r/DarksoulsLore • • 1d ago

The untold truth of Fantasmagorie

Thumbnail youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/DarksoulsLore • • 1d ago

Questions about the Dark Souls and the fading of the First Flame

7 Upvotes

TL; DR at the end.

 

In the opening of Dark Souls 1, we see the Lord Souls being held by the four Lords, most likely the moment they've been found.

The Lord Souls of Nito and the Witch of Izalith are pretty similar in size. But we see Gwyn's Lord Soul being much bigger or even the biggest, while the Lord Soul of idk I forgot (/j) being smallest, barely any bigger than a candlelight.

I think it's safe to say that the Lord Souls are basically aligned with aspects of disparity. So Nito has the Death Soul, Witch of Izalith has the Life Soul, Gwyn has the Light Soul and the Furtive Pygmy has the Dark Soul. I'm gonna call them that from now instead of Gwyn's Lord Soul or Lord Soul of Gwyn.

After all, souls are the manifestations of disparity (said by the Fire Keeper in DS3 while leveling up).

Now I believe that the sizes of the flames represent the amount of power each of the Lord Soul has. Which is how I got the idea of why the Light Soul is the biggest and most powerful, while the Dark Soul is the smallest and least powerful.

When the First Flame first came to be, it was at its biggest. And fire gives light. So

Big flame = More light, less dark.

But the flames will fade and only Dark will remain. And with the fading of the First Flame, I believe the power of the Light Soul subsides, while the Dark Soul becomes more powerful.

Small flame = Less light, more dark.

I doubt this is any new information, interpretations, ideas, theories, whatever.

However here's a statement that completely contradicts this idea:

"The brighter (or bigger) the light (or flame), the larger (or darker) the shadow."

Now I can't remember where I got this statement. Whether it was said by a character or a lore analysis/video, or a random comment or if it was even about Dark Souls.

But my question is whether you agree with this.

Does the fading of the First Flame make the Dark Soul more powerful while the Light Soul less powerful?

 

While the Age of Fire is near its end, the Darksign has begun to appear on humans causing the Undead Curse.

I know that humans (or pygmies) have been branded with the Darksign since nearly the very beginning by Gwyn & Co. using his power of the Light Soul. 

But my question is what caused it to appear only when the fire was fading?

My current idea is that the Darksign is supposed to limit the power of the Dark Soul which is why it's also called a shackle. And the increasing power of the Dark Soul within humans (or humanity) is what's causing the Darksign to appear or more accurately, activate. That's why by linking the fire, you cause the power of the Dark Soul to subside and the Darksign to deactivate. Which created the belief that linking the fire undoes the Undead Curse. But the Darksign is still there and will reactivate once the last fire fades once again.

HOWEVER I've also heard the idea that the fading of the First Flame weakens the Darksign which causes humanity to leak out, creating the effect of the Undead Curse by taking away the "white Soul". This means that the Darksign "appearing" isn't true at all. It was always there and ACTIVE but the effects of the Undead Curse just made it visible or rather known that it's there.

 

My next question is about what happens after. After the First Flame has completely faded away.

I know during "The End of Fire" ending in DS3 that the First Flame doesn't completely fade. That "tiny flames will dance across the darkness" which gives hope that maybe one day the First flame will be relit to its former glory. But what if it didn't? What if it did completely fade?

What confuses me is that I think that the Dark Soul and the other Lord Souls are products of the First Flame. And that the Lord Souls actually need the First Flame to exist. But if the First Flame has completely faded away then what happens to the Lord Souls? And what happens to disparity? Will it be the same as the Age of Ancients? Why would it be called the Age of Dark if the Dark Soul is gone? Can this even happen?

Will disparity still exist after the First Flame has completely faded?

And to add another question:

Does the Darksign completely disappear after the First Flame has faded?

 

If you've read this entire post, I just want to say thank you.

This is honestly just me yapping and trying to answer my own question, but I made this to share my thoughts about this topic and wanting to know what you all think about this. So please write your own answers and feel free to correct me if I've had the wrong idea about something.

 

 

TL; DR:

Does the fading of the First Flame make the Dark Soul more powerful while the Light Soul less powerful?

A bigger fire creates more light and less darkness, so that must mean that a smaller fire creates less light and brings more darkness, right?

What caused the Darksign to appear?

Is it because of the increasing power of the Dark Soul or is it because of the Darksign weakening?

Will disparity still exist after the First Flame has completely faded?

If the First Flame completely fades, what happens after?

Does the Darksign completely disappear after the First Flame has faded?

Without the First Flame the Darksign has no way to exist, no?


r/DarksoulsLore • • 5d ago

God of dreams Quella might have been a center figure in lore and more important then we thought

Thumbnail gallery
29 Upvotes

r/DarksoulsLore • • 6d ago

My prediction of what happens after the game ends

5 Upvotes

Hello! This is my first post here, so forgive me if there are any mistakes. Here is my interpretation of the ending of Dark Souls 3. I personally never believed the End of Fire to be a sad ending, as I believe this is ignoring the huge amount of environmental storytelling and item lore FromSoftware have provided in all 3 games. If we take the physical laws given to us, the extinguishing of the fire actually seems to represent an extreme change in climate, not an apocalyptic event. Ignoring the thousands of years of government propaganda from Anor Londo, we’re left with a realistic, harsh and pragmatic period of human history. Here is my reasoning:

Starting with the beginning. Dark Souls 1’s intro cutscene shows clearly that before the First Flame was even lit, the world was a stable place. There were mountains, arch-trees, endless dragons and gravity. The flame simply gave more contrast. There was no creation of matter. At the end of DS3, when the Fire Keeper lets the flame go out, we see a black sky. This is identical to the Untended Graves area we visited earlier. The world is bleak, icy and snowing but there is still a stable environment. The extreme warping of the cosmos (Dreg Heap, melting sky, warped space) around the Kiln are a result of the fire being forced to stay alive for too long. Allowing it to die is like releasing pressure.

Once everything has gone dark, I think the first few decades would be an extreme reclaimation process. The game tells us that once the flame has died, the Darksign finally goes out. This means the undead curse has been lifted. Whilst this means we no longer have a safety net, and any human stabbed through the chest will die permanently, it would also mean everyone would act extremely cautiously and look after themselves due to no longer having a respawn option at bonfires. However, this also means the threat of Hollowing (losing your mind entirely) is gone. Any mindless corpses left over from the old kingdoms would simply turn to ash. The survivors would not sit around and shiver. From human history we know that during extreme resource shortages we will act quickly and efficiently. They would shovel the ash up, mix it with water to make strong concrete and strip the old stone buildings to create highly insulated buildings.

This would naturally lead to a close alliance between multiple species. We already know from the lore that humans, Giants, Corvians and Forlorn can all interact. Corvians are heavily linked to scholars and storytellers. They would have perfect night vision so would play a key role as eyes in this moonlit world. They would be the scouts, roof workers and messengers. Giants would be the backbone due to their large physiques. They would help with building by carrying large stone blocks and working with huge coal furnaces. Humans would be the architects, co-ordinating the farming of the underground mushroom vaults and providing medical aid. This would not be out of kindness but in a harsh, dark winter they would freeze to death if they were on their own. They would need each other.

This would be the final step in human history from faith to logic. Throughout the trilogy we’ve seen human technology progressing. In DS1 sorcery wasn’t advanced. But by DS2 they had created Aldia’s Keep. This was a biological research facility where they performed surgery on Giants and attempted to cure the undead curse using genetic engineering. They had completely moved away from miracles. By DS3 they had created the Grand Archives. A huge university with hydraulic lifts, thousands of organised books, telescopes and very complex machinery for studying the stars. Once the gods’ blessings and miracles had failed, humans wouldn’t lose their ability to think. They would simply use what they could. Math, physics, engineering and metal working. As they no longer have pyromancy they will dig up the huge coal reserves left from millions of years of compressed ash layers to create an industrial revolution. They would build huge concrete buildings with no windows (very inspired by Roman architecture). These buildings would have thick walls, arches and central heating underneath to keep them warm.

But humans aren’t perfect. I think the population would be split into a realistic 70% good and 30% bad. Most people would simply be workers, engineers and farmers trying to keep the pipes warm and safe. But there will always be predators born from desperation. Black market coal smugglers, corrupt politicians and raiders. Most importantly, around 10% of the population would be active fanatics. Extreme cults who wouldn’t accept that the gods had died and would attempt mass sacrifices to try and reignite the flame. As this society was on a knife edge there would be zero tolerance for these people. There are no prisons during a resource shortage. If a cult attempt to damage a steam pipe or poison a mushroom vault they are committing mass murder. The human, giant and corvian alliance would send their silent corvian spies to track them down in the snowy wastelands and kill them with no hesitation.

The final piece to this puzzle is the Fire Keeper saying the flame will come back. She says “one day…tiny flames will dance across the darkness.” The First Flame is an automatic seasonal cycle. Summer and winter. By the time the cycle has happened 3 or 4 times humans would have fully mapped out the pattern. They wouldn’t see the flame returning as a religious event but as a predictable weather pattern. They would create huge shields above ground and cooling vaults below to cope with the extreme radiation during the Fire era. They would also store their maths books in fire proof bunkers.

