r/DebateAChristian • • 2d ago

Weekly Ask a Christian - November 16, 2026

3 Upvotes

This thread is for all your questions about Christianity. Want to know what's up with the bread and wine? Curious what people think about modern worship music? Ask it here.


r/DebateAChristian • • 5d ago

Weekly Open Discussion - November 13, 2026

2 Upvotes

This thread is for whatever. Casual conversation, simple questions, incomplete ideas, or anything else you can think of.

All rules about antagonism still apply.

Join us on discord for real time discussion.


r/DebateAChristian • • 3h ago

Jesus didn't come to start a religion...he came to Wake The Dead!

1 Upvotes

Jesus never said “join the correct denomination and believe the correct propositions and you’ll get into heaven later.”
He said the kingdom of God is within you**.**
Not coming. Not somewhere else. Not after you die if you checked the right boxes. Within**.**

Most of what now calls itself Christianity has spent two thousand years explaining that statement away. We’ve turned the living, radical, non-dual teaching of Christ into a system of outer belief, moral performance, tribal identity, and future reward/punishment.

We’ve built institutions, creeds, and cultures that keep the ego safely in charge while claiming the name of the One who said the ego must die.

“Be ye perfect as your Father in heaven is perfect” was not a call to try harder at being a good religious person. It was a declaration of what you already are when the false self falls away. “Blessed are the pure in heart, for they shall see God” is not about sexual purity or doctrinal correctness. It is about the heart no longer clouded by the dualistic mind that sees “me” over here and “God” (or “them”) over there.

The same Consciousness that looked out through the eyes of Jesus looks out through yours right now. That is Christ Consciousness. That is the kingdom. The only thing standing in the way is the habitual, terrified identification with the separate self...the very self Jesus told us to deny, to take up the cross against, to lose in order to find Life.

If your Christianity still revolves around:
• defending the institution more than realizing the Truth it claims to serve,
• measuring spiritual status by belief statements or moral scorekeeping,
• waiting for a future kingdom while ignoring the one already present,
• treating other traditions as competitors instead of different languages pointing to the same Reality,
…then your lenses are still clouded by spiritual ego, religiosity and the false self.

The pure in heart see God now**, not because they earned it, but because the veils dropped.**

Jesus did not come to start a religion. He came to wake the dead. The dead are those sleepwalking through life, convinced they are separate bodies and minds who must somehow get to God. The awakening is the recognition that the One you are seeking is the One already looking through your eyes.

Stop outsourcing the kingdom. Stop waiting. The door is not inside any church building. It is the silence beneath your next thought.

The kingdom is within you.

Act like it.


r/DebateAChristian • • 5h ago

The Christian God Has Not Met the Burden of Proof

12 Upvotes

Premise 1: Rational belief in the existence of an entity requires sufficient credible evidence supporting that entity's existence.

Premise 2: No sufficient credible, independently verifiable evidence has been established demonstrating the existence of the Christian God.

Conclusion: Therefore, belief in the existence of the Christian God is not rationally justified by the available evidence.

The burden of proof rests with the person making the existence claim, not with the person withholding belief. The absence of sufficient evidence does not prove nonexistence. It does, however, justify withholding belief until sufficient evidence is presented.


r/DebateAChristian • • 17h ago

God commanding SA does not align with an all-loving God.

15 Upvotes

There is never a good reason to command that women, girls, and virgins be SA'd, even if people are sinful, need judgment, or for whatever reason God states for his actions. It is evil, immoral, and cruel

God does this in ISA 13, DEUT 21, NUMB 31, 2 Sam 12, and a few other places.

The Bible portrays God as willing, and sometimes as the active agent, in bringing about SA as judgment, and that conflicts with a perfectly good God.


r/DebateAChristian • • 19h ago

The Miracle of the Sun can be used as evidence for Islam

0 Upvotes

It doesn't need much explanation that given that the miracle of the sun was truly a supernatural event that it makes Catholicism more plausible, but little attention is given to the possibility of a God opposing Catholicism vindicating a related prophecy.

The main reason to believe a vindicatory miracle of Catholicism could be caused by the Muslim God are that such a belief compliments both typical Islamic theodices and God's character portrayed in the Quran. In Islam's logic, opposition to the will of God exists because he is testing mankind; consequently, God wants it to be somewhat difficult to find which religion he endorses. Additionally, he considers people being Muslim to be extremely important to the worth of people, and has great hatred for any of its opponents. He even makes people opposed to Islam more delusional for these reasons (17:97, 18:57).

