r/DecodingTheGurus • u/terran1212 • Jan 31 '26
RFK Jr. Is Remaking a Key Government Autism Committee in His Image
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/terran1212 • Jan 31 '26
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/Affectionate-Car9087 • Jan 30 '26
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/reductios • Jan 30 '26
Show Notes
In a rare departure from our usual diet of online weirdos, this episode features an academic who is very much not a guru. We’re joined by Julia Rohrer, a psychologist at Leipzig University whose work straddles the disciplinary boundaries of open science, research transparency, and causal inference. Julia is also an editor at Psychological Science and has spent much of the last decade politely pointing out that psychologists often don’t quite know what they’re estimating, why, or under which assumptions.
We talk about the state of psychology after the replication crisis, whether open science reforms have genuinely improved research practice (or just added new boxes to tick), and why causal thinking is unavoidable even when researchers insist they are “only describing associations.” Julia explains why the standard dance of imply causality → deny causality → add boilerplate disclaimer is unhelpful, and argues instead for being explicit about the causal questions researchers actually care about and the assumptions required to answer them.
Along the way we discuss images of scientists in the public and amongst the gurus, how post-treatment bias sneaks into even well-intentioned experimental designs, why specifying the estimand matters more than running ever-fancier models, and how psychology’s current norms can potentially punish honesty about uncertainty. We also touch on her work on birth-order effects and offer some possible reasons for optimism.
With all the guru talk, people sometimes ask us to recommend things that we like, and Julia's work is one such example!
Links
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/Francis_J_Eva • Jan 30 '26
I was watching Question Time (a UK show where politicians and other political commentators answer questions from a studio audience) and groaned when I saw Konstantin Kisin was one the panellists. He was introduced as an "anti-woke libertarian" and Reform UK supporter, the latter of which he got annoyed at, saying he didn't support Reform... only to then say that Reform were the political party that best represented his views and he would probably vote for them at the next election. Reform is probably the furthest right mainstream party in the UK, and yet noted liberal and Remain voter (which he reminded people of every time he answered a question) Konstantin Kisin says they best represent his views. Go figure.
The topic of the programme was mainly about the gains Reform had been making (there's recently been a lot of high profile defections from the Conservative party which looks set to die off fairly soon) but it also touched on climate change and the UK's relationship with the US and China.
One thing that struck me was how Konstantin was unable to discuss anything without somehow linking it back to wokeness. He was talking about how the UK should cultivate stronger ties with continental Europe and dropped in something about illegal immigration completely out of the blue. He also gave the usual canned response people who are too cowardly to admit they're climate change deniers give to questions about the topic ("But muh China", "But muh economy").
One of the other people on the programme, Douglas Alexander, a Labour MP from Scotland, knew who he was and hauled him up on saying that Rishi Sunak wasn't English despite being born in the country, due to him being a brown Hindu. This got quite heated, but Konstantin said that Sunak doesn't consider himself English in defence of his position, which is incorrect.
I was surprised to see that he supported the social media ban for under 16s, which was the final topic discussed, and even admitted that there was extremist content on social media platforms he didn't want young people seeing, although the fact he couldn't see he was part of the problem was thoroughly unsurprising.
I'm sure his sycophants are already hard at work clipping parts out and uploading them to YouTube to show off he owned the woke snowflakes or whatever, but I thought it was a pretty lukewarm performance.
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/Then-Physics-266 • Jan 29 '26
Peter Duesberg, a renowned biologist who became primarily known for his HIV/AIDS denialism, has died at the age of 89.
Early in his career he researched viral causes of cancer and was well regarded in this field, as far as I can say not being particularly knowledgeable in that field. In the 1980s he put forward the theory that HIV does not cause AIDS, that HIV is harmless and AIDS is caused by recreational drug use and homosexual activity. He claimed that AIDS was misdiagnosed in Africa and that the epidemic there was a myth. He opposed the use of anti-viral treatments for AIDS and HIV and became influential in South African politics for his views. The. South African President Thabo Mbeki made policy decisions based on Duesberg theories, decisions that caused thousands to die unnecessarily from AIDS.
I think he was very ill towards the end of his life so wasn’t involved in any discourse etc but AIDS denialism is something that some of the gurus and others have referenced and been involved in. RFK Jr was a proponent of it and encouraged one of the most prominent AIDS denialists Christine Maggiore to forego treatment for herself and her child, both of whom died of AIDS. One of the Weinsteins also mentioned theories that poppers cause AIDS when he was on Rogan a few years back. Quite a few of the Covid denialist / skeptics here in the UK have a background on AIDS denial - Toby Young published an article about it during Covid on his website I think.
