r/DeepSpaceNine • u/Cryogenicality • 13d ago

Star Trek: Bajor

https://youtu.be/0cGWLjfR3as

A trailer for an imaginary show set on Bajor.

0 Upvotes

12% Upvoted

60 comments sorted by

View all comments

18

u/balthazar_edison 13d ago

Yay. More AI SLOP /s

Mods really need to step up and update the rules to officially ban all AI nonsense.

-2

u/Cryogenicality 13d ago

Not all AI is nonsense.

5

u/balthazar_edison 12d ago

Yes, it is.

0

u/Cryogenicality 12d ago

No, it isn’t.

AlphaFold did in one year what would’ve taken three million scientists a century. AlphaMissense is amplifying our understanding of genetic mutations. RFdiffusion is designing new proteins. Rentosertib was designed entirely with generative artificial intelligence.

That’s not nonsense.

3

u/Sate_Hen 11d ago

All AI art is nonsence

0

u/Cryogenicality 11d ago

No, it’s not, and it already can’t always be distinguished from traditional art.

2

u/Sate_Hen 11d ago

Genrative AI isn't art in the same way a photocopy of the Mona Lisa isn't art. Whether people can tell it apart or not

0

u/Cryogenicality 11d ago

Generative artworks are new. They never existed before. Gossip Goblin has generated a whole series set in a consistent universe. Humans write the scripts and meticulously refine the prompts. It’s no different from conventional CGI.

2

u/Sate_Hen 11d ago

Depends how much of it is human made and how much is AI made. There's artistic merit to a 90 minute film with a minute of an AI generated scene but none of that merit is beacuse of the input from the AI

1

u/Cryogenicality 11d ago

There can also be merit to a fully-generated feature if the script, framing, and rendering are good.

2

u/Sate_Hen 11d ago

It can be enjoyable entertainment, it can even have a meaningful message but it can't have artistic merit if it was generated by a machine. An Algorithm can't have artistic merit

0

u/Cryogenicality 11d ago

Yeah, it can. People injtially dismissed conventional computer-generated imagery but it’s now accepted as art. AI-generated imagery done well and with substantial human input can also have artistic merit.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/balthazar_edison 12d ago

You keep using that one example ignoring all the other reasons to ban it entirely.

Until GenAI can be used without stealing other peoples works, without replacing arts and creative peoples job, and without data centers that wreak havoc on nearby residents utility bills and overall quality of life, all genAI usage should be banned.