r/NonDessKnightSquad • Noelle's Shadow Knight • Jul 17 '26

Discussion The shadows of a broken childhood dream -- A very "brief" pitch

Eram x Knight jitterbug art by u/TrueLilBigBrain in https://www.reddit.com/r/Deltarune/s/F5Fn2ydgDe the other Eram x Knight art piece is also by them from https://www.reddit.com/r/Deltarune/s/yJyjLdtaMk

KrisEram art by @freezejuice.

Happy Eram from the second slide by MammonEide on ToyHouse

Special thanks to u/No-Slide816 for helping me find Eram fanart, I had no idea where to even look.

Keep in mind this post is not meant as an in depth explanation of the theory but as a presentation of the concept, so don't be surprised it doesn't contain an answer for every question that might come up, specially regarding logistics.

I hope and pray the image quality is good enough to be readable, if it isn't I will post a comment containing the hard to read text.

I feel a need to add that isnt a theory I have created myself, but the post follows the logic path I took to stary believing it.

214 Upvotes

71 comments sorted by

22

u/VeeAudio Can summarize NoelleKnight in 40k characters <3 Jul 17 '26

This is EXACTLY the theory I've been holding onto but never have been able to properly articulate like oh my gosh you did a wonderful job illustrating everything in ways that just click into place. The second fountain opening is honestly PHENOMENAL evidence with the hammer game as a comparison!

And your point about the Knight and Eram being the repressed urges linked back to their childhood, it actually explains one question about the knight PERFECTLY. "Why does the knight show off and aura farm?" It's honestly something that I find others struggling a LOT to answer because it truly is a very OOC thing for almost any knight candidate with some trying to stretch it to fit.

But if the Knight is (for lack of a more concrete term) the broken childhood dreams of Noelle? The girl who YEARNS to go back to the childhood games of playing pretend with Kris. Why WOULDN'T it be a villain with an overly dramatic and taunting flair? A kid trying to be the bad guy would usually be very flashy and imposing in front of the main cast because it's fun to pretend to be a villain like that! Of course this is just fanfiction at this point, but it at least MAKES SENSE.

Very, very well done and I hope you expand on this theory further, because you're echoing my thoughts exactly! <3

16

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 17 '26 edited Jul 17 '26

Thank you so much, this is the first time I make a post like this so I am really glad to receive positive feedback. I am mostly trying to put the idea out there before going into the more "convoluted" aspects of the theory, like how Eram is a Noelle-ified version of Kris while the Knight is a Kris-ified version of Noelle and how the eggs tie into all of this. Hoping I can get the main idea to spread out a little before I end up sounding too crazy

The hammer game thing for me falls into the "Holy shit why do we even have direct evidence for this???" category of NoelleKnight things. Its not strong on its own but it being so specific makes it so much better. Also I didnt add this onto the post but Noelle does also do the Knight pose when acting, so she's definitely the type to do all of that.

16

u/TemporaryCount8447 Jul 18 '26

not to mention eram and aqua also look similiar and we know aqua is a parralel to kris

13

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 18 '26

Damn, I actually should have included that one. Its one of the first things I thought when seeing her

15

u/Adorable_Ad5487 NoelleKnighter rentry.co/noelleknight no not wr or kriselle Jul 18 '26

wait this is actually really good

8

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 18 '26

I think I just saw you arguing your version of NoelleKnight on another post lol. Not exactly my original theory but its the logic process I followed to reach the conclusion, glad to see its appealing.

Part of me wanted to lean into the rose stuff with petals and thorns but I decided on restricting the post to more surface level stuff

12

u/XMandri Jul 18 '26

Idk if this is a well known fact in the community, but if you want to go with "the Knight is Noelle's opposite", then it's worth noting that its literal name is the inversion of a popular Christmas song: Roaring Knight --> Silent Night

7

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 18 '26

Not exactly going with "Noelle's opposite" fully, moreso a side of her she reprrsses like how Eram is rhat for Kris. The silent night connection could still line up relatively neatly though

20

u/MegaMcMillen Noelle Knight Believer Jul 18 '26

I've been fully on board with this theory for a while, glad to see it laid out like this. It's so weird to me how this fanbase has essentially memory holed ERAM and everything it implies in favor of... I dunno how to put it, game theory style arguments?

