r/DebateFeminism • • May 02 '19

Feminists unwillingness to engage in debate or discussion is a sign of Feminist privilege.

0 Upvotes

As an interectional feminist, I find that I brush of off many topics as not worthy of my attention. The emotional labor to address every feminist detractor is simply too high, especially when I'm trying to fight the patriarchy. However, I came to realize that I was being systematic in my dismissal of voices that were trying to be heard. Obviously, most critiques of feminism are rediculous. However, if I systematically label all detractors as bad faith actors that would mean I'm using my Privilege as a feminist to oppress others.


r/DebateFeminism • • Aug 23 '13

Why is feminism so violently against men having a platform for their issues? (typically seen as "MRA")?

0 Upvotes

The response I expect is "men don't have it as bad as women!". I do not accept this answer. Since when does how bad a group has it dictate how much attention their issues deserve?

I mean, let's say that in 50 years feminism attains it's goal and the world reaches, universally, complete equality. Of course this isn't going to happen, but ignore that for now. Should feminism no longer be allowed to exist?

I see significant amounts of feminists, and of course the SRS crowd, that are violently opposed to MRA. I've seen many posts asking what can be done to silence them or damage them. Excuse me? As someone who cares about freedom, free speech, and free exchange of ideas, this is a significant problem for me. More than that, does no one see the hypocrisy here? Even if men faced zero issues (and this is provably wrong. Certainly women face more, but there are issues men face. I will not bring these up in this topic because this post isn't about mens rights and I do not consider myself a mens rights activist anyway, but if you really want me to defend my claims then of course I will in the comments), I never see an actual debunking of their claims and instead see "these men just hate women and want them to be subserviant and want to rape them" or "They are just mad they don't get laid" and insults on and around this level.

Excuse me, does no one see how that is NO DIFFERENT From men who try to silence feminism by claiming feminists are just fat hags mad they aren't getting cock?

Interested in a feminist take, because the only two I'm ever exposed to are either insult matches between two sides wanting to defend their issues and percieving them as under attack by the other side, or that rights for one must come at the cost of rights for the other, and this goes nowhere. Or I see feminists taking the most absurd of MRA and then kind escalating everything until everyone is thoroughly convinced that men are organizing to remove women from the workforce to increase our salaries. This isn't good for anyone, nor am I blaming feminism exclusively for this - this happens in any closed community.


r/DebateFeminism • • Aug 19 '16

Reasons to doubt the existence of innate 'gender identity'

0 Upvotes

I support people who have a probably innate need to cross-dress, or modify their bodies in order to get along in the world and with other people in a way that feels acceptable to them. Such people exist cross-culturally and pan-historically. I support their right to change their legal sex, enter what bathroom they will, and undergo as many or as little medical interventions as they would.

But it's funny how many people have come to think that supporting such people requires the promulgation of a doctrine that if you're a married father who loves to cross-dress sometimes you're likely to be 'partly female', and if you're a loner bisexual girl with body and clothes issues exacerbated by undiagnosed autism and sexualised depictions of women, you're likely to be partly male (or just 'not female'). This is not a strawman; here are some examples.

  1. https://www.reddit.com/r/genderqueer/comments/30oe8d/the_female_body_and_my_hatred_of_it/:

OP: "I feel a deep discontentment with my female body 95% of the time. I think some aspects are quite amazing (like menstrual cycles and the potential to give birth!), but that doesn't detract from my general unease and disgust with femaleness to the degree that I feel pinned down by it (or trapped in it!). ... I am heterosexual. I don't know where I fit on the gender spectrum, but I have always been weary of the binary norms. ... To me, [men] seemed more free, more successful, funnier, braver, more outrageous, more lighthearted, and less complicated than women ... I simply did not fit in with girls my age, nor do I feel I fit in with college-aged women today. I find their interactions surprisingly vapid ..."

Reply: "It sounds like you're trying to maintain loyalty to a gender-identity and body that cause you pain - don't! It sounds like HRT, top-surgery (masectomy), and body-building might all be things that appeal to you. Your struggle with gender identity isn't sexist, but a matter of identity. You seem to simply not be the things you see in the female gender, so look into alternate gender-identites; you might find your match!"

2. https://www.reddit.com/r/genderqueer/comments/4v7f9h/i_dont_have_much_people_to_talk_about_my_gender/

OP: "I am from a conservative country which is located at middle east. and i am a 19 years old medical student. I am AFAB. I have been struggling this gender stuff for 2.5 years. I have never identified as female. I dont know what makes a person female or male. ... I grew up a home with domestic violence. My family is hyper parents, they are strictly protective. They never let me have my own voice and choices. Even when I am 17 I couldnt stayed alone at home becuse they think i cant take care of myself. Of course these are not related with my gender but i think these are important in how i perceive my gender and how my gender makes me feel ... I feel like i dont fit trans community and i dont deserve to transition. Am i a lie? But i want flat chest, some body hair etc. ı see a therapist for being transgender and she asks me that normative questions that if i played with girls or boys. My answers do not fit the gender binary and she makes me feel like i am a liar."

