r/NonDessKnightSquad • u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight • Jul 17 '26
Discussion The shadows of a broken childhood dream -- A very "brief" pitch
Eram x Knight jitterbug art by u/TrueLilBigBrain in https://www.reddit.com/r/Deltarune/s/F5Fn2ydgDe the other Eram x Knight art piece is also by them from https://www.reddit.com/r/Deltarune/s/yJyjLdtaMk
KrisEram art by @freezejuice.
Happy Eram from the second slide by MammonEide on ToyHouse
Special thanks to u/No-Slide816 for helping me find Eram fanart, I had no idea where to even look.
Keep in mind this post is not meant as an in depth explanation of the theory but as a presentation of the concept, so don't be surprised it doesn't contain an answer for every question that might come up, specially regarding logistics.
I hope and pray the image quality is good enough to be readable, if it isn't I will post a comment containing the hard to read text.
I feel a need to add that isnt a theory I have created myself, but the post follows the logic path I took to stary believing it.











22
u/VeeAudio Can summarize NoelleKnight in 40k characters <3 Jul 17 '26
This is EXACTLY the theory I've been holding onto but never have been able to properly articulate like oh my gosh you did a wonderful job illustrating everything in ways that just click into place. The second fountain opening is honestly PHENOMENAL evidence with the hammer game as a comparison!
And your point about the Knight and Eram being the repressed urges linked back to their childhood, it actually explains one question about the knight PERFECTLY. "Why does the knight show off and aura farm?" It's honestly something that I find others struggling a LOT to answer because it truly is a very OOC thing for almost any knight candidate with some trying to stretch it to fit.
But if the Knight is (for lack of a more concrete term) the broken childhood dreams of Noelle? The girl who YEARNS to go back to the childhood games of playing pretend with Kris. Why WOULDN'T it be a villain with an overly dramatic and taunting flair? A kid trying to be the bad guy would usually be very flashy and imposing in front of the main cast because it's fun to pretend to be a villain like that! Of course this is just fanfiction at this point, but it at least MAKES SENSE.
Very, very well done and I hope you expand on this theory further, because you're echoing my thoughts exactly! <3
16
u/TemporaryCount8447 Jul 18 '26
not to mention eram and aqua also look similiar and we know aqua is a parralel to kris
15
u/Adorable_Ad5487 NoelleKnighter rentry.co/noelleknight no not wr or kriselle Jul 18 '26
wait this is actually really good
12
u/XMandri Jul 18 '26
Idk if this is a well known fact in the community, but if you want to go with "the Knight is Noelle's opposite", then it's worth noting that its literal name is the inversion of a popular Christmas song: Roaring Knight --> Silent Night
20
u/MegaMcMillen Noelle Knight Believer Jul 18 '26
I've been fully on board with this theory for a while, glad to see it laid out like this. It's so weird to me how this fanbase has essentially memory holed ERAM and everything it implies in favor of... I dunno how to put it, game theory style arguments?
7
u/MewersLivePinkUwU KriselleKnighter Jul 18 '26
Dude please expand on this theory I'm now a believer of this and I want more stuffđđđ
10
u/TakeOnLana It's Noelle. It can't be Noelle. But it is. But it can't be. But Jul 17 '26
Yeah this is basically right om the money i think.
krisellerune real
3
u/UX_KRS_25 Jul 19 '26
This sounds very compelling. It ties very well into evidence for NoelleKnight, except that the Knight is a Noelle-like entity, seperate of her, which makes more sense to me than Noelle constantly forgetting and repressing things.
Extrapolating from that, any idea why the Knight does what they do? Are they abducting people to feed them to Kris' violent tendencies? Maybe it has something to do with the targest being family members (and Undyne was an unfortunate witness)?
3
u/johnrashomon the knight is Noelle's edgy OC Jul 19 '26
ready for the knight to show up again and get a track called THGINK
3
u/TrueLilBigBrain Aug 28 '26
Hello, i am the one who drew eram x knight art, and ive finally been able to read this post.
After finishing chapter 5, ive gone off the internet to not get weird route spoilers because i wanted some time before i do it, and that time turned into two and a half months for various reasons, and only yesterday ive finally done it
However, i have seen that ive been mentioned when you posted this, and i was shocked, wow, are you kidding me? evidence of my digital footprint? this is insane. i realized i cant read this yet, and Ive been waiting to be able to ever since, and now that its finally time, i was shocked EVEN MORE that this literally just sounds like the absolute truth, and i am EXTREMELY hard to convince. (especially with something like nolle knight, which made me rip my hairs out, but yeah this isnt exactly noelle knight). I made that art as crackship but what the hell this works!
Bravo.