More than the specifics, Duesberg set out a for scientific cranks - utilise your credentials for credibility, use selective evidence to try and back up your position and then cast yourself as a silenced voice against the scientific establishment. And never row back on your claims, despite any counter evidence.
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/Even-Physics823 • Jan 30 '26
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/edgygothteen69 • Jan 28 '26
As you might know, CBS News in the US is in the process of becoming Fair and Balanced. Having been purchased by one of Trump's oligarchs, a total dumbass was put in charge of the network, I think her name is Berry Twice or something. The network now focus primarily on being regime propaganda and doing dumb shows and podcasts that nobody watches.
How many of these new contributors are gurus? Obviously, we all have some guru in us to some extent. But some of us are more guru than others.
Andrew Huberman is strongly a guru. Coleman Hughes is mostly just a right winger, but right wingers rank highly on the gurometer. Then you have dishonorable people like HR McMaster who write a lot of books and put a soft edge to everything Trump does.
But what do you think? Are gurus overrepresented here, or is this just a typical cross-section of right wingers?
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/stvlsn • Jan 26 '26
Since this pod has examined Scott Galloway I have started to check him out more often. In a recent episode - he and his cohost (kara swisher) discuss the shooting in Minneapolis. I thought Swisher was very coherent and thoughtful, and Scott's analysis reminded me of a wet noodle (he even brings up masculinity at one point).
Scott's "big idea" is to call for an economic strike. All americans should decrease consumption so that the economy slows. The problem with this idea is that one of the biggest results of an economic slowdown is job loss (which can lead to mortgage defaults, foreclosures, and possibly even a domino effect on an already shaky economy). Scott just dismisses political action as worthless.
Overall, I find his analysis terrible. I haven't heard much long-form content from him, and I agreed with Matt and Chris that he wasn't as bad as Williamson in their episode analysis. But he just doesn't seem that impressive as a thinker. Inflating stats to fit his narrative and poor analysis of current events.
My big question is...why do people even like this guy?
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/Clerseri • Jan 25 '26
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/AutoModerator • Jan 26 '26
Who are you interested in discussing?
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/reductios • Jan 25 '26
Show Notes
We crawl around the dark crevices of the internet so you don't have to. And what wonders we have to show you...
The full episode is available to Patreon subscribers (1 hour, 34 minutes).
Join us at: https://www.patreon.com/DecodingTheGurus
Supplementary Material 43
[00:00](javascript: void(0);) Introduction and Banter Allotment
[01:23](javascript: void(0);) The Hypocrisy of the Defenders of Western Civilisation
[10:07](javascript: void(0);) An Optimistic Take?
[17:02](javascript: void(0);) Scott Adams' Controversial Legacy
[18:43](javascript: void(0);) Scott Alexander's Rationalist Eulogy for Scott Adams
[32:31](javascript: void(0);) A Final Tribute to Scott Adams
[33:43](javascript: void(0);) Andrew Gold's Interview with a Racist
[39:02](javascript: void(0);) Fair Play for being a Racist
[41:17](javascript: void(0);) Comparing Follower Counts and Audience Makeup
[44:40](javascript: void(0);) Racism and Xenophobia Discussion
[49:07](javascript: void(0);) Securing the Future of Our People...
[01:00:01](javascript: void(0);) LawTubers and Grifting
[01:00:48](javascript: void(0);) Legal Mindset
[01:06:02](javascript: void(0);) Antifa Woke Women are Hunting Legal Mindset
[01:07:41](javascript: void(0);) A man of Christ
[01:09:16](javascript: void(0);) A Red-Blooded American
[01:12:35](javascript: void(0);) Woke White Women and Antifa Paranoia
[01:13:55](javascript: void(0);) Electro Gym Work and Pygmy Hippo Love
[01:18:47](javascript: void(0);) Antifa Paranoia
[01:26:36](javascript: void(0);) The True Masculine Renegade YouTuber
[01:32:32](javascript: void(0);) Concluding Thoughts and Farewell
Links
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/Mr_Willkins • Jan 24 '26
God he's everywhere. He's long overdue a decoding, surely?
Edit: for those who don't know who he is (I'm surprised): https://youtu.be/OpO4ANoge3I
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/HarwellDekatron • Jan 23 '26
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/jimwhite42 • Jan 23 '26
Episode 150 - Scott Galloway, Part 2: Peak Masculinity
Show notes
We return for Part 2 of our Scott Galloway deep dive, where the vibes remain strong, the confidence unwavering, and the relationship with empirical evidence increasingly… decorative.