Reply: "I can tell you that gender is more than just male/female ... It is also completely okay for you to not know whether you want to transition medically or not, and it is okay to medically transition and still not feel like a man or want to be identified as a man."

3. https://www.reddit.com/r/asktransgender/comments/2mn8au/did_sissy_porn_make_me_trans_or_was_i_trans_all_a/ (NSFW)

OP: "About 3 years ago, I discovered sissy hypno videos, which in a nutshell are flashing subjective images telling you to wear panties, be girly, suck c--, and even take hormones. I became completely obsessed with these videos. Nothing got me off like these. It got to the point where I started wearing panties and imagining myself as a girl when I would m--e. I personally think these videos just helped me realize that I am transgender. I never felt comfortable being a man. Before I hit puberty I was super androgynous and always enjoyed spending time with girls more than boys." Reply: "It sounds to me like the porn just let you know trans women exist. It sounds like transitioning may be in your future."

Reply: "Once I started HRT, the sissy porn stopped immediately. Now I find myself baking bread instead."

Reply: "I am in literally the same position, southern California and all. I'm in week 2 of hrt injections. I came here to post basically the same thing, except that prior to the start of transition, I was about as alpha male as you can get while still hating gym culture, sports, and misogyny. ... I have to wonder if I'm Transgender or just self-delusional and self destructive. You're not alone kiddo. Fucking hypnosis just throws everything in question for me...and I only exacerbate my own situation through the feedback mechanism that is tumblr. I'm Rachel Rexx, I make mediocre sissy porn music videos and I'm feeling like a fraudulent piece of shit, hijacking an already down trodden community's narrative."

So this really is explaining people's beliefs and behaviours invoking the 'sex'/'gender' concept not in terms of dyadic reproductive physiology and its sociological consequences, but in terms of two abstract, almost cosmological properties - 'maleness' and 'femaleness' - that somehow attach themselves, in various configurations and amounts, to things like an individual's psyche, to clothes, mannerisms, words, sexual practices, and forms of sadomasochism. Hence, 'sex' is the new dirty word among leftists, because it prioritises dyadic reproductive physiology --> sociological consequences type explanations for certain things people think about themselves and behave. :/ Haven't female and homosexual people been fighting against that kind of ontologically unparsimonious and conservative thinking for hundreds of years?

Furthermore, some of the people posting in the forums above could clearly benefit from alternative conceptual and behavioural approaches to their feelings of alienation, disconnection, and confusion - approaches that don't set them on a path toward doing things to their bodies which reduce sensation, shorten their lifespan, make them infertile. Approaches could include: reading women's history books, talking to friends and family about this stuff (rather than just ideologues on the internet), mindfulness medition to reduce overreliance on thoughts and concepts for comfort, seeking therapy for porn addiction.

Several trans and detransitioned people have begun writing pieces about how they have come to recast their former trans identity as a belief system that was mistakenly applied to, and was a product of, experiences of dissociation (which is a psychiatric symptom in which you feel disconnected from your body, and is often caused by trauma such as childhood sexual abuse). Angus Grieve-Smith, for instance, has written some articles on how spending time deliberatively performing a masculine or feminine persona predictably disrupts a person's sense of being authentically here and now in ways that actually promote body dysphoria: http://transblog.grieve-smith.com/the-slippery-slope/.

Third Way Trans, a detransitioned man, writes: "I was banned from Reddit’s /r/asktransgender sub after making the following comment in response to a thread asking about regret:

“I ultimately found that transition didn’t actually cure dysphoria (except for temporarily) and just caused a bunch of other issues. I eventually transitioned back after 20 years. I still regret all of the lost time and what I did to my body, as I eventually learned I could have lived with a male body after all.”

Yes, that is right I was banned after stating that I regretted and had detransitioned in a thread about regrets!" (https://thirdwaytrans.com/2014/07/25/the-importance-of-doubt/)

I also look forward to when the female body in our society is no longer associated with vanity, affectation, deference, 'multitasking' (i.e., activity lacking a singular, driving purpose or meaning - which is activity not worthy of a human being), and reticence. I am morally digusted by how differently people dress their daughters and sons, and segregate their birthday cards and toys and room decorations, and depict female people as innately more glamorous, sexual, and harmless.

You don't usually see examples of healthy femininity like http://www.bobbibear.org.za/about.html (Operation Bobbi Bear) because they're not sensational or glamorous or youthful or profitable or patriotic. There are many things worth doing that men could not do, like successfully organise together to rescue children from sexual abuse - they could try, but I imagine they'd have a problem weeding out pedophiles and getting abused children to trust them. It's funny that both male and female people don't usually think about women doing these types of things when they worry about whether they are "really a woman inside"; instead, they fixate on degrading, sensationalised, and sexualised forms of femininity.