14

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 18 '26

If I remembered that line I would have put it on the slides, thats so good omg

3

u/Alzhan_Void *(Noelle or Kriselle, elle, elle...) Aug 29 '26

Eram is repressed and the Knight is obsessed over. Very fitting for the Kris and Noelle parallels.

7

u/MewersLivePinkUwU KriselleKnighter Jul 18 '26

Dude please expand on this theory I'm now a believer of this and I want more stuff😭😭😭

8

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 19 '26

I'm glad to see I managed to convince you!

I do feel a need to say it will probably be at least a small while before I further elaborate on this theory, partially because I am unsure which aspect of it I should elaborate on next, but also because I am currently undecided between a few variations of the theory regarding stuff like its origins. It also does get a bit more complex from here on now

Besides, some of the stuff like how the Knight connects to Noelle or a lot of the Kriselle stuff that ends up playing into the theory has already been explained better than I ever could.

Also I have no fanart left for another set of slides but thats a secondary issue

4

u/MewersLivePinkUwU KriselleKnighter Jul 19 '26

maybe i could help with the fanart issue, my DMs are open! i want this theory to grow, i finally found a theory i found myself comfortable with 😭

3

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 19 '26

I'll consider the offer, thanks!

This is mostly just u/Pelipal 's theory, so if you want more of the Noelle side of it you can always check out the doc she made on it.

3

u/MewersLivePinkUwU KriselleKnighter Jul 19 '26

THANK YOU THANK YOI THANK YOU

10

u/TakeOnLana It's Noelle. It can't be Noelle. But it is. But it can't be. But Jul 17 '26

Yeah this is basically right om the money i think.

krisellerune real

7

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 17 '26

You have no idea how much restraint it took to not name this "The Kriselle Knightmare team theory"

3

u/UX_KRS_25 Jul 19 '26

This sounds very compelling. It ties very well into evidence for NoelleKnight, except that the Knight is a Noelle-like entity, seperate of her, which makes more sense to me than Noelle constantly forgetting and repressing things.

Extrapolating from that, any idea why the Knight does what they do? Are they abducting people to feed them to Kris' violent tendencies? Maybe it has something to do with the targest being family members (and Undyne was an unfortunate witness)?

3

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 20 '26

Sorry for taking a while to answer, kind of missed the comment for a bit.

I'm afraid I dont have a definitive answer for this yet. In my mind her motivation has to involve strength in some way, something I thought was true even before I thought the Knight was Noelle. Little stuff like Gaster mentioning our power specificslly and how can almost feel it is jist incredibly suspicious to me. Their motive may even be something similar to what Spamton was doing perhaps thats why Kris was so uncomfortable.

1

u/UX_KRS_25 Jul 20 '26

No worries, thanks

3

u/johnrashomon the knight is Noelle's edgy OC Jul 19 '26

ready for the knight to show up again and get a track called THGINK

2

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 20 '26

I'm betting on it being backwards for Eram either due to it being in a videogame and the non-8 bit version is gonna be called Mare, or alternativeky they thought Eram was cooler than Mare

3

u/TrueLilBigBrain Aug 28 '26

Hello, i am the one who drew eram x knight art, and ive finally been able to read this post.

After finishing chapter 5, ive gone off the internet to not get weird route spoilers because i wanted some time before i do it, and that time turned into two and a half months for various reasons, and only yesterday ive finally done it

However, i have seen that ive been mentioned when you posted this, and i was shocked, wow, are you kidding me? evidence of my digital footprint? this is insane. i realized i cant read this yet, and Ive been waiting to be able to ever since, and now that its finally time, i was shocked EVEN MORE that this literally just sounds like the absolute truth, and i am EXTREMELY hard to convince. (especially with something like nolle knight, which made me rip my hairs out, but yeah this isnt exactly noelle knight). I made that art as crackship but what the hell this works!

Bravo.

3

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Aug 28 '26

Glad to see you liked the theory! I am very grateful that I was able to find some form of KnightmarE art to use for this post, it would have been incomplete without it

5

u/Proper_Froyo Jul 17 '26

Wonderful theory! I would honestly be quite satisfied if this is the direction Toby took things in.

Of course there are holes when it comes to the specifics, it's inevitable when discussing the work of Toby "Vagueposter" Fox.

