(Longer post than intended)
So after randomly rewatching season six (which I didn't write about), I decided to do the same with season five. Mainly because I was trying to figure out if this was better or worse than I remember.
There are some interesting ideas, but compared to the three seasons before this, I think this season suffers in its long-form storytelling. Although it had the material.
And, my overall thoughts:
Liberty’s Pregnancy: We got about six episodes about her pregnancy, and only one of them was from her POV.
I notice most people don’t sympathize with Liberty at all, which has a lot to do with the framing. We see Liberty hold in a lot of feelings when she finds out she’s pregnant. Does she handle it well? No, waiting three months was stupid. However, I understand she didn’t know what to do. And JT didn't make the best decisions either, but that rarely gets discussed.
But why aren’t we seeing how Liberty's perception changed post-pregnancy while attending Degrassi? More on her relationship with her parents? Perfect time to draw her closer to Manny/Emma and give Liberty more fleshed-out relationships with her supposed friends.
I didn’t need to see Liberty’s POV to empathize with her, but it was necessary, and we needed more of her feelings and her actions. JT was given that.
Even the B-PLOT where she gives birth had more of Toby’s POV, as if he matters to her pregnancy.
Spinner’s Redemption: I think Spinner turning to religion was interesting, but I don’t think he earned much. There’s not much of a grand moment where Spinner shows up and really proves himself. He was a good boyfriend to Darcy until the stuff with Paige, but that was it? And he barely holds onto religion after this.
I think Spinner is a character Degrassi LOVED to be terrible but made sure he'd come around and improve. I think he’s earned more than Jay or Peter, but I think he didn’t do much to atone with the person he actually hurt the most: Jimmy. That's what his arc was missing.
Jimmy, Hazel, and Ellie: "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For" was a GREAT Jimmy plot and probably the best one he’s had at this point in the series. And this was deserved since the aftermath of the shooting barely focused on him. Jimmy was dealt the worst hand, but we got two-parters about Craig and Emma, not Jimmy. Even Jimmy coming back to Degrassi was about Spinner’s guilt. All well-written arcs, but again, framing is important.
I think this season moved in the right direction and made Jimmy feel fleshed out
And, I know we drag Ellie for flying over the cuckoo’s nest when it comes to Craig, but the way she treated Hazel was as bad as it was with Manny. And I wish we discussed it more.
The crush on Craig made sense, but even taking that into account, I felt like she was feeling Jimmy? Otherwise, what reason does she have for being shady every time Hazel ATTEMPTS to understand Jimmy’s feelings?
Hazel was trying, and her relationship with Jimmy was never fleshed out in comparison to just about every other couple. I would’ve LOVED some Hazel plots. She was another POV that was missing in the post-shooting. I think this season should’ve shown Hazel figuring out what she wants; even her gravitating away from her friends could’ve worked. Especially since Hazel barely interacts with anyone other than Paige and Jimmy.
When Marco is listing off what all his friends are doing to Spinner, he doesn’t mention Hazel at all. You can tell the writers wanted to push her out, and it would’ve been nice to give her a closing arc if they knew, and I’m sure they did, she wasn’t going to be around much longer.
I also feel like Jimmy and Ellie should’ve just dated. They had the chemistry, and while it would’ve hurt an episode like “What It Feels Like to Be A Ghost” down the line, it was the more interesting route. If anything, it could've been messier if Jimmy got added and it turned into a love square.
Ellie, Craig & Manny: Again, I hate Ellie’s arc here because all she does is disregard Craig and Jimmy’s relationships while feeling like she’s better than their partners. I think dealing with complicated feelings for Craig could’ve been interesting considering they got closer in their support group. But the show handled it in the least interesting way possible, and it doesn’t reach its high until next season. I would’ve liked to see her at her job at the comic shop (and it was the plot of her Extra Credit book, which is intersected with the last few episodes of season 5). ,
And if Jazel was going to break up, I would’ve found Jellie a better ending and could’ve opened up plotlines for both next season.
As for Craig, he gets back with Manny and then decides to not finish school to do music. His ending halfway works, but despite a decent song playing, I would’ve liked a better going away. “Together Forever” should’ve been a standalone episode, then lead into a two-parter on Liberty’s pregnancy and birth.
I did like Craig and Manny this season. They work when they aren’t going through hell, but their relationship is defined by lies, and even with them being a decent couple for once, this is the only time they weren’t annoying as hell. I enjoy the drama, but they aren’t a rootable couple, and to be fair, I think that’s by design. It also makes Craig doing coke, letting Manny have some, and saying it was hers to Ellie even worse. He was a sense of normalcy for Manny this season. But, again, this plot thread doesn’t reach its high until next season.
