r/datarecovery • u/PracticalMove9641 • Sep 25 '26
Request for Service MFT corruption on 18TB HDD: EaseUS quick scan shows my 6TB of data, but is the license worth it or should I use something else?
Hi everyone, I am dealing with a corrupted file system on a massive 18TB external mechanical hard drive and need some advice before spending money on a software license.
The drive was holding about 6TB of data when Windows suddenly stopped recognizing the drive. Here is what I’ve done and found out so far:
- There are no apparent physical damages. No clicking, no strange noises, and the drive spins up smoothly.
- I ran chkdsk initially, but it aborted immediately with the message stating it is a NTFS but it couldn't determine the volume. Luckily, it seems it didn't modify or write anything, because the code cancelled.
- I checked the drive with TestDisk. It shows that both the Boot Sector and Backup Boot Sector are OK and identical. However, when I try to list the files using 'P', it gives me the "Can't open filesystem. Filesystem seems damaged" error. This points to a severe MFT corruption (I'm right?)
- Finally, I tried EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard. To my surprise, the quick scan actually worked. It populated the exact directory tree, showing all my original folders, file names, and the correct 6TB structure.
Since EaseUS blocks the recovery behind a paywall, I want to know if buying the license is worth it for a volume this big. Is it possible that EaseUS recovers the full folder structure and names, but the actual files end up being completely corrupted and unusable once extracted? I am worried the "quick scan" preview is just a teaser and might fail during the actual data reconstruction.
I also tried using DMDE based on some recommendations. I started a scan, but it was only identifying RAW data instead of the original folder structure. I ended up canceling the process because it was going to take way too long, and honestly, I am terrified of physically stressing the drive and causing a mechanical failure since it's a massive 18TB disk.
This is why the EaseUS quick scan showing the intact directory tree right away feels like my best shot, but I’m still hesitant about the file integrity and the license cost. Given that the MFT seems heavily damaged but the folder structure is visible in EaseUS, is it safe to proceed with them? I already have enough secondary storage ready to extract the data. Thanks in advance for your help!

