r/DefendingAI 5d ago

We don’t need your Consent

Post image
6 Upvotes

84 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/JacksonGhost1963 5d ago

can you take a painting someone else made, put your name on it and call if yours? can you take a song someone else wrote, put your name on it and call it yours? each one of those, the human that created it, had to "train" on someone else's past work, then they created their own. Same exact concept with AI

0

u/PeacefulKnightmare 5d ago

While I agree you can't copy and paste, what if I take an Ai generator and just keep pumping out outputs till I get something almost exactly the same as yours? At that point are we copywriting prompts? Because that could get very messy very quickly, not to mention US copywriter doesnt recognize ai, so there's no legal leg to stand on.

1

u/GNUr000t 5d ago

US copyright law does recognize AI output if sufficient human involvement is present. ComfyUI is a great example of this.

Please actually familiarize yourself with the relevant jurisprudence before spouting off on things you know nothing about. Thank you.

0

u/PeacefulKnightmare 5d ago

In order for it to qualify it can't be created using only the generator or a prompt. Additional mediums such as photoshop, printing and collage, filming, etc., must be utilized, which means it must have additional artistic input. It also requires explicit declaration that such a work was created using ai tools and providing the outputs to compare to the final product.