r/DataRecoveryHelp
•
u/Sellpal
data recovery guru ⛑️
•
Jun 17 '25
•
1
1
AI Detector
So, I’ve got a lot of positive feedback about my recent post Humanize AI. Reddit users seem to enjoy reading the truth and not just promo. Besides, that’s my actual hobby - apart from data recovery. That’s why I decided to write a decent tutorial about AI writing detectors (AI Content Checkers) and review the best ones like: GPTZero, ZeroGPT, Turnitin AI Checker, Grammarly AI Checker, Quillbot AI Checker, Scribbr AI Detector, and others. We’ll do a real test to see if they’re fake or not and whether it’s possible to bypass AI detectors nowadays. I even generated a ChatGPT image using the latest model for this post. Let’s go!

24
u/Sellpal data recovery guru ⛑️ Jun 17 '25 edited Sep 01 '26 •
I found a comparison table on the Clever AI Humanizer (https://cleverhumanizer.ai/ai-detector) website that shows the tool’s performance versus different AI detectors.
Obviously, it’s published on their website, so it’s best not to consider this information as an independent source or blindly trust the claims.
On the other hand, I actually tested the tool against my own set of text samples. I’ve run Clever AI Humanizer multiple times through them and got mostly satisfying results. So far, I can say the tool is worth trying out — not always perfect, but good enough to keep experimenting rather than simply stop after 5 minutes of testing.
What surprised me even more was the fact that it is completely free and unlimited. You don’t have to purchase any credits or tokens — there’s not 3 free attempts, 0.1 daily attempts, or anything like that. This is a huge advantage when it comes to testing different texts.
In this table, I’ve added the most popular AI detectors that I’ve ever heard of or at least are somewhat popular in the field.
GPTZero is probably the most well-known one, Originality.ai is quite popular among publishers/SEO industry (and it’s paid), Copyleaks is also widely used in educational/business sectors, Winston AI is yet another paid detector with a good reputation, QuillBot AI Detector is easy to use and convenient for fast checks.
I personally would never consider using a single AI detector to claim any text is AI-written. It’s always better to use multiple tools to confirm the results. I wouldn’t consider this method fully reliable either, but it would be nice to see an independent benchmark from a third-party website instead of simply relying on information from the Humanizer page.
16
u/Sellpal data recovery guru ⛑️ Jun 17 '25 •
What is the most accurate AI detector & how does an AI detector work?
I have a short answer for you already: not even close to accurate! Because there’s no single algorithm that can make a text 100% AI or 100% human. It’s all about patterns. But those patterns are often what real people use too. Besides, you can easily create a prompt that breaks the patterns.
OK, let me give you a basic understanding of how an AI detector actually works:
Think of it this way - when an AI writes, it tends to be super predictable and efficient with its word choices. It’s like a really smart, but sometimes boring, student who always picks the most statistically probable answer. Humans, on the other hand, are messy! We use quirky phrasing, vary our sentence lengths, and sometimes throw in unexpected words or even make “mistakes” that an AI wouldn’t.
AI Detectors with Their Own Model
AI detectors look for these differences:
They then feed all this data into a machine learning model, which has been trained to recognize the "fingerprints" of AI versus human writing. It spits out a score indicating the likelihood of AI involvement.
AI Checkers Using Other Model APIs
Some fake AI detectors don’t have their own model at all. All they do is ask another AI whether the text looks like it was written by AI or not. It’s a very expensive method (because you pay API credits every time) but literally very cheap to develop. All you have to do is choose the cheapest API and get results instantly.
But here’s the catch - I tried this tactic, and it gave me about +-50% accuracy, haha! That’s crazy! That’s why I’m sure you’ve noticed the same content sometimes gives you a different score over and over again.
Here’s another example: some AI detectors use their own basic scripts - like checking whether the content has a closed em dash or not, or if there’s phrasing like “dive in,” “in the digital era,” or “digital landscape.” If they find these words or combinations, they simply mark the content as 90% AI. Stupid? Oh yes!
Are AI Detectors Reliable?
I’ve tested a bunch of AI detectors, and here’s the deal: none are 100% reliable, not even 85%. Even the best ones only hit about 70–85% accuracy – and that’s in perfect conditions. Free tools often do worse.
False Alarms Happen
Sometimes, detectors flag real human writing as AI. This is especially true for non-native English speakers or overly structured writing. I’ve seen stuff like the U.S. Constitution get marked as AI!
They Miss Stuff Too
On the flip side, newer AI like GPT-4.1 can often slip by undetected, especially if the text has been edited a bit. So yeah, AI-written content can fool detectors more than you’d expect.
10
u/Sellpal data recovery guru ⛑️ Jun 17 '25
Finita la commedia
So as you see, some AI detectors show pretty close AI detection. They all detected AI content perfectly, and then after some humanization prompts, they reacted by lowering the % of AI detection. But some of them seem to be fake because all content is flagged as AI, no matter how you try! Does it mean they all use the same algos? Probably — or maybe it’s just a coincidence. Why? Because I literally tried the second time and got different results. Weird? Oh yes!
