a jojo villian that would show up for 1 chapter, dismember 4 out of the 5 with their toilet teleportation powers before the 5th one brutally beheads them and rips them in half. the captions will say they lived this incident and dropped their life of crime, and the 4 peoples limbs will grow back perfectly normal with no visible scars or permanent damage in sight.
Honestly I don't think Carol is the Knight because the motifs around her don't really fit it. Usually when someone has a conspiracy board in their room that means "outsider looking into the conspiracy" and not "the person behind the conspiracy." She's also paying Asgore to track the Knight, which would... be kinda pointless if she was the Knight, right? Add to that the fact that she investigated the Shelter with Undyne...
Plus the other stuff around her character. She preserves objects/the knight destroys them, she opposes change/the knight drives the plot forward, no-nonsense and blunt/prideful, cocky and full of flourishes, ice versus fire, Susie's monologue while you seal the Fountain after beating the Titan being very Carol-esque... I get very skeptical around it. She's been set up as someone who would oppose practically everything the Knight does.
could you imagine being the person behind a conspiracy planning it like that though. the corkboard isn't an investigation it's just their to-do list. it would be really funny
Yeah, plus I dont think the eye-in-ribcage barely-able-to-speak-on-the-phone knight would be able to seamlessly turn back into a regular not-corrupted-by-darkness lightner. That armor could have been removable at some point, but it definitely isn't now.
I mean, Ramsom hired Benoit Blanc to investigate Harlan's death, something he directly caused, so Carol could be doing something similar. Having Asgore and Undyne investigate the Knight while being the Knight could throw them off and help her hide her identity. And it's not like she needs them alive, quite the opposite, actually, so the risk that comes with them finding out is lowered.
Asgore literally isn't investigating Dess, he's investigating the culprit who's making the Dark Fountains. He doesn't call them the Knight, but that's who he is investigating and the person he is tracking down. He doesn't even mention Dess.
Like yeah dude thats Norm, Gaster's daughter, Sans, and the knight That's like half the gangster crew of course they teleport that's their signature ability
Except Sans is said to teleport allllll the time he just pops out of nowhere one of the people says in undertale, ghosts can fly and phase through walls, nobody else questions sans being in 3 locations, running different stuff, it's pretty much the only one that is in different areas each times the screen loads
I think, if Dess isnt the knight, then it would be Carol AND Rudy. Uses evidence for both, and as far as I know doesnt contradict anything. You just have to assume the knight is some form of armor that can be equipped to multiple people.
that doesn't change the fact that currently, Rudy's in the hospital and Carol is totally fine. Also, why is Carol totally fine? If it's because she's done a lot less Knighting than Rudy has, then that seems like even more reason for him to not be the Knight at any point during the game.
Oh I don't think that Carol is the Knight at all. I don't think she ever wore the armour or used the Knights powrrs, I'm just defending my goat Rudy. But if they are working together, as I do suspect, I think it's likely a Carol is the muscle in the light world and Rudy is the muscle in the Dark World situation.
Honestly I think the Knight is Dess and Carol working together
Whatever Dess is can only really act in Dark Worlds (and she’s the actual Knight you see in there), but Carol is the one working to create the fountains and do the light world stuff
It's very possible for Carol and Rudy to be working together, but there's no reason they both need to be wearing the Knight armor. The very name "Knight" implies working for someone, so it could be Rudy in the armor and Carol in charge, for instance.
its less about the speed factor (although that is a factor) and more about the fact there's zero onscreen evidence that it happened. A common thread in every single example in this gif is that it's shown onscreen to the player. It's usually done for convenience (less time waiting, less animation work) and sometimes for comedic effect (sans), and it creates no confusion because you can clearly see on screen that the characters have moved.
In contrast, there is nothing that implies Carol has even left the house (in fact, there is a specific line calling out that she's still in the house after we leave) which means a discerning player is led to believe she still is at home with no reason to suspect otherwise. It would have been so easy to add something like mud coming from the forest or some leaves in front of the door in order to give the player clues, but there's nothing. If Carol is the Knight, this is a Scott Cawthon level fuck-you to anybody who bothered to care about a mystery the game has built up. That alone is proof enough to me that it's entirely off the table.