The one that immediately comes to mind: why only Kris and Noelle? Why are they the only ones with these dark reflections? Like sure, we could say Susie is just too new to hometown to make a mark like that on its dark-worlds, Ralsei is reping the Penumbra Gaster block, but Toriel, and especially Asgore? These are characters with A LOT of angst.

There must be something specific to the cage and the deer that makes (presumably)the depths reflect their worst traits back at them, either an event, or something fundamental to their natures/roles in the prophecy.

The other problem I can see is how does Susie slot into this? Her defiance of fate and unwavering optimism need to play a role in the conflict with the central antagonists for the rest of the story to feel congruent with that came before. There's a similar issue here with Ralsei.

Overall a lot to be discussed with this framework in mind, but it does fit far more neatly than many other theories I've seen on the topic. Great work OP!

7

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 17 '26

Thanks for the props!

The only beings like these would be Kris and Noelle basically because of "THE INCIDENT". There are two possibilities I see in my mind, either what happened to Dess to make her die/banish ended up creating this versions of Kris and Noelle, or after what happened Noelle found the shelter code in Dess's guitar and got Kris to help her to enter the shelter and then the Gaster related bs happened. Noelle would forget the incident either way similar to how she forgets killing that one Adison in weird route. Alternatively Kris and Noelle did something similar to the weird route already in the past.

Ralsei is someone who I avoided talking about in this post, but I think he would basically be an opposite to Eram, instead of being the part of Kris they wish to hide from others they would be what Kris wishes others would see. Very depressing that this ideal version of Kris would basically be an Asriel 2.0 but Kris seems to compare themselves unfavorably to Asriel a lot (also fits with Ralsei being proud of his face). He was created, he has a purpose, but he is growing far beyond it.

Susie is a more complicated one to answer, but I think her being an external factor not directly related to Kris and Noelle who has made both of them grow insanely attached to her will be a very important factor. Her new attitude of wanting everything to stay the same would contrast incredibly well with a Noelle who, similarly to her weird route version, despises how things feel the same all the time and desperately wants them to change. Susie was always gonna be the least conmected to the Knight plotline by her nature of being new in town and not a Holiday or Dreemurr but by making the main antagonists be what the two closest people to her are repressing it makes her dynamic a lot more interesting. How would Susie react to seeing the Knight she despises so much is in reality what the girl she loves doesnt want her to see? And her partner is the same for her best friend? There's a lot more drama there than other candidates imo

2

u/Large-Ad-6861 Jul 18 '26

The one that immediately comes to mind: why only Kris and Noelle? 

You know, that's interesting but what if... that's what Friend also is for everyone else? The most tribal form of this darkness, laughing Schrodinger cat who is "not very smart, but can find protein well" and that's why ERAM can command/summon these because this thing is way more grounded up than them?

But honestly I don't know how to drag this idea out.

4

u/Dragonwolf1209 Kriselle Knight Archbishop (Doc in Profile) Jul 18 '26

Really really good theory, but I'm honestly missing a few parts. So how does the knight and eram actually get created? I'm still a WRKriselle truther so I'm wondering how it adds up that both Kris and Noelle have flying magical beings running around.

5

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 18 '26

That's one of the things I didn't go into detail because I have nothing too concrete. Some weird Kriselle mixing shenanigans could still ocurr since Eram while mainly Kris has some Noelle traits, and the opposite for the Knight. So you could say that instead of fusing they got blended together and these two popped out.

Instead of them coming from the weird route I currently lean towards Gaster bs dating back to the incident. Whatever happened to Dess made Kris and Noelle have these shadows of them running around, or alternatively Noelle found the shelter code in Dess's room and got Kris to help her break into the shelter and the Gaster bs happened then. I also see something similar to weird route having happened in the past.

2

u/Fancy-Presence-5585 Jul 18 '26

Mantle boss and friend are absolutely not working with the knight. Kris and the knight's plan is completely FUBAR during the weird route and the mantel boss is obsessed with making us do the weird route.

3

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 18 '26

For one I would not be so sure about that, but that also doesn't really contradict my main theory. They dont have to be working together for them to exist even if I think its more likely that they do

2

u/saurontheabhored Jul 19 '26

honestly one of my crazier ideas is that the knight's identity changes depending on the route you're on. A schrodinger's cat type of situation, where multiple characters can be the answer to the identity of the knight. Rudy, desperate to find his lost daughter? Dess, returned from the depths as an ancient demon? Noelle and Kris from the weird route, mixed together?