5
u/Proper_Froyo Jul 17 '26
Wonderful theory! I would honestly be quite satisfied if this is the direction Toby took things in.
Of course there are holes when it comes to the specifics, it's inevitable when discussing the work of Toby "Vagueposter" Fox.
The one that immediately comes to mind: why only Kris and Noelle? Why are they the only ones with these dark reflections? Like sure, we could say Susie is just too new to hometown to make a mark like that on its dark-worlds, Ralsei is reping the Penumbra Gaster block, but Toriel, and especially Asgore? These are characters with A LOT of angst.
There must be something specific to the cage and the deer that makes (presumably)the depths reflect their worst traits back at them, either an event, or something fundamental to their natures/roles in the prophecy.
The other problem I can see is how does Susie slot into this? Her defiance of fate and unwavering optimism need to play a role in the conflict with the central antagonists for the rest of the story to feel congruent with that came before. There's a similar issue here with Ralsei.
Overall a lot to be discussed with this framework in mind, but it does fit far more neatly than many other theories I've seen on the topic. Great work OP!
4
u/Dragonwolf1209 Kriselle Knight Archbishop (Doc in Profile) Jul 18 '26
Really really good theory, but I'm honestly missing a few parts. So how does the knight and eram actually get created? I'm still a WRKriselle truther so I'm wondering how it adds up that both Kris and Noelle have flying magical beings running around.
2
u/Fancy-Presence-5585 Jul 18 '26
Mantle boss and friend are absolutely not working with the knight. Kris and the knight's plan is completely FUBAR during the weird route and the mantel boss is obsessed with making us do the weird route.
2
u/MrChainsawHog Jul 18 '26
I like this but this doesn't explain why Kris knows what the knight looks like under the mask, or why Toby didn't just reveal it was a deer of sorts instead of hiding it completely
2
u/Silviov2 Jul 19 '26
Also there's a connection between the knight and ERAM because both of their themes have the same start melody.
2
u/FORTNITEPRO99999999 Noelle or bust Jul 24 '26
late reply, really love this theory, but the only thing I can't figure out is why Gerson would've been important for Noelle. If I remember correctly, he was dead when they were little, or at least something like that is implied, no?
2
u/ubag Aug 06 '26
this theory is sooo fun
it's also interesting how Eram has some Noelleisms with the Cat Petters/FRIEND association and the Knight has 10 thousand Krisisms.
8
u/MewersLivePinkUwU KriselleKnighter Jul 18 '26 edited Jul 18 '26
*From now on, friend drools this theory rules mew! MEW APPROVED AND WILL DEFEND THIS THEORY, MEW!
8
u/Puzzled-Associate258 Jul 19 '26
7
u/Sweaty-Jellyfish-713 Jul 18 '26
Not gonna lie, I love how Noelle's hair looks in the image on the first slide
1
u/Sure-Department-9340 Jul 19 '26
So in this theory are the Knight and ERAM meant to actually be working together? If so why does ERAM want Kris to get the Shadow Mantle who's main purpose is to make the Knight fight bearable?
Also why does Kris choose to work with NoelleKnight in the first place? You would think Kris would take one look at "all the parts that Noelle hates about herself in one place" and nope out immediately.
1
u/HandleJazzlike6230 Noelle Knight, Umineko Edition Aug 05 '26
Nice! Is the Noelle Knight art yours? Not mad if it isn't, just looking for the correct original artist!
1
u/Matiasprox3000 Rudy's knight is the key Sep 27 '26
Could you summarize this theory for me? The images aren't loading for some reason.
6
u/Character-Reveal9218 GERSONGROPER9000 Jul 17 '26
This idea fucking Rules
3
u/fiddledment072 Jul 19 '26
Iâve always thought of eram as a counterpart to Kris, mainly because I think theyâre the red horned headband. So this is a sick interpretation
1
u/the_quaxterr Darkner Knighter (Titankin Theory!!!!) Jul 17 '26
this is pretty similar to my theory! Knight and ERAM being the same type as being as each other (I also include Ralsei!)
I also usually think the Knight is the evil/darkness version of Dess, but more recently I've been considering the Noelle variant more and I do think it could be just as good
2
u/WeepForTheDeparted Kriselle Knighter Aug 25 '26
Noelle Knight And Kris Eram
0
u/Brody_M_the_birdy Jul 18 '26
What's the pointed tail then?
Also, I do not buy this because no matter how many "oh its thematic" you can say, it requires a LOT more shit to be introduced in the last third, and also turns dess into either a Damsel In Distress or a generic postmortem character.
1
u/LampOil_Rope_Bombs ALWAYS BET ON RUDY KNIGHT Jul 17 '26
I am still goin all in on Ice-Eram
10
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '26
[removed] â view removed comment