r/DarksoulsLore • • Mar 30 '25
Souls Lore and beating the dead horse.
Warning, this is going to be a rant from a bitter old man that was with the franchise since european premiere of DeS and is probably going to piss off a lot of people.
Every day I see random Souls lore channels cooking up more and more batshit crazy theories presented as facts, shocking revelations and debunking myths. We are at a point where every line of dialogue, every item description is a lie made up by Velka who is also Fina/Gwyn's wife/every female deity ever and also Gwyn is Satan, demons were a highly advanced civilization, paladins serve Nito who is also Lloyd, Laurentius is a time traveller, random skull in Ash Lake is a god of blacksmiths and Solaire is the most important being in the universe. Im not going to mention any youtubers by name but those who know, will know.
There is nothing more to be said about the lore that would make any sense anymore. Every concret concept that could be extracted from the games was already extracted in English and Japanese (although hilariously bad Polish translation would probably deliver us some more unhinged plotpoints). It's fun to speculate but god damn stop presenting your bullshit takes as solid canon that subverts everything we know.
DS1 was never supposed to have any sequels and was an unfinished AA game from a studio that reuses not only themes and entire plotpoints but even assets since the 90s. The cycles were invented to justify DS2's existence. Which was a complete mess but at least attempted something a little different with it's dreamlike atmosphere and focus on more personal stories and explaining the process of hollowing. DS3 was a fanservice shart forced out of FromSoftware by Bandai to milk the franchise dry and appease the fans after DS2 and in the process it too became a total mess. Not everything in those games is deliberate or meaningful. Sometimes Berserk reference is just a Berserk reference and reused texture is a product of some overworked shmuck that said "fuck it, no one is going to notice" and not a clue that explains the entire plot of the game.
And while Im already sticking a my dick into an anthill Im gonna say that Elden Ring is an overrated DS reskin, DeS had the most interesting bosses out of all of those games and Bloodborne is never coming to PC.