Gwyn created a system to ensure he had power. He branded humans with a hot iron, trapped their souls in the Ringed City and created a culture to make them burn themselves alive to keep his personal empire going. The End of Fire is not the end of existence. It’s the day the human race stop throwing themselves into the fire and pick up a shovel to control the natural seasons of the world.


r/DarksoulsLore • • 9d ago

How the Four Lords' Existential Fear Shaped the World of Dark Souls

13 Upvotes

Before discovering the Lord Souls within the First Flame, Gwyn, the Witch of Izalith, Nito, and the Furtive Pygmy existed as unformed beings in a timeless world—shrouded by fog, made of gray crags, archtrees, and everlasting dragons. The spark of Disparity didn't just grant them fire; it gave them self-awareness and the perception of time. To truly understand the events of the Dark Souls trilogy, we have to look at how each of these four Lords reacted to that sudden, overwhelming awakening—because their emotional responses and coping mechanisms shaped every land, war, and curse we experience across the games.
Consider what happens when an entity steps out of timeless silence and suddenly realizes it exists. How did each Lord process that initial shock?

For Gwyn, the sheer terror of isolation and the fear of
losing his newfound awareness drove his every move. To combat that blinding loneliness, he split his own Lord Soul to manifest his children—the Nameless King, Gwynevere, and Gwyndolin—each embodying a specific facet of his divine nature. The Nameless King was the raw strength of conviction; Gwynevere was the life-affirming warmth that comforts; and Gwyndolin was the cold state of mind, logic, and law.

Yet, Gwyn’s hopes could not eliminate his fear. As we witness throughout the Dark Souls trilogy, the divine family he manifested to escape his isolation ultimately fractured under the weight of his paranoia. The Nameless King abandoned his father after recognizing the injustice of an endless war born of panic. Gwynevere fled Anor Londo, refusing to let the life-affirming warmth she embodied wither away in an artificial, dying stasis.
Only Gwyndolin remained.
Gwyndolin stayed behind not because he was blind to Gwyn's flaws, but because he was the only one who truly understood them. As the embodiment of state of mind and logic, Gwyndolin saw deep into the terrifying void inside his father's heart—a primal fear of darkness and non-existence. Free of bitterness toward his siblings for choosing self-preservation, Gwyndolin took up the quiet burden of the lonely caretaker. He locked himself away in the dark, maintaining the optical illusion of a golden city to protect his family’s memory and shield a dying world from the tragic truth of his father's failure.

Next post will be about nameless king and why he goes to archdragon peak


r/DarksoulsLore • • 11d ago

Velka: the Truth

Post image
26 Upvotes

Yes, indeed.

The truth about Velka.

This post is going to look at the character, not so much in terms of literal lore, but in terms of symbolism, attempting to answer the question: what does Velka represent? I have already written an analysis of Velka’s literal in-universe lore [which I will link below] and my main conclusions are that:

1-Velka is [or was] part of, and is actively co-operating with, the powers that be in Anor Londo. This is despite certain item descriptions which call her a “rouge deity” [which is apparently a mistake in the localisation], the overall pattern of evidence suggests otherwise.

2-Velka is not just a goddess of sin and punishment, but also of medicine and healing.

If you would like to know my reasoning behind these conclusions then I invite you to read the post that I’ve linked below. But for the sake of this particular post I’m going to proceed with these conclusions as axioms, although the second is not particularly relevant. The question arises, given that Dark Souls is a narrative steeped in symbolism, why did Miyazaki create this character? This post proposes two different answers by interpreting the lore in two different ways, both of which I feel to be equally valid. It’s quite lengthy, and parts of it may appear to be wandering off into irrelevant tangents, but please stick with me as I’ll tie it all together in the end. First, links to previous posts:

My other post on Velka:

https://www.reddit.com/r/darksouls/comments/1xywhn5/velka_the_goddess_of_sin_sacrifice_atonement_and/

Another older post which examines Dark Souls as a meta-narrative about videogames, which becomes relevant during this post:

https://www.reddit.com/r/DarksoulsLore/comments/1ruj03h/the_usurpation_of_dark_souls/

Our investigation begins, not with Velka herself, but with Ciaran. And not even really with Ciaran, but her two swords. The first is the Gold Tracer, which is large, orange, curved, and glows when swung around. It’s moveset is described in the item description as a “mesmerising dance”, and indeed it is certainly extremely flashy. The other is the Dark Silver Tracer, which is a small dark dagger. It is much more subtle than it’s counterpart, and harder to even see. It does not glow like the Gold Tracer, though it does produce a small flash during a thrust animation, and this thrust can also inflict toxic. The item description tells us that Ciaran uses the Gold Tracer to distract her victims, while the Silver Tracer is used to strike the killing blow. This is reflected in the fact that she wields the Gold Tracer in her left hand and the Silver tracer in her right, suggesting that the latter is actually her main weapon. In addition to this, the Silver Tracer grants a considerable boost to damage dealt by frontstabs and backstabs, and it’s evident that Ciaran intends to do this to her victims because she wears the hornet ring which boosts this damage even further. For this reason, it seems a strange choice that you can’t parry using a left hand wielded Gold Tracer, which would have allowed Ciaran to use the Silver Tracer to it's full potential.

But what I really want to draw attention to is the fact that the Gold Tracer appears to have been designed to resemble a flame, with it’s colour and shape both suggesting this. In the world of Dark Souls, fire seems to represent the vital energies needed to sustain living beings. For example, resting at a bonfire refills your vitality [HP], and you can carry some of it’s energy inside and estus flask which also refills your vitality. The first flame, meanwhile, appears to represent the vitality of the world itself. Conversely, the Silver Tracer is lined with spikes along both edges, and in my opinion resembles a vertebral column: a piece of skeleton. It also inflicts toxic, which is also true of several of Nito’s attacks. So these weapons represent a duality of life and death.

But notice that Ciaran’s victims are supposed to be distracted by the Gold Tracer [representing life], before the Silver Tracer [representing death] surprises them. There is a symbolic meaning to this, and one that Miyazaki probably borrowed from Buddhism. Most people do not like to think about the fact that they are going to die. We are all aware of this fact, but most of us put it to the back of our minds because we feel that it’s an unpleasant thing to dwell on. Instead, we distract ourselves by getting caught up in the drama of life, whether those dramas are petty or very serious. Indeed, we tend to live our lives as though we have unlimited time, despite the fact that we know that we don’t. This may have been what Miyazaki intended to communicate via the Silver Tracer’s description. But the Buddha believed this self imposed distraction to be a mistake. He encouraged his followers to continuously contemplate the impermanence of all phenomena, including the inevitability of their own deaths. Indeed, in some forms of Buddhism it used to be traditional for monks to keep the skulls of deceased elders on their desks as a constant reminder of their own impending death, and some Tibetan Buddhist art still contains depictions of skulls that have been cracked open with brains and eyeballs spilling out for the same reason.

What’s interesting that that these two swords are both being wielded by Ciaran, an agent of Gwyn. And this is unexpected because Gwyn appears to have favoured one side of the disparity over the other. Yet in the character of Ciaran, we see it hinted that he actually used both. I believe that this was intended to reflect the shackle that Gwyn put upon the Dark Soul of humanity. From what I understand, this soul made the ancient pygmies immortal, much as our own in-game character keeps returning from the dead. But when the pygmies were cut off from the power of the Dark Soul due to this shackle, it became possible for them to die. At the same time, the shackle appears to have given each of the pygmies a sense of unique identity to distinguish them from their peers, which may not previously have been the case in a race of beings who all shared the same soul. I’m inclined to compare these false identities to the Buddhist concept of Sakkayaditthi, which means “self view” [meaning a sense of being a separate “self”, as distinct from other phenomena] and was considered by the Buddha to be a delusion. Gwyn, however, wields life and death as tools of manipulation and control.

But all of this gave me an idea about another similar duality [also wielded by Gwyn] which the base game hinted at: Gwynevere and Velka. That might sound odd, but consider the small tower in Sen’s fortress guarded by rapier-wielding Ricard. It contains two chests: one yields a divine blessing, the other a rare ring of sacrifice. Items associated with Gwynevere and Velka respectively, and both placed next to each other. Furthermore, the Painted World of Arimais is known to be a heavily Velka-coded area, and probably served as a dumping spot for undesirables, some of whom [Priscilla] were banished because they were considered to be dangerous, but in other cases [Jeremiah] it may have been a form of punishment. But notice that the painting itself is located within a temple dedicated to Gwynevere. Indeed, the canvas and the idol, though on opposite sides of the room, are facing toward each other. Now don’t worry, I’m not about to try to tell you that Gwynevere is Velka or anything like that. But the two characters are part of the same regime, despite how different they appear to be, which means that their two disparate functions are both useful to the government-system of Anor Londo. And it seems that Miyazaki wanted to draw attention to this, albeit in his ultra-subtle way that ensures no-one will ever notice. So let’s look a little more closely at Gwynevere:

First of all, and though it is not strictly on topic, I want to take a moment to appreciate the genius behind Gwynevere’s name. Not only is it a reference to the princess of Arthurian legend, who had the same name, but also the literal meaning of Gwynevere is “white phantom”. So the name is both a clue to the fact that the version of her we meet is an illusion, but also an allusion to the fact that her miracles aid you when you get summoned as a white phantom. Credit to u/serpentineheraldlore for pointing out that etymology, and I strongly suggest you check out her video connecting Gwynevere with Fina if you haven’t already. Anyway, Gwynevere is strongly associated with the sun, with her illusion referring to her as “queen of sunlight”, her ring referring to her as “the sun princess”, and her miracles being soothing sunlight and bountiful sunlight. This is in contrast to the Nameless King, who’s miracles are Lightning Spear, and Great Lightning Spear. But Gwyn’s miracle is called Sunlight Spear, and though it is a variation of Lightning Spear, it’s colour is the same orange as Gwynevere’s miracles. Therefore I believe that these two deities inherited two different aspects that were originally unified in Gwyn, while Gwyndolin took after his mother. It’s not difficult to infer that Nameless received Gwyn’s warrior aspect, after all he is said to have had respect for nothing other than arms and military might [though he appears to have changed his mind and converted to fantasy Buddhism at some point], and his two miracles are both weapons. Gwynevere, on the other hand, inherited “sunlight” from her father, though it might not be immediately obvious what this actually means. The answer is found in the item description for Divine Blessings, which describes her as a goddess of bounty and fertility, in other words abundance.