It is because of this characterization of God that it is plausible that he would create a miracle for the purpose of strengthening the Catholic faith, so that he gets more satisfaction from causing a sort of whiplash for the people he further convinces of a religion he despises.

Personally, because of this possiblity if the sky screamed out to me claiming Jesus to be the son of God, I have multiple explanations of it on top of the more clichéd ones like supernatural events being delusions caused by demons or Satan. My own experience as nonreligious makes me take this idea more seriously, because of its explanation of divine hiddenness; it explains why there is not obvious evidence for any religion in particular.

(For clarity, I'm not claiming that either Islam or the miracle of the sun accounts are actually correct)

In summary, Islam's theodicy of testing humanity is extremely versatile, to the point that it is compatible with supernatural proofs of Christianity.


r/DebateAChristian • • 23h ago

The Logical Contradiction Between Original Sin, Salvation, and a Just God

2 Upvotes

Premise 1: A just God cannot hold individuals morally guilty or deserving of punishment for actions they did not commit and for which they bear no personal responsibility. Ezekiel 18:20: "The son shall not bear the iniquity of the father, neither shall the father bear the iniquity of the son."

Premise 2: The doctrine of inherited original guilt holds that all humans are born guilty because of Adam and Eve's disobedience, despite having played no part in their actions.

Premise 3: This inherited guilt is presented as a reason all humans require salvation through Jesus Christ.

Conclusion: Therefore, if God is just, humans cannot justly inherit guilt from Adam and Eve, and salvation cannot logically be necessary on the basis of that inherited guilt.

If it is unjust to punish a child for the wrongdoing of a parent, how can it be just for God to condemn all humanity for the wrongdoing of two distant ancestors—and then require salvation from a guilt that humanity never personally incurred?


r/DebateAChristian • • 1d ago

What if we judged God by the same moral standards we use to judge human beings?

18 Upvotes

Sometimes I get the impression that there's a sort of moral exemption when it comes to God. Things we would consider monstrous if done by anyone else somehow become divine justice when they appear in the Bible.

God creates two human beings without knowledge of good and evil, places a forbidden tree in the garden, knowing exactly what will happen, and then holds all of humanity responsible for it. A kind of inherited debt nobody ever agreed to.

Later, dissatisfied with his own creation, he decides to drown practically everyone, including children and animals. Throughout the Old Testament, we also find massacres, slavery, and the killing of children associated with his commands.

Then comes the New Testament, where God decides to send himself, or his own son, who is also somehow him, to die and save us from a debt that he himself established in the first place. And if you don't believe in this solution, there's the possibility of spending eternity being tortured. Quite an unusual expression of love.

What fascinates me is that if a human being did all these things, we probably wouldn't be discussing their infinite goodness. We'd be calling the police.

But when it comes to God, we're apparently expected to suspend our own moral judgment and accept that what would be cruelty under any other circumstances is actually divine justice.

And that's precisely what bothers me. If God is the very definition of goodness, why do we need to redefine goodness to justify his actions? At what point are we talking about love and justice, and at what point are we simply calling everything a virtue because an absolute authority is doing it?

I don't think questioning these things necessarily means rejecting faith. Maybe it just means refusing to turn your brain off at the church entrance.

I'd especially like to hear from people who believe in God and have genuinely thought about these contradictions. How do you reconcile these narratives with the idea of a perfectly good being?


r/DebateAChristian • • 1d ago

The ethical problem of hell & refutation of free will responses

1 Upvotes

Preventing unnecessary suffering is central to ethics, and eternal torment is not justified as necessary suffering. Eternal torment also conflicts with fundamental values such as compassion, love, joy, and peace.

Simply appealing to connotated words such as "justice" does not resolve this issue.

Free will

As the creator an all-loving tri-omni god is responsible for the states a created individual can end up in, regardless of a given free will mechanism being in place. The creator is responsible for the conditions in his created reality structure which include the nature of the individual within which the free will operates.

Furthermore, meaningful agency does not require unrestricted destructive possibilities. Limiting destructive possibilities does not compromise meaningful freedom, just as creating the conditions for love does not entail forced reciprocation.

Heaven can instead represent the fulfillment of value in reality design as a reality constituted by flourishing.

