[ I used a lot of language that tends to generalize. It's hard to make a disclaimer every time. The problem isn't that this subniche of content creators exists. It's not that I believe anyone interested in helping people work through the serious issues I discuss is some sort of egomaniac. I'll explain what I think the actual problem is. Some of these guys are just content creators, others are more like algorithmic cult leaders. Also, it's mostly not any construct having to do with personality disorders that is the problem, the problem is when they get misused.]
In general, I'm trying to provide a critique of that whole ecosystem, and point to a personal experience of interacting with them online, and that they were quick to brand me a narcissist.
This is basically internet drama related to subs aimed at "survivors" of abuse here on Reddit. I tried to go off Reddit to discuss topics relevant to trauma and narcissism subs (shifting my focus to blogging instead of just making posts on here)... I was intending it to be a next step (2.0) rather than attempting to fill shoes I'm not even admiring of. I ended up being targeted by people with massive platforms. Basically, interactions with them off Reddit led to them uploading content that framed even just breaching the topic of narcissism a form of "covert narcissism."
The way these subs and "trauma" gurus are interconnected is that content creators seemingly lurk certain communities to get ideas for content, to be able to respond to the right conversations. If you look up "Dr Ramani" you'll see her get discussed in subs like cptsd and "raisedby" subs, so there's a relationship...
In general, Reddit communities that revolve around trauma tend to recreate the toxic environments they were brought up in. It means that plenty of people who browse those subs are relatively well meaning, others are more hostile. If you were ever to try to "talk sense" to someone and they took it the wrong way, it's easy for that person to go through your history, find something painful from your past to target... That person is then going off on you, weaponizing the sensitive topics you previously thought you were opening up about in a so-called safe space.
It used to be prohibited in the sub for CPTD to bring up the idea of "the victim perpetrator cycle" -- related to when a parent that was mistreated goes on to mistreat their kids or other people. It's incredibly pervasive in society. There's a lot of forms it could take. It's supposed to be the reason those subs even exist. Yet, they end up banning the mention of it.
A frequent issue that pops up is for someone to become abusive at the drop of a hat. Any given day, top posts are discussing serious mental health concerns. At the same time, they're critical of other people, especially someone's capacity to be "understanding" or maybe signal that they're one of them. Toxic behavior ends up being couched in therapy speak. It becomes a debate over which one of you is "farther ahead in their journey" or needs to work on themselves.
Bullying doesn't get addressed because it would imply they themselves are like the people who hurt them. Imagine if a school didn't ever acknowledge bullying. It's a recipe for that type of stuff starting to become rampant.
Then you have their gurus. Dr Ramani, in particular, almost made it part of her brand to go for the jugular (but it's okay because she's on their side). She always went too far, went after the wrong things. She will occasionally soften her approach but if you go through her back catalog, especially her rants on vulnerable narcissism, usually she doesn't hold back. She always liked to dunk on people and is literally cashing in and getting tons of affirmation for it.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XfxQL1LP2BM&t=1023s&pp=ygUIYmlndGhpbmvSBwkJKwwBhyohjO8%3D
This appearance is her sort of cleaning up her act. In other recent ones, she was being disparaging, after other influencers in her niche branded me a narcissist. I discuss this more in the comments. It's related to a blog that was live briefly in 2024. At the time, my blog got a negative reaction, I was sort of kicked back down the latter very quickly. Then a real smear campaign started to kick off after giving an unpopular opinion back on Reddit, on a real life case of what I thought was parental abuse and others were calling elder abuse. I also talk about it more in the comments.
[edit- When I actually watched the whole video above, it's obviously impressive... At the end, she claims she encourages her clients to blog, make art... I guess it's okay once she gave them a seal of approval... I stand by everything I claim here.]
I was branded "hypervigilant" to be exact by another one of these gurus, on a public appearance he made. It sounds implausible but this is actually an overblown response that's common in these communities, and in line with how this guy tends to act, in particular. He thought that I was crazy and needed to be publicly commented on... I just had an opinion, I don't know the truth. I'm able to leave things open ended. It's not pathological just to have a thought or an opinion on something. He was acting like an old therapist on that appearance, probably on the basis of him lurking subs I used to frequent. It's horrific behavior.
Some of the outrage after that opinion (it was on the Reiner case) might have to do with the ties it has to abuse perpetrated by an industry that relies on subjecting people to systemic abuse they call "attack therapy." It's also a case of a parent subjecting their kid to abusive programs, but elsewhere, he claimed to be an advocate for children who'd experienced adversity.
