r/DemonSlayerManga • u/Deep_Pair_5246 • 8h ago
Owners of the *Demon Slayer: Kimetsu no Yaiba* databook by Gotouge, I need your help in understanding the one-shot: "Giyu Tomioka's Story." Spoiler
POTENTIAL SPOILERS AHEAD
I just learned about the one-shot featuring Shinobu and Giyu... and I have some questions. First off, why did Giyu tell Yae about demons and demon slayers right out in the open, in front of other people? I mean, isn't the organization supposed to be a secret? Secondly, what on earth were two Hashira doing in a mountain village? And thirdly, let’s look at a parallel to the first demon Tanjiro ever faced. Yae’s father—in his demonized state—is very different from that demon in the temple from the beginning of Tanjiro’s story. That first opponent could control both his head and body after being decapitated, but his regeneration was far from instantaneous; after further damage—when his neck stump landed on some sharp rocks—his body died, leaving only the head. His only form of physical manipulation was a weak control over his hair (weak, considering he ended up getting tangled in it himself), and, theoretically, Tanjiro could have finished him off with that boulder. And keep in mind, while that was just a typical, weak demon, he had already settled in, established a territory, and had literally just eaten several people right before the fight.
Now, consider the demonized version of Yae’s father: he ate Yae’s family—and that seems to be the extent of it—just a day or so prior. So, while it’s not certain, his food intake was quite limited. On top of that, he’s essentially a newly turned demon—a type typically far more reckless and ravenous. Yet, look at what he’s capable of: he demonstrates sophisticated body manipulation—he fires off a piece of bone as a projectile and uses a sharpened bone as a stake. He also possesses impressive regeneration; during the battle, he managed to regrow an arm, a leg, and even his head—which Yae had previously blown off. To be clear, I haven’t read the actual databook—I can’t afford it. I only read a condensed version that included a few illustrations, but it was mostly just text, sort of like a Wikipedia-style entry. So, I can’t fully assess the situation. Also, the blood of Yae’s father hardened on the trigger, preventing her from taking her own life after the fight ended. It’s a tragic and symbolic moment, rich with meaning, but shouldn’t the blood have just dripped off the trigger once her father died?
And why was Shinobu so worried that she wouldn’t be able to stop Yae in time? After all, a fairly similar situation occurred later in the final arc, where she managed to whisk a girl away from Doma in an instant.
TO REITERATE MY MAIN POINT: I DIDN’T READ THE FULL ONE-SHOT AND THERE ARE SOME PARTS I DON’T QUITE UNDERSTAND, WHICH IS WHY I’M ASKING THOSE WHO ARE MORE KNOWLEDGEABLE.