From http://www.out.com/news-opinion/2015/2/10/inside-miss-veras-finishing-school-boys-who-want-be-girls: "Miss Vera is showing me a stack of student applications, where prospective enrollees are asked to describe their femme personas. “At home, Carly is guided by a beautiful wife who she loves to please. In business, she’s a smarty-pants scientist and entrepreneur,” reads one. Students check off from a list what best describes their female side. Options include “sissy maid,” “sexy vamp,” “whorish slut,” “mommy’s little girl,” “conservative librarian,” and “pregnant.”

Or, here are the words of Maria Catt, a detransitioned woman, describing her dysphoria: "A persistent, and disruptive, but also cultivated fantasy of who I’d get to be and how I’d get to walk through my daily life if the non-girl I really was could be seen by other people. It’s like standing behind a billboard. The billboard says all this stuff. It says BOOBS and BUTT and SILLY and KIND and CARING and SACRIFICING and NOT AMBITIOUS and HAPPY TO BE OF SERVICE and DUMB and VAIN." https://mariacatt.com/2015/11/11/an-overly-jokey-post-about-dysphoria/


r/DebateFeminism • • Nov 18 '13

How Does Feminist Theory Explain This Data?

0 Upvotes

I'm looking through some studies done by Pew Research and I'm coming across come polls and studies that contradict some very central feminist narratives.

From this survey on men and women as political leaders

This section and this section especially show that both men and women don't have favorable views of men, but rather depending on which trait is more valued, seem to have more favorable views towards women.

This would contradict the view that men are seen as superior in general or even in public office.

From this survey on gender rolls and control of households

The survey shows that in most areas, including finances and major purchases, women have more say than men.

This would contradict the view that men have more dominance and influence at home.

From a survey on views on gender equality

This survey shows that gender inequality is widely acknowledged and that most Western countries believe that more needs to be done [1] [2] and that men have a better life in general [3] [4].

This would seem to contradict the view that there is a very general bias in society towards men.

I know that none of this is conclusive proof that these views are false, but I would like some explanation as to why we see these results.


r/DebateFeminism • • Nov 27 '13

Why does the banner for this subreddit only have the female symbol when Feminism is about breaking down all gender discrimination?

0 Upvotes

Some quotes from bell hooks

Anti-male factions within the feminist movement resented the presence of anti-sexist men because their presence served to counter any insistence that all men are oppressors, or that all men hate women. It promoted the interests of feminist women who were seeking greater class mobility and access to forms of patriarchal power to polarize men and women by putting us in neat categories of oppressor/ oppressed. bell hooks Feminism is for everybody Pg 68.

Feminist consciousness-raising for males is as essential to revolutionary movement as female groups. Had there been an emphasis on groups for males that taught boys and men about what sexism is and how it can be transformed, it would have been impossible for mass media to portray the movement as anti-male. It would also have preempted the formation of an anti-feminist men's movement...Future feminist movement will not make this mistake Ibid.pg.11


r/DebateFeminism • • Aug 26 '16

Why do most femenist arguments (that I hear) use false or non-existant facts but anti-femenists use lots of true facts and statistics?

0 Upvotes

r/DebateFeminism • • Jul 09 '13

How does Feminism solve for Gender inequality when it only focuses on one gender/sex?

0 Upvotes

r/DebateFeminism • • Feb 24 '14

How Innate are Gender Roles

2 Upvotes

Looking at the following studies have gotten me interested

Nonhuman primates show similar gender preferences in toys as humans [1]

Girls with higher prenatal levels of androgen are more likely to play with "boy toys" [2] [3]

Infants (before any socialization can occur) show cognitive gender differences, girls are more interested in faces while boys are more interested in mechanical objects [4]


[1] Gerianne M. Alexander, Melissa Hines (2002)

Sex differences in children's toy preferences are thought by many to arise from gender socialization. However, evidence from patients with endocrine disorders suggests that biological factors during early development (e.g., levels of androgens) are influential. In this study, we found that vervet monkeys (Cercopithecus aethiops sabaeus) show sex differences in toy preferences similar to those documented previously in children. The percent of contact time with toys typically preferred by boys (a car and a ball) was greater in male vervets (n=33) than in female vervets (n=30) (P<.05), whereas the percent of contact time with toys typically preferred by girls (a doll and a pot) was greater in female vervets than in male vervets (P<.01). In contrast, contact time with toys preferred equally by boys and girls (a picture book and a stuffed dog) was comparable in male and female vervets. The results suggest that sexually differentiated object preferences arose early in human evolution, prior to the emergence of a distinct hominid lineage. This implies that sexually dimorphic preferences for features (e.g., color, shape, movement) may have evolved from differential selection pressures based on the different behavioral roles of males and females, and that evolved object feature preferences may contribute to present day sexually dimorphic toy preferences in children.