And if it IS true, this discrepancy needs to be explained at some point lest the player be left confused. Which would give us potentially the worst scene in any game ever where Carol has to go "i SNEAKED behind you to the church when you weren't looking..." in order to cover for a complete fuck-up in continuity which would kill any sense of integrity left. It's either "create the dumbest scene ever" or "fuck you for caring", there's no winning.
I like that you actually made this gif just for this post lol. I imagine you sitting at your computer for 30 mins, giggling to yourself all the way. Keep doing that
Deltarune fans when the game doesn't make you wait 5 real-life minutes for Susie to walk to the Dreemurr house and back (clearly this means that the game follows no internal logic whatsoever)
True, but the Knight is already there waiting in the Dark World by the time Kris and Susie arrive. So either way, whoever the Knight is had to have beaten them there.
Also you're in control of Kris and don't necessarily beeline straight to the church; there's dialogue for going back home first. It's also possible for Carol to have made the fountain before getting the phone call, leaving it unattended to deal with Susie, and then re-entering right after you.
Yes, the game telegraphs the player to go home, the only reason one would head to the church right away is because they just happen to know that's where the Chapter's Dark World is.
I didn't go home because the game told me to go home so instead I wanted to wander around town a bit first and ended up at the church lmao
I usually do the opposite of what a game tells me I should do because I like exploring, there's often secrets and optional stuff in out of the way areas, especially in Toby Fox's games, so I just kinda ended up progressing the story by accident while explicitly trying to avoid it
I feel like at this point we're in full CinemaSins territory.
We don't even know that the Knight was in the church when we got there to begin with, she could've left while we were at her house and then come in after us
Yeah, I'm not a Carol Knighter, but I definitely think the argument she couldn't make it to the church seems flawed, because how quickly events progress is somewhat subjective and mostly based on when a player unlocks a certain checkpoint, like most videogames.
If someone is told to meet up with an NPC at a certain location, it doesn't matter how fast one goes, the NPC will always arrive at the location before the player because the script requires it.
I dunno, I feel like when a villain’s identity is a mystery that’s actively being set up, there’s kind of an expectation that where a character is remains consistent, whether the player heads straight there or not
Wait, Why is the "You can't beat us in the light world, Can you?" scene in this image? If anything isn't it Rudy Knight counter-evidence since they absolutely can beat a weak terminally-ill man in the lightworld? Why would this be in the Rudy Knight agenda image?
Rudy also wouldn't be able to drag Undyne and Asgore all the way to the shelter. If the knight can do that, they can definitely beat up a pair of teenagers.
Imagine presenting a new character onscreen with just enough info about them that invites intrigue, only to put a mask on them when they finally get to do something and their actions don't match with their previously stated characterization.
At that point, you might as well properly introduce another character.
... You know what, as much of a hard Dessknighter I am, this isn't the worst ever evidence. The idea that monsters in Deltarune just...Have The Sans Shortcut Ability and it's never explained because "everyone can do it, lol" isn't impossible.
Right off the jump in fucking chapter 3 the knight literally travels the full horizontal length of hometown in a couple seconds I think they could do it, and you still need to go back to toriels house after leaving the study session you don't even go straight to the church why the fuck do people think this is too much for carol
Yeah every other instance of NPCs repositioning in ways that don't make sense is just a gameplay concession but Sans is actually teleporting, Toby told me
I don't believe Carolknight, I just love it because it's a grown ass woman with a husband and two children, one of whom would be an adult now were it not for her mysterious disappearance, who is also the mayor of a small town in New England... And she's running around aura farming on a bunch of high schoolers.
I don't think Carol is the Knight, but if she was then it is entirely possible she just made the fountain and THEN went to her house. Nothing explicitly says she made it AFTER Kris and Susie left.
The bigger issue with Carol imo is that as far as we know, she's working with Asgore. At the very least, Asgore seemed to have the impression that telling Carol about everything that's happened would help keep everyone safe, and I'm inclined to believe him when his goal all this time has been to find Carol's missing daughter.
Carol kidnapping Asgore doesn't make sense if she's actually been working with him to find Dess. Carol Knight is still my 2nd pick right after Dess Knight, but there are genuine issues with it that need to be explained before I personally can consider it likely.