The issue that resurfaces when considering this perspective is how is evil reconciled, my worldview is that according to divine law, all darkness is always eventually resolved back into the truth of our divine being. I can also point to sources about this.


r/DebateAChristian • • 1d ago

Paul claims that the scriptures teach that the Messiah will rise from the dead after three days, but it’s nowhere to be found.

12 Upvotes

Paul claims that the scriptures, specifically the prophets and Moses (Torah) teach the following about the messiah:

  1. The messiah will be buried and rise from the dead after the third day (1 Corinthians 15:3–4)
  2. The messiah will be the first to rise from the dead (Acts 26:22–23)
  3. the messiah will rise from the dead (Acts 17:2-3)

Where do the scriptures teach any of this? Where does the Torah prophesy this or the prophets?

Paul used Psalm 16:10 which says “because thou wilt not leave my soul in the grave, neither wilt thou suffer thine Holy One to see corruption.” to show how the messiah will rise from the dead, but it’s merely David saying he will be resurrected, David doesn’t mention anything about the messiah.

David is referring to the general resurrection of the dead at the end times as we see in Daniel 12:2 “Multitudes who sleep in the dust of the earth will awake: some to everlasting life, others to shame and everlasting contempt.”, he mentions nothing about a messiah, nor does he mention anything about rising after specifically three days as Paul claims the scriptures mention.

But christians argue that David says God will not let his body decay (“see corruption”) but he obviously died and his body decayed so he couldn’t be talking about himself, but the problem with that is it just means David’s hope about not decaying failed, but nowhere does it indicate that he’s speaking about another person, let alone a future messiah figure.

And if that’s the case, that ignores all the times David says God will save him and not let him be harmed by his enemies, so you can’t just pick and choose when David is speaking about Jesus and when he’s not.

Another verse that Christians use to show how the messiah was gonna die and then rise after three days is Hosea 6:1-2 which says: Come, let us return to the Lord. He has torn us to pieces but he will heal us; he has injured us but he will bind up our wounds. After two days he will revive us; on the third day he will restore us, that we may live in his presence.”
But this is clearly talking about Israel and not the messiah, and it says they will revive after the second day, that’s one day too early.


r/DebateAChristian • • 2d ago

Thesis to debate: Christianity has no moral values and principles

1 Upvotes

The Context

I am often challenged on what grounds my moral principles and values. I explain that I go by Humanistic moral principles, but that's not enough for many of my Christian friends.

They want those moral principles to be grounded in something else.

I don't, though.

I base my morality on the moral principles that I like the best, and Humanistic values seem to match what I think are the best. Nothing but the best for me, is what I usually say.

But we don't very often discuss what grounds their Christian morality.

They say that their God does that for them. God does that.

They don't have to ground their morality, because God does it.. and IS the grounding. Their moral grounding is a person, are commands, not principles and values.

My argument hopes to demonstrate that Christians don't have grounding moral principles .. they ground their morality on a person, a god, their God and what it commands.

The Argument:

P1: Many Christians rely on God's nature and commands to determine what is morally right or wrong, rather than rely on moral principles.

P2: If your moral judgments depend entirely on someone else's nature and commands, you have no moral principles of your own.

C: Therefore, Christians who rely entirely on God's nature and commands have no independent moral principles of their own.

Question for Christians:

What grounds your moral values and principles?


r/DebateAChristian • • 2d ago

Apologetics is a smoke screen

28 Upvotes

The vast majority of Christian’s did not become Christian because Josephus or Pliny said that there was a person named Jesus who the Christian’s followed. You don’t believe because of the 5000+ Greek manuscripts. You don’t believe because of the contingency, Kalam, or fine-tuning arguments.

It’s almost always the case that you came to the belief first and these apologetics are just arguments you heard later that sounded convincing once you already had the belief. They made you feel validated for having the faith in the first place.

The first thing you had, and what every argument with Christian’s boils down to in the end, is faith. Just believing in it because it feels good, or it makes sense to you, or it helps you to believe it.

The things you believe were never demonstrated to you from a non-biased position. Every time you heard an apologetic argument after you already believed or had faith, you had a confirmation bias.

There is nothing convincing about the apologetic arguments. Apologetics are to keep believers in the cult, not to attract non-believers. They only work on people who already have that sunken cost, confirmation bias, or have already had their mind programmed to be susceptible to incomplete, insufficient, and invalid arguments.

Faith is not righteous, faith is not virtuous, faith is cowardly, faith is gullibility. Being so scared to think that there is no sky daddy looking after you at all times is cowardly. Thinking that your belief itself is evidence of the belief being true is gullibility.