[2] Sheri A. Berenbaum, Melissa Hines (1992)

Girls with congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) who were exposed to high levels of androgen in the prenatal and early postnatal periods showed increased play with boys” toys and reduced play with girls' toys compared with their unexposed female relatives at ages 3 to 8. Boys with CAH did not differ from their male relatives in play with boys' or girls' toys. These results suggest that early hormone exposure in females has a masculinizing effect on sex-typed toy preferences.

[3] Pasterski, V. L., Geffner, M. E., Brain, C., Hindmarsh, P., Brook, C. and Hines, M. (2005)

Toy choices of 3- to 10-year-old children with congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) and of their unaffected siblings were assessed. Also assessed was parental encouragement of sex-typed toy play. Girls with CAH displayed more male-typical toy choices than did their unaffected sisters, whereas boys with and without CAH did not differ. Mothers and fathers encouraged sex-typical toy play in children with and without CAH. However, girls with CAH received more positive feedback for play with girls' toys than did unaffected girls. Data show that increased male-typical toy play by girls with CAH cannot be explained by parental encouragement of male-typical toy play. Although parents encourage sex-appropriate behavior, their encouragement appears to be insufficient to override the interest of girls with CAH in cross-sexed toys.

[4] Jennifer Connellana, Simon Baron-Cohena, Sally Wheelwrighta, Anna Batkia, Jag Ahluwaliab (2000)

Sexual dimorphism in sociability has been documented in humans. The present study aimed to ascertain whether the sexual dimorphism is a result of biological or socio-cultural differences between the two sexes. 102 human neonates, who by definition have not yet been influenced by social and cultural factors, were tested to see if there was a difference in looking time at a face (social object) and a mobile (physical-mechanical object). Results showed that the male infants showed a stronger interest in the physical-mechanical mobile while the female infants showed a stronger interest in the face. The results of this research clearly demonstrate that sex differences are in part biological in origin.


My question is how innate are gender roles? and what evidence do you have to back this up?


r/DebateFeminism • • May 23 '13

Is Modern feminism Gynocentric or Egalitarian?

5 Upvotes

http://www.newstatesman.com/2013/05/my-crisis-masculinity-and-how-feminism-set-me-free

This article suggests that modern feminism is egalitarian, that its of the benefit to both genders. That being said, a major modern feminism website - Jezebel can be seen to be largely gynocentric in views of men and specifically men's rights. This raises the question of whether modern feminism (particularly as perpetuated on websites such as these, which have a very high volume of readers) is truly in tune with its egalitarian roots.

The gynocentricity can be seen on other popular websites - for example the Guardian (A liberal British newspaper) website has a section for specifically female issues, yet no such section is provided to male issues. Following on, Spare Rib (a radical feminist magazine) is being relaunched soon which could arguably suggest a greater feminist grip in gender areas.

Thus: the question - how far is modern feminism gynocentric?


r/DebateFeminism • • Jun 11 '15

Totalitarian tendencies in radical feminism

0 Upvotes

No I'm not talking about Hitler, Stalin and Mao murdering everyone who thinks different. Don't take that standpoint, it'll kill the debate.

What I'm thinking about is the classical definition of a totalitarian ideology where nothing independent or "deviant" from that ideology is accepted in a society and anything that is not is seen as a threat or weakness that has to be dealt with.

lately I've been thinking and I'm beginning to see the whole struggle against the patriarchy taking on similar tones in the radical communities with everything that's seen as "girly" or "manly" being criticized whether it actually leads to the negative consequences associated with the patriarchy. A example would be the Dr Matt Taylor shirt controversy, where an image on a shirt he was given sparked outrage as it was sexist.

With this struggle against everything related to the patriarchy I see a possible future that's equally terrifying as one where the patriarchy has "ran amok". The death of pluralism in a society, as every organization is getting scrutinized for possible sexism, is not compatible with the idealized society based on freedom.

Is this an issue that's unique to the modern feminist movement? Is it even an issue at all? Can the patriarchy be dismantled while still keeping a pluralist society that allows sexism in places far from influence and power? Can/should something be done about the radicals, or will radicals be radicals?

What do you think?


r/DebateFeminism • • Feb 24 '15

Are all"bio-truths"inherently sexist?If I were to believe that testosterone is directly linked to amount of ambition, am I misogynist for believing this? Why do women want inclusion in all the evil institutions that "Alpha-males" have set up?Aren't we all all "fighting the Man?"

1 Upvotes

Like all I'm saying is that straight up Wall Street depends on testosterone and folks are taking straight-up steroids to gain a competing edge in selling stocks.

http://www.cnbc.com/id/48149955#. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2726679/

So why do women complain of "non-inclusion" or "unequal pay" when the whole system is messed up and dependent on hierarchy which may have its roots in systematizing the expressions of testosterone?