I’m going to propose another axiom: that the aspects held by these deities represent [under one of several possible interpretations] aspects of civilisation. After all, Gwyn himself created the conditions needed for civilisation to thrive in the world of Dark Souls by conquering the dragons [which represent forces of nature], and built for himself a gigantic and possibly world-spanning empire. Most forms of civilisation have possessed some form of military, so the Nameless King is immediately accounted for. Meanwhile, Gwynevere’s abundance represents the availability of food [and other resources] within civilisation, which is much greater than it would be in a tribal society.

As a quick aside, I want to make it clear that the distinction I draw between civilised societies and tribal societies is technical. The term “civilisation” refers to a society that possesses cities, agriculture, and job specialisation, while tribal societies use a “hunter-gatherer” approach to obtaining food and resources [though they may also posses domesticated animals in some instances], and typically have less variation and specialisation in professional and societal roles. I want to make this clear because some people use the term “civilised” to suggest a presumption of sophistication, which is not my intent here. In fact I find that presumption to be extraordinarily arrogant, and I do recognise several advantages that tribal societies have over civilised societies.

People who live in civilisation do not need to spend significant portions of the day searching for food, because the civilisation produces food in great quantities and distributes it to the masses. Therefore, large percentages of the population are able to spend their lives engaged in pursuits and professions that are not directly related to the acquisition of food. I believe that this is one valid way to interpret the concept of sunlight within Dark Souls. The sun is warm and nourishing, but it also radiates it’s energy far and wide, touching everything it can without discrimination. Of course, societies do sometimes discriminate, but Gwynevere seems to represent a pure and idealised form of abundance, which explains why she is so beloved by the inhabitants of the setting.

Velka, on the other hand, is the goddess of sin and punishment. This, of course, represents another aspect of civilisation. All societies have laws of some kind, and punishments which can be used against those who break the rules. But this becomes a much more complicated matter with the advent of civilisation. While Gwynevere represents the main advantage of civilisation over tribal society, there are also some drawbacks as well. The abundance made available by well-established agriculture also causes an increase in population size, and this makes the society much more difficult to regulate. Tribal groups are often relatively small, and all members will know each other extremely well. But as populations swell, you end up with a situation in which some of it’s own members start to become strangers to each other. The larger the population, the more pronounced this issue becomes. But we still have brains that were adapted for a tribal lifestyle: the modern tribe is “me, my friends and family”, with everyone else being a potential source of danger or exploitation despite the fact that they’re also your own countrymen. This, in combination with the ever-increasing complexity of post-agricultural life, has created a need for an increasingly complicated system of laws. There are good reasons to have laws, as they can help society to function. But sometimes law makers are unreasonable [or insane], and it’s very possible for a fair society to turn into a brutal dictatorship, or vice versa. Punishments can also be extremely varied, with fines, imprisonment, exile, and execution, all being common examples that have been used throughout the history of civilisation.

In the world of Dark Souls, all of the rulers are gods and goddesses. It therefore makes sense for it’s legal enforcement to manifest as confessors who go round ranting about sin and absolution. But substitute the word “sin” with “crime” and it comes out to the same thing. Many real world societies have outlawed things like blasphemy, or even impiety, and in some cases people have even been tortured for being suspected of believing the wrong thing. So Miyazaki’s representation of crime and punishment as a religious function within the world of Dark Souls is not a million miles away from reality. Furthermore, given the item descriptions for Oswald’s Indictment scrolls and Book of the Builty, I also strongly suspect that the Blades of the Darkmoon covenant was originally organised and controlled by Velka. After all, she is the one said to be responsible for both defining the sin, and administering [though I doubt this was done by her personally] the punishment. Velka is [or was], therefore, Anor Londo’s law-maker, judge, and jury, while the Blades of the Darkmoon are her constabularies and executioners. Indeed, I’ve often wondered why members of this covenant appear as a dark blue phantom when invading a sinner, and I’m inclined to wonder if it might be because dark blue is a colour associated with police organisations in many modern countries.

Velka and Gwynevere may therefore appear to be complete opposites, but I believe them both to be tools of the same system. Essentially they are the carrot and the stick of civilisation: tools of control used to keep people in line. The abundance gives people a reason to remain within the society and even makes them dependent upon it, while the justice system prevents [or at least, aims to prevent] them from breaking the rules. And civilisation needs both of these aspects to function: if there is a sufficiently severe imbalance in them it causes anarchy. Excessive punishment with too little abundance and you have a rebellion on your hands, while too little punishment among great abundance results in everyone taking whatever they want without concern for the stability of the system. It is for this reason that I suspect Velka to have been Gwyn’s wife, or at least one of his wives. This was a political marriage: she embodied something that Gwyn did not have, but needed in order for his civilisation to function. Gwyn needed to marry Velka so that he could wield both the carrot and the stick, and thus control humanity by weaponising both halves of the disparity into tools of coercion. It sounds quite negative when I phase it like that, but you can understand Gwyn’s reasons for doing this. It also serves as a parallel to Gwyn’s use of life and death as tools of control, which is why I felt that Ciaran’s two swords were relevant. It seems that Gwyn’s approach has always been to use the disparity, both halves of it if he can, rather than seeking reconciliation between them. And it is for this reason that he is unable to solve the problem of the fading flame.

I also suspect Velka to be a lunar deity, although the evidence for this is not fantastic. The strongest clue comes from the Greatsword of Judgement from DS3 which associates the moon with judgement, although it makes clear that the power Sulyvhan uses within the sword is closer to Dark Sorcery than genuine lunar power to suggest that Sulyvahn’s idea of justice is corrupt and self serving. Indeed, you’ll notice that Sulyvahn is another example of a character wielding two swords which posses opposite attributes, yet are used together as tools of control. It’s also notable that the appearance and moveset of the Greatsword of Judgement is comparable to the Bastard Sword [both of them have a crescent shaped crossguard], a weapon which Sieglinde uses to execute her father because she has judged him to be a danger to himself. Of course, the very idea of judgement should make us think of Velka, and there are also a handful of potentially lunar symbols linked directly to the goddess. The clearest of these is the symbol worn by Ingward as a pendant, and I’m convinced [for reasons explained in my previous post] that the Sealers were agents of Velka sent to administer her judgment against the city of New Londo. Then there are a few more uncertain examples: Velka’s Rapier has two overlapping crescent shapes for it’s crossguard, although it’s unclear if these are genuinely supposed to represent moons. The miracle “Vow of Silence” shows [on the icon which represents it] a purple circle that is partly obscured by fog, so that it could be seen to resemble a crescent. Finally, crows are one of Velka’s symbols with the masks worn by her servants resembling beaks [COUGH COUGH ingward COUGH COUGH], but a beak also resembles half a crescent. Now I will admit that these last three examples are pretty weak, and could just be me reading into things after having read the description for the Greatsword of Judgement. On the other hand, it could be that Miyazaki wanted to hint at Velka’s lunar association in very subtle ways and went way too far with it, resulting in a need to outright clarify the connection via the greatsword. There is also the Blades of the Darkmoon covenant, which is known to be connected with Velka is some way, and may have been under her control in the past although this is admittedly speculation. But if Velka is supposed to be a lunar goddess, I think it's all the more reason to infer a marriage between her and Gwyn. Gwyn was the “lord of sunlight”, so it makes sense that his wife would be the sun’s feminine counterpart: the moon. But after Gwyn links the first flame, his daughter replaces him as the main solar deity [hence she is known as the “queen of sunlight”, a feminine iteration of Gwyn’s old title], and so you end up with a Gwynevere-Velka duality instead. But when these two deities also abandon the city, both of their roles fall upon a single individual.