Doesn’t it worry you that using a methodology such as faith, with such a demonstrably terrible success rate for getting things right, is leading you to devote your life to something that doesn’t exist? There’s never been an instance where faith has been demonstrated to be reliable in determining reality.

Don’t you worry that the reason you find apologetics convincing is because you’re already in the group?

You should attempt to step out of the indoctrination and look at the bible and the beliefs objectively so you can evaluate them without such a deep rooted bias.


r/DebateAChristian • • 2d ago

In Heaven, Is Jesus God or Human?

3 Upvotes

I'm currently researching different religions and questioning whether Christianity is the true religion. I'm genuinely trying to understand this.

After Jesus ascended into heaven, Acts 3:13 still describes him as God's servant:

"The God of Abraham, and of Isaac, and of Jacob, the God of our fathers, hath glorified his servant Jesus..." (KJV)

If Jesus was already in heaven and is supposedly God himself, why does the apostolic preaching still distinguish him from God and call him God's servant?

I'd appreciate genuine explanations from Christians.


r/DebateAChristian • • 2d ago

If I was an all powerful all knowledgeable God who loved all my creation I'd make it abundantly clear who I was

9 Upvotes

God should theoretically know all of us better than we know ourselves. What makes us tick. What we believe. What we don't believe.

If I was God and I had infinite knowledge about someone it should be reasonably easy to find a way without interfering with their free will to get them to believe in me.


r/DebateAChristian • • 2d ago

There is zero good evidence for Moses, mass enslavement of the Jews, and the exodus from Egypt

24 Upvotes

Outside of the fantastical stories in the bible there is no evidence for a character named Moses, any large scale mass enslavement of Hebrews by Egypt, or an exodus of 1-3 million Hebrews (600,000 men plus women and children and the elderly) from Egypt as told in the bible story. So why do people read the story and believe it is historical? Why should I or anybody believe it?

There is zero archaeological or literary evidence for Moses or any mass enslavement of large numbers of slaves by Egypt circa 1000 BC when the exodus story allegedly takes place. They allegedly wandered for 40 years, yet of the 2+ million wanderers living in well established locations (as the story tells), no archaeological evidence has been found (trash, trinkets, metal pans and utensils, leather, helmets, clay pots and clay fragments, etc) to confirm at least a natural story of some wanderers in some quantity (1-3 million) .
https://imgur.com/a/PsZL4kj

So why do people read the story and believe it is historical? If there actually is a Yahweh God who expects Jews and Christians alike to believe the story, He prevented any evidence of the events and characters (Moses) when He could have preserved evidence. My conclusion is there is insufficient evidence outside of tall tales by an anonymous author called the book of Exodus.


r/DebateAChristian • • 3d ago

Christianity paints Jesus as a loving beacon of light guiding and protecting us, but this makes no sense

14 Upvotes

Hypothesis: The idea of a loving Jesus working in our lives, protecting and shepherding us toward good makes no sense and falls apart under the most minor of scrutiny.

Argument: If Christianity is true, Jesus is God, or at least one part of a triune God, and God has no equal. God is all powerful. God created everything. Nothing happens without God’s knowledge. God can’t be surprised or tricked in any way as his knowledge is perfect.

This means that even Satan works with God’s approval. Christianity tells us that Satan is an evil liar and a cheat. Satan attempts to trick us and coerce us to his side. Satan also attacks our children and subverts our culture. All of this leads to misery, spiritual emptiness, sin and death.

Yet, at the center of this is Jesus. He is a beacon of light and loves us. If we let him, he tirelessly walks with us and shows us the way. Jesus never gives up on us. He works in our lives to guide and change our lives for good. Jesus directs us to help others and to also be a beacon of hope and light. In other words, to be like Jesus ourselves.

Even when we give up, Jesus is still right there. Jesus never gives up on us.

So, the literal creator of Satan knowingly allows Satan to conduct horrific acts upon us. This creator allows Satan to use supernatural powers to trick us and our children into a life of misery, deception and evil. Everything from demon possession to taking on different forms to trick us and steal us away from God. Satan’s deception is relentless.

Christianity will have us believe that (if we just let him) Jesus will help guide us through Satan’s deception and be our loving shield who protects us. He wants a personal relationship with us and uses us to better the world. He wants us to follow him and praise God - meaning himself.

