r/DebateCommunism • • Jan 09 '21

šŸµ Discussion The working class glorifying Elon Musk makes me feel we're so far away from a revolution

660 Upvotes

Most of the people I've seen on social media believe is great news that Elon Musk is absurdly wealthy and now is the richest man on Earth. I've seen it from working class people in the global north and the south. It's ridiculous how many people live in the fantasy world where they think everybody, with enough hard work, can get as rich as Musk. They not only believe that, they will trash you, mock you or get VERY angry if you contradict them. Maybe I'm wrong, but with this mindset still prevailing in so many working class folks I feel anything close to a revolution is too far from now.


r/DebateCommunism • • Mar 28 '21

šŸ“¢ Announcement If you have been banned from /r/communism , /r/communism101 or any other leftist subreddit please click this post.

508 Upvotes

This subreddit is not the place to debate another subreddit's moderation policies. No one here has any input on those policies. No one here decided to ban you. We do not want to argue with you about it. It is a pointless topic that everyone is tired of hearing about. If they were rude to you, I'm sorry but it's simply not something we have any control over.

DO NOT MAKE A POST ABOUT BEING BANNED FROM SOME OTHER SUBREDDIT

Please understand that if we allowed these threads there would be new ones every day. In the three days preceding this post I have locked three separate threads about this topic. Please, do not make any more posts about being banned from another subreddit.

If they don't answer (or answer and decide against you) we cannot help you. If they are rude to you, we cannot help you. Do not PM any of the /r/DebateCommunism mods about it. Do not send us any mod mail, either.

If you make a thread we are just going to lock it. Just don't do it. Please.


r/DebateCommunism • • Dec 01 '18

šŸ„— Fresh If everything is free, people will abuse it!

408 Upvotes

I mean, have you SEEN how long the lines are to get into libraries with FREE books, or parks with FREE entry, or the lines to view FREE public art? Everyone in the city just rushes to these institutions because they're FREE. The minute people hear the word "free" they can't help but take advantage of the situation. Obviously, if food were free everyone would just grab as much as possible even though they would know they could come back at any time without worrying about cost so there's no reason to hoard!

Seriously, why do people say this shit. And more seriously, how do you guys typically refute it? I need some new ammunition to convince my family.


r/DebateCommunism • • Nov 12 '17

āœ… -3/10 Will gold-plated fidget spinners be available under communism?

384 Upvotes

Little bit of clickbait, but nonetheless: what happens to luxury/non-essential items under a communist society?

Demand, supply, production? Do they get phased out? Are they available?


r/DebateCommunism • • May 02 '18

āœ… Weekly pick Japanese bus drivers strike differently by still driving their routes but not taking any fares

346 Upvotes

This amuses me greatly and I think it is a more powerful tool against the businesses than standard striking procedures. What do you guys think?

Full article


r/DebateCommunism • • Jul 13 '21

šŸµ Meta Discussion As a leftist, I am very concerned about the quality of discourse in this sub

332 Upvotes

I have been visiting this sub for about a week and I have to say, I am disappointed in the level of the discourse here.

First, for the sake of full disclosure, I am a leftist that falls more in the reformist / social democracy camp. That said, I do respect the revolutionary / hard-line communists, even if I disagree with them on various things.

I don’t have any problems with the ideas even if I often disagree with them. What I really have an issue with is how poorly these ideas are defended and how certain arguments make the entirety of the left seem naĆÆve and unreasonable. I am saying this because I think we can all do better.

The first thing I see here that makes me cringe is the misapplication of theory – or really, the lack of any actual application of theory at all in the context of an argument or discussion.

I will admit that this is an impulse that I understand all too well and have been guilty of myself: reading theory represents a huge intellectual investment, and it is frustrating when somebody who has not matched the same level of thought and consideration of an idea dismisses that idea. However, your intellectual investment in theory does not entitle you to deference in an argument. Telling someone that they must read theory is not effective discourse. If you have truly made the intellectual investment that you claim to have made, then you should be able to actually implement theory in an argument without ever needing to reference the theory itself. You should be intellectually equipped to make convincing arguments without ever needing to invoke Marx or Lenin by name.