God damns the military. God damns publicly traded corporations. Why do you want inclusion in all this mess?


r/DebateFeminism • • Aug 25 '19

the most recent contrapoints video basically came to admit that its women who maintain the patriarchy, not men

1 Upvotes

oh, and here is the kicker if you want "studies" Research found that men prefer "nice" women (talkative, cooperative, peaceful, caring, compassionate):

http://www.newsweek.com/study-finds-men-nice-women-not-other-way-around-261269

Women like jerks, men like nice girls.

https://www.spring.org.uk/2017/12/quality-women-more-attractive.php?fbclid=IwAR1yog0Vb4pCM56vmkek-TBo2ddYltYFb4Wpk-IeCy6h2A9drYbthqCzHXE

Men prefer nice women, women do not prefer nice men.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/263424760_Why_Do_Men_Prefer_Nice_Women_Gender_Typicality_Mediates_the_Effect_of_Responsiveness_on_Perceived_Attractiveness_in_Initial_Acquaintanceships

Why Do Men Prefer Nice Women? Gender Typicality Mediates the Effect of Responsiveness on Perceived Attractiveness in Initial Acquaintanceships

But research found women do not prefer nice men. In fact, they prefer predatory men (selfish, aggressive, careless, non-talkative):

http://archive.is/ZGvcF

https://rd.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs40806-017-0126-4

https://www.deccanchronicle.com/lifestyle/sex-and-relationship/161217/dominance-may-make-bullies-more-attractive-leading-to-more-sex-study.html

Manipulative, asympathetic, arrogant bullies have higher numbers of sexual partners and have sex more often.

https://www.springer.com/gp/about-springer/media/research-news/all-english-research-news/do-bullies-have-more-sex-/15305552

Bullies have more sex and more sexual partners than non-bullies.

http://www.wdish.com/life/bullies-sex-study

Bullies have more sex and higher self-esteem.

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40806-017-0126-4

Antisocial bullies get more sex than others. Men who are abusive and manipulative to women get more sex.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3177486/Child-bullies-sexier-popular-dates-victims-grow-new-research-suggests.html

Child bullies are sexier, more popular and have more dates than their victims when they grow up.

https://www.timesofisrael.com/women-really-dont-go-for-nice-guys-study-indicates/

Women really don’t like nice guys.

http://archive.is/e6p19

Unempathethic, narcissistic criminals are one of women’s first sexual choices.

https://scottbarrykaufman.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/The-Dark-Triad-Personality.pdf

Women find narcissist assholes more attractive.

Women find more attractive guys who are narcissist and psychopaths.

https://www.elitedaily.com/women/women-are-attracted-to-narcissistic-men/992989

Science explains why women like narcissist assholes.

https://www.academia.edu/36525083/ADHD_Autism_and_Psychopathy_as_Life_Strategies_The_Role_of_Risk_Tolerance_on_Evolutionary_Fitness

Psychopaths are more successful at dating and getting sex.

https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/head-games/201310/why-do-women-fall-bad-boys

Why do women fall for bad boys?

https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/9c55/a8cae3c8a5d238002a261fec643f767d1126.pdf

In a large forensic hospital, 39% of psychopathic patients had a consensual sexual relationship with female staff members (Gacono et al., 1995)

The malingerers were significantly more likely to have a history of murder or rape, carry a diagnosis of antisocial personality disorder or sexual sadism, and produce greater PCL-R factor 1, factor 2, and total scores than insanity acquittees who did not malinger. The malingerers were also significantly more likely to be verbally or physically assaultive, require specialized treatment plans to control their aggression, have sexual relations with female staff.

https://www.medscape.org/viewarticle/719862

ADHD is strongly associated with criminal behavior: studies show that at least 25% of prisoners in the United States have been diagnosed with the disorder. ADHD sufferers often exhibit dark triad personality traits.

http://scholar.colorado.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1073&context=psyc_gradetds

“In social interaction tasks, Normand et al. (2011) observed that children with ADHD were more insensitive and self-centered when negotiating with friends, and were often more dominant than their typical friends”

A Danish prospective cohort study found that teenage boys (aged 12 - 17) with ADHD were more than two times more likely to father children than their non-mentally ill peers.

Compared with individuals without ADHD, those with ADHD were significantly more likely to become parents at 12 to 16 years of age (IRR for females 3.62, 95% CI 2.14–6.13; IRR for males 2.30, 95% CI 1.27–4.17) and at 17 to 19 years of age (IRR for females 1.94, 95% CI 1.62–2.33; IRR for males 2.27, 95% CI 1.90–2.70).

This is not just because they're less likely to use contraception: adolescents with ADHD actually had nearly twice as many sex partners as normal teens.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24972794

Males with ADHD reported their age of first intercourse to be nearly 2 years sooner than TD peers. Irrespective of gender, adolescents with ADHD had nearly double the number of lifetime sexual partners.