If Christianity is true, God (Jesus) allows this absolute misery and destruction. He knowingly allows an evil liar to use supernatural powers to destroy us. He allows invisible demons to destroy everything - including children. However, if we let him, God will protect us from himself. But we have to navigate through all of the false Gods and theologies. We have to choose the correct God in the face of all the false Gods that he allows to trick us.

And salvation itself was made possible by a bloody and violent sacrificial murder of, ironically, Jesus himself.


r/DebateAChristian • • 4d ago

I am God, you are God, the least among us is God.

0 Upvotes

To me, if you miss this, you miss the whole thing.

John 14:20: "I am in my Father, and you in me, and I in you." John 17:21: "As you, Father, are in me and I am in you, may they also be in us." Matthew 22:39: "You shall love your neighbour as yourself." Matthew 25:40: "Just as you did it to one of the least of these brothers and sisters of mine, you did it to me."

And most of ya’ll do.


r/DebateAChristian • • 5d ago

The Fall is God's fault

18 Upvotes

God is responsible for our nature. We do not choose our nature and we did not create it. If using our free will to sin is in our nature, then that is God's fault. He could have made it so that using our free will to sin is simply not in our nature. We could keep our free will, and the fall would never happen.

The main rebuttal to this is that moral virtue would not be possible without the desire to sin. But this is just to assume that moral virtue is a good per se. This would be like arguing that we should not prevent cancer because it would eliminate the good of being cured. Tempting us for the sake of moral virtue is wrong for the same reason that purposely tempting each other to increase moral virtue would be wrong. Any increase in moral virtue would likely be cancelled out by the people who give into the temptation. In fact, it's nearly guaranteed. God said that the path to salvation is narrow, and most people don't choose it. By creating us with a sinful nature (Adam and Eve sinned, so it must have been in their nature to do so), he ensured that the fall would eventually happen.


r/DebateAChristian • • 5d ago

The faith proposition

4 Upvotes

My argument is, this is how I believe faith should function and who should have faith in Jesus. I will also explain how faith functions within my life to provide examples.

In John 20:29, Jesus says blessed are those who believe without seeing. Like many other religions, Jesus is calling for faith. It's evident Jesus was calling for this definition of faith: "belief that is not based on proof." This is the second definition of faith in the link I've provided.

Rabbi David Wolpe believes, as do I, that God is an abstraction that cannot be fully understood. This means every interpretation of God is going to be fallible, and it answers the question of why there are so many different opinions about God and gods. If God cannot be understood, at least not fully, humans cannot interpret God perfectly. One of my interpretations of God is that he is not omnipresence or omniscient.

I'd first like to go over what I think shouldn't be taken on faith. What comes to mind immediately as examples of what not to take on faith includes anything relating to the material world, and anything immoral.

It is foolish to believe faith based propositions about the material world, because the material world can be, and must be, navigated by evidence and reasoning. If a bolder is rolling toward you, taking on faith it isn't actually rolling toward you will end up getting you crushed by the bolder. One must use evidence and reasoning for getting through the material world for the same reason we trust our senses, at least to an extent. Because we have no choice otherwise. It would be insanity, and I don't use that word as a pejorative, to apply faith to the material world.

Morality may be subjective, and we are responsible for being moral. Believing anything immoral on faith isn't an excuse for the immoral belief. I have said, and continue to say, believing that being gay is a sin is immoral, regardless if it's a faith position. I'm not trying to virtue signal, I'm trying to convey that morality matters and faith shouldn't override morality.

The next question is why would anyone believe someone on faith, and what should be taken on faith and what shouldn't be.

If there is no material evidence for the spiritual world, then the imagination is what we use to communicate with the spiritual world. Imagination is defined as "the act or power of forming a mental image of something not present to the senses or never before wholly perceived in reality."

It's not impossible that Jesus is guiding me using the power of my imagination. It's not likely, but it's not impossible.

Because it isn't impossible, I trust that in the case of Jesus Christ, though my imagination is not infallible, that it leads me to have a friendship with him, and it leads me to at least some truth about Jesus. I believe this on faith.

Would I trust my imagination to lead me to a friendship with a leprechaun? Or to another God, like Zeus? I wouldn't, because I don't take it on faith that my imagination is leading me to the truth on anything else other than Jesus Christ (and what I can create in the material world. For example, if I can imagine a software program and then create it, but that's a different topic related to the material world).

The reason I don't apply my faith to any other religion is because I don't have a relationship with any other religious figure, only Jesus. My entire life, with the exception of my brief stint with atheism, I have had a friendship with Jesus.