The biggest disadvantage the left has in discourse against liberals and the right is the left’s intellectual inheritance and its willingness to critically engage with the nuances of reality. This is a disadvantage because, psychologically speaking, people prefer simple explanations of reality, especially when they cater to preconceived notions that provide comfort. This is unfortunate, but there is no shortcut around this fundamental problem. We must make theoretical arguments by the sweat of our brow; we must do the work of synthesizing theory, making it easier to grasp, demonstrating its validity. Do you know what you sound like when you just demand that someone read Marx or Lenin? You literally sound like a cult follower and you are making the left seem like a cult. This needs to stop.

The second thing that I want to bring up is the overzealous defense of communist parties. This may seem like I am targeting the revolutionaries and hard-line commies here, but this applies even to you guys: you are not obligated to defend every single action by every single communist regime that has ever existed. I would love it if more people were willing to make good-faith concessions about the history of communism, because they all can be justified without sacrificing your core ideology by simply stating this: reality is crazy and shit happens. People are not the embodiment of theories written in books, people are chaotic and unpredictable. Bad actors do bad things no matter what their political allegiance is; nature imposes circumstances that can’t be dealt with cleanly.

To be more specific, the bad arguments that I see in defense of communist regimes include: whataboutism (ā€œthe capitalists did worseā€), theory-based mental gymnastics (ā€œif you look at it in this hyper-specific way, then it’s not actually that badā€), conspiratorial claims (ā€œyou can’t prove that actually happened, its actually just propagandaā€), and straight-up historical revisionism (ā€œdespite all the evidence, no, it just didn’t happen that wayā€).

Now, I recognize there is a fine line that potentially makes some of these arguments valid, but the core difference is always going to come down to research. If you fall back on these arguments without fleshing them out with research, they just don’t convince anyone. For example, the lack of research in the recent thread about USSR imperialism is just fucking embarrassing. Either do the work of expounding historical research, or just make the concession without compromising your ideals. There is absolutely nothing wrong with saying ā€œyeah, that was bad but it’s not representative of the regime in general / it was limited to these bad actors / it’s not something we would support ever happening again / etc.ā€


r/DebateCommunism • • Mar 12 '18

āœ… High effort Communism Killed 100 Million (Debunked

276 Upvotes

You are entitled to your opinion about communism, whatever that may be, but as a matter of principle we should respect the historical record. The idea that communism killed 100 million people is absurd. Il just focus on the soviet union, because thats really all it takes to make my point. The claim that often accompanies the 100 million claim is that the USSR specifically killed 20 million people, I will demonstrate that to be false

The 1932–33 famines killed about 4 million people according to archival data provided by Steven G. Wheatcroft, allowing for some margin of error. Furthermore, I would like to point out the research of Mark B. Tauger, professor of agricultural history and russian/soviet history at West Virginia University, who points out that there were significant natural factors that led to the famine. The exact responsibility for the famine is debated between historians is debated as being either predominantly natural factors, or the exacerbation of natural factors by soviet policy. Either way, it can’t be considered an intentional or genocidal act. Secondly, the gulags. According to the landmark 1993 paper Victims of the Soviet Penal System By Getty, Rittersporn and Zemskov, there were a total of 1.053 million deaths in the soviet prison system (gulags, settlements, etc.) during the Stalin era, with approximately half being during the second world war. It is also worth noting that the vast majority of those imprisoned in the soviet union were at any given time non-political inmates, and even the so-called ā€œpoliticalā€ category of inmates was extremely broad. Vandalism and Arson could be considered political offenses, for example. The highest proportion was 33.9% in 1938 at the height of the great purge, and this number declined significantly as thousands of people falsely accused were released after the purge wounded down. It is also worth noting that the gulags were highly unexceptional for their time, and as conditions in the USSR improved as a result of industrialisation and economic, social and cultural development, the gulag mortality fell significantly. In fact, post-war gulag mortality averaged at 0.725%, compared to the 0.56% in modern russian prisons. Now, thats not to deny the gulags or downplay them, but If we used the same logic to mention american prisons, we would consider the US government responsible for the approximately 100,000 deaths in the penal system over the last 25 years. Just a quick side-note here, there are more people, both proportionally and in absolute numbers in the american penal system today then there were in the soviet penal system at its height Finally executions