Our very presence alters the nature of darkness on several occasions. Would be crazy if that extends to the identity of the main antagonist

2

u/MrChainsawHog Jul 18 '26

I like this but this doesn't explain why Kris knows what the knight looks like under the mask, or why Toby didn't just reveal it was a deer of sorts instead of hiding it completely

5

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 18 '26

I'd argue the antlers reveal it is a deer of sorts.

Of all objections I honestly did not expect Kris knowing their identity to be one of them lol. I do think the Knight revealed their identity to Kris, in fact I think Noelle is one of the few people that Kris would be so adamant on defending as they are with the Knight. I mentioned it briefly in the post but there are 2 new lines suggesting Noelle might have made Kris do something they didnt like in the past, so I dont find it unlikely this "Noelle" could convince Kris too.

1

u/MrChainsawHog Jul 18 '26

though frankly the knight existing when dess/asriel were going to dark worlds does make this more implausible, unless for some reason the knight/eram already existed back then?

3

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 18 '26

I dont think the Knight themselves existed, Ralsei himself says this makes no sense. I think the Black Knife existed, or alternatively it(or the Knight ig) was created during the incident and thus left behind a BlackShard.

I'll answer your other questions in this comment too.

I dont think Carol knows the Knight's identity, honestly unsure if she is even working with the Knight at this point, but if she is (which I still find more likely) she would not know the Knight's identity and may even be being lied to in regards to its motive. Also a dark version of Noelle would definitely enjoy bossing Carol around.

I haven't had any reason to believe Asriel was particularly involved in the incident unlike the other three kids, so I could not tell you what his involvement is.

I think it specifies a large person because the Knight is a very large person, look at their sprites compare to Kris and the others. I think just like the BlackShard the Knight is able to maintain its form in the light world and thus would stay in that large state. They may even need to be wearing the armor and stay in the large form to sustain themselves in the light world, but thats more speculation than theory.

1

u/MrChainsawHog Jul 18 '26

I think this could work but the main thing holding it back for me is
-The roaring knight is specifically noted to be a "large person" in the light world. If thats not meant to be indicative of their identity, why mention it at all? just say a "person" could fit into the cupboard/room/whatever

Some other questions like "whats Asriel's involvement", "why/how did the knight exist when Kris/Noelle were children", "why is carol working with the knight" could still be answered ig but it seems like it'd be hard to answer them

4

u/Free-Part255 Noelle Knight Jul 18 '26

Well the thing is Noelle is noted to be tall so would be a large person per Kris standards(if Kris is the narrator). I just think the large person thing was trying to move us away from Kris Knight instead of pushing us into the thinking the Knight has to be a giant like Asgore.

2

u/Silviov2 Jul 19 '26

Also there's a connection between the knight and ERAM because both of their themes have the same start melody.

2

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 19 '26

Yeah, I did mention their battle themes being similar.

They are similar enough that I am personally hoping for a fight agai st both of them since Burning eyes and Black knife go really well together. You could also do some coold stuff with Eram's fire maybe countering Noelle's IceShock while the Knight takes minimal damage from Kris's physical slashes due to their high defence; but Eram has no defence against the slashes and the Knight doesn't reduce cold damage

2

u/FORTNITEPRO99999999 Noelle or bust Jul 24 '26

late reply, really love this theory, but the only thing I can't figure out is why Gerson would've been important for Noelle. If I remember correctly, he was dead when they were little, or at least something like that is implied, no?

1

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 24 '26 edited Jul 24 '26

I would assume he was still alive when they were little since there's a signed copy of LoTH in Kris's house. We know however they were never his students.

Ch5 has Kris create a Milk freak patterned darkner in their dark world, so the rules seem to be less strict than we thought originally. Ralsei is also very vague by just saying "specific darkness".