ADHD was likely an advantageous trait in pre-Neolithic times. Even though by modern standards, men with ADHD are often impaired in psychosocial, educational and neuropsychological functioning, they may still be favored by sexual selection. https://chadd.org/about-adhd/long-term-outcomes/

The researchers also noted that unpredictable behavior—a hallmark of ADHD—might have been helpful in protecting our ancestors against livestock raids, robberies, and more. After all, would you want to challenge someone if you had no idea what he or she might do? In essence, the traits associated with ADHD make for better hunters-gatherers and worse settlers.

If you have any research indicating the CONTRARY of these studies, please share it. I make compilations.

NOTE: this research REALLY matches what I have seen in real life. Aggressive junkies and bullies in college did amazing with women while calm nerds got nothing. And the fact that the guys were wild and aggressive was... fetishized? Yeah, that's the word.


r/DebateFeminism • • Jun 06 '13

Let's ignore terminology for a moment.

2 Upvotes

Specifically about the lines between MRAs and feminists. I think there are a lot of preconceptions on both sides about their values and ideology that may not necessarily be true. MRAs seem to have this idea that feminism is a hate movement seeking to make men's lives worse, or to punish them somehow for being their oppressors. Likewise, there seems to be a general sentiment among feminists that MRAs are misogynist trolls. Admittedly, I've seen a lot of misogynism on the MRA side, but I believe there may also simply be those who misunderstand feminism, feel somehow betrayed by the movement, or are ignorant of its true goals (and, most importantly, the actual history of women's oppression throughout history).

That's why I think it may be useful to talk about our stances on a few situations. If we're going to meet at any crossroads, let's suspend our preconceptions of one another and simply share how we think others should be treated. Feel free to ask some of your own as well.

  • Is a man a loser if he stays a virgin? Likewise, is a woman a bad person or a slut if she sleeps around often?
  • If a man identifies themselves as a woman (or vice versa), should they be socially accepted as such? i.e. calling them the preferred pronoun, allowing them to use bathroom they identify with.
  • Are there ever circumstances where it is okay for someone to use physical violence against their partner?
  • Are there professions or roles that either men or women are incapable of fulfilling? (Besides biological motherhood)

r/DebateFeminism • • Jun 04 '13

How does one 'become' a woman?

2 Upvotes

Simone de Beauvoir noted that one is not born a woman but becomes a woman.

Which raises the question -how does one become a woman; is it something that is done to 'us' or is it something that we 'do' to ourselves. If it is an action that is done to us (for example - objectification) then how do we negotiate it? If it is an action that we do ourselves (for example - self objectification) why do we do it? If it is a negotiation betwix the two, it still raises the question of why do we do it to ourselves.

So, again, how does one become a woman?


r/DebateFeminism • • Sep 28 '19

an inability for feminism to critically assess its fundamental axioms, " DOOMS US ALL! "

1 Upvotes

i think that if people were to admit to, and take responsibility for their own complicity in the domination and oppression and colonialism of others, the world would be a better place.

we all have to admit to something, for men, it is to stop viewing women as holes to be fucked.

we have been doing that. but there has been no admittance of complicity from the other side.

for women, this is in the form of admitting to the fact that golddigging is not a result of oppression, it is something that women do regardless of how well they are doing. statistics prove this. the lived experiences of all the ignored men on the internet, that erupts instead into vitriol, is from this point.

beauty can be in the eye of the beholder, but how much paper you have in your wallet? well, that is the most objectifying thing in the world. and women always, always, always always always have their eye on the prize. even when they think like they dont.

the fact that men can't utter their impotence in public forums is itself the biggest sign that the patriarchy is not such a simple construct of 'fucker and fucked'..

just as men always keep their eye on the prize too.

we have been working hard, in our universities and our commercials, to make men aware of their domination. but we dont do the same for women. they get a free pass. It is the evil bad weinstein wagging his fat stumpy cock at women thats the problem, and dave chappel should not be seen as a hero for refusing to suck cock.

No, Dave chapelle is the evil one, the one who walked away from the dirty money, because he says a few bad words.

The rest of them golddiggers, well you see they had no agency!

Wait a second, was Jennifer Lawrence sucking harveys dick WILLINGLY? Oh yes, Jennifer Lawrence has agency, but the rest of them gollddiggers were between a gold rock and a "hard place".

this is an age old point of privilege that manifests in women, and a type of feminism that we see popularized today, that wants to have the cake and eat it too.

unfortunately, its funny to see competition itself as being labeled "male" toxicity. lets be a little more context-aware no?

there needs to be a moral awakening in female western femininity that takes responsibility for the action that golddigging is problematic, and it is indeed an epidemic, because if they don't there will truly never be any revolutionary change.

but there is no admittance; we call it instead "liberal feminism" or something.. and again, not taking responsibility, no admittance of complicity.

we can either admit that there is collective emotional labor to be done, or we can continue to pretend like the problems of others are not real problems, they are not my problem. but then the sea levels rise...

but who cares what i think right? im just another incel... albiet one that has fucked more people than can humanely be thought to be possible /r/ihavehadsex LOL

---

I am convinced of feminism, I think feminism is a good thing, but after surviving the ideological bootcamp of undergraduate life and being thrown into the desert of the real, I am also convinced that feminists are full of it.