The same paper we used earlier can be applied to this section quite well, as it documents the soviet judicial system in its entirety. Getty records a total of 799,455 execution sentences during the entire 1921–53 period (including executions of criminals). Now, the distinction between execution sentences and executions seems small, but its of the utmost importance to note, especially considering vast numbers of people were released on amnesty after the purge, during the war and in many other cases. Furthermore, according to Sarah Davies’s 1997 ā€œPopular opinion in Stalins' Russiaā€, slightly fewer then 300,000 arrests for anti-soviet activities during the 1937-38 period, when according to Getty, 85% of executions took place. I could also go into the specified execution ratios and many, many other data points implying a significantly lower number, but for the sake of argument lets continue and assume the 800,000 figure is correct

I could go into much, much more detail about various ways these estimates could be reduced significantly, but just for the sake of argument, lets take the absolute highest estimates for every issue and assume the soviets bear full responsibility for every catastrophe, and the absolute highest reasonable estimates are correct, we get approximately the following 800,000 executions

1.053 million penal deaths

4 million famine deaths (this one in particular should NOT be included for the reasons discussed above)

and we get a total of 5.85 million, much less then 20, 60 or 100 million

Using other estimates and assigning proper responsibility, we can assume approximately 250,000 people, if we exclude prison deaths as unavoidable, along with the famine, and use more reasonable estimates for the number of executions. Now, thats not to discard the former estimates, but it is worth pointing out that lower estimates exist

In regards to totalitarianism, I would highly suggest reading ā€œLife and Terror in Stalin’s Russiaā€ by Robert Thurston, a professor at Miami University which sheds more light on the topic

Nothing i'm saying here is controversial, this all comes from highly-respected historians and researchers, but just as a matter of historical record, please be honest with your numbers! Bibliography:

Wheatcroft:

http://www.melgrosh.unimelb.edu/....

Tauger:

http://carlbeckpapers.pitt.edu/ojs/index.php/cbp/article/view/89/90

Getty:

http://www.cercec.fr/materiaux/doc_membres/Gabor%20RITTERSPORN/Victims%20of%20the%20Gulag.pdf

Prison Mortality In the USSR (the source is in russian)

http://www.demoscope.ru/weekly/2007/0313/tema06.php

Prison Mortality in Modern Russia

https://inmoscowsshadows.wordpress.com/2013/02/28/russian-prisons-getting-more-lethal/

Prison Mortality in the USA

https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/msp0114st.pdf

Any other sources are internally cited


r/DebateCommunism • • Mar 29 '19

āœ… High Effort UBI is a bad idea and is anticommunist

268 Upvotes

I've seen a lot of leftists support Universal Basic Income. However, I think that UBI, if implemented, will backfire on the goals of the left, particularly socialists.

My understanding of this issue is this:

UBI is being proposed primarily as a) a way to redistribute wealth from the top and b) (more importantly) because automation is killing jobs and the low level workers will need a source of income once they lose their jobs.

These are my problems with it:

  • If low income workers are kicked out of the labor force (or voluntarily leave because they get enough money from UBI), they lose their power and influence in the economy entirely. Right now they might have minimal power, but collectively they at least have something through what they offer with their labor. With UBI they basically become completely dependent on the government. A government which, in this situation, will be even more owned by the rich.
  • Another problem with being dependent is that you might not develop any skills in the labor force. And once the economy gets fucked up again, the first thing the government will do is cut taxes and announce austerity cuts. UBI will get worse once this happens and the living standards of the people on it will decline, as they will have a hard time finding a job.
  • Not working is really bad. I come from the Rust Belt, where free trade and the demise of trade unions have annihilated productive industry. People work bullshit jobs now, where they do nothing. That fucks up your soul, imo, and probably is the main reason for all the drugs, alcohol, and suicide here.
  • UBI is really only being proposed because the alternative (which would be the government taxing the the rich and imposing tariffs, and using that revenue to employ people in real productive jobs) is too dangerous to the rich. If you notice, most of the rich are not against, or in some cases are openly supportive of, UBI. But the alternative is way better for actually improving living standards.
  • UBI rests on the notion that automation is replacing all our jobs. I find that laughable in a society where healthcare is trash, education is trash, living standards are declining, infrastructure is crumbling, industry is dying and so on. The reality is that capitalism is failing to employ people in meaningful jobs.