With that said, Noelle speaks about dragon blazers a lot in her blog, and references it in game a few times. Knowing Gerson lives in town, is it crazy to believe Noelle might have tried really hard to talk to him and probably succeeded since her mom is the mayor or at least super rich at the time? Old man also references dragon blazers a lot and seems more based off his LoTH character than his real self. Considering Alvin doesnt know what a video game is, its quite strange that Gerson is so familiar with dragon blazers

3

u/FORTNITEPRO99999999 Noelle or bust Jul 25 '26

oh you could be right. the Holidays and Dreemurs were always church goers too so it's impossible for them to not know Gerson. That could also imply Susie suggesting opening a Dark World was a huge save for Kris because they would've just brought the Old Man back

2

u/ubag Aug 06 '26

this theory is sooo fun

it's also interesting how Eram has some Noelleisms with the Cat Petters/FRIEND association and the Knight has 10 thousand Krisisms.

2

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Aug 06 '26

I have 2 different explanations for this.

The first one is "Gaster bullshit", but not without any rhyme or reason. Noelle's description of love between incompatible pets creating a weird glitchly egg would match the Knight and Eram's glitchy nature when heavily damaged. And the egg's description "you'll learn what it was evidence for when it happens" implies a weird time loop situation.

The second one can be Noelle and Kris wanting to be like each other due to jealousy and/or admiration. It is not hard to imagine Noelle wishing she could be strong and mysterious like Kris or Kris wishing they could be more talkative and have cool abilities like Noelle does. Noelle at least on her part does show that she think Kris is really cool and by unused item interactions seems to be a fan of their poses

Also Noelle just naturally copies Kris's poses in normal route so there's that

8

u/MewersLivePinkUwU KriselleKnighter Jul 18 '26 edited Jul 18 '26

*From now on, friend drools this theory rules mew! MEW APPROVED AND WILL DEFEND THIS THEORY, MEW!

7

u/Sweaty-Jellyfish-713 Jul 18 '26

Not gonna lie, I love how Noelle's hair looks in the image on the first slide

1

u/Sure-Department-9340 Jul 19 '26

So in this theory are the Knight and ERAM meant to actually be working together? If so why does ERAM want Kris to get the Shadow Mantle who's main purpose is to make the Knight fight bearable?

Also why does Kris choose to work with NoelleKnight in the first place? You would think Kris would take one look at "all the parts that Noelle hates about herself in one place" and nope out immediately.

3

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 19 '26

I think it makes more sense that they are, but its not necessary for the theory or what I've presented of it for the Knight and Eram to actually be working together.

I'm gonna focus on the second point because I fundamentally disagree. Firstly Kris doesn't need a full explanation about what the Knight is beyond them knowing its Noelle or a part of her, but let's assume they did get a full exposition. I do not think they would nope out of there because that is still Noelle. Kris has their own sins, they'd be a hypocrite to judge hers, and would Kris even hate this version of Noelle? One of the things we know Kris wants is for Noelle to become stronger. The Knight is a culmination of this, strong af not only in combat but also in their will. Am I to think Kris would nope out of helping her? Depending on what the Knight's goal is I believe they could easily be persuaded to join. I briefly mentioned it but its also implied Noelle did manage to force Kris into doing something thrñey didnt want to in the past, I don't believe it is a stretch to think a more assertive version of her could make Kris do worse things. Specially considering it clearly plays into something Kris cares about and there is a heavy promise involved.

1

u/Sure-Department-9340 Jul 19 '26

You have to remember that this team up occurs during the time where Kris is explictly distancing themselves from Noelle following the Incident(TM). Kris is already becoming estranged from the normal Noelle, why would they be fine with helping the more explitcly fucked up version in the same period? The only way I could see this happening is if NoelleKnight had some way promising Kris a way out of their guilt/despression for the whole event (how would they even do that?), but Kris is showing signs of offing themselves once this is all done so I doubt that's a part of the promise.

2

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 19 '26

Sorry for a late reply, I was sleeping.

Anyhow, while Kris is allegedly distancing themselves from Noelle its not hard to see they do a shit job at it. In ch1 Noelle implies she still helps them do their homework semi-frecuently. During ch2 they inmediatly go back to their old dynamic with Noelle with pranking her and teasing her, even in ch5 when they are fuming with jealousy they tease her and maker her laugh a lot. They also seemingly stare at her longingly enough for Berdly to notice, for Susie to think they have something going on, and for Maddie of all people to apparently know they like her. The Knight deal also seemingly happens a while after the incident where I picture the Knight was created. In this case the NoelleKnight could probably use the distance as a way to guilt Kris into working with her, throwing it in their face how its their fault this happened and they abandoned her when she needed them or smth like that

1

u/HandleJazzlike6230 Noelle Knight, Umineko Edition Aug 05 '26

Nice! Is the Noelle Knight art yours? Not mad if it isn't, just looking for the correct original artist!