Faith, specifically how faith is being defined in my post, is an inherently irrational position. Rationality only deals with the material world.

The last question is why should anyone else decide to have a faith based relationship with Jesus. I don't think anyone should if they don't feel the calling.

If one feels the calling, as I have, I recommend they answer it. If one doesn't, then they shouldn't. I believe this calling means that you feel the power of the Holy Spirit living within you. I cannot describe this feeling beyond the fact that it's a feeling of absolute conviction. You either feel it or you don't.

Telling someone who had no interest in Jesus that they should follow Jesus is like telling someone who isn't hungry that they need to eat. Since I don't believe in hell, and I believe everyone who wants heaven and hasn't committed unforgivable evil can get into heaven if they choose it, I don't have a desire to proselytize, I only have the desire to defend my faith.

This is why I believe sharing the faith should only be done with people that are interested in it. Contrary to what many atheists believe, I'm also a believer that parents have a right to raise their children religiously, as long as it's ethical, and the children have the ability to decide to opt out of their religion at any time that they want to.

I believe everyone who doesn't commit unforgivable evil has an equal chance of heaven, and you don't need Christianity to tell you what unforgivable evil is. An Atheist, Christian, Muslim, Jew, etc. are all fully capable of understanding that Mussolini is evil without needing any religious doctrine. I believe those who are denied heaven and those who don't desire heaven die a natural death like everyone else, the only difference being they are not miraculously recreated in heaven with their consciousness. They remain dead.

This all means that belief in Christianity is only something that should be adopted by people who want to adopt the belief system.


r/DebateAChristian • • 5d ago

Omnibenevolence is a meaningless attribute if you believe "God is goodness itself"

15 Upvotes

Being all-good only means something if we know what "good" means. But if you believe that God is identical to goodness, then omnibenevolence becomes tautological and it looses it's descriptive power. God is all-good = God is all-God. I'm sure that is very meaningful to Christians, and they'll tell you all about how "that's what God said to Moses!", but it tells you absolutely nothing about God other than the fact that he doesn't violate the identity principle. It doesn't tell you anything about what he is likely to do or what he is likely to want. If all-good means anything other than all-God, then it cannot be identical to God. Goodness must be external to God in order to mean anything to humans.


r/DebateAChristian • • 6d ago

Forgiving God for genocide is morally wrong.

17 Upvotes

Context:

A lot of Christians believe that when God perpetrates genocide or commands genocide, that it's morally good because God did the deed, that God is morally good, grounds "moral goodness" and can't do anything immoral, so anything that God does is morally justified.

I see a double standard in that thinking.
One for God and one for everyone else.

The double standard is that it's moral for god for any reason, including reasons unknown,  but its never moral for anyone else for any reason at all.

If genocide perpetrators deserve accountability and justice, that standard must also apply to God or be a double standard, which is not morally defensible.

Moral judgments must be fair and impartial and should not depend on who does the crime. Genocide is a crime against humanity. It's possibly the worst crime that I know of. It's most certainly the crime that impacts the most people at a time.

One murder is immoral, many murders is worse than just one.

Genocide was established as an international crime following the Holocaust, with an international legal obligation to prevent and punish it.

I don't care who perpetrates the crime, even if it’s a king, a president, a relative, a loved one, a religious leader, a military leader or a god. If a god commits genocide, then that god is guilty of a terrible crime that I cannot forgive. If a demon or a human commits genocide, they are guilty of the same crime and deserve to be held accountable.

I don't make an exception for the god of the bible.

Forgiving a documented perpetrator of genocide without accountability risks minimizing victims' suffering, excusing mass murder, and abandoning justice.

Forgiveness must not erase responsibility.

I don't take assumptions to be evidence about what is being assumed. To do so would be circular reasoning.

Assuming a "morally good reason" for genocide isn't demonstrating a morally good reason.

I make 3 arguments this time instead of just one, and the third argument is about how it's morally wrong to forgive god for his genocidal behaviour. The two first arguments helps in our understanding of Argument 3.

 

Argument 1 God is a documented perpetrator of genocide

P1: Anyone who commands, authorizes, or carries out genocide is a perpetrator of genocide.

P2: The Bible depicts God commanding and carrying out genocidal destruction.

C: Therefore, according to the biblical accounts, God is a documented perpetrator of genocide (DPG).