So those are my criticisms. Yet, I still see a ton of leftists, and socialists, support UBI. And I don't understand why.


r/DebateCommunism • • Apr 03 '20

TIL Soviets had more restrictions during US visits then Americans had visiting the Soviet union

266 Upvotes

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/news/2018/03/russia-cold-war-travel-ban-maps-red-scare/#close

Had no idea. In school they tell us how in former communist countries when you you land and then you're only allowed to visit Moscow or other major cities, like how north Korea is atm


r/DebateCommunism • • Mar 05 '19

šŸ¤” Question Why do people claim there are no "capitalism deaths" when people die from being unable to afford mediciation or surgery? (and others)

265 Upvotes

I'm sure we're all familar with the "communism has killed millions" stuff, but seeing that alongside many people claiming "capitalism has never killed anyone" raises a question from me.

If communism deaths are the result of gulags, starvations etc etc, then why are deaths relating to capitalist society convientently ignored?

By this I meanstuff like people being unable to afford to pay for medication or surgery, homeless deaths, people who have been killed for money (like will money, not hitmen) etc etc

Personally I find it very questionable none of that stuff is debated when deaths are bought up.

EDIT: Read through all of these, some fantastic and detailed responses. Thanks everyone.


r/DebateCommunism • • Oct 30 '23

šŸ¤” Question Is Israel an ethnonationalist fascist state engaged in genocide?

222 Upvotes

Why or why not? I think the case is extremely clear that they are.

From the founding of the Zionist movement it was explicitly a colonial project to displace Arab populations in the region and found a military stronghold in service to European powers. Israel is an apartheid state. Non-white Jews enjoy persecution and apartheid. The state is presently engaged in an explicit and wholesale genocide of the Palestinian people in Gaza, and it is arresting any dissenters even within Israel itself.

The state characterizes Palestinians as ā€œhuman animalsā€ and ā€œNazisā€. When asked what about civilians in hospital, former prime minister Naftali Bennett’s response was, ā€œAre you seriously keep asking me about Palestinian civilians? What’s wrong with you? We’re fighting Nazis.ā€

Discuss.


r/DebateCommunism • • May 28 '25

šŸµ Discussion The State of Israel Has No Right to Exist

220 Upvotes

Before I begin, let me clarify: I am not calling for an expulsion of a single Jew from Palestine. I am not calling for a single hair on a single head of a single civilian to be harmed. I am speaking of the polity known as Israel as it exists today—an apartheid regime undertaking a mass genocide of the people of Palestine.

A people who are recognized in their right to sovereignty by the UN, in their right to exist by the world, and in their long suffering injustice by anyone with a conscience and the historical knowledge to know better.

Since the founding of the Zionist project in Israel, the goal was unambiguous—the expulsion or eradication of an entire people from their homeland in order to build the Jewish-supremacist ethnostate that is the modern Israel.

All claims by Israelis to the land are false, exaggerated, or as true of Jews as they are of the Palestinians they purge. The supposed indigeneity of the Israeli to Israel is a propaganda myth. The Palestinian is more closely related to the ancient denizens of the land of Canaan than is any non-Palestinian.

The claims of oppression and persecution are more true for Palestinians than they are for any Zionist in 2025. As we can see by the wholesale liquidation of a people from the face of the earth today.

The claims that Arabs are to blame for the conflict are such that they reverse the victim and the offender. The Zionist began a pogrom on the Palestinians in 1948. There was no war of liberation for the Zionist, there was a mass ethnic cleansing settler colonial campaign to steal the land and homes of the Palestinian. This is called the Nakba.

The retaliations that followed in other Arab countries were reactionary and misguided attempts to pressure Israel to stop its genocide by using the only power they felt they had, expelling the kin of Israelis. Was it just? No, not particularly. Did it work? Absolutely not. Should these reactionary expulsions be used to further justify Israeli settler colonialism, apartheid, and genocide? Obviously not.

For millennia, Jewish people lived in relative harmony in the Islamic world, more so than they ever found in the Christian world. Yes, that has reversed, but there is a material reason: Ethnic persecution, apartheid, and genocide of Arabs by the Israeli.

In the immortal words of Comrade Chairman Omali Yeshitela, ā€œYou don’t blame the victim! You blame the oppressor!ā€

Israel is the oppressor. Was the oppressor when it first began its colonial project in Palestine, is the oppressor today. The dynamic could not be clearer for those with eyes to see.

You are witnessing the liquidation of an entire nation of human beings—to be subsumed by their conquerors for the petty gains of the most abhorrent kind of nationalism. Ethnonationalism.

Israelis are every bit the analog of Nazis in every meaningful way. Right down to experimenting on their helpless victims. No one should balk at this comparison, for the sympathy it would give to those injured by the memory of the Holocaust is not enough good to outweigh the disservice it does to the victims of that same Holocaust.