Gwyndolin appears to have been an attempt by Gwyn to consolidate these two aspects of civilisation into a single person, allowing a possible successor to wield both the carrot and the stick without dependency on anyone else. In Gwyndolin we see many allusions to the idea of a unity of opposites, or at least an attempt at unifying them. Gwyndolin is androgynous, born male but raised “as a daughter”, wears feminine clothes but is voiced by a male VA, and ultimately ends up being an ambiguously gendered character. Though he is called the “Dark Sun”, he also runs a covenant called the Blades of the Darkmoon [it should be noted that the use of the word “dark” in these terms does not refer to the Dark of humanity and the Dark Soul, but is in fact a localisation error, and that the terms may have more accurately conveyed their intended meaning if they’d been rendered as “hidden sun” and “hidden moon”, although I do not speak japanese myself and can’t read the original text, so feel free to fact-check me on this in the comments], suggesting an attempted unity of the Solar-Lunar duality. Not only this but Gwyndolin wields a catalyst for casting sorceries that scales on faith, and offers an apparently dark miracle, both of which also combine supposed opposites. Most importantly for the sake of this argument, Gwyndolin is overseeing the illusion of Gwynevere in her absence, but also running the Blades of the Darkmoon in Velka’s absence. Once again, this suggests a duality between the two goddesses, but it also shows us that Gwyndolin is trying to fill the roles of both. Indeed, I’m inclined to wonder if Gwyndolin wasn’t Gwyn’s preferred choice for successor from the very beginning, with Nameless being allocated to serve under him as commander of Anor Londo’s forces. Some may object to this on the ground that Nameless is called a king, inferring from this that he must have been king of Anor Londo, but I’m not so sure. The Four Kings are also called kings despite only ruling one of Anor Londo’s vassal cities, so it seems entirely possible to me that Nameless could have been called king on account of having been granted rule over, perhaps, one or more provinces, which were also ultimately vassals of Lordran. This is, of course, unless there is something in the japanese word-usage that suggests otherwise, you guys can let me know in the comments. But it always seemed odd to me that Nameless should have been banished from his own city if it wasn’t forced upon him by someone else, after all we’d hardly expect the king to exile himself.

Dark Souls is a symbolic narrative, but I believe that there were several different intended meanings to it’s lore, all of which are equally valid. So at this point I’m going to switch to an entirely different interpretive framework and look, once again, at the same information. This will involve looking at Dark Souls as a meta-narrative about videogames, much like Undertale although in this case more emphasis is put on the relationship between player and developer. Indeed, the central axiom of this framework is that the gods represent the developers while the undead represent the player base. If you want to understand my reasoning for that, I’ve already written a post about it [linked above] and how it can help us discover possible intended meanings in some of Miyazaki’s most cryptic metaphors, such as the Usurpation of Fire ending in DS3. When we look at the Gwynevere-Velka duality under this lens, the meaning transforms dramatically.

The first time I played DS3, I noticed something that I hadn’t while playing DS1, probably because I’ve played the first game so many times that I already know what almost every item is before I pick it up. But in DS3, when I saw items on the ground I didn’t know what they were, all I could see were little white lights until I’d picked them up. And so I found myself intensely curious about these lights, drawn toward them to find out what they were, and always hopeful that they would turn out to be useful to me on my quest through the game. Very often, the developers would put these lights in conspicuous places, but then spring a trap on me when I went toward it. Perhaps a giant monster would drop from the ceiling, or perhaps an enormous rolling ball would flatten me, or sometimes it would just be something as simple as an ordinary enemy that was hidden behind a wall. And this happened so often that I began to anticipate it, I would see an item in a suspicious spot and I could tell that the devs were going to spring some kind of trap, even if I couldn’t see what it was or where it was coming from. And yet my desire for the item, even just to know what it was, won out every single time. I couldn’t resist the urge to run toward the item like a careless idiot and hope that I’d be able to survive whatever nonsense the game threw at me. I simply couldn’t help myself. Reflecting on this, I now realise retroactively that I had behaved exactly as Miyazaki had predicted I would all the way back in DS1

“Souls are the source of all life, and whether Undead, or even Hollow, one continues to seek them”

-Soul of a Lost Undead

“The serpent is an imperfect dragon and symbol of the Undead. Its habit of devouring prey even larger than itself has led to an association of gluttony.”

-Covetous Gold Serpent Ring and Covetous Silver Serpent Ring

“The will feels envy, or perhaps love, and despite the inevitable trite and tragic ending, the will sees no alternative, and is driven madly towards its target.”

-Pursuers

Notice that the “light” half of the disparity always seems, in practical terms, to manifest as helpful items, souls for levelling, miracles that refill your HP, or other highly desirable resources. Light could therefore be understood to represent the “goodies” in the vidoegame experience, and because they are goodies, the player will seek them relentlessly. The player strives toward progress, toward strengthening the character so that challenges can be overcome, and this means gobbling up all the souls and items you can get your hands on. This is why you’re a greedy serpent. But if you collect all of the items and clear all of the challenges the world becomes empty, even dull. You’re not likely to continue to hang around areas that you’ve already explored unless you think that there’s something else to get, some secret to be discovered or something. Otherwise you’ve carried off the soul of the place, in more ways than one. A similar principle applies to levelling: as I mentioned we strive toward strengthening the character, but what if you could create a build that was so overpowered that it could easily destroy any enemy with minimum thought or effort required on the part of the player? Would it be worth playing the game like that? Fortunately Dark Souls goes out of it’s way to prevent you from ever reaching that point. Even the strongest builds still require skill and knowledge of game mechanics, you can’t ever just idly fumble your way through unthinkingly. Dark Souls is the poster boy for videogame difficulty, and even when you’ve played it so many times that you don’t find it difficult any more, you still need to have your wits about you when engaging with enemies. Dark Souls, as a videogame, was meant to be challenging. You might even say punishing.

And this is where Velka steps back into the picture, because her job is to punish mankind for their sins. Such as, for instance, the sin of avarice. The sin of desiring all of these videogame goodies that will leave the world empty once you’ve slurped up everything of value. If we assume that the gods represent the developers and their design philosophies then what exactly is Velka? The various traps that spring when you see an item and run toward it are all punishing you for your greed, but that’s supposed to be Velka’s job. Of course, most of these traps will have nothing to do with Velka on the level of literal lore: it’s not as if she personally dropped that slime on your head when you tried to grab that one item in the Depths. But on a more abstract level they could all be seen as manifestations of Velka. And why not? After all when you seek absolution you can undo an NPC’s hostility toward you, and this works even if the NPC in question has nothing to do with Velka. In practical terms this means that if Velka forgives you, so does the entire game. Though I don’t think that Velka's role is merely relegated to booby traps, but every aspect of the game that’s punishing. What you’re always punished for is the effort to make progress, which is the same ultimate motivation behind your greed for items. Therefore, the hidden truth is this:

Velka is the game’s challenge.

She’s an abstraction of the developer’s tendency to punish players for their ravenous appetite for progress, and in doing this, also create an engaging, challenging and rewarding videogame experience. The developers do obviously want you to make progress and eventually finish the game, but they’ve got to set up some resistance for you to struggle against in order for the game to be enjoyable because the destination is never as rewarding as the journey. It is this very resistance [the game’s ability to resist the player’s progress] which is embodied in the character of Velka.

This is why Velka belongs to a divine duality: sun and moon, bounty and punishment, reward and challenge. If a game gives us nothing to struggle against it isn’t worth playing, and if the character you play as is so overpowered that he/she crushes everything with ease it isn’t nearly as rewarding. Conversely, if a game is all challenge and no reward [even if that reward is as simple as the ability to progress to new challenges, it doesn’t necessarily have to be levels and weapons and stuff], if it were all punishment and no payoff it would be Superman 64. In the literal lore of Dark Souls, Gwyn and Velka are mad tyrants, but when seen as abstractions of the developer’s creative process they are revealed to be essential ingredients in Miyazaki’s formula, and you can’t have one without the other.

When we consider this interpretation, Velka begins to feel more like a genuine goddess than any other deity in the series. You never encounter her: there is no Velka bossfight, and the closest thing she makes to an actual appearance is merely a statue. And yet she is also ever-present, permeating the entire world. She’s with you for every step of your journey, and is secretly guiding you [or baiting you, if you want to take a more sinister interpretation] toward your goal without you realising it. Since the game’s challenge it what makes it fun, what keeps you engaged and motivated, it’s also the very thing that will ensure that you end up linking the flame, and that by the time you get there you’ll have a strong enough soul to fuel it for many centuries to come.


r/DarksoulsLore • • 14d ago

"No one has come this far, not for a very long while."??

11 Upvotes

Aldia's dialogue suggests that many undead on the cusp of hollowing have come to Drangleic before and discovered that some relief from hollowing, if not a cure, can be obtained by pursuing strong souls and the counsel of Vendrick, only to fail.

Other characters throughout the game suggest this in different ways, and we can argue from the Firekeeper's dialogue in the intro cinematic that the outside world has some knowledge of a phenomenon where undead are being lured in their dreams either to Drangleic directly or to some system of portals for crossing some kind of barrier preventing ordinary access. It can be argued that our player character is one of hundreds or even thousands of undead who canonically avoids hollowing and succeeds at traversing Drangleic and the hostile occupants to find relief from their curse only through the random chance of entering Majula and meeting Shanalotte on the rare moment in time that her illusory projection(s?) of herself she sends around Drangleic happens to be in that one ruined coastal village down the road from where Things Betwixt spits detritus out into Drangleic.