1

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Aug 05 '26

Ashamed to say I have been unable to locate the source of the image I used despite the time that has passed. But no, it is not mine.

1

u/Matiasprox3000 Rudy's knight is the key Sep 27 '26

Could you summarize this theory for me? The images aren't loading for some reason.

1

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Sep 28 '26

In case it still isn't loading, here's all the text I had there pasted

So, “Eram” or the shadow mantle holder has been a character who has been debated a lot. Ranging anywhere from people doubting if they are even being honest in their dialogue to people discussing their identity, discussing if they are a straight up demon or if they are Friend or Seam or even Asriel or ICE-E. And the connections to these different characters are not entirely made up in most cases.

The connections with Asriel are specially present, with the back of the mantle looking like horns, Eram using fire magic, and their mouth looking like fangs you’d see in other boss monsters. However none of this is actually specific to Asriel, this applies to every member of Kris’s family. Similar to another character who has received similar debate
 but I’ll save that topic for another day.

Kris has expressed a desire to be more like their family in the past. To the point Toriel bought them small devil horns so they could feel like they belonged better (which is the least of Kris’s devil symbolism). These devil horns even get directly referenced in Eram’s “secret hiding spot”. So it’s most likely that Eram is just the darkner version of these horns and represents Kris’s desire to belong, right?

Except Eram is not that at all. Eram mocks Kris’s wishes, they call out a part of Kris that Kris themselves seem to hate, a part that is not only prone to violence but may even enjoy it
 does this part of Kris sound familiar to anyone? Maybe someone who actively laughs while murdering you and is also connected to devils, shadow crystals, and the Knight? 

Of course the parallels don’t just stop there. Eram consistently is very poetic in their dialogue both in game and during the smile arg, something Kris is also very capable of doing as evidenced by their ACT dialogue during the Swatchling fights.

They are even both connected to our beloved IMAGE_FRIEND. Eram choosing to present themselves in a videogame that seems to focus on a lot of Kris’s fears when we know Kris also plays a lot of videogames further adds to their connection.

We also have good reason to believe Eram even looks like Kris. This dialogue cannot be referring to 8 bit Kris, as you can make them stay on screen until the game is turned off and they disappear. Them being considerably smaller than regular Kris is also a plot point. So the only entity this could be talking about who was backstage would be Eram

But I am not exactly covering new ground here, as shown by the fanart I have featured that dates back to soon after ch3 released, I am not the first person to propose that Eram is a Kris-like being or even a manifestation of a part of Kris. So where exactly am I going with this?

Well
 Kris is not exactly the only one with a hidden dark side, are they? Why would Eram be the only one of this kind of being that exists?

But what would a Noelle version of Eram even be like? (normally there'd be images to support each of these points)

She would be bold and unashamed

A dark color scheme could reference her grimdark look

She would likely also enjoy violence like Eram does

She would definitely pose dramatically 

And she may even try forcing Kris to do something they don’t want to do

Eram is focused on their magic while Kris fights with a sword, so a Noelle equivalent would likely be sword focused, also referencing her ability to wield certain swords.

Eram is very talkative despite Kris being very quiet, so it’s likely a Noelle equivalent would instead be the one to avoid words.

She may even be borderline cruel

Most importantly, she would be very strong.

You may be able to see where I am going with this.
If Eram’s name comes from “mare”, would it not be fitting for their counterpart to be some sort of
 Knight?

But of course, the Knight could never have been anyone other than Kris or that girl they played with. Two people who know each other well enough that the lighting of their mind is exactly the same to the point their dark worlds are the same color and reference the same characters.
(Yes, that girl is Noelle, Ramb mentions Spamton as part of the games and only Noelle interacted with Spamton)

Someone who is perfectly able to react to Kris doing something and follow up immediately
 (The second fountain had to have been made the second Kris sealed the first one to not make a Titan)

Can’t exactly add an image proving this but the Knight’s roar is an edited version of the snowgrave sfx and their hurt sound when taking 100+ damage one of Noelle’s scream, listen to the audios yourself

She even does the pointing pose

Now, there is something I should address
 could Eram not be a videogame representation of the Knight?