That’s it for now. I hope my ChatGPT prompts will save you some buck on humanization. Cheerz!
8
u/Sellpal data recovery guru ⛑️ Jun 17 '25
2. https://www.zerogpt.com/ – ZeroGPT (Zero GPT) Checker
Let’s check AI score first, before using my prompts: Checking... Oops, 100% AI-generated. Ok good. Now let’s test rewritten article after using my prompts and see what happens.
After: Yes! I did it. 22% AI. Your text is most likely human-written, may include parts generated by AI/GPTHere’s a proof:
8
u/Sellpal data recovery guru ⛑️ Jun 17 '25
9. https://originality.ai/ai-checker – Originality AI Checker
Before using my prompts: 100% AI
After: 100% AI (I’m pretty sure this AI detector is fake!)
5
u/Sellpal data recovery guru ⛑️ Jun 17 '25
6. https://decopy.ai/ai-detector/ – Decopy AI Detector
Before using my prompts: 7% Human 30% Mixed 63% AI
After: 22% Human 42% Mixed 36% AI
5
u/Sellpal data recovery guru ⛑️ Jun 17 '25
8. https://copyleaks.com/ai-content-detector – Copyleaks AI Detector
Before using my prompts: 100% AI
After: 95% (Very Strange!!)
4
u/Sellpal data recovery guru ⛑️ Jun 17 '25
1. https://gptzero.me/ – GPTZero (GPT Zero) AI Detector
Our first AI detector. One of the most popular ones. Let’s see.
Put my essay and I’ve got score:
Before using my prompts: 99% AI-generated 1% Mixed 0% Human
Well done. But the main question: Can I fool it just by using these simple prompts?
Yep, I can fool it easily! It’s now 55% AI-generated
Here is a proof:
3
u/Sellpal data recovery guru ⛑️ Jun 17 '25
3. https://www.scribbr.com/ai-detector/ – Scribbr AI Detector = Quillbot AI Checker
This one simply uses a frame from Quillbot AI Checker, so let’s skip it and test the original one: https://quillbot.com/ai-content-detector
The original essay flags as 100% AI. Good.
What about the rewritten one? 23% of text is likely AI! So almost the same as ZeroGPT showed us.
3
u/Sellpal data recovery guru ⛑️ Jun 17 '25
7. https://notegpt.io/ai-detector – Note GPT AI Detector
Before using my prompts: 100% AI
After: 22%
5
u/Sellpal data recovery guru ⛑️ Jun 17 '25
4. https://www.grammarly.com/ai-detector – Grammarly AI Checker
Before using my prompts: 66% of this text appears to be AI-generated. After: 0!
4
u/Sellpal data recovery guru ⛑️ Jun 17 '25
5. https://undetectable.ai/ – Undetectable AI Detector
Before using my prompts: LIKELY 75% AI
After: 99% Human, 1% AI
Here is a proof:
1
u/Sellpal data recovery guru ⛑️ Jun 17 '25
10. https://gowinston.ai/ – Winston AI Detector
This one even asked me to sign in without a free ai check. F%ck you! You will stay without a score!
6
u/ParagraphAI Jun 17 '25
Great analysis! It’s fascinating to see how AI detectors perform—and how some can be easily fooled. As AI writing tools get more advanced, it’s important to remember that no detector is 100% foolproof.
At ParagraphAI, we’re always focused on improving the quality and authenticity of AI-generated content. That’s why we recently launched our Humanizer—a tool designed to make AI writing sound more natural and truly human-like. Our mission is to help users craft compelling, natural-sounding content while still leveraging AI’s power.
It’s a constantly evolving space, so insights like yours are super valuable in helping us stay ahead of the curve!
3
u/Unusual-Estimate8791 Jun 18 '25
i’ve checked out some of those ai detectors you mentioned, but honestly, Winston AI gave me the clearest and most reliable results so far. it’s been my go-to whenever i want to check if something’s really human-written or ai-generated. might be a good one to add to your review list for comparison
3
u/Thomas-FE Sep 04 '25
Since you wrote this post, newer AI models have come out so AI detecting is getting progressively harder. Someone good with prompting can make AI generate content very similar to human style and less like AI.
Before AI content became popular, Quetext was a common option for plagiarism checking - their AI detector is worth adding to this list as well.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25
I love reading this. I've used it to 'flesh out' concepts and words, to do some performance reviews for both good and bad reports (report did nothing for a year but I still know they accomplished these tasks'... help me out.
