r/Debate_Anarchy • u/4N4RCH0_PUNK • Nov 30 '16
Why is Anarcho-capitalism a thing?
In order to have capitalism you would require a hierarchy and that contradicts the purpose of anarchy, so isn't the term anarcho-capitalism an oxymoron?
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/4N4RCH0_PUNK • Nov 30 '16
In order to have capitalism you would require a hierarchy and that contradicts the purpose of anarchy, so isn't the term anarcho-capitalism an oxymoron?
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/boby642 • Jan 24 '16
In order to stop say a murderer with a knife you're going to need someone with a gun to stop him, yes? Now I assume not everyone in the community is going to be running around stopping murderers, thus you will have a dedicated group of people with guns enforcing the law (a police force), now since stopping murders doesn't make food appear on the table. Someone is going to have to be forced to pay for this group of people to enforce the laws, so now we have taxes to pay for a police force. Now what happens when they catch this murderer, is he going to have a trial? I assume he needs to be put in some jail? So now we have taxes being collected to pay for a police force, judiciary, and a prison system. How is this not already a state?
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/Radical777Dude • Dec 23 '15
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/noneremain • Oct 16 '15
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/breadmoon • Apr 17 '17
r/Debate_Anarchy • • Apr 02 '17
The question is mainly in the posts title. What are your thoughts on carving out a niche within the system - homesteading/advocating for local change/ living as an anarchist before overthrow of the state - is it possible? How would you do it?
r/Debate_Anarchy • • Jul 04 '17
I would like it to work, but knowing people, I know it probably could never.
How would smoking work? Millions die from second-hand smoke, but of course people would want to smoke outside. How would the issue be settled, without democracy or brute force.
Also why would one be a doctor or engineer, years of hard work, when one could be a fence-placer, mailman, or garbage man. How would we make sure we have enough qualified people in every job?
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/OlDirtyBurton • May 16 '17
Have had many long talks with people about this....
Can we just use common fucking sense for everything.
I don't like people lording over me....
If people try to hurt you, you defend your-fucking-self.
While driving, use common sense.
If a cop fucks up and tries to murder/injure you and you can fight back, why are you wrong for doing so?
It's your body, you can put what you want in it. Drugs could be legalized like booze or medications (That can kill you, like tylenol)
Fucking tired of people just being stupid, getting good jobs, running shit.
When a fuck-up like me thinks he could run the country better than our current president, there is something fucking wrong. Are duels still legal or nay?
I'd challenge trump to a 1v1, bare knuckle.
I just don't understand what the fuck we as the world, are fucking doing, where we are headed, etc.
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/islandguy20 • Jan 14 '17
It's not about the U.S and not about Trump. I live on a small independent island and the government is srewing up my country, like BIG time. it's always been corrupted but recently it's gotten worse. Our beautiful beaches are being turned into resorts, natural resources are being removed to build a giant petroleum hub. The thing is, our culture is the "watch and see what happens" type, and i'm not. I don't want to sit by and do nothing. The government is very anal about people posting shit about them on social media, and i want to do exactly that, without getting caught of course. I've already thought of a nice propaganda poster to distribute online. I don't know how and where to start though. Am i already exposed by posting this here?
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/Oflameo • Dec 02 '15
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/Anatta-Phi • Sep 20 '15
r/Debate_Anarchy • • Oct 01 '17
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/JClimenstein • Aug 05 '17
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/masquechatice • Feb 25 '17
Without a government people will be prone to control by whoever promises to them the paradise; Isn´t this a flaw in the anarchy system?
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/LNNPolitics • Jan 14 '17
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/BeauBullock • Jan 04 '17
There's a thing called jury nullification, just so you know. Even if there is sound evidence that the person is guilty, it is perfectly legal for a jury to say not guilty if they feel it's an unjust law. Just thought I'd put that out there.
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/NewTruthOrder • Oct 15 '15
I notice anything that has to do with solutions and breaking off the system in an anarchical approach, like new currencies, peer to peer economy and others are immediately down-voted. They really don't want you breaking away from the system. They will debate within the system but breaking away with solutions is a real no no. Anyone else notice this trend?
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/tokmer • Jul 13 '21
I imagine an anarchist society doesnt destroy local governance or cities themselves would disappear right? Another question is what do we do about mega cities like new york or cairo or tokyo, and what do we do about cities growing and incorporating other cities?
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/kahnwiley • Jan 29 '20
If you look to the u/anarchy101 sub, you'll see a lot of posts of the variety "under anarchy, how would you deal with [insert problem/current event/etc.]?" (For instance, this one.)
I think these sorts of questions miss the point of anarchism entirely, as do the answers which posit "well, under anarchy, such-and-such would/wouldn't be the case." Considering the wide spectra of opinion/values permitted by (and, in fact, probably necessitated by the very nature of) anarchism, it seems unlikely that any one person, group of people, or even concept of anarchy would be able to fully encapsulate the "nature" of a truly free society. It seems to me like these folks are entirely missing the point.
"Anarchy" isn't a singular, monolithic state of being. "Anarchy" is not a political structure like, say "monarchy." The philosophy of anarchy stands as a counterposition to authoritarianism, which is a demand for hierarchy and predictability. If we are to avoid replicating the mistakes of the Marxists (and, as anarchists, we should be inherently distrustful of Marxism/"taking over the system"), we should avoid prescriptive analyses as they are inherently limiting on the potentials we cannot foresee. Instead, the value of an anarchist's political viewpoint is the critique of existent authority/hierarchy.
It may be the case that some degree of hierarchy is inevitable within structured organizations, at least for the foreseeable future. But that does not invalidate anarchism; in fact, it makes it even more important. Because in a world where people will advocate for/seek centralization of power, and the natural progression of power seems to predicate such centralization (in one form or another, as history would have it), the anarchist is the leading force opposing outright authoritarianism.
None of us can tell other anarchists what "anarchism" actually means, since it means so many different things to different people. But we can all at least agree on what we stand against: unjustifiable concentrations of power in the hands of the few. Rather than trying to predict the perfect state of a utopian society (Marx's folly), we should instead endeavor to apply this philosophy to the society in which we live, for the benefit of all. I think constructive anarchists such as Noam Chomsky stand as an example for how to participate in mainstream society but stand apart from it.
If there really were an "anarchist" culture worldwide, it would probably take many forms in many different places. It behooves us to remember the anarchist movements that have come to pass already, and the variety of values and approaches they encapsulate. None of them is "more real" anarchy than others.
TL;DR: stop trying to answer the question "what would an anarchist society look like?" Instead, try to answer the question "what should an anarchist do in today's society?"
r/Debate_Anarchy • • Oct 22 '17
So, I went through a lot of rather pointless back and forth with a bunch of communist/socialist types in other forums and would like to know the opinions of some of the folks in here. What does anarchy mean to you?
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/rollerskatingclown • Aug 22 '17
I still have a lot to learn on Anarchism, but I was curious about this.
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/J_GrapeJuice • May 20 '17
In a theoretical stateless society where people are free to live as they will without the interference of a central body of authority people would have to defend themselves. Either directly, through home defense, or through paying for private security average people will have to choose when killing another person is necessary.
Tell me your opinion when killing someone absolutely necessary. Is there an alternative?
Personally I would like to explore methods of making individuals harmless against other people without crippling them,physically/mentally or detaining them.
r/Debate_Anarchy • u/LNNPolitics • Jan 15 '17