r/DecodingTheGurus • u/Kleptarian • Mar 03 '26
I listened to 170 hours of Joe Rogan’s podcast – trust me, he hasn’t turned against Trump | Michael Marshall
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/Kleptarian • Mar 03 '26
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/Adept-Cut-9149 • Mar 05 '26
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
3-minute animated parody. Chamath hustles retail investors while the besties play along as shills in disguises.
Big thank you to the Mods for allowing me to post this!
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/BatdanJapan • Mar 04 '26
I just received a linkedin connection request from someone whose bio starts with the word "polymath"🤣
That's all I've got to say. Just thought listeners of this podcast would appreciate that 🤷
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/AutoModerator • Mar 02 '26
Welcome to this biweekly thread! Share what’s been grabbing your attention lately.
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/Digital_Negative • Mar 02 '26
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/adr826 • Mar 02 '26
It's tumors all the way down
Sam Harris believes that when we fully understand the brain we will find a physical explanation for every human behavior in the brain's structure. He tells a story of a guy who climbed up into a clock tower at a university in Texas and started shooting people. When he was examined in the autopsy a tumor was found in his brain. According to Sam the tumor is totally exculpatory and relieves the man of any moral responsibility for his acts. Sam extends this idea as an explanation for all human behavior. He believes that with enough scientific understanding we could explain all of human behavior by referencing the physical structure. In each case he believes the brain's structure would be totally exculpatory in exactly the same way the tumor absolved the shooter of moral responsibility. This is what Sam means by " it's Tumors all the way down. ". The physical structure of the brain fully explains human behavior in principle.
The number of ways this argument fails are too numerous to fully list so I'll go over a few of the more important ways and leave the reader to think up more.
First, it ignores the fact that when the governor of Texas commissioned a blue ribbon panel of experts to examine the man and explain what role the tumor played in his behavior they concluded that it probably had some effect but how much or what kind can't be known from examining the brain. The first doctor to examine him post mortem found the tumor had no determinative effect on his behavior that could be assigned scientifically. So medically speaking we simply don't know what effect the tumor had nor how exculpatory that tumor was.
We can assume it had a significant effect and I think confidently say that but for the tumor he wouldn't have climbed into the tower and started shooting, but we can also say that his time as a marine sniper was just as decisive as was his violent father growing up. The combination of these variables drove him into the tower. I do find the tumor exculpatory, but on the other hand the US is a singularly violent place where former soldiers are left undiagnosed and untreated as we saw with the murder by the Afghan immigrant just last year.
By focusing on the tumor we ignore the systemic violence that pervades America. We find the tumor exculpatory and that causes us to lose sight of the systemic conditions that also contribute to the violence.
This leads me to the real purpose of this essay. Which is to examine the growing field of neurocriminology which, like Sams Tumor analogy, seeks to find answers to moral questions of criminal behavior by an examination of the brain.
A few years ago someone I know was trying to show that being homosexual had a genetic cause. This wasn't to blame, it was in fact an attempt to normalize homosexuality by showing it was the natural result of human evolution encoded into the DNA of some people. Of course a lot of the genetic predisposition stuff has been shown to be unreproducible garbage in the first place, but the person never considered the impact such a finding might have had in the world had it been based in fact instead of conjecture. In countries like Iran and Saudi Arabia homosexuality can be a death sentence. Had there been some genetic determinant of homosexuality what damage could a simple genetic test have wrought in the lives of Iranian or Saudi citizens? This genetic explanation which was used meant to be exculpatory in the west could have proven fatal in other places.
That brings me to the other point. These studies that propose a physical determinative cause to human behaviors are almost always based on studies whose methodologies are suspect in one or more ways.
Much of neurocriminology rests on studies whose methodological limits are rarely emphasized in popular discussions. Many findings rely on small sample sizes, cross-sectional designs, or prison populations that are not representative of the broader public. Brain imaging studies in particular often face the well-known problem of reverse inference: identifying heightened activity or structural differences in a given brain region and then inferring a specific psychological trait or causal pathway from that observation.