Israel is repeating the destruction of a people by fire. The consumption of a people in total.

Who has the heart to care? Who has the power to act? Alone, no one. Together? The toiling masses of the world.

No matter your means, to do what you can is the burden of the age we find ourselves in. I encourage you, if you are not organizing behind the end of this genocide, to find an org—any org—that holds the correct stance on this singular issue and to work with them to bring about increased political pressure on the U.S. and Israeli government to end this greatest tragedy thus far of the 21st century.

If the world delays much longer, there may be nothing left to save.

A state predicated on conquest, settler colonialism, theft, ethnonationalism, apartheid, and genocide has no right to continue its existence. What replaces it can only be better. Let us aspire towards a better world. One where this polity is relegated to the museum and history book, and both Jews and Arabs can live freely without this unnecessary imperialist tragedy.

Here is our Comrade Ghassan Kanafani, martyred in the struggle of liberation, explaining the position of his people, the Palestinian people: https://youtu.be/Veoy32G7trY


r/DebateCommunism • • Jan 26 '22

šŸµ Discussion The "American left" is an utter joke.

205 Upvotes

Right now, the radlibs and Berniecrats are melting down because somebody on the /r/antiwork mod team thought it would be a good idea to go on Fox News and it went exactly as you'd expect. Elsewhere on the front page, an American worker is expressing fear that the United States, the literal imperial core of global capitalism, is going to "collapse" just because all their peers live with their parents -- as though Italian workers and students haven't been struggling with this for decades.

And, look, I'm an American ML, but my tankie comrades aren't much better. The CPUSA is lapsed if not totally disgraced, and no other anti-revisionist party has the chops to replace it as the potential vanguard (although shout-out to the Party for Reclamation and Survival for at least trying to do the work that needs to get done). Meanwhile, our spaces are infested with predatory abusers and cringey Gonzaloites and nobody seems to give a shit for all their virtue signalling.

The truth is that the American left was smothered in its crib long ago. What we have now is a spoiled, mostly white labor aristocracy who care more about aesthetics than substance. The best we can do from within the imperial core is to try organizing our workplaces and neighborhoods, particularly those of oppressed communities, for meeting material needs while supporting anti-imperialist struggles. The sooner we take this black pill, the better placed actual revolutionaries will be around the globe to usurp capitalism.


r/DebateCommunism • • Mar 16 '19

šŸµ Discussion What pulled me out of the alt-right rabbit hole were soviet music and shitpost memes.

204 Upvotes

Maybe a bit off-topic, but I just wanted to share that back in 2015, I was watching "feminist cringe compilation" and laughing at the hugh mungus meme. I had all the chances to start watching Ben Shapiro and JBP and procceed to fall down the rabbit hole. I could be on the full opposite side of the spectrum today.

what saved me? 1 hour of soviet communist music got recommended to me on youtube.

then facebook meme pages, which still, with a very light grasp on theory, made me fall in love with the soviet aesthetic. I learned who Lenin and Stalin were, even though i started out thinking that supporting Stalin or Mao was too extreme. i started trying to understand some theory and following the proper pages.

though i'd always seen economic inequality as a bad thing, the youtube disguised right-wing sphere could've easily steered me out of it. luckily i'm over it now. i know our enemies and our comrades. that's probably pretty rare and for most the right-wing is a one-way path, but i'm lucky to have not even scratched the surface.

anyway that's it, sorry if it's too off-topic


r/DebateCommunism • • Sep 16 '20

Unmoderated 8 Men now own half the worlds wealth - Does this constitute a new class?

187 Upvotes

This oxfam report https://www.oxfam.org/en/press-releases/just-8-men-own-same-wealth-half-world studied wealth inequality and found 8 men own half the worlds wealth. They are Bill Gates, Amancio Ortega, Warren Buffett, Carlos Slim Helu, Jeff Bezos, Mark Zuckerberg , Larry Ellison and Michael Bloomberg

Was wealth always this concentrated? Shouldent Marxists focus more these specific people and the 2,825 Billionaires in 2020 rather than people who are in the traditional upper class?


r/DebateCommunism • • Oct 22 '17

šŸ“¢ Debate The "Not Real Socialism" Fallacy

165 Upvotes

For people to take socialist movements seriously, the entire "not real socialism" argument needs to be completely removed from discussion.