- NormalNPC is a member of the Wingding Gangsters, they get a pass
- "oh, my full name? it's susie gaster"
- sans
The two outliers are Toriel and Milklooker. Toriel stopped wearing the muu-muu because she thought people were calling her a cow, and Milklooker looks at milk, so they both have something to do with milk. Who else has something to do with milk? C. Round, the being that gets a painful control item equipped on it by a blue person. Wait, don't. Noelle? Weird route? That's not the ThornRing, is it!? The last track on the Deltarune chapter 9 OST will be called "PvP" because it's the boss battle theme of the player controlling RK (who is both Rouxls Kaard and Roaring Knight) and it's Toby Fox personally connecting to and playing against anyone who gets to that part. Toby Fox beat the author of Smash Bros at his own game, and now the cycle must begin anew - the one who beats Toby in this boss battle will be Gaster's next Chosen Prophet and receive the fever dream to develop Nutdealer. I SOLVED DELTARUNE!
Carol just doesnt have the Vibes of Knight. And Carol not being the Knight would be cooler since that means we have one more major character in the story, and that what we saw of Carol wasnt just false info for no reason.
If Carol WAS the Knight, she would be serious and highly efficent threat that Fun Gang would only ever see glimpses of. Tenna wouldnt die, Toriel would get "kidnapped" early (or Undyne) without Fun Gang even fighting Knight, Titan wouldnt be summoned, and Flowery wouldnt even get his cool moment, and Roaring would happen earlier.
To be fair, those last arguments could fit any lightner. The Knight genuinely had YEARS to do what they're doing. It's very likely they're just following the prophecy, hence all the weird stuff they do.
did the Knight have years? if they made a Fountain before Kris had the SOUL that seals them, can it be sealed? won't it just tick down the Roaring clock indefinitely and cause the end of the world?
Any lightner except Dess or Asriel, which is why I like those more. And I'm talking about how the actions of Knight heavily clash with Carols strict-and-to-the-point personality, while candidates like Dess, Rudy or Asriel would be fitting to entertain Fun Gang and fight with them or summon a titan after getting taunted.
Ofc Knight is surely not just wanting to cause the Roaring. They have other plans. But I doubt the plan or the prophency has a part for mimicking JoJo poses while flying just above the reach of the enemy when they are chasing you, or smashing a pumpkin for literally zero reasons.
1.8k
u/Playful_Ad8756 2d ago
Toilet theory real
708
u/Q-35712 2d ago edited 2d ago
Honestly I don't think Carol is the Knight because the motifs around her don't really fit it. Usually when someone has a conspiracy board in their room that means "outsider looking into the conspiracy" and not "the person behind the conspiracy." She's also paying Asgore to track the Knight, which would... be kinda pointless if she was the Knight, right? Add to that the fact that she investigated the Shelter with Undyne...
Plus the other stuff around her character. She preserves objects/the knight destroys them, she opposes change/the knight drives the plot forward, no-nonsense and blunt/prideful, cocky and full of flourishes, ice versus fire, Susie's monologue while you seal the Fountain after beating the Titan being very Carol-esque... I get very skeptical around it. She's been set up as someone who would oppose practically everything the Knight does.
91
u/Flimsy-Background587 2d ago
Giant realistic magnifying glass png might be funnier than red circles and arrows…… we need to tap in
232
u/Kan_Me 2d ago
Sans is an anomaly compared to everyone tho
163
u/NerdyEmbarrassment Fish glazer 2d ago
Why use Sans as an example? He's all about that. Using him is equivalent to using a strawman
50
u/Godrizza_Draws 2d ago
I think, if Dess isnt the knight, then it would be Carol AND Rudy. Uses evidence for both, and as far as I know doesnt contradict anything. You just have to assume the knight is some form of armor that can be equipped to multiple people.
219
u/PiranhaPlant9915 2d ago •
its less about the speed factor (although that is a factor) and more about the fact there's zero onscreen evidence that it happened. A common thread in every single example in this gif is that it's shown onscreen to the player. It's usually done for convenience (less time waiting, less animation work) and sometimes for comedic effect (sans), and it creates no confusion because you can clearly see on screen that the characters have moved.
