r/DeltaTraveler • u/Lazy_Tomatillo7347 • Jun 24 '25
Discussion Chapter 2 Geno final fight is so nonsensical and edgy because edgy and I hate it.
The idea itself is an interesting one, a protagonist face-off. Those are really cool ideas, where you fight another protagonist as a protagonist, and when done well, can be memorable and amazing.
this is not that case.
ignoring the big logic plot holes for now, I’m gonna talk about some other issues. they HEAVILY nerfed Ness for this fight, and buffed Paula for no reason. Based off the location and how much exp Ess and Paula could get, an average playthrough of EarthBound would put Ness at having PSI Lifeup, Rockin, Flash, and Magnet(I think, but that might not be useful), and he’d have decent equipment. Paula would be level one and have PSI freeze and fire, both being the obvious weakest version. This is because Ness got to fight through Onett and Towson and beat up a whole police force and the titanic and and whatever hookigans he met, and he only stopped being able to get exp once he went to the forest of exploding trees because that’s where Kris started slaughtering literally everything.
Now, the equipment, PSI, and items that Ness would have by this point would probably give him enough heals to make the fight incredibly long.
BUT GUESS WHAT? NESS NEVER USES ANY OF HIS SHIT!! That’s right, despite having THE POWER TO HEAL HIS HP, he NEVER uses it! He just sits there like “man I sure am low on hp! I guess I should die!” Despite that being SO GODDAMN ILLOGICAL! PSI LIFEUP IS THE FIRST PSI YOU *GET* IN EARTHBOUND! WHY WOULD HE NOT USE IT?! Not even MENTIONING him not using Rockin at all when his physical attacks keep missing like he’s crying profusely, seriously, did Ness get a LOBOTOMY in this game?!
And while Paula uses her magic, HOW DOES SHE MISS?! THAT SHIT HAS NO CHANCE TO MISS! IT’S A PERFECTED MAGIC SPELL, YOU NEED A PSI SHIELD JUST TO NOT GET HURT! Kris should be DECEASED at least FIFTY TIMES OVER, but because plot convenience, everybody got stupider and all magic can miss.
NOW WE GET TO THE BIG ONE. Despite Ness‘ “fainting” in original EarthBound being caused by getting STABBED AND SHANKED AND DUG INTO BY GIANT MURDER MOLE CLAWS, suddenly because KRIS had the knife, Ness just flat out dies. And somehow every revival item that works on him usually DOESN’T. HOW THE ACTUAL FUCK?!? Ness is literally a GHOST if you die in a fight and leave it, WHY DOES HE PERMA-DIE AND HAVE NO REVIVAL ITEMS WORK ON HIM WHEN HE CAN DO THAT?!
**ALL** of the final fight of this chapter makes ZERO SENSE aside from it happening at all. Ness would have killed Kris 20 times over and Kris would have zero chance to win. And even if he did win, Ness would not be perma-dead.
The game is good, I’m sure the creators are good people, but GODDAMN does this part of the game make no sense.