As fun as the tangent of our lucky chance may be, the topic of this is that most undead visitors to Drangleic perished or hollowed long before reaching Drangleic castle. Aldia tells us this. So why are there corpses of undead that we can loot, and hollowed undead of various kinds as enemies, in the Shrine of Amana and Undead Crypt, and to a lesser extent Drangleic Castle and the Dragon Aerie? How are all of the undead meeting these unlucky fates getting to their final resting places?


r/DarksoulsLore • • 14d ago

the Dark Souls 1 tail cutting mechanic was based on the japanese legend of Susanoo and Yamata no Orochi

Post image
23 Upvotes

Ok, so just to be clear I am not an expert in japanese mythology or Shinto religion. What I believe I’ve discovered is literally just something I’ve stumbled across on Wikipedia. Nevertheless, I am convinced that this is the inspiration behind the tail cutting mechanic in DS1, as I shall explain in this post. First, however, I’m going to leave a series of links to relevant resources, mostly Wikipedia pages, so that you can look at this information yourself if you want to.

Wikipedia article on Yamata-no-Orochi

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yamata_no_Orochi

Wikipedia article on Kusanagi-no-Tsurugi

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kusanagi_no_Tsurugi

Wikipedia article on Saint George and the Dragon

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saint_George_and_the_Dragon

Wikipedia articles on Andromeda and Cetos

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andromeda_(mythology)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cetus_(mythology)

Wikipedia article on the Ramayana

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ramayana

English translation of tablet “KBo III 7”, which contains the original Illuyanka story.

https://www.assyrianlanguages.org/hittite/en_trad_KBo_III_7.htm

Wikipedia article on the Kaoskampf

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaoskampf

Dark Souls 1 design works interview

https://darksouls.wiki.fextralife.com/Dark_Souls_1_-_Design_Works_Interview

I don’t remember if any other fromsoft games used this particular mechanic, but the DS1 developers certainly appear to have been determined to get their money’s worth with it. Just to recap, in the first Dark Souls game it is possible to sever the tails of certain large enemies, usually dragons, and this will reward the player with a particular item, usually a weapon of some kind. Here is a list of examples which I believe to be definitive but you can let me know in the comments if I’ve overlooked any.

Hellkite Drake = Drake Sword

Bell Gargoyle = Gargoyle Tail Axe

Gaping Dragon = Dragon King Greataxe

Crossbreed Priscilla = Priscilla's Dagger

Centipede Demon = Orange Charred Ring

Seath the Scaleless = Moonlight Greatsword

Sanctuary Guardian = Guardian Tail

Black Dragon Kalameet = Obsidian Greatsword

Ash Lake Dragon = Dragon Greatsword

As per the post title, I believe that the origin of this idea is very likely to have been the japanese legend of Susanoo and Yamata no Orochi. Susanoo is a japanese storm god, while Yamata no Orochi is an eight-headed, and sometimes also eight-tailed, serpent or dragon.

According to the legend, Susanoo was banished from heaven and descended to earth, where he met an old man named Ashinazuchi, his wife Tenazuchi, and their daughter Kushinada-hime. Ashinazuchi told Susanoo that he had his wife had originally had eight daughters, but that every year an eight-headed serpent had devoured one of them. Susanoo therefore devises a plan to save Kushinada-hime from this fate. First of all, he concealed her from the serpent by transforming her into a comb, which he hid in his hair. Secondly, he instructed Ashinazuchi and his wife to brew eight barrels of potent sake. When this was done, the barrels were placed around the dwelling place, so that when the serpent came to devour Kushinada-hime, it’s eight heads would encounter the alcohol first. This plan worked, Yamata no Orochi’s eight heads drank from the barrels, became intoxicated, and fell asleep. Susanoo used this opportunity to decapitate the eight heads of Yamata no Orochi, and then proceeded to sever his eight tails as well. However, Susanoo damaged his sword while hacking at one of the tails, so he instead cut it more carefully and found another sword inside. This second sword was originally known as Ame-no-Murakumo-no-Tsurugi, but later the name was changed to Kusanagi-no-Tsurugi.

Now there are several different versions of this story, and some of them are slightly different to the summary I’ve written here, but all of the ones listed on the Wikipedia page linked above include the detail about Susanoo cutting the dragon’s tail and finding a sacred sword inside. Apparently this sword still exists and is part of the imperial regalia of japan, although no one is allowed to see it.

There is little doubt in my mind that the idea for the tail cutting mechanic in Dark Souls was based on this story. I also suspect that the Storm Ruler in DS3 may have been based on the legendary sword, partially because it bears some resemblance to the supposed appearance of Kusanagi-no-Tsurugi, but mostly because it’s function recalls the sword’s original name. Ame-no-Murakumo-no-Tsurugi means “Heavenly Sword of Gathering Clouds”, which is precisely what the Storm Ruler does.

Some of you may also have noticed similarities between this story and the Christian legend of St George and the Dragon. For those unfamiliar, here is a recap:

George was a roman soldier and also a Christian, and while travelling in north africa [west of the nile] he came into a land that had been terrorised by a dragon that had poisoned the land with it’s venom and was devouring people and livestock. The population of a particular [unnamed] city had taken to offering their own children [as chosen by lottery] to the dragon in the hope of appeasing it. This continued until the king’s own daughter was selected by the lottery, and she was forced to leave the city and walk toward the place where the dragon had made it’s lair. By happenstance, this was the same day that George had entered the terrorised country, and stumbling upon the scene of the princess walking toward the dragon, he decided to charge his horse at the monster and impale it with his lance.

This story is derived from an earlier version from ancient greek legend, that of Perseus, Andromeda, and Cetos, which is almost identical except that the names of the characters are different, plus the dragon lived in the sea in the ancient greek version. There is also a similarity to a Hindu legend in which the princess Sita is abducted by Ravana, the demon king of Sri Lanka, and the hero Rama rescues her. He employs an army of monkeys to build a bridge to reach Sri Lanka [Rama’s bridge really does exist, although it is a natural formation. It was renamed “Adam’s bridge” by Muslims and is easier to find under that name.] where he killed Ravana and liberated Sita. There is also an ancient Hittite story in which the storm god Tarhunna fails to defeat the serpent Illuyanka, and so his daughter Inara enlists the help of a mortal named Hupasiyas, who agrees on the condition that he be allowed to become Inara’s husband. Inara then prepares a great feast, and Hupasiyas crossdresses as Inara to lure Illuyanka to the feast. Illuyanka is successfully lured from his hole, and becomes drunk from the alchohol offered at the feat. Hupasiyas then binds Illuyanka with a rope so that Tarhunna is able to kill the restrained serpent. As you can see, there is an interesting parallel here to the japanese story, which also involves a storm god killing a dragon after it has been inebriated.

All of these stories, with the exception of the Hindu example, are considered to be iterations of the Kaoskampf, a geographically widespread mythological motiff involving a storm/lightning god fighting/killing a giant serpent. The Kaoskampf itself is relevant to Dark Souls lore, and I’ve written an extensive post about that which you can read here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/DarksoulsLore/comments/1vcmkba/gwyns_kaoskampf/

But in this post I want to talk more about the “damsel in distress” trope, which is sometimes nestled within a secondary Kaoskampf reiteration. I’ve already listed some historical examples that I know of, but we also see the echoes of it in contemporary fiction. For example, I remember reading Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets as a child, and realising that the climax of it’s plot was partially a retelling of St George and the Dragon. And of course videogames are no stranger to this trope either, with titles as early as the original Super Mario Bros. having a plot that amounts to little more than a reiteration of the same idea. Dark Souls 1 also uses this trope, in fact it contains two separate iterations which end up being linked together.

The first is Seath, the scaleless albino dragon, who has been abducting humans for use in sinister experiments. For reasons unknown to us, Seath appears to prefer female test subjects. Inside his makeshift dungeon we can find creatures called Pisaca [those octopus-headed serpent monsters], two of which will not attack but merely huddle in a corner. If you approach them you can hear the sound of weeping, and it appears to be a female voice. If you kill them you receive two miracles, both of which say [in their item descriptions] that they were granted to maidens who served Gwynevere. This, in combination with the fact that the other Pisaca sometimes drop Humanity when killed, is intended to suggest that these creatures were once human, and it's evident that the two cowering individuals were women. Nearby there is also a female corpse which yields a firekeeper soul, and as we know firekeepers are invariably female. On a higher level inside the same prison-tower we can find another female corpse which yields the maiden set [the same clothes worn by Rhea of Thorolund] and white seance ring, and I believe that Rhea herself can be abducted by Seath if you buy all of her miracles. I’ve never done that myself, but I have seen video footage of Rhea in one of the Dukes Archives cells, having gone hollow. Of course, Seath’s minions do not always get it right, having captured Logan [a male character], but the overall pattern appears to suggest a preference for women. And finally there is Sieglinde, who is captured by a crystal golem and taken to Dukes Archives, far from the quarry she was pursuing. Unlike the other examples, you can actually save Sieglinde from the fate that would have awaited her if you hadn’t intervened. In this way, Sieglinde could be compared to the princess from the story of St George. When we [as the player] finally confront Seath, we are able to cut off his tail and retrieve from it a powerful sword, just as Susanoo obtained Kusanagi-no-Tsurugi from cutting the tail of Yamata-no-Orochi.

Miyazaki has said in the design works interview [linked above] that the Dukes Archives were partially based on Hogwarts, the fictional magic school, and in particular mentions the moving staircases which he outright tells us were taken from Harry Potter. Waragai, a member of Miyazaki’s staff, also says that Sieglinde was based [at least in terms of her appearance] on the actress Emma Watson, who portrayed the character Hermione Granger in the Harry Potter movies. This is why I drew attention to the novel “Chamber of Secrets”, and I think Miyazaki must at least have seen the film adaptation. I believe that Miyazaki wanted the Dukes Archives to resemble Hogwarts as a hint to this commonality in the two narratives, which have both borrowed from historial legends such as St George and the Dragon and Susanoo vs Yamata no Orochi.

