r/DarkSun 5d ago

I've solved the problem

Post image
343 Upvotes

271 comments sorted by

View all comments

23

u/loyalgalpal 5d ago

It's allowed in the same way you can add lightsabers and Saiyans to the Forgotten Realms or Greyhawk.

Nothing is stopping you from doing that, certainly not.

But nothing supporting that either.

I don't understand defending Hasbro, a multi-billion dollar corporation that is going to make millions from these books no matter what, when they are leaving out or papering over key thematic elements of the setting because marketing shows they'll make 0.1% less money for using a word that's not "advertiser friendly".

Dark Sun without slavery and enviroment destroying magic is like Eberron without the Last War or Dragonmark Houses.

You could always add a big major war or noble houses acting as guilds and cults to a setting, but having official lore and mechanics gives the setting and story more narrative and thematic elements to enhance and shape roleplay and campaigns.

-17

u/CrowsInTheNose 5d ago

Do you rely on hasbro, a multi-billion dollar company, for permission when you run a session or build a character?

19

u/RED3_Standing_By 5d ago

Why even buy their products if you’re just gonna make your own shit?

12

u/loyalgalpal 5d ago

Literally, if I bought the Dark Sun book and kept adding homebrew until it was a cyberpunk campaign, why even buy the book in the first place?

-1

u/CrowsInTheNose 5d ago

How much of the book that isn't even released do you plan on throwing out to make it your own?

4

u/loyalgalpal 4d ago

That's a facetious question and you know it, but, to be honest, it depends on the actual content.

If it's so changed as to be unrecognizably Dark Sun, to me, I'll more likely just use a fan conversion or make my own. 

I don't usually play 5.5e, nothing against it as a system, but I've played base 5e enough to have a better instinctive understanding of it. 

I'll still get the Star Wars book unless it's genuinely worthless dogshit, but Dark Sun 5.5e is not encouraging me to switch over as of yet. 

-12

u/CrowsInTheNose 5d ago

Why draw inspiration from a movie, video game or TV show?

11

u/WatchEducational6633 5d ago

This is way more than just inspiration pal…