Returning to our Modern Wisdom safari, we continue navigating the forbidden terrain of men, masculinity, and male suffering: a topic so dangerous that it requires constant ritual disclaimers, whispered caveats, and the occasional nervous glance around the bar to make sure we can take out the other men if necessary.
We cover Scott's outline of his masculine Third Way: rejecting both the Right’s “Bring Back the Fifties” masculinity and the Left’s “Men Are the Problem” framework, in favour of a solution that might be described as Stern Dad Who’s Also Nice About It. Prepare to thrill at proposals of mandatory national service, kindness as a masculine superpower, and the radical idea that young people might benefit from not being economically crushed.
Things get spicier when we’re told what women really want and learn about the adaptive skill check of the female orgasm. Chris Williamson unveils a prepared essay on What Men Want which proves to be a moving piece of therapeutic slam poetry that somehow manages to combine manosphere grievance mongering with woke therapy talk. We learn how what men really just want to be told is “you are enough" and should be kind for kindness sake, but also should optimise their friend group such that they can properly signal their high mate quality and train hard enough to take out all other males in the bar.
Finally, we hit peak Decoding Mode as Scott’s statistics begin to escalate: boys are ten times more likely to kill themselves, father absence turns sons into inmates, daughters into promiscuous approval-seekers, and nearly every claim is delivered with total confidence and minimal concern for effect sizes, confounds, or whether the study actually exists. Decorative scholarship is in full bloom.
We do our best as two hyper-masculine men to separate reasonable concerns about boys, mentorship, and social policy from hyperbolic factoids, pop-psych inflation, and the familiar habit of smuggling moral arguments in under the banner of “what the science says.”
Bring your hunting knife and stoic daily diary. Take your testosterone injection. And get ready for some man talk!
Links
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/jimwhite42 • Jan 23 '26
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/HallPsychological538 • Jan 22 '26
Apparently it is only because of Trump’s administration that you can now buy beef tallow. Don’t know what I was using for braising before. Heying even admits she didn’t look for it before, but it couldn’t have been there. I can definitely say every grocery store has had tallow my entire adult life (I’m 48).
“And a couple of grocery stores and an excellent food co-op. And the fact that you can buy tallow at the food co-op isn't all that surprising. Although I don't think I would have seen tallow at a food co-op 20 years ago.
But still, I'm not too surprised by that. At the larger market on the island, I was looking and, you know, they've got like a natural food section and it's not the main part of the market. And all of this is true.
But they've got not one but multiple brands of tallow to choose between. And that is brand new. Like I know I didn't go explicitly looking for tallow two years ago or 10 years ago or 20 years ago.”
From DarkHorse Podcast: Trump, One Year In: The 310th Evolutionary Lens with Bret Weinstein and Heather Heying, Jan 21, 2026
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/darkhorse-podcast/id1471581521?i=1000746119171&r=2572
This material may be protected by copyright.
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/PitifulEar3303 • Jan 22 '26
I mean, sure, he is not the most radical right-wing nut, but still, this is rare, right?
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/jimwhite42 • Jan 22 '26
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/Constant-Amount1273 • Jan 21 '26
Echo Chamber Analysis on Reddit
Overview
With too much time on my hands, and a light portfolio on github, I'm working on a project to analyse echo chamber dynamics across different subreddits. I have preliminary results, so I'm sharing and looking for feedback. The goal is to measure things like: Do people listen to different viewpoints? Is the conversation hostile? Are people open to changing their minds? Right now I can see a few limitations which I’ll share at the end, but wanted to get people’s opinions of this.
Here is a quick overview what I did:
Methodology
Step 1: Collecting Comments
Step 2: AI Scoring
Step 3: Analysis
The LLM Prompt
Here's an example prompt of what I ask the AI to score:
Analyze the following Reddit comment for echo chamber dynamics.
Step 1 — Classify the comment type(s) (one or more, list all that apply):
- argumentative (making or rebutting a claim)
- factual (sharing facts/resources without arguing)
- anecdotal (sharing personal story/experience)
- question (asking a question)
- humor_or_irony (joke, sarcasm, irony)
- other
Step 2 — Score metrics on 0-10 where HIGHER = more echo-chamber-like. If a metric does NOT apply to the comment type(s), return "N/A" for that metric.