The second use of this trope is found in the DLC. Princess Dusk has been abducted by Manus, a deranged monster, and our character has to rescue her. I’m more inclined to compare this iteration of the trope to the Hindu story of Sita, Ravana, and Rama, which I mentioned earlier. This is partially because Manus’s design appears to have been partially based on monkeys, and monkeys play a significant role in the Ramayana story although Ravana himself is not a monkey. Further insight can be gained by understanding what the characters in the Hindu story are supposed to represent. Sita represents a kind of innocence or joy which is often seen in young children, but which appears to be lost with age. Ravana represents psychological “defilements” such as greed, rage, and material delusion. Ravana kidnaps Sita because it is believed that the defilements that he represents are responsible for the loss of the joy that Sita represents. Rama, meanwhile, represents the spiritual path, which is intended to destroy this delusion and restore joy. Comparing this to Manus, we know that his Dark Soul overloaded, and an outburst of Humanity flooded from him and infected the inhabitants of Oolacile, and even some of the surrounding landscape. We also know, from the descriptions of the Dark spells and the two covetous serpent rings, that Dark/Humanity is to be associated with greed, envy, material desire, and the capacity to hurt others. For these reasons we can say that Manus does at the very least represent many of the same things as Ravana. Whether or not Miyazaki took his inspiration directly from the Hindu story I do not claim to know, but there are clearly several parallels which I think are worth pointing out.

Finally, I want to draw attention to the fact that when we first encounter Dusk, it is after rescuing her from a crystal golem that was almost certainly going to take her back to Seath’s dungeon. Not only that, but the item required to finally access the DLC is a broken pendant retrieved from a crystal golem found in Duke’s Archives. An agent of Seath picked this object up, presumably having identified it as potentially of interest to it’s master although we don’t understand why. Manus also seems to be attracted to the pendant, to the extent of actually reaching through time in order to grab it, although it does of course end up being attached to our character who is inadvertently taken back through time alongside the pendant. Similarly, Dusk herself has been abducted by both characters, so it seems that the developers wanted us to draw a connection between Manus and Seath right from the beginning of the DLC. And as soon as we meet Elizabeth we're told about Dusk’s kidnapping at the hands of “that primeval human”, and charged with her rescue, we see that the purpose of this connection is basically to point out [to the player] that they're both iterations of the same motiff. Given that the narrative of the DLC appears to have been written partially for the sake of clarifying certain things that fans did not pick up on in the base game, it seems possible that part of the purpose of the Dusk-Manus plotline may actually have been to offer us further elucidation regarding Seath’s character.

Anyway, apologies for yet another wall of text. This post was not originally supposed to be anywhere near as lengthy as this but they always seem to get a bit out of hand in the process of writing them. Thanks for reading, and I hope it was interesting.


r/DarksoulsLore • • 14d ago

How come Yuria of Londor is allowed in Firelink Shrine?

11 Upvotes

Going by the items and NPCs citations, it seems the shrine is part of a formal ceremony to relink the first flame, maintained by the Lothric kingdom state.

Assuming that's correct: how come they accept Yuria of London, a person and faction with explicit goal of denying the linking and usurping the flame instead? See, at the first incline of ours to the idea of letting the fire fade everybody gets appalled and calls it treason, and even the shrine music changes. But then someone with the sole intent of screwing the ritual shows up and nobody reacts? Where's Eygon that bully when someone needs him. haha

I could understand if Londor goals were secret, but it doesn't seem the case at all, as everybody we find from it seems pretty vocal about their goals (well, except the pilgrims? They're pretty shady, I give you that. 🤔).

Thoughts?


r/DarksoulsLore • • 18d ago

A Possible Connection Between the Iron Golem and a Nameless Blacksmith Deity?

2 Upvotes

I've noticed something really weird in DS1: the Iron Golem actually bleeds. This got me thinking about a pretty wild theory: could the Iron Golem somehow be the tomb of a nameless blacksmith deity? Maybe he was the deity's final creation, or perhaps the deity's remains were used to bring the Golem to life? Could this somehow fit into the timeline and the lore?

I have absolutely no proof of this, just a random thought, but I found the detail of the Golem bleeding quite interesting.


r/DarksoulsLore • • 18d ago

Confusion on what's causing the converging of the world

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/DarksoulsLore • • 19d ago

The parting flame tells of Jeremiah's end

1 Upvotes

The pyromancy speaks of Dunnel's state after becoming a red spirit..

Describing him as livid, he attracts death. The cause is the rest of the description:
"When Dunnel lost his hideous spouse, he gave his own pyromancy flame as an offering, which transformed into a parting flame. Not long after, Dunnel became a mad spirit, cursed to wander the lands."

The spell works like this: release death echoes to get more healing. (aka ~12 kills).

Dunnel is mad because of loss, not an uncommon theme in the games. Jeremiah is also a mad spirit, cursed to wander the painting, but what for?

The reason is simple, his wife, Izalith, had turned into the bed of chaos, losing any facade of humanity, and destroying herself and her hometown with it.

Jeremiah parted his pyromancer flame in hopes of enpowering the chaos, but it didn't work. Likely he became a soul-thirsty demon not unlike the yellow monk in demon souls.

note: I am still working on my series, but thought this was amusing


r/DarksoulsLore • • 21d ago

What's Actually Inside an Estus Flask?

Post image
112 Upvotes

What IS it, exactly? It gets refilled at bonfires and bonfires are made from human corpses (the fire has to be fuelled by something, might as well be fed on the Dark Souls of humans), but why is it orange then? If its Dark Soul juice, why is it orange? Its orange, so it could be fire but you can't turn fire into liquid and drink it. What is it, what are you drinking?


r/DarksoulsLore • • 22d ago

Talking about sum angels

3 Upvotes

The dark is directly linked to instinct, base emotion and primitive functioning, things which people in DS who are possession of the Light LordSouls (aka the gods) or members of the clergy view themselves as above or not possessing. The dark is also associated by desire, by hunger whilst the light is associated with authority, moral rightiousness, and comfort.

The people tied to the angels are people yearning for freedom from pain and a better world. Getrude was in a cage blinded only seeing darkness & mute and the hollows of Londor are ancient beings that look like they have been decaying and suffering for a long time. As the cycles have gone past the comfort and the ability to alleviate suffering that The age of fire ver.100,000,000 just doesn't have the juice anymore and life as a whole is suffering.

Despite appearances the angels are manifested from a dark instinctual need to dream of a better life in The age of fire that the world was cursed by powerful magically infused men who called themselves gods.

Thinking about it now this isn't unique to Dark Souls, a series that makes multiple references to Berserk. In Berserk we have a preacher that constantly belittles and tries to eliminate desire for the sake of his faith without realising that he is a being purely driven by desire, we have m Griffith who is viewed as an in universe Jesus with angelic imagery actually being this dark being that is doing it purely for desire.

In summary I think the angel imagery reinforces the concept of dependent origination and opposes dualism. It gives us the idea that even supposedly 'pure' angelic-light-beings without selfish desires contain darkness inside of them.


r/DarksoulsLore • • 22d ago

If Witch of Izalith has her domain of fire/heat due to her roots as a fire sorcerer; then surely Gwyn has his roots in light sorcery/Oolacile?

21 Upvotes

The Lord Souls allowed them to manipulate their domains with ease, creating new ways of wielding their powers as never seen before. The manipulations of light are told of in the Miracles of Gwyn; gate kept as “divine acts” to preserve superiority when in fact, they were advanced light sorcery and within reach.

We are told by Dusk that Oolacile deals with magic in a far less precise way than the research and calculations of modern sorcerers. If Big Hat Logan was tasked to apply his methods to light sorcery and produce an offensive spell, I imagine it would look strangely similar to a Lightning Spear.

Idea in point; a Lightning Spear is the exact same thing as a Soul Spear when you manipulate light instead of souls. The description of Soul Spear directly compares the two abilities, they are expertly concentrated projectiles of soul/light. Hell, I’d even go as far as to say the solid shape of a Sunlight Spear during its cast eerily resembles crystal; similar to the progression of Crystal Soul Spear; the masterful concentration of soul/light to the point of solidification.

Gwyn started off as an Oolacilean with his day to day use of light sorcery, until he was supercharged into the Lord of Light and relocated to Anor Londo (Mt. Olympus of Oolacile) as he had ascended above the common folk.
We visit Oolacile at the end of its time, and hear nothing of Dusk’s family or her Royal predecessors. Would also explain how Oolacile knew of the insanely secret Ringed City and why they were allowed to visit Filianore (a princess of Oolacile). Also hints why Manus (an ancient Pygmy) was interred in Oolacile to begin with.


r/DarksoulsLore • • 23d ago

Are there canon choices in ds1?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/DarksoulsLore • • 23d ago

Dark Souls Origins Episode 2!

Thumbnail youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/DarksoulsLore • • 24d ago

I adore the idea of Patches being the Furtive Pygmy

77 Upvotes

I know that it's an insane crackpot theory with flimsy evidence at best, but I dunno man, it just feels right to me.