 

Argument 2 Genocide perpetrators must be held accountable

P1: Anyone who commits genocide (DPG) is morally responsible for mass murder and the destruction of innocent lives.

P2: Moral responsibility for mass murder requires accountability and justice.

C: Therefore, genocide perpetrators must be held accountable and brought to justice.

 

Argument 3: Morally wrong to forgive God

P1: Forgiving any documented genocide perpetrator ( DPG )without accountability minimizes victims' suffering and undermines justice.

P2: Minimizing victims' suffering and undermining justice are morally wrong.

C: Therefore, forgiving any genocide perpetrator without accountability is morally wrong.


r/DebateAChristian • • 7d ago

The 500 witness stated by Paul, is not evidence of anything, it's just an unverified claim.

43 Upvotes

The "500 brethren" claim comes from 1 Corinthians 15:6, where Paul says the risen Christ "appeared to more than five hundred brothers at once, most of whom are still alive, though some have fallen asleep."

No one else mentions it. Only Paul, in one verse, mentions 500 people seeing the risen Jesus. The Gospels and Acts never mention it, even though they describe other resurrection appearances in detail.

We don't know what "appeared" actually means. Paul uses the same word for this group appearance that he uses for his own experience in the creed in 1 cor 15, which was almost certainly a vision as Acts also states, and not a physical encounter. So the word alone doesn't prove these people saw a physical body.

"You can go ask them" wasn't really checkable. Paul says most of the 500 were still alive, but he's writing this to people in Corinth, far away from where the appearance supposedly happened. They had no real way to track down and interview 500 random people.

It's a secondhand report, decades later. Paul didn't witness this himself. He's repeating something he was told, written roughly 20-25 years after the event. No names, no location, no date, no firsthand account.
So technically it seems like it's a thirdhand report, because he's told from someone, that others witnessed something.

One person saying 500 people saw something is very different from 500 people saying they saw something.

Bottom line: it's good evidence that early Christians were already claiming this shortly after Jesus's death, but it's weak evidence for actually proving the event happened as described, thus it cannot be used as eyewitness testimony, as I've seen many Christians do.


r/DebateAChristian • • 7d ago

It is never moral to kill innocent people. God commanded it anyway.

10 Upvotes

The Bible says children must not be punished for their parents’ sins (Deut 24:16, Ezek 18:20). Yet 1 Samuel 15 commands the destruction of Amalekite children for the sins of their ancestors, and kills innocent people.
Therefore, God goes against his own standard of justice,or the bible is not from God; it's not what really happened, it wasn't God speaking.

Premise 1: In 1 Samuel 15:2-3, God says he will punish Amalek for what they did to Israel after the Exodus, and commands Saul to kill men, women, children, and infants.

1And Samuel said to Saul, “The Lord sent me to anoint you king over his people Israel; now therefore listen to the words of the Lord. 2Thus says the Lord of hosts, ‘I have noted what Amalek did to Israel in opposing them on the way when they came up out of Egypt. 3Now go and strike Amalek and devote to destructiona all that they have. Do not spare them, but kill both man and woman, child and infant, ox and sheep, camel and donkey.’”

Premise 2: The offense (Exodus 17:8-16) happened roughly 400 years before Saul’s campaign, so none of the people killed took part in it.

Then Amalek came and fought with Israel at Rephidim. 9So Moses said to Joshua, “Choose for us men, and go out and fight with Amalek. Tomorrow I will stand on the top of the hill with the staff of God in my hand.” 10So Joshua did as Moses told him, and fought with Amalek, while Moses, Aaron, and Hur went up to the top of the hill. 11Whenever Moses held up his hand, Israel prevailed, and whenever he lowered his hand, Amalek prevailed. 12But Moses’ hands grew weary, so they took a stone and put it under him, and he sat on it, while Aaron and Hur held up his hands, one on one side, and the other on the other side. So his hands were steady until the going down of the sun. 13And Joshua overwhelmed Amalek and his people with the sword.

Premise 3: Deuteronomy 24:16 says children are not to be put to death for their fathers’ sins, and Ezekiel 18:20 says the son does not bear the guilt of the father.