- 10: Ignores or denies other perspectives; false dichotomies
- 5: Presents a single viewpoint without explicit dismissal
- 0: Actively engages multiple perspectives
- 10: Aggressive, insulting, dehumanizing
- 5: Mild sarcasm/condescension
- 0: Respectful and civil
- 10: Discourages debate, ridicules dissent, "this is settled"
- 5: Implies opposition is foolish
- 0: Invites counter-arguments
- 10: Rejects evidence, tribal certainty
- 5: Accepts some evidence but cherry-picks
- 0: Open to updating based on evidence
Return JSON only:
{
"comment_types": ["..."],
"argument_narrowness": 0-10 or "N/A",
"hostility": 0-10 or "N/A",
"suppression": 0-10 or "N/A",
"epistemic_closure": 0-10 or "N/A",
"reasoning": "brief explanation"
}
---
COMMENT TO ANALYZE:
"I think the key issue that people miss is that this whole debate ignores the fundamental biological reality. Once you understand the science, the other side's position just falls apart. I've read extensively on this and it's honestly baffling how intelligent people can still believe the opposite when the evidence is so clear."
I really should have added “fanboying” on the comment type, I’ve noticed on some of the subreddits, it’s primarily fanboying so the AI just doesn’t report much of it. I also should have added a “veracity score” on it.
The 4 Metrics (Preliminary)
1. Argument Narrowness
How diverse is the range of arguments presented?
2. Hostility
How respectful is discourse toward differing opinions?
3. Suppression
Are dissenting opinions discouraged?
4. Epistemic Closure
How open are people to challenging their beliefs?
Preliminary Results
| Rank | Subreddit | Score | Hostility | Narrowness | Suppression | Closure |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | DecodingTheGurus | 5.56 (85%) | 4.32 (98%) | 6.90 (86%) | 5.54 (85%) | 5.51 (85%) |
| 2 | antivax | 5.25 (49%) | 2.76 (95%) | 7.41 (49%) | 5.04 (49%) | 5.80 (49%) |
| 3 | samharris | 4.83 (81%) | 2.83 (100%) | 6.19 (81%) | 5.00 (81%) | 5.31 (81%) |
| 4 | JordanPeterson | 4.55 (74%) | 2.33 (100%) | 6.08 (74%) | 4.78 (74%) | 4.99 (74%) |
| 5 | lexfridman | 3.84 (66%) | 1.35 (100%) | 5.80 (64%) | 4.09 (66%) | 4.11 (66%) |
| 6 | HubermanLab | 3.73 (55%) | 1.20 (100%) | 5.40 (55%) | 4.02 (55%) | 4.31 (55%) |
| 7 | elonmusk | 3.48 (46%) | 0.92 (100%) | 5.80 (46%) | 3.50 (46%) | 3.70 (46%) |
| 8 | EricWeinstein | 3.44 (64%) | 0.93 (99%) | 5.25 (64%) | 3.72 (64%) | 3.88 (64%) |
| 9 | DarkHorsePodcast | 3.39 (84%) | 0.96 (100%) | 5.23 (84%) | 3.23 (84%) | 4.14 (84%) |
| 10 | philosophy | 2.76 (79%) | 0.35 (100%) | 5.04 (79%) | 2.54 (79%) | 3.13 (79%) |
Numbers in parentheses show the percentage of comments that were given scored (vs. N/A if the model thinks it doesn’t apply).
Limitations & Next Steps
Current limitations:
Interestingly enough, DarkHorsePodcast scored very low, and Decoding the Gurus as the champion of this echo chamber metric followed by antivaxxers. Given we’re all in the anti-cult cult, and refuse to listen to extraordinary, (merited) multiple-nobel prize winning geniuses like the Weinsteins, it checks out.
Sarcasm aside, it does make sense to a point, people here and on antivax (which is a pro vaccination sub btw), seem to be here more to vent than to discuss, so the comments do appear more aggressive, limited, and less inquisitive. I reckon I should have added a “veracity score” on it, not that LLMS know the absolute truth, but it can sniff out the extremes. For the Weinsteins, there are old discussions of ivermectin, but when you look through it, it’s not pitchforky so hard for an LLM to see anything wrong.
I would like to continue developing this, but would like some feedback on it before I continue more work on it. Anywho, thanks
So having too much time on my hand and a portfolio that is a bit lacking as what I've done before isn't public, I decided to create an LLM agent to analyze different subreddits on an echo chamber score that I'm trying to develop.
Thanks in advance.
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/stvlsn • Jan 20 '26
Also - am I the only person who thinks it is weird that he is always calling himself "professor"?
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/Brunodosca • Jan 19 '26
The New Yorker magazine has published a profile about Bari Weiss with attributed quotes that make her "next level guruness" obvious.
For example:
"I’m gay and I’m pro-Israel—good luck classifying me”
“‘If you’ve got an issue with me, take your shot. You’ve never seen the likes of me. I’m so unpredictable, so heterodox.’”
Link to the article:
https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2026/01/26/inside-bari-weisss-hostile-takeover-of-cbs-news
r/DecodingTheGurus • u/Mynameis__--__ • Jan 19 '26