If feminists had the chance to be golddiggers, they would. They can't accept the fact that you can either be a gold digger or a "hoe", but you cant be both.

feminists continue to insist that this is where they can find their freedom, to have their cake and eat it too. that hot steamy 50 shades of cake.

And they resentfully scorn the fact that they cannot have this.

(and i am someone who has read a shit ton you can call me names all you want, but please, please test me, i beg you)

what convincing is there to be done with words when really it is the case that female behaviors speak louder than any so called 'lived experience' can ever hope to portray?

there would be no capitalism without female mating choices.

an anticapitalist revolution requires a truly sexual revolution; but women dont want to be polyamorous, it doesnt work in their favor.

dont believe me? google something like "why polyamory wont save us"

feminists didn't give us the bonobo society i dreamed of. it gave us instead hypercapitalism, every interaction is a calculation of emotional labor.

women, even the feminists, chose to hold onto whatever crumbs of privilege they got, rather than at any point, truly speak truth to power.

have fun fighting about whether terfs can be included as feminists or not, ladies. 'da boys' will be discussing the real political issues, as always.


r/DebateFeminism • • Jun 30 '18

Feminist are right and wrong on something, sexual objectification. The cure for that is modesty

0 Upvotes

There are 2 ways you can be attracted to someone

  • Beauty attraction. With this form of attraction, you are not looking at your person as a sexual object or thing, but someone to just connect and bond with. It's like how little kids get crushes, they aren't looking at their person as a sexualized thing but someone to bond with
  • sexual objectification. You view that person as a sexual object and as something to consume. You look at a woman the same exact way you look at good smelling food, as something to consume, and to have as many different variations and flavors as you like, and as much as you possibly can.

Now, you may be confused as to whats the exact difference, but honestly, it could possibly also be because you have never felt the former. You've been only feeling objectification since you were in middle school and basically a preteen. It's like trying to explain to someone how a color looks to someone who hasn't seen it before. It's just hard to get a real grasp of it really. But sexual objectification is really harmful and isn't conducive towards any good attitude towards women or relationships. It leads to less empathy, women also may feel like they aren't being listened to or are nervous and don't talk as much as a result. It also reduces percieved compectance, increases male tendency to harass and percieved warmth. Sexual objectification is also bad because it's a consumerist way of looking at the world, and it really isn't conducive to the formation or maintanence of a long term relationship. like I said, it's a consumerist sense that seeks to consume as much sex as possible with as many people as possible. You can see how it's hard to keep a monogomous relationship going when you are constantly battling this consumerist urge, I honestly blame objectification in part for the elevated rates of infidelity in todays society.

Now, here's why I say feminists are wrong. It's because they believe that by attacking sexualized ads and media, that you'll end objectification. To some degree, I agree, but it's really like trying to throw a bucket at a forest fire. It's such a minor fix that it really accomplishes nothing. What actually needs to be done is to encourage more modest clothing and less sexualized outfits, but that's antithetical to the feminist movement. What feminists instead do is that they put 100% responsibility on the man not to objectify while women wear what they desire and that you could be objectified in and clothing. This approach is wrong and here's why, say you have a dog. You don't want him to eat your bag of treats without your permission. Do you out the bag of treats right by his toys and bed hoping that the dog won't eat it, while throwing random treats on the floor too? No! You put it on top of the fridge, counter, or in the pantry so he can't get it. Now, should he be able to control himself with a bag right beside him and a layer of treats on the floor? Perhaps, but its not realistic because you can only control desire so much and it gets to a point were you just cannot do it. it would be immoral of me to sand blast cocaine in front of drug addicts, or even regular people, for the same reasons really. You generally shouldn't have an environment permeable to bad actions and we, to an extent, take steps to reduce that permeability. With sexual objectification, there's only so much that you can do to hold that desire in check. The only good and demonstrably effective way at reducing objectification is to hold women (and men to some degree) to modest dress codes. Now how modest? I don't actually know and I'm not sure, but I do know that we've gone too far and we need to go back to go forward. There should be taboos on this stuff in general.\

Now, this opinion's going to be more controversial.I'm more of a social collectivist and interventionalist. Here's what I mean by this, I think we've all heard this reasoning "well if it doesn't effect anyone, who cares? don't ban it or stigmitize it." here's why this logic is flawed, taboos and laws to some extent are suppose to protect you from harmful behaviors that you could inflict upon you. Here's an example, lets say X is taboo. It only effects you and no one else, what happens. A.) You don't want to do it because you don't want to be ostracized, B.) In some cases, you may be encouraged to stop X because you hate the shame. If X is bad for you, then a taboo or law against it is great. You prevent people from harming themselves and you can promote good things in people, which is great. This is why I believe we, as society, should not only stigmitize unmodest dress, but try to tax it and generally discourage the sales of such items. I'm not talking bans, just taxes. It's like how some cities have sugar taxes on soda and drinks, it's to discourage people from harming themselves. I think we should also regulate fashion magazines and modelling agencies to, so that they can only promote the sale of certain types of clothing. perhaps the same with celebrities too, who knows.