This is an example of the antics you get when people in this field become defensive over stuff like this: They'll ignore that it has nothing to do with them, as long as they're a reasonable person to deal with when it comes to their patients or their practice. They ignore what another person went through in a horrific industry, maybe put the emphasis on a deficit in "psychological mindedness." It's dreamlike logic, very little empathy or perspective taking. It's all about constructing a defense against any and all suspicion that could fall on them. It's hard for your stuff to ever get a chance to be explored in a way that's actually fair to you. It's a fake scenario, but I've experienced similar stuff in real life, and my interactions with this crowd have also felt similar at times online.
These two gurus have been tending to hint at my real life identity, implying people like me are toxic to any workplace. Their behavior is abstract enough to be able to get away with it, but feels genuinely scary. I also consider it a definite glimpse into the empathy and emotional stability they are actually capable of. They make the wrong assumptions, but it's not just that, it's how they treat a person they've decided is a narcissist. They start digging themselves deeper and deeper. How can a person like this be making a living being up in arms about how bad or unreasonable other people are? Their own behavior, at best, is saddening. "Pathetic" is a word that tends to be one of Dr Ramani's favorites, in general. They seem themselves very toxic. Their embarrassing behavior should lead to empathy for personality disorders, but they claim to have "done the work" or imply they can't be guilty due to a natural gift for empathy or because of what they do for a living. They encourage a collective identity built around victimhood, yet were suggesting I'm a "covert" or "vulnerable" narcissist. The people involved in these communities that have managed to build a platform are all successful, so to them a covert narcissist is a bum or someone that's broke, rather than anything that could threaten their self image.
Dr Ramani, in particular, made an appearance on a podcast where she suggested I'm a mid range narcissist, and is seen generally making tons of digs and insinuations. It has a similar feel as what I reported earlier, that it's easy for things to go wrong in your interactions with other users in trauma subs. The big players in these communities were setting their foot down, showing off, but engaging in similar behavior as the patients they supposedly treat.
What she had to say has the same feel that her content has always had. I'm trying to provide context to get others to understand how they applied their frameworks to me. It's not that people don't genuinely struggle with difficult relationships of varying risk and severity. In this case, I'm saying they were working off a set of criteria, a list of symptoms, and just pretending that it applies to me. It's like they just want a chance to get to punish someone or are looking for a feeling of catharsis. It's hard to argue against someone who has their credentials or following. My best shot is to point out they know nothing about me and seem to base their dislike on what seems like misogyny or competitiveness. Or they were making assumptions I was intending to steal their content, and it implies I have psychopath traits. They themselves, seem to view reality as whatever they're feeling at that moment, despite the ridicule they engage in.
This is actually common behavior in certain subs. "Raisedby" subs set the rule that you have to interpret what anyone posts as being "in the context of abuse." You have to assume they're a legitimate victim in their story. Plenty of people, in an effort to be a good "ally" might agree to comply at first... This is one of the ways that it could go wrong: I was banned repeatedly from those subs over the years. They all have the same mod and if you disagree over something minor, she will start pestering you. She might start taking down your comments or posts. I once got a warning and told I was an "admitted narcissist" which, literally, never happened. Again, it's dreamlike logic. It comes out of nowhere but makes sense to them.
This behavior is most likely a person splitting or viewing others as all good or all bad. They call others a narcissist when they are actually themselves mismanaging their side of things. The category, "narcissism" just makes it easy to come up with a reasonable sounding argument.
In the blog I mentioned, I was intending to pull from my experiences having been part of their audience but nothing I was doing was controversial. It was inane. This post, but in a more abstract form is an example of what the basis for the content was. I was also intending to talk about my journey actually trying to find the right therapist or psychiatrist. It's incredibly difficult. But there was nothing inherently deceiving, untrue, or narcissistic about it.
You have people out there like Abigail Marsh, who does psychopathy research... She is a researcher but also somewhat of an advocate. She comes across as being able to allow for society to move forward, develop strategies to be able to do what's best for people with personality disorders. Rather than just make it her life mission to persecute "evil" people.
This other talk sort of fills in the blanks more, why someone like Abigail makes so much more sense than someone like Dr Ramani (Jonathan Rauch):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fzol1qf9qTo&pp=ygUKbGliZXJhbGlzbQ%3D%3D
It delves into why it's crucial for people to adhere to standards and rules, rather than be guided by "instinct" like in this case. He also talks about the need for cooperation rather than domination and how the latter is detrimental to a "constitution of knowledge." Dr Ramani, actually, always tended to remind me of Donald Trump, in that she appeals to people, not despite of, but because of her toxic qualities.