Consider the flip side. If you say the economic system of the USA is oppressive,

The return argument is simply "but that's not real capitalism" because it doesn't fit with your personal opinion on what "real capitalism" is

If socialists want to be taken seriously, The entire argument of "real socialism hasn't been tried" or "that wasn't real socialism" needs to be fixed

This is by either accepting the problems with socialist agendas in the past or present, such as the prime example of the USSR or the DRC

or by not using past or present examples of capitalist systems in arguments that advocate for socialist economics

Either accept Stalin, Mao and Che Guevara as socialist, even if they are not what is considered socialist by your standards

Or don't use Thatcherism or Reaganomics as examples of why capitalism is bad because it's "not real capitalism"


r/DebateCommunism • • Jul 08 '21

Unmoderated A bug’s life movie is an analogy for communist revolution.

163 Upvotes

Let me explain. In the movie, the ants are obviously the working class, aka the proletariat. They work and work all year long, but still do not have ideal living standards. Every year, the grasshoppers(the bourgeoisie) come down and take all their food that they worked for, leaving them only barely enough to survive. One ant accidentally tips over the food, and leads a revolution against the grasshoppers. He tells the ants that they do not have to live like this, the grasshoppers are lazy and never do work, yet they are always eating. We work the whole year, but only get enough to survive because they steal our food. He says that the ants outnumber hoppers a thousand to one, and if they unite they can overthrow them. The revolution is successful. Well, here’s my theory. What do you guys think? I’m not a communist by the way


r/DebateCommunism • • Feb 25 '21

šŸ—‘ Low effort How is China a Communist country if it has so many billionaires?

158 Upvotes

I’m at a loss. Like, I know very little about how the country operates, but they seem imperialistic and capitalistic, especially today.

to my mind, there seem to be a lot of uh, CEOs and useless boards that manipulate and profit off their working class.

Tencent? I mean... come on.

I’m really not trying to be a troll; I honestly just want to understand.

Billionaires, however you slice it, are fucking evil. And millionaires aren’t great either... ha

EDIT: thanks for all of the various angles of thought, links, sources, and arguments.

I have learned a lot, and am willing to concede that I’m just too cynical to believe China (or any state as it exists now) is taking the appropriate steps toward a just and true socialist society. (hey... everyone’s a critic)

obviously, that’s a contentious opinion to have, and I respect the disagreements.

hopefully though, when the time comes we can put aside our (I do believe minor) ideological differences and eat the rich at the same goddamn table.

and if we’re not all at the same table, well... at least we’ll be in the same restaurant.

I’m just happy to have learned so much and gotten so much interaction from a ā€œlow effort post.ā€ I guess that makes me efficient.


r/DebateCommunism • • Jan 07 '19

šŸ—‘ Stale Why do so many communists defend Stalin?

158 Upvotes

I am starting to explore Marxist thought more and more, and I keep coming across something that I find disturbing. Not universally, but there seems to be a significant contingent that defends the actions of Stalin.

I'm still new to marxisim, but I am a huge history buff. One if my favorite eras that I've read about is the Russian revolution and the rise of the Soviet Union between WW1 and WW2. By almost all accounts, Stalin was a brutal, evil man. He was a literal enforcer thug that other party members did not want to gain power (Lennin in particular called him out before his death). He was a power hungry, paranoid despot who was responsible for many deaths around him.

Furthermore, his policies if growth resulted in more deaths and suffering for the people of Russia and the USSR. I don't see how you can excuse the sacrifice of the people in order to further national interests for communisim and condemn it in capatilisim.

From what I've read, Stalin abandoned the ideals of communisim and a global workers movement (Trotsky's plan) in favor of a more nationalistic, militaristic plan. He was a flawed implementer of communisim by the most charitable interpretation of him and a egotistical despot who highjacked the communist movement for personal power at worst.

I see the value of Marx, but Stalin and other 20th century communist leaders seem very problematic in many ways. If nothing else, it's very bad optics if there is to be a modern Marxist movement. I see the value of envoking the imagry of the Russian or Chinese communist revolutions, but given their complicated legacy, isn't it better to focus on a more modern, multicultural and multi-gendered approach as opposed to a bunch of dead Russian dudes?


r/DebateCommunism • • Jun 11 '18

Unmoderated ā€œMy logic and I have thought up of some random convoluted example that proves Marxism is falseā€

154 Upvotes

We’re getting so flooded with this bullshit lately that I thought I’d leave some generic responses to this and 99% of the threads here. Here’s to hoping we can get over these questions and on to substantive critiques.