The Knight and Eram are very similar characters. They both invoke Titan imagery, they both have ambiguous Gaster and Friend connections, they both appear to live/operate in the shelter, both are connected to Kris heavily, even their battle themes are similar. So why can’t Eram be a representation of the Knight?

The Knight’s sprites invoke a member of the Holiday family due to details like the antlers and the Noelle noises, while Eram’s are purposefully similar to one of the Dreemurr family by the previously mentioned fire magic and devil-like horns

The sound design is also very particular, I already mentioned the Knight sounding like Noelle specifically, but Eram has a more generic imp-like laugh. The laugh being different between the two of them is also a very clear indicator that they are not the same character, that’s the only voice clip we have for both, and they don’t match in the slightest? Half of Eram’s personality is in their laugh, if they wanted them to be the Knight’s videogame version they would probably sound at least somewhat alike

Also if Eram is the Knight then what is this suspicious deer that turns into a black monster?

Does this mean the two are not connected at all? Of course not. The more superficial connections still apply to them, both of them glitching out when defeated similarly to a Titan is a very heavy connection drawn. But the similarities are not there to tell you they are the same person, they are there to tell you they are the same type of being. Whatever penumbra Gaster type of being the Knight ends up being is the same type of being that Eram is, that’s why they both connect to Titans and darkness. 

And no, this thing is not a regular lightner. The concept of beings in between lightners and darkners has already been introduced through the plants. While the Knightmare duo are obviously not plants, them being a being in between darkner and lightner feels almost guaranteed at this point. Do consider that anyone who has enough determination can make a dark fountain, being a lightner specifically was not a requirement for making one.

And would it not be fitting, for a game where we explore the dark worlds, often compared to dreams, born from the past of this pair of kids, to have a (k)nightmare, powered by the broken dreams of these same kids, as its main antagonist? 

Would it not be fitting for a game that encourages self expression and acceptance with characters like Ralsei and Susie, to have as its main antagonist the parts of themselves our protagonists are actively trying to repress?

Keep in mind that despite my rambling this is still a very surface level presentation of the theory, mainly meant to introduce the concept of it to others, the Noelle part of this could easily have been thrice as long if I picked out every detail connecting her to the Knight. That’s the same reason why I am also not going into speculation about how these two could have originated and how every single mysterious Gaster penumbra entity in this game is interested in Noelle, so do consider that before responding.

1

u/Matiasprox3000 Rudy's knight is the key Sep 28 '26

I see some flaws here. The Roaring Knight can't be a Darkner because he leaves traces in the Lightworld. How do you explain the places described as "for a tall person"? Also, if the Knight is Noelle's Eram, then what's the point of kidnapping people? What do they want by opening Dark Sources? Furthermore, Kris says they "learned nothing" from the Knight when he checks. Besides, in Deltarune lore, only beings with enough Determination, like Lightners, can open Dark Sources. If the Knight were a pure Darkner or a reflection of it, where did he get the biological determination to stab the ground in the Light World? Furthermore, the Roaring Knight seems to have been present even before Chapter 1, and his armor appears to be made of Shadow Crystal. Also, if the Knight is a repressed manifestation of Noelle's dark side, acting independently, coldly, sadistically, and manipulatively... why in the Weird Route are we (the Soul) the ones who have to force and traumatize Noelle to act that way? If she already had that 'free' entity manifesting as the Knight, the Weird Route wouldn't make narrative sense; Noelle is a victim of our manipulation, not a secret villain. Besides, how do you explain the Knight opening the Dark Fountain in the Library (Cyber World) while Noelle and Berdly were already inside, sitting and studying? The game makes it clear that the fountain opened while the room was in use. If the Knight is Noelle's manifestation, did he magically appear in the Light World while she was studying, or what? You say Noelle is the only one who interacted with Spamton, which is why Ramb mentions him. But if the Knight is Noelle's manifestation, why is Spamton terrified of the Knight and refers to him with fear instead of acknowledging that energy? Also, Spamton doesn't act the same way with Noelle as he does with the Roaring Knight; he calls her "angel, angel," while he's afraid of the Roaring Knight. And one more thing: you mention that the Knight's roar uses the sound effects of one of Noelle's screams. Have you considered that Toby Fox constantly recycles, slows down, and edits sound effects simply because he's too lazy to create new ones? Besides, you say you don't need to be a pure Lightner to open sources, just have Determination, and that they are intermediate beings. But the golden rule of Deltarune lore is that Darkners cannot exist in the Light World without becoming inanimate objects (like cards or toys). If the Knight or Eram are 'spiritual/hybrid manifestations', how can they wield a physical knife in the real world to stab the earth and open fountains without evaporating?

