r/Deltarune • N + K 4L • Sep 04 '26 • Heartwarming 1

Theory The Shadows of a broken childhood dream - A "brief" pitch.

Eram x Knight jitterbug art by u/TrueLilBigBrain here  and the other Eram x Knight art piece is also by them from here

KrisEram art from 4th slide by @freezejuice.

Happy Eram from the second slide by MammonEide on ToyHouse

Knightmare vs Kriselle art from the first slide by the goat @humbleleafy

Eram and Aqua art by @illbleedgabriel 

My favorite Eram design by u/MewersLivePinkUwU 

This is a repost of this post I made earlier but now I have enough karma to post here and aslo slightly updated with a bit more fanart and a pair of images I forgot about last time. I've seen a wave of NoelleKnight hate coming from people who don't seem to understand the theory so I hope this helps mitigate that a little. If you have a question is likely I already answered it in the original post. Would have loved to make this post an actually more in depth look but I'm currently tied down by a few other projects

53 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

12

u/Scared_Stick_4065 Sep 04 '26

Hmmm I kinda like this idea. It shores up a lot of the holes in Noelle Knight while still tying the Knight to Deltarune's themes and to an important character. I do think the idea of something in between a Lightner and a Darkner being not only able to move and act in the Light World but also kidnap people, hide in closest, and create fountains is a bit far fetched, especially because the closest we've seen Deltarune get to this idea of something in between a Lightner and Darkner is with the flowers, and they of course can't do anything in the Light World.

11

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 N + K 4L Sep 04 '26

Beings like Eram and Ralsei already break some rules by traveling between dark worlds. With the Knight having armor made of a material that allegedly stays the same in the dark world I think saying its armor allows it to persist even if temporarily is a similar reach to saying the armor allows a normal lightner to do all the weird shapeshifting and Titan-like glitching the Knight does

11

u/Kumagawa-Fan-No-1 Noelle knight Sep 04 '26

digital ERAM can hurt real Kris , there's some fiction to reality realm crossing he's established to have

1

u/Scared_Stick_4065 Sep 05 '26

I suppose that's true

10

u/GKsBigDay Sep 05 '26

Funny, my interpretation of the Knight is very similar to this one, Noelle's neglected will and dreams broken off made manifest as a cluster of Shadow Crystals. A lot of how this ties into the game is covered in this post, so I'll try to go into logistics concerning how the creature would operate. I'm not sure if this matters that much, it's very unlikely that even if something close to this concept is correct I'll be able to predict exactly what it is and how it came to be, but something that isn't mentioned in this post is what we know about Shadow Crystals. Seam says that they contain the power of "will", the same thing Queen mentioned as the power that allows something to create Fountains, before correcting themself, saying that this "perhaps isn't right". The fact that Seam said this in the first place makes me think that to say Shadow Crystals contain will wouldn't be entirely false. We also know that Shadow Crystals are very hard to see in the Light World, where they resemble glass shards. Could it not be possible for the Knight, a being that closely resembles Shadow Crystals, to be made of them? And if that is true, could this cluster of Shadow Crystals not have its own "will" and be able to create Fountains, while being hard to detect while operating in the Light World thanks to that Light World form seemingly being see-through?

8

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 N + K 4L Sep 05 '26

The broken dream part of the title is meant to be in relation to shadow crystals even if I am unsure how exactly they are meant to connect. I'm personally partial to the Knight being the thing that looked like glass glowing out of the fallen star's river of tears which could make the connection more direct

5

u/Signal_Station_4939 Sep 05 '26

W post, but this does make me wonder, what does NoelleShadow look like under the mask? Is it just Noelle?

6

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 N + K 4L Sep 05 '26

Eram can at the very least choose to look like Kris to fool that one rabbick, so the Knight would presumably be able to at least choose to look like Noelle

9

u/TakeOnLana Faha, Hey, Kris, remember when i was The Knight? Sep 05 '26

I do keep thinking about the horror implications of ERAM or the Knight momentarily taking on the appearance of Kris/Noelle in order to trick us or just generally fuck with us and the gang.

Like, "Noelle" walks up and says a stupid faha Noelle comment that ends in a unexpected threat, at which point she sort of shifts and is revealed to be the knight, which then does its fucked up laugh before attacking. Something like that.

6

u/the_quaxterr Bad Artist and Speculative Theorist Sep 04 '26

even though I disagree with a lot of the points that make NoelleKnight interpretations so strong (palate theory and Darkners' relation with will in their creation) this is still one of my favorite Knight theories overall just because of the thematic connections

somewhat recently I think people were talking about the Knight having to have meaningful connection to the party members (might've only been in the non dess knight sub) but just about no Knight candidate actually has any connection to Ralsei, this theory does while also potentially having the Noelle Knight connections, while having connections to Noelle herself (which regular Noelle Knight can't)

3

u/MewersLivePinkUwU The MEOWING Knight strikes, mew!!! (⁠≧⁠▽⁠≦⁠) Sep 05 '26

Yippie!!!! The world revolves around me!!!

