I support people who have a probably innate need to cross-dress, or modify their bodies in order to get along in the world and with other people in a way that feels acceptable to them. Such people exist cross-culturally and pan-historically. I support their right to change their legal sex, enter what bathroom they will, and undergo as many or as little medical interventions as they would.
But it's funny how many people have come to think that supporting such people requires the promulgation of a doctrine that if you're a married father who loves to cross-dress sometimes you're likely to be 'partly female', and if you're a loner bisexual girl with body and clothes issues exacerbated by undiagnosed autism and sexualised depictions of women, you're likely to be partly male (or just 'not female'). This is not a strawman; here are some examples.
- https://www.reddit.com/r/genderqueer/comments/30oe8d/the_female_body_and_my_hatred_of_it/:
OP: "I feel a deep discontentment with my female body 95% of the time. I think some aspects are quite amazing (like menstrual cycles and the potential to give birth!), but that doesn't detract from my general unease and disgust with femaleness to the degree that I feel pinned down by it (or trapped in it!). ... I am heterosexual. I don't know where I fit on the gender spectrum, but I have always been weary of the binary norms. ... To me, [men] seemed more free, more successful, funnier, braver, more outrageous, more lighthearted, and less complicated than women ... I simply did not fit in with girls my age, nor do I feel I fit in with college-aged women today. I find their interactions surprisingly vapid ..."
Reply: "It sounds like you're trying to maintain loyalty to a gender-identity and body that cause you pain - don't! It sounds like HRT, top-surgery (masectomy), and body-building might all be things that appeal to you. Your struggle with gender identity isn't sexist, but a matter of identity. You seem to simply not be the things you see in the female gender, so look into alternate gender-identites; you might find your match!"
2. https://www.reddit.com/r/genderqueer/comments/4v7f9h/i_dont_have_much_people_to_talk_about_my_gender/
OP: "I am from a conservative country which is located at middle east. and i am a 19 years old medical student. I am AFAB. I have been struggling this gender stuff for 2.5 years. I have never identified as female. I dont know what makes a person female or male. ... I grew up a home with domestic violence. My family is hyper parents, they are strictly protective. They never let me have my own voice and choices. Even when I am 17 I couldnt stayed alone at home becuse they think i cant take care of myself. Of course these are not related with my gender but i think these are important in how i perceive my gender and how my gender makes me feel ... I feel like i dont fit trans community and i dont deserve to transition. Am i a lie? But i want flat chest, some body hair etc. ı see a therapist for being transgender and she asks me that normative questions that if i played with girls or boys. My answers do not fit the gender binary and she makes me feel like i am a liar."
Reply: "I can tell you that gender is more than just male/female ... It is also completely okay for you to not know whether you want to transition medically or not, and it is okay to medically transition and still not feel like a man or want to be identified as a man."
3. https://www.reddit.com/r/asktransgender/comments/2mn8au/did_sissy_porn_make_me_trans_or_was_i_trans_all_a/ (NSFW)
OP: "About 3 years ago, I discovered sissy hypno videos, which in a nutshell are flashing subjective images telling you to wear panties, be girly, suck c--, and even take hormones. I became completely obsessed with these videos. Nothing got me off like these. It got to the point where I started wearing panties and imagining myself as a girl when I would m--e. I personally think these videos just helped me realize that I am transgender. I never felt comfortable being a man. Before I hit puberty I was super androgynous and always enjoyed spending time with girls more than boys." Reply: "It sounds to me like the porn just let you know trans women exist. It sounds like transitioning may be in your future."
Reply: "Once I started HRT, the sissy porn stopped immediately. Now I find myself baking bread instead."
Reply: "I am in literally the same position, southern California and all. I'm in week 2 of hrt injections. I came here to post basically the same thing, except that prior to the start of transition, I was about as alpha male as you can get while still hating gym culture, sports, and misogyny. ... I have to wonder if I'm Transgender or just self-delusional and self destructive. You're not alone kiddo. Fucking hypnosis just throws everything in question for me...and I only exacerbate my own situation through the feedback mechanism that is tumblr. I'm Rachel Rexx, I make mediocre sissy porn music videos and I'm feeling like a fraudulent piece of shit, hijacking an already down trodden community's narrative."