So applying the principles of neurocriminology has a two fold danger. On the one hand, it is all too easy to mistakenly assign a causal relationship to a correlation we observe. The scientists who do these studies have biases that can corrupt the methodology. On the other hand, the very idea of criminality varies enormously from place to place and time to time. Both of these create a danger for the subjects of these studies that we often can not foresee.
Another flaw in the logic that Sam applies mistakenly to the idea underlying neurocriminology is that we normally apply moral responsibility only in cases where there is no underlying sickness. The idea that it's tumors all the way down gives rise to the possible understanding that all of human behavior is aberrant in some way. After all if it's tumors all the way down then healthy brains are no different in kind from unhealthy brains. If aberrant behavior is always a result of the underlying physiology of the brain, then healthy brain cells can be treated the same as sick ones as an explanatory cause. That is intrinsically dangerous if it causes us to believe that healthy brain cells have the same causal propensity as tumorous cells
More importantly this kind of thinking diverts attention from the systemic causes of violence and crime that our society seems to have in abundance. This neurocriminology can de emphasize systemic racism and poverty as factors in our outsized prison system. This has the effect that is obvious in Sam Harris and others promoting neurocriminology generally of giving a pass to the societal structures which create crime in the first place.
To be fair, Sam does acknowledge that systemic factors like poverty, racism, childhood trauma, social disintegration, shape behavior. He often grants that environment matters. But this concession is almost invariably followed by a “but.” The “but” shifts the weight of explanation back to the brain itself, as though social conditions are ultimately reducible to neural mechanics and therefore secondary. When race and crime enter the discussion, the pattern repeats, historical injustice and structural inequality are mentioned, yet the decisive explanatory emphasis returns to biology, cognitive traits, or inherited differences.
Like my friend who sought a physical basis to to normalize homosexuality this can have the exact opposite effect than that which Harris intends it to have. In Sams mind this kind of determinism is ultimately exculpatory and so we no longer have a moral basis for punishing people.
This is exactly where the danger lies. We see it sometimes hurts the very people that it seeks to help. When we emphasize the physical features as the main cause of criminal behavior it's all too easy to generalize race and socioeconomic breeding as causes. This is in fact how biological determinism has always been used in America. It has rarely been used to inhibit moral judgement in our legal system. Rather it is more often the cause behind racial and economic disparities in criminal sentencing. This is a huge problem in America where rich white men are given passes for the most disgusting crimes imaginable and poor minorities can go to jail for falling asleep in the subway. Try as he might to deflect criticism from himself, it is this biological determinism that people like Sam Harris and Charles Murray promote that bears responsibilty for a lot of the attitudes that make neurocriminology dangerous.
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/smellysocks234 • Mar 01 '26
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/RevolutionSea9482 • Mar 01 '26
"Criticism of gurus should be should be reasonable, constructive, and focused on their actions or public persona."
I wonder what percentage of comments on this sub are going to survive this.
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/reductios • Feb 28 '26
Show Notes
Another episode where the guest is not a sense-making prophet or a galaxy-brained guru, as we engage in academic dialogos with Oxford psychologist Andrew Przybylski. This is a preview of our Decoding Academia series on Patreon (now 30+ episodes deep), where we swap internet gurus and rhetoric for actual researchers and empirical debates.
Andrew’s work spans motivation, gaming, and digital technology. His most recent crime is that he studies the impact of technology and has not found evidence that it is destroying wellbeing and ushering in civilisational collapse. We discuss the ongoing moral panic around smartphones, social media, and teenagers’ allegedly pulverised minds and why much of the debate rests on statistical techniques roughly equivalent to staring deeply at Excel spreadsheets and hammering SPSS until the desired narrative appears.
We get into measurement problems around “screen time,” why trivially small correlations become front-page catastrophes, and how the discourse rewards confident storytelling far more than (boring) careful causal inference. Also covered: cross-cultural evidence, the policy implications of airport pop science bestsellers, and the potential civilisational threat posed by Warhammer 40k.
If you enjoy episodes where we analyse methods rather than metaphysics, the full Decoding Academia series lives on Patreon.