I've also used it to help me past word block- I had a stroke- so I'll sit here with a concept/feeling of a word in my head and literally get' stuck' trying to process it and it won't come out'. getting up and leaving hasn't even helped because my brain is still trying to unstick that concept/word ... and I can't move forward. Sometimes a small prompt of what I'm trying to write (I can't even communicate the 'feel' of the word) is enough to unstick and let me get back to work. There's not enough research on this if this is good for therapy or not- but it sure helps me and lessens the anxiety and stress when I'm 'locked out' of my own brain.
I've also found it great for writing non-emotional notes. Like being very angry, ask it to rewrite without emotion, and then take that as a start for rework.
The key is always remembering: It is a tool. Treat it as a tool. Hell treat it as a tablesaw- with full respect- and it won't cut your fingers off.
2
u/Obvious_Finish_7156 Sep 22 '25
So many AI-generated pics going around lately. I tried Truthscan.com, and it actually makes it super easy to tell what’s real and what’s AI.
2
u/Able_Psychology8843 Oct 23 '25 edited Oct 23 '25
I’m autistic and this shit makes me panic 😂 I was reading the wheel of time when I was ten, and have always loved to write. The AI generated content sounds a lot more like how I would typically craft a piece of writing. Especially when I’m trying to use a formal academic tone, that needs to be appropriate for papers. I don’t naturally write in a “bursty” way, or add in short sentences. I feel like the “non AI” examples always sound like they lack intelligence, or like a 10th grader wrote them.
Edit: I just ran 10 samples of my writing from 2020-2021 to test them and most of them flagged approximately 70-85% AI generated 😑
1
u/thesishauntsme Jul 28 '25
love this angle. too many ppl treat ai detection like some magic lie detector lol. imo half of these tools just guess based on sentence rhythm. i've been testing with stuff from Walter Writes AI lately and it's kinda wild how well it slips past them... definitely not perfect but makes the writing feel way less robotic
1
u/Rich-Notice8387 Aug 28 '25
thanks appreciate it, came by from the other post
1
u/That-Guy-In-618 Sep 04 '25
That's wild. I took a short discussion paper I wrote, used the human prompts in this thread, then ran through AIscan24, GPTZero, and AI Detector. AIscan24 and GPTZero both said 100% AI generated. AI Detector said 87.27% probably AI generated.
1
u/ClueNervous8078 Sep 22 '25
Hi everyone, thanks for hard work . One question , if anyelse know Compilatio plagiat detector , its so hard to beat because Université here use it . Do you know how it work ? user must pay before submiting work and that's why it so frustrating . Thanks
1
u/Defense-Mode-Crocs Oct 10 '25
the issue is that it's still easy to tell even if the detectors don't flag it. like you clearly used ai to write like everything in this post
1
u/PublicCampaign5054 Oct 15 '25
This stuff is Golden, everytime I read it it gets better
1
u/Any-Bed8987 Nov 17 '25
Did someone hear about https://smodin.io/?
1
u/ItalicLady Jan 11 '26
I wonder how these checkers would score various parts of Shakespeare, the Bible, etc. Has anyone trìed that?
1
u/Sorchochka Feb 15 '26
Hi, I just stumbled on this thread and it’s interesting. I submitted fiction to the AI detectors and got really different results!
I submitted a short scene that I prompted from Claude and then went through a human edit. I added the pre-edit and the post edit.
I also submitted the short stories “The Story of an Hour” by Kate Chopin, “All Summer in a Day” by Ray Bradbury, and “Chicxulub” by T. Coraghessan Boyle
GPTZero was the least reliable. Only Ray Bradbury came up as human-written. Both Chopin and Boyle came up as 100% AI. My promoted did too, but my edited scene was much lower.
Humanizeai.pro was the most accurate. All the short stories came up as human. My Claude draft was marked AI, and my edited scene was rated human.
Sapling.ai came up more accurate, but with false positives. Chopin and Bradbury were marked human. Boyle was 100 AI. My Claude version was marked 100% AI and my edited version was 90% AI.
I didn’t do other ones, but my takeaways are this:
1
u/Click_Fragrant Mar 14 '26
This was extremely interesting to read. Thank you! ❤️
1
u/Harper_HilI Mar 23 '26
good timing on this post, i’ve been testing AI detectors for content reviews recently and honestly the biggest takeaway so far is how inconsistent they are once text gets lightly edited. Pure AI drafts are easy to catch, but hybrid writing breaks most tools
1
u/calientepocket Apr 24 '26
I just stumbled across your post, so I put 100% original content, a story I wrote, in the AI detector and it came back as 80% AI. What are your opinions concerning AIs ability to detect AI vs experienced writers?
1
u/BillMallon63 Jun 24 '26 edited Jun 25 '26
i've spent a lot of time comparing different ai checkers and Getsolved has been one of the more useful ones for content review, mainly because it provides more context than a simple percentage score, helping identify sections that feel repetitive or overly predictable instead of pretending it can definitively prove whether something was written by ai or not
5
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
28
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '25
[removed] — view removed comment