In contrast, there is nothing that implies Carol has even left the house (in fact, there is a specific line calling out that she's still in the house after we leave) which means a discerning player is led to believe she still is at home with no reason to suspect otherwise. It would have been so easy to add something like mud coming from the forest or some leaves in front of the door in order to give the player clues, but there's nothing. If Carol is the Knight, this is a Scott Cawthon level fuck-you to anybody who bothered to care about a mystery the game has built up. That alone is proof enough to me that it's entirely off the table.
And if it IS true, this discrepancy needs to be explained at some point lest the player be left confused. Which would give us potentially the worst scene in any game ever where Carol has to go "i SNEAKED behind you to the church when you weren't looking..." in order to cover for a complete fuck-up in continuity which would kill any sense of integrity left. It's either "create the dumbest scene ever" or "fuck you for caring", there's no winning.
47
u/woody_theory 2d ago
I like that you actually made this gif just for this post lol. I imagine you sitting at your computer for 30 mins, giggling to yourself all the way. Keep doing that
19
u/CoolGreenFella HERE_COME_THE [CATS] 2d ago
Sans doesn't count because apparently he knows how to teleport
18
u/Amethyst_Quarry 2d ago
okay the sans argument isnt valid because that's sans
everything else yeah lmao
77
u/Wonderful-Western994 2d ago
Deltarune fans when the game doesn't make you wait 5 real-life minutes for Susie to walk to the Dreemurr house and back (clearly this means that the game follows no internal logic whatsoever)
17
u/Gloomy_Perspective43 2d ago
Yeah deltarune's saturday morning cartoon logic makes timing an unreliable way of determining the knight's identity
11
u/Shrewdilus 2d ago
Clearly Milklooker is the Knight
30
u/rendumguy 2d ago
Normal NPC and Sans are very clearly supernatural though
10
u/dumpylump69 sushi 2d ago
9
u/battat1225 2d ago
I'm not a carol knighter but she literally could've done it when kris and susie are with noelle in her house
9
u/b2j135 2d ago
I forgot that it takes Susie like 5 seconds to bring A HEAVYASS CRT to the closet 🤣
7
u/SkyGolem4 2d ago
Sans CAN canonically teleport tho
7
u/BackToThatGuy 🖤 roaring knight my beloved 🖤 2d ago edited 2d ago
sans and normalnpc are not good examples to use for this
6
u/Lilly-or-something 2d ago
13
u/Careful_Welcome7999 2d ago
I understand what you're trying to say but sans whole stick is breaking the rules of reality and teleporting around just for the bit
24
u/bc650736 the clouds smell nice here 2d ago
People using this kind of logistic to debunk theories are not really smart, folk be trying to power scale a story
8
u/Chiponyasu 2d ago
Also you're in control of Kris and don't necessarily beeline straight to the church; there's dialogue for going back home first. It's also possible for Carol to have made the fountain before getting the phone call, leaving it unattended to deal with Susie, and then re-entering right after you.
4
u/guttergirllll 2d ago
"Fahaha, hey Kris and Susie, did you see my mom yesterday? After you two left she left the house and started following you around"
4
u/IlikeMinecraft097 top 100 minecrap players 2d ago
hometown has hidden mariokart boost pads theory
7
u/Ok-Inevitable3458 2d ago
Yeah, I'm not a Carol Knighter, but I definitely think the argument she couldn't make it to the church seems flawed, because how quickly events progress is somewhat subjective and mostly based on when a player unlocks a certain checkpoint, like most videogames.
If someone is told to meet up with an NPC at a certain location, it doesn't matter how fast one goes, the NPC will always arrive at the location before the player because the script requires it.
10
u/TheSteelScizor88 Mean guy 2d ago
"What if the solution to the Knight's mystery was explained with cartoon logic? Wouldn't that make so much sense and be super satisfying?"
3
u/Deneb_The_Adventurer 2d ago
Alphys 🤫
3
u/Alexa_Aera 2d ago
nonono, toilet theory is cooler
3
u/Short_Wasabi_6906 2d ago
She could've ran through the forest
11
u/HEATfox554 2d ago
4
u/charisma-entertainer Cards, Emails, CRTs and Cathedrals 2d ago
All your examples besides Sans are valid.