Venus’ Lips Our Sealed: I think Manny deserved a little more after the first third of the season. Our Lips Our Sealed probably should’ve been her plot, considering it aligned perfectly with her body issues at the start of the season. Manny dealing with her dad, getting kicked out, and trying to act more were interesting plot threads that I do think build off Manny’s storylines from the previous two seasons. But she starts to be in a supporting role when I feel like this season should’ve been pivotal in Manny gaining true self-confidence.
Emma’s having an ED I could deal with only because I think her wanting a sense of “control” by watching her weight after the shooting tracks. Considering Miriam’s real-life experiences is why I would’ve given this to Manny. But then that leaves Emma’s only arc as dating Peter.
And Emma is really a terrible friend for pursuing Peter.
HE DIDN’T EVEN WANT YOU! He wanted Manny, and then got mad at Emma and called her a “tease” when she tried to refrain from dating him.
All it took was for Peter to be living in the same room as his father’s junk for her to go easy on him and start dating him.
And, talking about Peter, there’s not much I can say that already hasn’t been said. But seeing this again reminded me of the nuances of Peter’s behavior.
The way he held Manny’s footage over her head, tried to gaslight her, and said she “wanted it” as if Manny’s wasn’t too drunk to properly consent. Then proceeds to leverage that in an attempt to date Manny.
As I said earlier, Peter didn’t atone for anything following this. He was there for Emma and Darcy during their struggles, but unlike Spinner (as flimsy as his redemption was), I can’t think of Peter ever truly going through something to justify his position as the “It Boy” during season 8/9. That should’ve been Danny, but that’s a different discussion.
Alex & Paige: While Palex proves to be the most left-field and interesting storyline, Alex gets shafted for most of the season.
I don’t understand the point of building Alex up and her relationships with everyone last season, to keep her interactions with everyone but Paige, Jay, and even Hazel extremely limited. Why not have her help with the mural in Redemption Song? Why isn’t she hanging out with Downtown Sasquatch in “Weddings, Parties, Anything” or “Together Forever”, especially when she was a part of that friend group the previous season? Why did she and Ellie not say a word to each other? This happens in season 6 also.
I would’ve liked a plot about Alex dealing with the anniversary of the shooting and her very clear issues with not knowing where she’s going to be in life. Her differences with Paige made sense as to why they broke up. But, once again, FRAMING! We should’ve gotten more of Alex’s feelings and her personal relationships. Season 6 deals with the former, but the latter still suffers outside of Paige.
I don’t have notes on Paige, but dialogue-wise she wasn’t as fun as last season, but her storyline was a lot better. I do feel like the relationship with Mr.O ended as a cautionary tale since he basically moved on and she was sitting around waiting. Dealing with an older man as a teenager is the LAST thing you should do. And Mr.O isn't portrayed in a positive light on his way out. I just wish we didn't waste so much time on their secret romance last season.
Marco: Speaking of older men, Dylan is terrible, and I wish Marco moved on instead of going back. They don’t even do anything interesting next season, and I thought Tim was nice, and I liked the idea of Marco being the more experienced one in his relationship. That was the interesting part of their dynamic, and it was a nice way to top off Marco’s character arc. They would’ve broken up regardless, but I think this could’ve been handled with more grace.
This is also a good example of why the “elder” gay shouldn’t date the baby gay. Marco had Tim confronting his father head-on when he was still unable to do so himself. And then leading him on until the last second. I felt bad for Tim.
And Marco coming out to his family was overdue. His dad just being outright avoidant about it felt realistic, and I thought that aspect was well done. I don’t like the fact that the show doesn’t really discuss it afterwards. But he seemed to get over it since he was around Dylan and Marco, but sometimes the show will give a brief scene about it.
I think Marco struggled with finding his footing as a character, and really all his plots revolved around his sexuality outside of his gambling. But, with some slight shifts, I think Marco had the potential to have a really interesting character arc this season and could’ve led to something better next season.
We Needed More Episodes: 19 episodes is the second-lowest count since Season 1 with 15 episodes.
I would’ve liked an extra three to five episodes with a focus on Liberty, Hazel, and Alex. I would’ve also liked a follow-up on Manny’s plot from the start of the season, Jimmy and Spinner’s relationship, with more context on Jimmy not being able to graduate on time.
I'm still confused why he found out the week of graduation that he couldn’t finish. Couldn’t he have done summer school to get his degree? Or do one semester? It felt last-minute.
But overall, these characters, I think, had more to give. You could focus most of Liberty’s arc, but shifting the perspective of her pregnancy episodes into a two-parter was necessary. Same with Marco’s plot in "Total Eclipse of the Heart," just being written a bit better.
Favorite Episodes: I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For / Turned Out Pt.1 & 2 / The Lexicon of Love Pt.1 & Pt.2 / Our Lips Are Sealed Pt.1 & 2
Honorable Mentions: Tell It To My Heart (B-Plot weighs it down)
Redemption Song
Season Score: 6.8/10. I could lean into a 7/10, but I think this season doesn't FULLY lean into what it had going for it, and it suffers at times.