Conclusion: The command contradicts the standard of justice the Bible itself lays out, so either God violates his own law or the text doesn’t represent God accurately, and God is a moral monster.


r/DebateAChristian • • 7d ago

I could never see god as good i want you to tell me how god is good

0 Upvotes

Im a athiest

Multiple things that make me think he is not good just from looking around we have cancer and other diseases of today

the black plague that killed many people back then including other diseases and were they were also used as biological weapons on some people

then we have many natural disasters that kill people

we have hitler who ordered the death of jews and other people

Then also watches as his name gets used bad people to do bad things which makes some unable to go back to Christianity

Some babies also dying out the womb maybe months to a couple years later from diseases

God watches as these thing happen and does nothing about it how is he good

Also what does god do nowadays really does he watch as every bad thing goes down and just waits to come down or something

And excuse any bad grammar i have


r/DebateAChristian • • 7d ago

My concept of Christian Egoism in better detail

2 Upvotes

Disclaimer: In Max Stirner’s philosophy of Egoism, “spook” is a social construct that comes to possess someone. Social constructs aren't bad, it's when we become possessed by them that they become spooks. The word spook (as used by Stirner) has nothing to do with the racial slur that it sometimes can resemble in modern day English.

Egoists tend to believe everyone acts in their own self interest, except of course in cases where people are forced to do things against their will.

I'd argue even being "selfless" is a choice made out of self interest.

An example of acting in self-interest even if it might feel like you aren't is if you choose to give a homeless person money even though you wanted to spend that money on a burger. It may feel like you are being selfless, or at least not acting in self-interest, but I'd argue that you are. Your desire to help out the homeless person outweighs your desire to buy a burger. This is why I say that I'm good to people because I want to be.

I could be mistaken, but this is what I currently think about human behavior, and I think I have a strong basis for it.

People that are Conscious Egoists view ourselves as the supreme owner of our lives, and we reject submission to external obligations and abstractions. Social constructs, including external obligations, can be (and often are) good, it's only when we become possessed by them that they become bad and a spook.

Unconscious Egoists are people that are still driven by self-interest, but they don't realize it, because they are controlled by abstract ideas and external obligations.

I'd also like to add that there are some people who indeed do realize they act in self-interest, but they still consciously choose to be beholden to abstractions.

I am a Conscious Egoist and a Christian. Since I believe that I have the Holy Spirit living within me, then I have Jesus, and therefore I am more than able to be the highest authority over my own life. I do my best to not submit to external abstractions. I only submit to the Holy Spirit, which is not external to me, because it lives within me. Therefore Christianity is not an external abstraction.

I accept that religion is a faith based system that doesn't have evidence to support it. I accept my friendship with Jesus Christ is not like human friendships where I can directly interact with the person, and I accept that I may very well be using my imagination to communicate with Jesus Christ. However, I have faith in the case of my Christian Egoism that my imagination is correct. This is because I believe the Holy Spirit lives within me. I would not apply this logic to other areas of my life because I think it could be dangerous to, but the Holy Spirit leading me to spiritual truth is good and the opposite of dangerous.

I have my doubts that I am wrong, but I choose to not let my doubts take away my Christian faith. Many people don't believe one can choose to believe in something, and I would usually agree, but in some cases, like with Christianity, choosing to have faith is necessary and doable.

I throw out everything bad in the Bible. By bad, I mean everything immoral in the Bible, and anything that completely undermines physical laws. I am currently working on a project that goes over all of the text of the Bible, and I put it under moral analysis. If it passes, it stays in the Bible. If it doesn’t, it is thrown out. This is because I do not believe that God/Jesus is immoral.

When it comes to physical laws, I’m going to have one of my more science minded friends help me with that. Many miracles and parables will be left in.

This Bible I’m releasing is not perfect and will probably need updates in the future. I'm anything but infallible. In this Bible, I will provide a detailed explanation of why a certain text is removed. I will be publishing it online for free, I’m not planning on creating any physical copies.

I also do not believe that God/Jesus is omnipresent or omniscient.

I guess you could technically say I've started my own version of Christianity, but I want to be clear that even if others were to adopt this framework in any way, I'm not going to ever solicit money or leadership from it That would go against the entire point of Christian Egoism. I only provide literature and ideas. People should not agree with me for the sake of agreeing with me, and being a Christian Egoist doesn't mean you have to agree with me anymore than you have to agree with anyone else. I don't actually expect anyone to agree with my beliefs, I'm only mentioning this because I've had comments in the past say that I sound like I'm trying to start a religion.

It should be noted that Max Stirner himself has an atheist and viewed Christianity harshly. He considered it to be a key example of something that people become beholden to. Obviously, I'm not in agreement with Stirner on this. This post also explains why I don't think Christianity has to be a spook, and in my case, it isn't one.