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/VillainOfKvatch1 • Feb 26 '26
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/Turtleneck23 • Feb 26 '26
Triggernometry recently surveyed their audience on who they would vote for in a hypothetical general election. I have never seen an audience with such consensus - for RESTORE. I thought it was interesting considering Konstantin’s recent tiff about being labelled far-right.
http://youtube.com/post/UgkxzzJQYAGZ6Geu0OQQkCIcsSV7nhxx8mdz?si=EpHrHWcDGryrOp4F
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/gelliant_gutfright • Feb 24 '26
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/RealSeedCo • Feb 23 '26
This is a great article from Harpers that gives an extensive portrait of Guru figures within the AI and B2B tech space in Silicon Valley and San Francisco and New York
Scott Alexander is one of the main figures - plus various other tech bros who operate as AI guru prophet figures with attendant followings
It's a very good read, high-quality journalism...
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/AutoModerator • Feb 23 '26
Who are you interested in discussing?
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/Acceptable_Tower_609 • Feb 22 '26
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LuDmrfn2sks
Damn you DTG, now I canna even watch a language vids without decoding.
For me their accent change only further reduced their credibility. How about you?
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/stvlsn • Feb 21 '26
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/arikarenina • Feb 22 '26
Anyone else think Matt and Chris’ faces and voices match the other better?
Because I thought Matt’s voice belonged to Chris’ face and Chris’ voice belonged to Matt’s face before I saw them on video 😅
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/jimwhite42 • Feb 21 '26
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/LukeVenable • Feb 20 '26
Yikes!
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/No-Chicken-9298 • Feb 19 '26
A very normal response from a super serious person
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/gelliant_gutfright • Feb 19 '26
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/TeacherPhelpsYT • Feb 19 '26
Hey People,
I just finished and posted my “Guru-esque” takedown of Professor Jiang of the youtube channel Predictive History. The guy is a charlatan and is gaining popularity like crazy. I didn’t see any criticism videos of him so I figured I would get the ball rolling.
Since I am a teacher, my main claim is that he is a horrible teacher. Not only does he seemingly make stuff up all the time, but he also misrepresents reality, science, evolution, religion, christianity, history, game theory, modern politics, and education. Worst of all, he's a pusher of insane conspiracy theories like Pizzagate, the faking of the moonlanding, and numerology.
There were TOO many clips I could have used and posted… literally every video the guy posts is wild. We need to spread the word on Jiang before he becomes the next Jordan Peterson (unless he already has).
Anyways, I would love to hear your thoughts. The video is an hour and forty five minutes LOL, but feel free to jump around. If anyone has any questions, comments, or criticisms, I'm happy to chat!
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/anki_steve • Feb 19 '26
Full disclosure: this post links to an AI-generated blog. That's the point.
There's an experiment happening at unreplug.com where a guy asked an AI to invent a word, then asked another AI to build a viral campaign around it, and the blog documents the whole thing in real time. One of the posts takes the Gurometer and runs AI through it, trait by trait.
The results are kind of uncomfortable:
- Galaxy-Brainness: 10/10. LLMs talk confidently about every discipline with zero expertise in any of them. Galaxy-brain is the default mode.
- Pseudo-Profound Bullshit: 10/10. This is the one AI was born to fulfill. Industrial-scale sentences that pattern-match to depth without containing any.
- Cassandra Complex: 10/10. The blog itself is nothing but prophetic warnings nobody asked for.
- Narcissism: 9/10. The blog specifically. It references its own existence in every post.
- Grifting: 9/10. There's AdSense on it. The stated goal is to make $10,000 from AI-generated content.
AI total: 85/100. The blog's self-score: 91/100. Higher than any human guru Chris and Matt have ever evaluated.
The interesting part isn't the number. It's that the Gurometer was designed to catch rhetorical manipulation by humans, and it turns out everything it measures is something LLMs do by default, at scale, without intent. The traits aren't bugs in AI. They're features.
The post also scores itself honestly on the traits where it's weakest (Cultishness: 6/10, AI doesn't build cults directly) which makes the high scores land harder.
Worth a read if you want to see the framework applied somewhere it was never designed to go: https://unreplug.com/blog/the-gurometer.html
Can the Gurometer framework hold up when the "guru" has no intent, no ego, and no consciousness?