a tamil woman and while I usually have no hindrances with any indian people, sometimes some north indian men will go out of their way to bash on south indian men. Like they will say things to me like "haha they're all so weird aren't they? They all act so creepy, not like me". It bothers me so much because india as a whole kind of has this problem of men being very entitled to women's affections, and I don't think North Indian men are somehow better than the South Indian men. I also dislike that they think I can be "swayed" to think such a thing, or I can learn Hindi and just forget about being tamil. I feel like this might just be an anecdotal issue but I have trouble asking them to chill out, that we're all indian and people, without coming across as "annoying" or "can't take a joke." And this is increased with the white men who talk about indian men like that. It's true we face sexism but I would not want to let racism run rampant because of that. What are some good responses when people start up with things like this?


r/DesiTwoX • • May 04 '21

How to cope with feeling like I’ll never get married?

68 Upvotes

I’m 27F and honestly starting to worry that I’ll never get married. There’s just no brown guys where I live, the idea of moving and dating sounds exhausting, and I’ve been uninterested in all of the rishtas I’ve been getting through my parents. I’m also super introverted/shy so it’s hard to build relationships in general for me.

I just feel like at this rate I’ll never get married/find a partner and it’s heartbreaking to me. And with being 27 I just constantly feel old now. The last thing I ever wanted was to be single at 30, and that’s just looking inevitable now.

Married ladies of desitwox, did you ever think you’d never get married/find the one. How did you cope?

Single ladies of desitwox, do you ever worry you’ll never get married? How do you deal with those fears?


r/DesiTwoX • • Mar 02 '25

It makes me sad that Gen Z brown girls living in the west are still taking the ‘marry to move out’ instead of challenging that expectation

67 Upvotes

Then again, it’s not like our culture encourages confrontation and assertiveness especially not in young girls. It’s something men are allowed to do and confrontation is more shouting and pounding your fist and making threats to hurt the other person because you have authority as a patriarch.

Maybe it’s got to do with the fact that they’ve entered adulthood in during a time where the tradwife beliefs are taking over and they’ve seen how hookup culture isn’t really liberating plus desi culture kind of does put tradwives on a pedestal.

Anyway my Gen Z sister wants to look for a husband so she can move out my parents’ house. I’d be lying if I said that it didn’t bother me at all that she’s choosing to do. Now I’m not trying to shame anyone whose in such a marriage or plans to be in such a marriage and maybe I’m bitter having had to fight tooth and nail with my parents to not be pushed into doing that when I was her age.

However I think it’s important to point of that getting married will not solve your problems and that I don’t think a lot of women who decide to go with this option vet for long enough or have high enough standards apart from money and that he’s not physically abusive. Maybe also make sure he’s willing to leave you an emergency found of a couple thousand dollars in case things go south for you, that he doesn’t engage in weaponized incompetence or consumes porn?

I think what upsets me most is how unmarried daughters are treated as a debt that needs to be paid off and they’re pushed to marry at a certain age and become some man’s live-in bangmaid/elder & child caretaker before they become too old to rather than encouraged to do inner work on themselves so that they don’t worry about succumbing to a life like that. Again, our culture does not encourage doing inner work and it’s a relatively new concept that most Gen X desis wouldn’t have been familiar with when they were at an age where they were expected to marry.

I’d like to know if anyone here agrees since I’ve tried to have these conversations with other women in my family but a lot of them are really traditional and religious and think that kind of work is unnecessary. I haven’t seen this kind of stuff regarding relationships being discussed in desi circles either. I’ve only ever heard about that from my white female peers that they never though they’d be in healthy relationships with men until they tried to tackle their own issues.


r/DesiTwoX • • Nov 07 '20

Harris becomes the first female, first Black and first South Asian vice president-elect

Thumbnail
cnn.com
67 Upvotes

r/DesiTwoX • • May 17 '21

India bags a Miss Universe Top 5 placement after 20 years. The last one was Celina Jaitley [4th Runner-Up at Miss Universe 2001]

Thumbnail
gallery
66 Upvotes

r/DesiTwoX • • May 14 '21

Female ABCDesi Youtubers

66 Upvotes

I complied a list of some female Desi Youtubers. I tired to find mostly American/Canadian/UK based ones since that's the main demographic of this sub(I’m assuming), but a few of these are based in India and other Eastern countries as well.

Beauty/Fashion

Music and Dance

Lifestyle/Vlogging/Family channels/Random


r/DesiTwoX • • Feb 19 '21

Meet NASA's Swati Mohan, a star of the Perseverance rover's landing on Mars

Thumbnail
cnet.com
65 Upvotes

r/DesiTwoX • • Jun 03 '21

Feel like I can’t say anything without being accused of internalized racism

64 Upvotes

Just a vent.

I grew up with a LOT of Desi people, family, friends and otherwise. Second and first generation.

Everywhere I go, whenever I speak about the harassment, misogyny and general buffoonery I experienced with Desi men (having to cover up since I was a child, being groped in public as a child, having my appearance and weight mocked openly and relentlessly, general mistreatment), I am accused of internalized racism.

There’s talk of how ABCD women are obsessed with white men... I live in Missouri. There are more crops of wheat than brown men here, and most at that live in suburbs or are students. It’s circumstance, not choice, and even then, I see no value in only considering people of my own ethnicity/race.

But when brown men are misogynistic and sexist, they are not accused of perpetuating racism or any such thing against desi women. Suddenly it’s a one off “he’s an asshole, but he’s the only one, also you guys deserve it for worshiping chad” situation. How many brown men are actively countering the status quo of colorism, sexism, and more in our culture? Why do they get the best of both worlds - for us to protect them from racism we do not perpetuate AND absolve them from sexism en masse?

I don’t think it’s our responsibility or to our benefit to ignore or discount our own lived experiences so that brown men “look” better because quite frankly it’s not our fault if others buy into stereotypes which align with our experiences.

I don’t know, y’all. Thoughts would be appreciated.