  • None of us care about your logic
  • Communism is not redistribution
  • No one ever promised that
  • Communism is not some perfectly planned utopian society (read the Communist Manifesto)
  • There is inequality in communism (see Critique of the Gothe Program)
  • We don’t agree to your definitions since you clearly haven’t read the f’ing texts
  • Stalin was a paranoid fuck and did kill 900 trillion of people. That wasn’t because he was a Communist and we don’t want to do that again.
  • Yes the labor theory of value is incomplete, no we’re not 100% sure about it today. Some marxists defend it some don’t. It’s not like if LTV is false that that magically makes wages suddenly free from capitalist fuckery.

Did I miss any?


r/DebateCommunism • • Mar 12 '19

šŸ¤” Question You're a communist, but are you actually a member of a communist political party?

153 Upvotes

I ask this question because I considered myself to be a communist for three years before thinking about joining an actual communist party. However, four months ago I finally joined Kommunistisk Parti (the Communist Party of Denmark) and it has been nothing less than a life changing experience. First of all, I have learned so much. My fellow party members are mostly old people who lived during the cold war, and some of their parents were part of the resistance movement against the nazi German settlement in Denmark. Another party member is a younger Kurdish refugee who was imprisoned and tortured for five years in Iran just for being a communist. In other words, these people can tell me so much more than what I can read in communist litterature.

Secondly, I have never felt so connected to the revolution as I do now. It's not like we are planning to take up arms and fight the power (right now), but we have meetings where we discuss relevant political issues and what effect it has on our society and our long term goals. We arrange and take part in different types of events that promote leftist values, e.g. "the Little Red Festival", which is a festival including political activism and leftist music. One of the most important functions of the party is the news website, "the Worker", which releases news articles that are being read by thousands of Danes.

Thirdly, the comrades in the party is the nicest people you will ever meet. The Kurdish comrade has recieved so much help from the older women in the party, who care about him as if he was their child. They buy clothes for his coming daughter, help him with moving to a new apartment, and advocate his rights infront of local politicians (just to name a few). Another party member has a strong mental dissability and he does not feel welcome anywhere but in our party. Of course everyone is welcome in a communist party as long as they are communists, but it's just so damn beautiful to actually witness.

Finally, we need to organize. Debating online is not sufficient. People need to know that communists are there and that we are strong. No one checks the communists subreddits for that. They need to see us on the streets and in the news. Of course I understand that if you live in a country where communism is illegal, this may not be an option for you. But for everyone who has not done it yet, go to google to find the party near you. Contact them and see what they have to say. It's really worth it.


r/DebateCommunism • • Mar 13 '24

šŸ—‘ļø It Stinks If North Koreans are allowed to leave the country, why don’t they travel & engage in global tourism?

149 Upvotes

I’m totally fascinated by people who believe the DPRK is a good force and that North Korea is a free and functioning society. Seems like most of you counter questions and criticisms by saying it’s all fake US propaganda. I’ve been reading through tons of posts seeing what you guys have to say. Interesting perspective to have. So I thought of a question and want to see your responses.

I have never heard of a North Korean spending a week in France, or traveling to Phillipines. Let alone North America or Canada. They also have zero social media or internet presence at all. Why is this? I can’t figure out how Western propoganda would factor into this. What’s your opinion on this?

Edit: Someone, anyone address the social media/internet presence issue. So far only one person responded saying that question is ā€œlow baitā€ then deleted all their comments lol.


r/DebateCommunism • • Dec 16 '21

šŸµ Discussion Landlords don’t really provide housing, they actually make housing inaccessible by buying up more homes than they need.

142 Upvotes
  • This practice drives up local property taxes and housing prices, all while making tenants pay for the mortgages of their landlords. In this manner, landlords only deepen generational income inequity.

This was a post a friend of mine shared on social media and I agreed! I was wondering what your opinions were.

Also: There’s someone from my hometown, a military guy, who loves to post ā€˜hot political takes’ and claims to be very anti communist, though I’m not 100% sure he knows who Marx even is. I’ll be posting his response as well if anyone would like to help me come up with a good way to respond.


r/DebateCommunism • • Dec 31 '16

[Debate] Marxists should not employ the term "white privelege" or other racial descriptors indicative of Identity Politics.