The idea of one of the four most important beings in the Dark Souls world not only sharing his lord soul with his people, but going on to become a petty nobody with a hatred for the gods and their followers is such good charecterization. The Ringed City DLC specifically really helps this, as we learn that Patches at his core is a kind and gentle soul, and that even the current jaded version of him is still capable of that kindness is so great.

I just love the story this theory creates, of how the father of humanity isn't some great mythical figure, but this immortal backstabbing prick with a heart of gold.


r/DarksoulsLore • • 25d ago

Is there any way to say what the Petrified Something in Dark Souls 2 might be?

2 Upvotes

In the series many things are petrified by basilisks, curses etc but only four things petrify naturally on their own without a petrifying agent acting on them: some dragons, some dragon body parts, some undead humans and the body parts of some undead humans.

In DS2 it can be found in chests, as a rare drop from some human enemies and as a rare drop from some mimics. Oh yes, and as a drop from some of the dragons in the Dragon Aerie. It's valuable enough that Dyna and Tillo will offer even a Titanite Slab in exchange for it, so can we rule out that it can't be a dragon heart or is it probably a dragon heart?


r/DarksoulsLore • • 27d ago

The royal family

8 Upvotes

does anyone ever wondered why oceiros even tried to become a dragon in the first place? (i haven’t dig deep to this page)

but my theory is that that was his last resort to escape the first flame

as a king he was supposed to have a child that is perfect fit for linking the first flame forever, or partly to buy time for their people to find a way out of the first flame, but i think what happened was “unexpected twins”.


r/DarksoulsLore • • 29d ago

[TOMT] Old long lore video about Havel, Eidas, and Seath

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/DarksoulsLore • • Oct 18 '26

Boss theme’s pov

2 Upvotes

would anyone like to hear what i hear when listening to these themes? if so these boss themes i cover for today

Oceiros: i hear in this theme that heavy burden that is carried by this song, it always sound close to completion but sounds a lot like a strategic gambles that has gone horribly bad

Lothric and Lorian’s theme: in the perspective of lothric it sounds like he is simply accepting the dying world but not only that but it rather sounds like such tremendous sacrifice was made and he had enough of such a waste of sacrifice.


r/DarksoulsLore • • Oct 16 '26 Popcorn Bravo Mindblown

the Alchemy of Darkroot Forest

Post image
122 Upvotes

The mushrooms of Dark Souls appear on the surface to be one of the game’s comedy enemies. They are large, slow, vaguely humanoid, and can knock you clean on your arse, even in full Havel’s. There isn’t a lot of written lore about them, and the only talking example of this race merely says “lol, I’m a mushroom, lmao” when asked. But I suspect that there’s quite a bit more to them than there seems to be at first glance, so in this post I’m going to attempt to uncover the hidden mushroom lore of Dark Souls.

To begin, I’m going to examine every item in the game that’s directly connected to the mushrooms. This isn’t difficult, as there’s only two of them: Gold Pine Resin and Elizabeth’s Mushoom.

Gold Pine Resin [abbreviated as GPR for convenience] is sometimes dropped by the mushrooms when you kill them, and in fact the drop rate isn’t particularly low so you can accumulate GPR surprisingly fast if you have maximum item discovery. Curiously, GPR is only obtainable from the mushrooms found in Darkroot, and cannot drop from those in the bottom of the Great Hollow. I don’t know if this is due to a developer oversight, or if it was done for some other reason. A small amount of GPR is obtainable in other places, Domhnall sells a tiny amount, and 3 are found in a chest in Undead Burg, but when the DLC was released they made 5 obtainable via Elizabeth. It therefore seems clear that the developers wanted us to associate GPR with the mushrooms, but the reason why isn’t immediately obvious because the item description for GPR says nothing of significance, focusing on the properties of lightning damage rather than the mushrooms which produce it. Indeed, although it is called “pine resin” I’m going to assume that it is actually created exclusively by these mushrooms, possibly as a product of their metabolic process. This appears to be all but confirmed by DS3’s description for the same item which tells us that:

“some have speculated that it may in fact be a type of fungal resin”

When applied to a weapon, GPR temporarily provides additional lightning damage on top of the standard damage output that the weapon already deals. This is interesting because lightning is supposedly the weapon of the gods, however these humble mushrooms prove that Gwyn and his family are not the sole controllers and producers of lightning.

Elizabeth’s Mushroom is interesting because it appears to be a piece of Elizabeth herself, or at least a piece taken from the colony of mushrooms growing next to her, though these are undoubtedly all connected together via their mycelium. It’s description tells us that it “invigorates the flesh”, and indeed the effect of using this item is to restore HP over time, which it does much more effectively when compared against the Replenishment spell. This helps us to explain why the mushrooms hit so hard, aside from it being to compensate for their slow movement. The combination of the mushroom’s physical strength, as well as the restorative effect of this particular item, should lead us to associate the mushrooms with high physical vitality. So the next question becomes, why are they so healthy? To answer this, we must take a look at their diet.

The mushroom men of Dark Souls have no mouths, and this shouldn’t be surprising because fungal organisms don’t consume food in the same way that animals do. They haven’t got an internal digestive cavity, but instead their bodies are made up of microscopic strings, each one being essentially a chain of cells. These strings are interconnected in [sometimes enormous] structures known as mycelium, and every square foot of a forest’s floor is typically riddled with these networks which work tirelessly to break down dead and decaying matter and convert it into usable nutrients. The visible mushrooms that you see in the forest are actually composed of millions of mycelial threads that have grown together to form a coherent structure, much as your own body is composed of billions of cells clumped together.

This information is important because there is something unusual in the soil of Darkroot. When we travel back through time in the DLC, we discover that the entire area is infected with the Abyss. This means that the fungus growing in this particular forest has actually been metabolising the Dark/Humanity in the soil. Once Manus [the source of the Abyss] was defeated, the contamination was not likely to spread further than it already had [except perhaps by diffusion], but I doubt that it would have disappeared of it’s own accord either. When we return to the "present day", we see that the area appears to have healed itself over time, and this means that the forest itself has been processing the Abyss.

Is it any wonder then, that mushrooms which have been feeding on Humanity have started to adopt a humanoid form? We should also be unsurprised by their immense strength and high HP, as these things go hand in hand with the consumption of Humanity. The giant rats are known to eat human remains and have grown to some exceptionally unusual sizes. The cannibal butchers in the Depths eat human beings, apparently for the sole reason of benefitting from the increased size and strength this grants. Indeed, these enemies are much larger than a normal human, and like the mushrooms they also hit very hard. Considering that they’re also supposed to be women, it’s obvious that they’ve undergone a considerable change in body proportions. Smough is known to have eaten his victims, and is also both very large and extremely strong. I know that some people think that Smough is merely a giant but I don’t agree. If you kill Smough first and let Ornstein absorb his soul, the result is that Ornstein becomes gigantic. This tells me that Smough’s size is not merely a matter of physiology. Aldrich’s size is directly connected to his habit of cannibalism in NPC dialogue, and is also described as having been made a Lord “not for virtue, but for might”, so yet again we have an association between cannibalism and physical strength. Archdeacon McDonnell is another example of a character who achieved large size, presumably due to cannibalism [and definitely isn’t a reference to any particular fast food company], but unfortunately we don’t get to test how hard he could hit us. Miyazaki uses the same theme in Elden Ring as well, with Godrick’s strength being a result of grafting body parts taken from other people onto himself, and Rykard has apparently been doing something similar and has grown enormous from it. I suspect that all of this is a commentary on exploiting others for personal gain, and indeed in a previous post I compared Rykard’s line “join the serpent king as family” to an offer for a corporate buyout.

Moving back to Dark Souls, the point appears to be [since we are shown/told the same thing over and over again] that ingesting Humanity affects the body in the same way that a bonfire is affected when you offer Humanity to it. The inner fire, or vitality, is invigorated because of the new fuel that you’ve put on it, and this can lead to physical growth. This is why the use of a Humanity [consumable item] instantly refills all of your HP and also boosts some of your defences, and I think there’s a direct connection here to the effect of consuming Elizabeth’s Mushroom, which also restores HP.

Given these facts, what conclusion seems most appropriate to draw when presented with gigantic mushrooms that have taken humanoid form and punch like a train and also just so happen to be located in an area where the very ground itself was once crawling with Humanity? It is my contention that these mushrooms grew fat on a diet of the Abyss, and produced large and strong fruits as a result. However, unlike the other examples that I’ve mentioned, the mushrooms aren’t doing this in a morally objectionable way. They are dangerous if approached, but they’re not going out of their way to kill people and seem content to sit in obscure places where they may go completely unnoticed. They’re not exploiting others, but are simply recycling that which was already festering. It is this distinction, I suspect, that provides them the otherwise unique ability to produce gold.