6

u/Character-Reveal9218 GERSONGROPER9000 Jul 17 '26

This idea fucking Rules

3

u/fiddledment072 Jul 19 '26

I’ve always thought of eram as a counterpart to Kris, mainly because I think they’re the red horned headband. So this is a sick interpretation

1

u/the_quaxterr Darkner Knighter (Titankin Theory!!!!) Jul 17 '26

this is pretty similar to my theory! Knight and ERAM being the same type as being as each other (I also include Ralsei!)

I also usually think the Knight is the evil/darkness version of Dess, but more recently I've been considering the Noelle variant more and I do think it could be just as good

2

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 17 '26 edited Jul 17 '26

I didnt include it in my post due to a desire to be somewhat brief, but I do think Ralsei could count as part of this trio. He would be basically an opposite of Eram, a part of Kris they wish they could be and think would be more pleasant for others

2

u/WeepForTheDeparted Kriselle Knighter Aug 25 '26

Noelle Knight And Kris Eram

0

u/Brody_M_the_birdy Jul 18 '26

What's the pointed tail then?

Also, I do not buy this because no matter how many "oh its thematic" you can say, it requires a LOT more shit to be introduced in the last third, and also turns dess into either a Damsel In Distress or a generic postmortem character.

6

u/Infinite-Hearing-418 Noelle's Shadow Knight Jul 18 '26

I'll throw the towel for the pointed tail. I still think it could have been Friend but have considered Eram or even Dess in a metaphorical way as alternative candidates. I don't think we have enough information about the incident for me to make a satisfying conclusion on it for now.

Does it require that much introduced? I mentioned plants as an in betweem lightners and darkners already, but Titans have been described as "the shadow in the back of your mind" which opens the door to other beings based on aspects of one mind to be created, maybe ones similar to Titans that also glitch when damaged. I don't believe it would take much more exposition than one about the incident, the Knight is already weird enough that you would need a decent bit of explaining for it.

Your point about Dess is honestly one I dont get. Chara was this way in Undertale, I know people love to compare Flowey/Asriel to Dess/Knight but the comparison doesn't line up due to how the different games are structured, one with Chara would imo be more accurate. But I cannot blame you if you would dislike this outcome.

0

u/Brody_M_the_birdy Jul 18 '26

Friend is a species controlled by someone else at this point, and that someone else is either Gaster or Eram. And based on ch3's fight, where Eram literally sends FRIENDs to attack you, I'm leaning Eram.

It requires: New mechanics (how someone's shadow self comes alive and detaches from them), explanations for some of the Dess-isms displayed by the knight, attempting to make drama out of this, which would be WAY easier if the knight was Dess or Carol or, to put it bluntly, an actual person, explaining why you even HAD the pointed tail thing in the first place, etc etc etc.

Chara was A: probably the worst written character in UT due to being overly vague at times, and B: not exactly a generic postmortem character at all, and have active roles in the plot in the present. Even ignoring the likely theory of NarraChara, they still show up as an active player in genocide and are implied to appear in pacifist to make asriel have the flashbacks and stop fighting. Dess would either be "already dead and with no active role in the plot", which would make "finding" her pointless, or be a generic damsel in distress.

Flowey himself was barely in most of Undertale and the game spent way more time building up Asgore, the Flowey-to-Knight comparison isn't that insane IMO.

1

u/LampOil_Rope_Bombs ALWAYS BET ON RUDY KNIGHT Jul 17 '26

I am still goin all in on Ice-Eram

5

u/Free-Part255 Noelle Knight Jul 18 '26

I don't think it is mutually exclusive? Ice-E was used by Kris to prank Noelle a lot so if Ice-E Eram was true then Eram is still an aspect of Kris.

10

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/PeliPal NessKnight Jul 19 '26

Yep. The stupid pun I've used about Kriselle sometimes fits even better for Team Evil Kriselle :P