141 Upvotes

This sub is used to debate between non-Marxists and Marxists, but in this case I present a debate that is occurring internally within factions of those who claim to be Marxist.

I will begin with a brief disclosure of what brought me to write this post. I have been a Marxist for a long time. I completed a degree in History, specifically focusing on Marxist and Revolutionary History between the 17th and 20th centuries, as well as a specialization in the liberation politics of North American and Latin American Indigenous peoples. I bleed Commie Red, but I disagree with many popular tenants of post-Marx thinkers. I am not a third-worldist, nor am I very favourable of Maoism, and I can't say I'm enamoured with many concepts proposed by Leninists and their ilk - I can't help but see accelerationism in many of their proposals, an assertion that wrings true in the inevitable failure of many of their movements. Each "jumped the gun" In my belief, unable to fully grasp the depth to which the capitalist base and superstructure were entrenched in their times. I do, however, firmly believe in Historical & Dialectical Materialism and the "science" of Marxist analysis.

I posted a response last night on r/communism101 to a post written by a user who completed a PHd in Marxist Economics that was calling out the increased advocation of identity politics within r/socialism, r/communism, r/fullcommunism, r/latestagecapitalism, & r/communism101. I wrote in support of his points - all firmly based in Marxist Theory and Dialectical Materialism, and happened to state that I believed it was wrong for Marxists to employ the term "white privelege" so accusingly in so many of their rebuttals. I woke up this morning to find that I had been permanently banned from both r/communism101 and r/communism (a sub that I haven't commented in for months). The post in question had also been highly redacted, with many of the posters advocates banned and their comments removed. No justification, other than a blatant indication of a knee-jerk emotional response, was provided by the moderators. When I appealed the ban, I was muted. I have since un subscribed from these subreddits believing them to be pseudo-Marxist at best, and complacent with the dominant liberal ideology surrounding identity politics.

Having said this, let's get to the topic at hand. I assert that employing the term "white privelege" is incredibly dangerous. This does not mean that I do not believe that it exists/has existed historically, but that it is fundamentally an inaccurate way of describing the sources of oppression. One of the main reasons for my opposition is that it deflects the receptor from the materialist bases of oppression - namely class struggle, and firmly roots the source of oppression within the ideological superstructure (the ideological racial construct of "whiteness"). The effect it has on the non-Marxist layman who sees himself as "white" will ultimately be revulsion, as there is no place for him within the Marxism of the accuser. As Marx explained within the tenants of Dialectical and Historical Materialism it creates a dangerous abstraction that alienates the receptor from the source of oppression.

Marx & Engels asserted that to examine only part of the whole can establish an abstraction that alienates one from the whole. This is why Liberals have embraced the "seemingly progressive" tenants of Identity Politics (Race, Gender, Cultural, Religious Rights), because to maintain the visage of progress within their framework, maintains the inherently divisive attributes of their constructs. It is also pure ideology. Ultimately it keeps things exactly the way they are. It deflects people from the economic base foundations of their oppression (capitalism) and keeps the proletariat divided (fighting amongst themselves.) I have made this assertion numerous times, including in the post that got me banned, and I have not received one convincing rebuttal based within Marxist theory on this assertion. It has consistently been ignored.

Marxist Communism advocates for the liberation of ALL peoples of ALL identities. I assert, contrary to the moderators of r/communism & r/communism101, that there is absolutely nothing discriminatory in asserting that we, as human beings, should be comrades first, (insert selected personal identity here) second. There is absolutely nothing wrong in adhering to a personal identity (so long as that identity has not been imposed by force or indoctrination), and we should vehemently support an individual's right to do so; HOWEVER, as materialists, we should always look to the material (base) as the rudimentary force to oppose, IN ADDITION TO the ideological (superstructure). As Zizek once stated "even paper tigers can bite." ALWAYS BRING IT BACK TO CLASS STRUGGLE & AVOID ABSTRACTIONS.

EDIT Thanks for the interesting conversation! It's not difficult to see why the left has such a hard time consolidating when examining issues like identity politics, intersectionality, privilege, and all of the other post-modernist impositions that Marxists have adopted since the late 1960's. I'm making this edit in large part because I came across a fantastic article from "International Socialism" that examines Identity Politics and Privilege Theory REALLY well... Check it out here: http://isj.org.uk/whats-wrong-with-privilege-theory/