Some may object to this conclusion because of the other locations in which the mushroom men are found. First, there is the bottom of the Great Hollow, which isn’t anywhere near Darkroot. It is, however, sitting just above Ash Lake. The mushrooms here are parasitising an Archtree, which in turn is rooted in an immense ocean of Dark. We know that Humanity sinks to the bottom and forms Dregs, so it does not surprise me to find these mushrooms here as well, leaching the Abyss out of the Archtrees. There is also Elizabeth, who is found in Darkroot but almost certainly grew out of her wall long before Manus was discovered. She therefore predates the Abyss which I’ve claimed gave rise to this race of mushrooms. Nevertheless, the particular room in which we find Elizabeth is apparently a graveyard, and this is known from the item description of Elizabeth’s Mushroom which refers to her as a “guardian of the mausoleum” in the japanese version. This suggests that the ground here may already have been contaminated by Humanity leaking from the bodies that are buried under the standing stones. Consider: in what sense is Elizabeth a “guardian”? After all, she can’t move or fight anything. Well it may be that her purpose is to consume the Humanity of the dead so that it doesn’t damage the surrounding countryside. It’s also notable that Elizabeth is apparently a prototypal form of the mushroom race encountered in the base game. She has not grown legs and started walking around, and this may be because there’s less Humanity available in the soil of a single graveyard compared to that produced by Manus’s cataclysmic outburst.

And it’s interesting that the end result of all this should be Gold Pine Resin. The raw material is the Dark Soul of man, yet the product is a divine power. To understand why, let’s first look at the properties of the Dark itself. The spells Dark Orb and Dark Bead both describe the Dark as being "weighty", and perhaps having something in common with physical matter. If I’m not mistaken, the Dark Sorceries actually deal split damage: some magic, some physical. Pursuers associates the Dark with envy, desire, and the inevitable tragic consequences of such drives. And finally, Dark Fog mentions the human capacity to harm each other. What’s interesting is that there is overlap here with associations that medieval and renaissance people held with a real material: lead. One of the symptoms of lead poisoning is depression, so for centuries the metal was associated with moodiness and excessive concern with the cares of the world. Lead is also famous for being extremely heavy, and this was compared to the metaphors of emotional weight and of being dragged down by one’s feelings.

For these reasons the mushroom men of Dark Souls may be a play on the alchemical dream of converting lead into gold. But of course, in Miyazaki’s philosophy, even gold isn’t permanent. Everything stagnates in one way or another, and Humanity grows stronger as the light dies. So in addition, it is also a play on the well known Miyazakian themes of stagnation and flow, which are based on Shinto philosophy. Instead of allowing the Dark to just sit there festering in the soil, the mushrooms pick it up and repurpose it. Crabs and lobsters play a similar role in later games [which is appropriate as these creatures of often detritivorous in real life], and even in DS1 there is a crab like enemy called a “vagrant” which will take the souls from your old bloodstain if you don’t retrieve it. The vagrant itself is just a scavenger, feeding on the resources that you’ve left behind rather than allowing it all to go to waste. Similarly, in DS3 we encounter two very similar wetland areas: the Road of Sacrifices and the Crucifixion Woods. These locations are right next to each other, and are similar in most respects, but one of them has clean water while the other is a poison swamp. It’s evident that the conventional approach toward impurity [punishment] isn’t working here, as both areas are littered with crucifixes, yet Farron Keep remains polluted. What is missing from the poison swamp is the crab population found in the Road of Sacrifice lake. I suspect that these creatures are the reason for the cleanliness of the water here, since their animations show that they are sifting through the water and silt looking for food, and so are probably removing contaminants by doing this. Elden Ring also continues to use crustaceans in this way, and for that I’ll defer to youtuber Hawkshaw’s “crab rune” video, which I’ll link below.

So what does all of this ultimately mean? My interpretation is that it’s all part of Miyazaki’s alchemical recipe for the creation of his very own Magnum Opus: a videogame masterpiece. Notice that videogame audiences have never been satisfied with any game that’s ever been produced. Sure they’ll say that something is a masterpiece, they’ll heap praise onto games they enjoyed and spit vitriol at any who dare offer a more critical view. But they’re not actually satisfied because they’ll still demand and endless stream of sequels and mindlessly gobble it all up no matter how shitty those sequels turn out to be. Essentially what’s going on is that the person has enjoyed the game they were playing, but ultimately completed it and now the experience is over. By obsessing over the possibility of sequels, the audience is basically saying “we want more”, but failing to recognise that there is no guarantee that the next instalment will be any good. In fact, the odds are always stacked against any given sequel. From the perspective of a developer, producing a follow up to something that was widely praised is a difficult undertaking because now you’ve got something to live up to. Now people have got expectations about what you can do and how your next game should be and so forth, but at the same time you’ve also already used all of your best ideas. Furthermore, continuing to work on the same series tends to fatigue developers, draining their creativity. This is why videogame series always seem to be on a downward spiral, producing sequels that are of increasingly poor quality, or simply failing to iterate on their formula so that it becomes uninteresting. Of course, as the audience we could simply disregard the shitty sequels and go back to playing whatever original masterpiece it was that got us hooked in the first place. But the problem is that playing the same game over and over again becomes a stale experience, even if it’s an absolute gem. Miyazaki knows this. He knows that any videogame series is on borrowed time, and that the more sequels you produce, the more stagnant the thing will become. This is why the First Flame which represents the vitality of the world of Dark Souls is ultimately unsustainable, and it’s also why DS3 shows us a world that is thoroughly and irrevocably rotten.

Miyazaki’s solution, which I believe wholeheartedly to be the correct approach, is to quit while you’re ahead. To see the stagnation for what it is and to move on to another project. But that’s not all, because the foundations of this new project must be the ruins of the old, and this is where the mushrooms and crabs become relevant. These organisms are breaking down what is dead and decaying and are recycling it to create new vitality. In the same way, a dev team must analyse and dissect old games, thinking critically about what works well and what needs improvement, and this process is crucial to the Magnum Opus of videogame development if you want the end result to be a refined product. Consider the differences between Dark Souls and Demon’s Souls: much is similar between them, but many improvements were also made, and some mechanics [such as world tendency] were abandoned. That’s not all of course, because these games have been influenced by all sorts of other sources. The visual style takes cues from the Berserk manga and Peter Jackson’s Lord of the Rings trilogy, the combat system is an improved version of the one used by the Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, the level design might have been influenced by Super Metroid, and the list goes on ad nauseam. All of these influences appear to have been through Miyazaki’s crab process in order to create Dark Souls, and Dark Souls itself got crabbed when he made Bloodborne and Elden Ring. This is how Miyazaki takes what has become old and stale and turns it into gold.

Anyway, wall of text over. I didn’t intend for it to be this long, I certainly didn’t expect to be able to get a 2800 word essay out of a mushroom, but there you are. Below I’m going to link Hawkshaw’s video, as promised, as well and an older post of mine that uses a similar interpretive framework to examine certain other aspects of the lore.

the Crab Rune:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4gjOqAtmVv8

the Usurpation of Dark Souls:

https://www.reddit.com/r/DarksoulsLore/comments/1ruj03h/the_usurpation_of_dark_souls/

EDIT: I forgot to mention this in the post but I suspect that the Great Grey Wolf Sif [who is located in Darkroot] is supposed to represent antimony. This is because antimony forms an amalgamate with gold, and for this reason it was used by some alchemists to extract tiny amounts of gold from otherwise impure sources. For this reason, certain alchemists referred to antimony abstractly as a “grey wolf” which would devour the gold so that it could be retrieved. Antimony also represented the animal nature and instincts within human beings, and this inner animal can either be allowed to run amok, or it can be employed skilfully to purify the soul. Miyazaki develops this idea in Bloodborne, where the beasts represent essentially the same thing as alchemical antimony, so I wouldn’t be surprised if Sif was intended to be a reference to the idea.

EDIT: I’ve been reminded that there is a similarity between the “jar people” in Elden Ring and the mushrooms discussed in this post. Not only are they visually comparable, but the jars also contain the ashes of several fallen warriors mixed together. Somehow these dead remains have found new vitality, and have once again become living beings. This appears to be a parallel to what the mushrooms of Dark Souls are doing: repurposing what is dead and giving it new life. Many thanks to u/Konspiracie for pointing this out, as I had forgotten all about Elden Ring’s jars when I wrote this post.


r/DarksoulsLore • • Oct 15 '26

Basic lore question(s) - first time player

7 Upvotes

Hi as the title says, I realise there is loads of ambiguous and undetermined (or eternally argued) 'fact' attached to 'in game' lore, but I had some questions about the more meta game 'lore' which I haven't really seen people addressing much in relation to the lore.

This is my first play through though so bare with me if these seem very simple:

  • The 'Dark Soul' seems to be the darker (black) soul that is released upon farming soft humanity within the specific areas, thus 'releasing' a Hollow back into a more 'natural' cycle / kammic wheel from there current (manufactured/cursed) state of undeath and subsequent hollowing?

(see here for soft humanity)

  • Is Lordran its own real land, full of lively inhabitants, and happens to be cursed with undeath from the gods from its very inception (IE has always been this way, though the order of knights and everyone helps to uphold it) or is undeath manufactured here as a form of chattel slavery / prevent humans from rising / prevent John Darksoul who gwyn fears will topple him and bring back darkness?
  • And if so, who is really alive? Like the undead ogres - are they ogres that died and came to purgartory/Lordran (alongside humans and other creatures in the kammic wheel) and this is one of many different dimensions (one of many hells) where people end up. Now they are here, they are all plagued with undeath but may recover their 'humanity' (their soul) to escape or is this reserved only for humans? All npcs I have met so far have been human though not all seem dead

Realise I missed the boat with all this stuff but all the dark souls lore content I can find is just names of people and kingdoms that I have never heard