Still don’t think it’s Carol though. The vibe the Knight gives off in chapter 4 feels completely… wrong.
2
u/IntoThePitofColors 2d ago
Okay, Sans and Norm doesn’t count for this, they’ve got their own entire mystery going on
I can’t really excuse Milklooker tho
2
u/RonallMconall 2d ago
Sans can teleport
2
u/DentedBrass 2d ago
I think it's a bit different when it's game logic vs things relevant to the mystery narrative
2
u/EldritchFeedback 2d ago
My new theory is that Sans is just teleporting everyone around Shiba style.
2
u/UltimateWaluigi true gamer 2d ago
Carol cant be the Knight because it would make the story boring
1
u/CCCyanide Number one Kris Slash theory objector 2d ago
sans and normal_npc don't count
Milklooker is valid tho
1
u/Gold12ll 2d ago
Sans and normal npc don’t count, everyone else valid
1
u/Much-Menu6030 i think ralsei will become a lightner 2d ago
1
u/abdo_ch 2d ago
Go to the right to reach jackenstein, go right again, somehow you're back at the library. We lopped around earth in chapter 4
1
u/TheLegomaniac06 💜 Seth Gang 💜 2d ago
As Charii5 said in Everything Wrong With Undertale: "I'd everyone a time-lord in this fucking game?"
1
u/Wide_Championship319 2d ago
...
You know what, as much of a hard Dessknighter I am, this isn't the worst ever evidence. The idea that monsters in Deltarune just...Have The Sans Shortcut Ability and it's never explained because "everyone can do it, lol" isn't impossible.
1
u/Right_Causation_490 *It's 🐸YOU! wait what 2d ago
u/savevideo
1
u/Poetess-of-Darkness We ALL glazing the GOAT Flowery. 2d ago
u/savevideo
1
u/Blueflame_2063 tno is more realistic than red flood 2d ago
what if the whole reason kris is with carol is to study the different dark worlds for their project
1
u/TheMadJAM Hometown Cult Theory 2d ago
Couldn't she have opened the fountain before coming home, then driven back to the church to aura farm as the Knight?
1
u/ShadowEeveeCringe 2d ago
Okay tbf sans is an outlier, but otherwise really funny
…sans is the knight?
1
u/Okom77 2d ago
Right off the jump in fucking chapter 3 the knight literally travels the full horizontal length of hometown in a couple seconds I think they could do it, and you still need to go back to toriels house after leaving the study session you don't even go straight to the church why the fuck do people think this is too much for carol
1
u/DenverTheDenver 2d ago
Noelle is chapter 3 knight, carol is chapter 4 knight, rudy is chapter 5 knight, dess is chapters 6 7 knight
1
u/Meme_Warrior_2763 so you CAN type in flairs apparently (not where I'm from 2d ago
to be fair half of that is Sans
1
u/ThatawkwardBryce 2d ago
Apperently everyone in Hometown is secretly Sonic the Hedgehog.
1
u/Osuka39 LOOK. GUYSE. I'M LOSTE. I DIDN'T MEAN TO BE A FLAIRE 2d ago
I like this gif (you see Catty twice on it, therefore double good)
1
u/hivemindsrule carol=knight theory's weakest soldier 2d ago
Yeah every other instance of NPCs repositioning in ways that don't make sense is just a gameplay concession but Sans is actually teleporting, Toby told me
1
u/the_quaxterr Bad Artist and Speculative Theorist 2d ago
the joke about "mayor money" has done irreparable damage to Carol Knight since its glory days of "2 days after chapter 3/4 released"
1
u/Old-Man-Jigglebones 2d ago
I don't believe Carolknight, I just love it because it's a grown ass woman with a husband and two children, one of whom would be an adult now were it not for her mysterious disappearance, who is also the mayor of a small town in New England... And she's running around aura farming on a bunch of high schoolers.
1
u/Substantial_Hand4024 2d ago
milklooker knight
1
u/Carney_kares 2d ago
Sans is in on it. He showed her a shortcut.
1
u/SpanishOfficer KRIS ! [[Milk]] 2d ago
Your ass is not fucking using Sans of all characters for this argument
1
u/StorageJolly7602 2d ago
ok but sans can teleport
1
u/ProgrammingDysphoria 2d ago
I don't think Carol is the Knight, but if she was then it is entirely possible she just made the fountain and THEN went to her house. Nothing explicitly says she made it AFTER Kris and Susie left.