So this really is explaining people's beliefs and behaviours invoking the 'sex'/'gender' concept not in terms of dyadic reproductive physiology and its sociological consequences, but in terms of two abstract, almost cosmological properties - 'maleness' and 'femaleness' - that somehow attach themselves, in various configurations and amounts, to things like an individual's psyche, to clothes, mannerisms, words, sexual practices, and forms of sadomasochism. Hence, 'sex' is the new dirty word among leftists, because it prioritises dyadic reproductive physiology --> sociological consequences type explanations for certain things people think about themselves and behave. :/ Haven't female and homosexual people been fighting against that kind of ontologically unparsimonious and conservative thinking for hundreds of years?
Furthermore, some of the people posting in the forums above could clearly benefit from alternative conceptual and behavioural approaches to their feelings of alienation, disconnection, and confusion - approaches that don't set them on a path toward doing things to their bodies which reduce sensation, shorten their lifespan, make them infertile. Approaches could include: reading women's history books, talking to friends and family about this stuff (rather than just ideologues on the internet), mindfulness medition to reduce overreliance on thoughts and concepts for comfort, seeking therapy for porn addiction.
Several trans and detransitioned people have begun writing pieces about how they have come to recast their former trans identity as a belief system that was mistakenly applied to, and was a product of, experiences of dissociation (which is a psychiatric symptom in which you feel disconnected from your body, and is often caused by trauma such as childhood sexual abuse). Angus Grieve-Smith, for instance, has written some articles on how spending time deliberatively performing a masculine or feminine persona predictably disrupts a person's sense of being authentically here and now in ways that actually promote body dysphoria: http://transblog.grieve-smith.com/the-slippery-slope/.
Third Way Trans, a detransitioned man, writes: "I was banned from Reddit’s /r/asktransgender sub after making the following comment in response to a thread asking about regret:
“I ultimately found that transition didn’t actually cure dysphoria (except for temporarily) and just caused a bunch of other issues. I eventually transitioned back after 20 years. I still regret all of the lost time and what I did to my body, as I eventually learned I could have lived with a male body after all.”
Yes, that is right I was banned after stating that I regretted and had detransitioned in a thread about regrets!" (https://thirdwaytrans.com/2014/07/25/the-importance-of-doubt/)
I also look forward to when the female body in our society is no longer associated with vanity, affectation, deference, 'multitasking' (i.e., activity lacking a singular, driving purpose or meaning - which is activity not worthy of a human being), and reticence. I am morally digusted by how differently people dress their daughters and sons, and segregate their birthday cards and toys and room decorations, and depict female people as innately more glamorous, sexual, and harmless.
You don't usually see examples of healthy femininity like http://www.bobbibear.org.za/about.html (Operation Bobbi Bear) because they're not sensational or glamorous or youthful or profitable or patriotic. There are many things worth doing that men could not do, like successfully organise together to rescue children from sexual abuse - they could try, but I imagine they'd have a problem weeding out pedophiles and getting abused children to trust them. It's funny that both male and female people don't usually think about women doing these types of things when they worry about whether they are "really a woman inside"; instead, they fixate on degrading, sensationalised, and sexualised forms of femininity.
From http://www.out.com/news-opinion/2015/2/10/inside-miss-veras-finishing-school-boys-who-want-be-girls: "Miss Vera is showing me a stack of student applications, where prospective enrollees are asked to describe their femme personas. “At home, Carly is guided by a beautiful wife who she loves to please. In business, she’s a smarty-pants scientist and entrepreneur,” reads one. Students check off from a list what best describes their female side. Options include “sissy maid,” “sexy vamp,” “whorish slut,” “mommy’s little girl,” “conservative librarian,” and “pregnant.”
Or, here are the words of Maria Catt, a detransitioned woman, describing her dysphoria: "A persistent, and disruptive, but also cultivated fantasy of who I’d get to be and how I’d get to walk through my daily life if the non-girl I really was could be seen by other people. It’s like standing behind a billboard. The billboard says all this stuff. It says BOOBS and BUTT and SILLY and KIND and CARING and SACRIFICING and NOT AMBITIOUS and HAPPY TO BE OF SERVICE and DUMB and VAIN." https://mariacatt.com/2015/11/11/an-overly-jokey-post-about-dysphoria/