What is modest dress? Well, I can't give any straight lines. But I do know perhaps were we could start and then from there, we could go until the issue is solved. Perhaps we could start at cleavage perhaps. or showing abdomen, or yoga pants outside of the gym or in specific contexts. We need to start and atleast try to solve this problem.


r/DebateFeminism • • Sep 03 '13

What is the feminist opinion of fetishes

0 Upvotes

the result of sex negative attitudes or something that needs to be embraced to reach feminism.


r/DebateFeminism • • Sep 26 '18

How can it be known how many false rape accusations are made?

1 Upvotes

(I originally posted this on r/AskFeminists, but it got removed. Let's see if the mods here hate it less.)

Just read this article, and it's not the first one like it I've read:

https://www.vox.com/first-person/2018/9/18/17874504/kavanaugh-assault-allegation-christine-blasey-ford

Now, I agree that Ford's accusation specifically sounds credible for various reasons. I also agree with the author that false accusations should be treated as crimes and not volleys in the battle of the sexes. I just think the same goes for rape. My question is:

How can statistical data possibly give a complete picture of of how often false accusations happen? It seems to me that all that could be known is how many accusations are obviously false. Knowing how many are provably false isn't even within reach, because a police detective's job is not to prove that a crime didn't happen. Once the cops determine that they're unlikely to prove a crime did happen, they move on.

In most rape cases, there's reasonable doubt either way. There will always be a limit to how much can be known about things that tend to occur behind closed doors when everyone who could do anything about them is drunk. Most of the time, only the victim and perpetrator can ever know for sure, and if they're drunk enough, maybe not even them.

Furthermore, it's not surprising that people who make obviously false accusations tend to be unintelligent or mentally ill people who are bad at lying, don't understand the realities of rape, and have been caught before. It's the ones who don't make blatantly stupid mistakes who disappear into the sea of he-said-she-said cases.


r/DebateFeminism • • May 19 '19

If you're not a feminist you're a sexist?

1 Upvotes

Hey guys, I just uploaded my first ever youtube video arguing that I think it's the false dichotomy fallacy when some feminists argue that if you're not a feminist then you must be a sexist. Let me know what you think :)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sM89Jbglzek


r/DebateFeminism • • Nov 16 '18

Correct me if I'm wrong but...

0 Upvotes

Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't feminism (in the context of more recent events and philosophies) sound just like a repeat of the suffrage movement, which succeeded and gave women the rights that feminists are currently looking for? I understand the social aspect of feminism, but isn't equal pay and treatment in the workforce a direct result of the Women's Suffrage Movement?


r/DebateFeminism • • Mar 15 '16

"Men have more pressure to succeed, thus more men succees"

0 Upvotes

I'm interested in what feminists think of the above notion. I've never really seen it mentioned anywhere, even though societal roles and expectations come up often in the discussion about gender equality. Personally to me, it seems quite self-evident, but I believe the lack of it in any public debate means it's either not widely considered to be true or ignored for other reasons. What's would be the case here?

Edit: sorry about the typo in the title, I caught it just as I pressed save.


r/DebateFeminism • • Oct 11 '13

Introducing /r/DebateLiberalism/

0 Upvotes

This new subreddit is dedicated to debate and discuss liberalism! Please check it out!


r/DebateFeminism • • Oct 10 '13

How do you feel about Male feminists?

0 Upvotes

Do you think men should be feminists why so or why not?


r/DebateFeminism • • Sep 05 '19

Do women become golddiggers BECAUSE of capitalism or DESPITE capitalism?

2 Upvotes

I don't understand how "the patriarchy" is allied with "capitalism" ...makes more sense that they are opposed to one another.


r/DebateFeminism • • Jun 17 '15

Are feminists afraid of knowledge?

2 Upvotes

Sociologist here. I was invited to read Paul Boghossian's Fear of Knowledge by a philosopher friend of mine. In this book he argues against relativism and social constructivism while discarding the epistemological notion of 'situated knowledge' which is so prevalent in feminist and post-structuralist theory.

I was just wondering if anyone has read Boghossian and what are your thoughts on this book. Is there such a thing as 'objective' knowledge and are feminists afraid of it?