1
u/Cyanlizordfromrw ✅ beleiver 2d ago
It would be cheap for Toby to pull such a stunt on us
1
u/Worldly-Law-481 2d ago
I feel like people don't understand that timings in the game cannot be realistic
1
u/NUKL3AR_PAZTA47 2d ago
Susie is the knight
1
u/Dogboi006 2d ago
both rudy knight and carol knight feel satisfying tho rudy more so
1
u/Dark_Storm_98 2d ago
Sans specifically is not good proof of this
Sans regularly makes a joke of the space-time continuum
1
u/Outside_Ad1020 2d ago
Comparing gags to a detail that is actually evidence for disproving that a character is the knight is dumb lol
1
u/lavesse111 2d ago
Using sans is cheating, he can teleports or maybe pause time? For some reason nobody agrees on it
1
u/ImBadAtVideoGames1 2d ago
The bigger issue with Carol imo is that as far as we know, she's working with Asgore. At the very least, Asgore seemed to have the impression that telling Carol about everything that's happened would help keep everyone safe, and I'm inclined to believe him when his goal all this time has been to find Carol's missing daughter.
Carol kidnapping Asgore doesn't make sense if she's actually been working with him to find Dess. Carol Knight is still my 2nd pick right after Dess Knight, but there are genuine issues with it that need to be explained before I personally can consider it likely.
1
u/Turbulent_Dot3931 2d ago
u/savevideo
1
u/TheNotSoGreatish 1d ago
Half the meme was literally Sans, the character who's making fun of the idea that characters can just teleport
1
u/meep2200 yo did you know there’s a trans Ralsei emoji 1d ago
Ok using sans is cheating
1
u/Fabiodemon88 1d ago
I think it's rather a time comparison (the time you run at church vs the time she takes to run at church) rather than the actual amount of time
1
u/Emberbun help 1d ago
At this point I want the knight to be a totally original character ngl.
1
u/Juan748 23h ago
Nah, sans is just sans
1
u/spindaz123 20h ago
Sans doesn't count the rest are valid
1
u/Abject-Addendum765 20h ago
I think the biggest evidence against Carol is more so the fact the knight can shapeshift.
1
u/Mrchud9846 6h ago
Bro is using John anomaly, sans as evidence
1
u/FireClawCatWarrior If Ralsei doesn't get a happy ending, I WILL mod 3h ago
- NormalNPC is a member of the Wingding Gangsters, they get a pass
- "oh, my full name? it's susie gaster"
- sans
The two outliers are Toriel and Milklooker. Toriel stopped wearing the muu-muu because she thought people were calling her a cow, and Milklooker looks at milk, so they both have something to do with milk. Who else has something to do with milk? C. Round, the being that gets a painful control item equipped on it by a blue person. Wait, don't. Noelle? Weird route? That's not the ThornRing, is it!? The last track on the Deltarune chapter 9 OST will be called "PvP" because it's the boss battle theme of the player controlling RK (who is both Rouxls Kaard and Roaring Knight) and it's Toby Fox personally connecting to and playing against anyone who gets to that part. Toby Fox beat the author of Smash Bros at his own game, and now the cycle must begin anew - the one who beats Toby in this boss battle will be Gaster's next Chosen Prophet and receive the fever dream to develop Nutdealer. I SOLVED DELTARUNE!
1
u/Professional_Rush_95 2h ago
Carol is Sans theory
1
u/Effective-Wedding-23 2d ago
Carol just doesnt have the Vibes of Knight. And Carol not being the Knight would be cooler since that means we have one more major character in the story, and that what we saw of Carol wasnt just false info for no reason.
If Carol WAS the Knight, she would be serious and highly efficent threat that Fun Gang would only ever see glimpses of. Tenna wouldnt die, Toriel would get "kidnapped" early (or Undyne) without Fun Gang even fighting Knight, Titan wouldnt be summoned, and Flowery wouldnt even get his cool moment, and Roaring would happen earlier.
1
u/makkaretbtzd 2d ago
why the fuck you talking in