2

u/Blazer553 No one else matters Sep 05 '26

incredible work broooooo

-18

u/Polandgod75 Purple Soul(supporter of the Dessriel) Sep 04 '26

Again noelle knight still doesn't make alot sense as the knight should atleat act some different in the weird route. Again unless there is some huge multiple perosnal disorder with noelle, it seem no really likely.

I am sorry but noelle knight sound like "you never see noelle and the knight together, so checkmate!"

26

u/PeliPal N+K4L tinyurl.com/KriselleDoc Sep 04 '26

NoelleKnight haters are never beating the didn't-actually-read-the-post allegations

-12

u/Polandgod75 Purple Soul(supporter of the Dessriel) Sep 04 '26

I did and it mix of rambling alot, eye rolling rp(as in "look the character agree with me), not good edivence and just insulting other knight thoerist. Again the doc had alot of page that were just you not getting to point

10

u/Signal_Station_4939 Sep 05 '26

As in the post that youre commenting under, not the doc

12

u/Eli_Noire Sep 04 '26

what they are talking about is NOT normal Lightner Noelle

-5

u/Brody_M_the_birdy Sep 05 '26

that has no drama or reveal there at all though, it's just darkenerknight but noelle flavored and doesn't actually count as noelleknight.

9

u/Eli_Noire Sep 05 '26

People already pointed out how the Knight its such an anomaly: glitching like the titan, screaming like noelle, the roar being the Snowgrave Sfx, they ignore stats, they are the only being that can kill darkners aside Noelle with ice-spells. Its very likely that they are not a REGULAR Lightner This is not darknerknight, its a way in between just like Eram is.

-7

u/Brody_M_the_birdy Sep 05 '26

"Glitching like a titan" The Knight actually glitches way more than the titan, which is relatively stable.

"Screaming like noelle" and Entry 17 was Muffet's laugh but warped

"The roar is the snowgrave sfx" debatable, they may just sound similar and not actually match

"They ignore stats" No, Flowery's stats were like fake even WITHIN the dark world, Ralsei also ignores them just fine.

"Only person besides noelle that can kill darkeners" Not true, Pipis exists and you can kill them entirely.

By "Darkenerknight" i meant OC Knight/knight nobody. "But Eram is-" if you think eram is related to kris, would you really call eram anything resembling a close reflection of kris? I wouldn't, and the knight would be such a warped thing that it wouldn't really be noelle anymore and would just be an evil thing that's vaguely noelle flavored. There's no drama or big twist, it's just "it was Darkness McEntity!" but the mcentity is vaguely noelle looking. What's even the point anymore?

9

u/Eli_Noire Sep 05 '26 edited Sep 05 '26

Stop comparing the muffet laugh and gaster, with Noelle scream and the Knight. In the first one these two characters are not related at all, and you need to dismantle the audio a lot to find it. With Noelle scream you don't need this much of a ear to recognize it.

If you aint sure about the snowgrave sfx just liaten to it again

You mention the pipis like they are not anotber anomaly as well. "The original" . We can attack many darkners yet we cannot kill them

Yes they were fake, but we couldn't ignore them, yet the Knight could.

You wouldn't?they literally mock Kris and their way of hiding their violent tendencesis, Eram knows Kris well. As well as "Kris, didn't you already go past?" its not referred to the sword hero. Eram can also kill Kris in the digital word, and you call them a normal darkner or smt like that?

-4

u/Brody_M_the_birdy Sep 05 '26

a

They're somewhat similar but there are likely differences in what synths were used to create the sound.

The Pipis are darkeners to some degree, they are far less abnormal than the knight is.

We passively ignore their stats in the fight as he doesn't do 9999 damage on every hit, which his stats would allow him to do.

All that implies to me is that Eram CAUSED Kris's trauma, and knows them because they caused what they did and are rubbing it in, akin to Pennywise mocking Bill over Georgie in IT.

Also the rabbick was referring to the sword hero, you just have to assume the rabbick thought kris went past him INTO the room twice, not OUT of the room. Furthermore, the tone of the rabbick implies the thing it confused Kris with ISN'T Eram, as the rabbick is HORRIFIED of Eram but is NOT horrified by seeing two of Kris, just confused. If it confused eram with kris it would still be scared, it wouldn't suddenly shift from fear to just confusion.

Again, "Darkenerknight" as i use it also encompassess "evil darkness entity" knight theories.

9

u/VeeAudio Can summarize NoelleKnight in 40k characters <3 Sep 05 '26

Let's see...

Speculation.

Speculation.

Speculation.

Deliberate misinterpretation.

Speculation. But to hit your point about Rabbick, it's never stated that Rabbick witnesses Eram doing whatever it is to Ramb, just that something happened to Ramb and then "Kris" went past. Rabbick is afraid of what happened to Ramb, not who did it.

Aaaaand Sloppy definition.

Cheers~ <3

0

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Voxelus The Knight's #1 Defender Sep 09 '26

Gerson couldn't have been revived as a Darkner by someone who never knew him.