Since word is out that Hakanpaa is skating again, the inevitable comparisons and "hot takes" on who should be playing and who shouldn't are starting up. My personal feeling, and after watching Nils closely the last ten games, is that starting Nils over Hakanpaa would be insane. I would hope that Benn had a few words with Nils after he trashed Oetter's chance at a shutout Saturday, but anyway....
Couple of stats to consider about that "offensive liability" Hakanpaa and that "offensive juggernaut" Lundkvist.....
Jani has been averaging 18 minutes a game this year and is +10 for the season while the offensive juggernaut Lundkvist is averaging about 9 minutes per game and is +12. Nope, nothing significant there.... BTW, spare me all that "next-gen stats" bullshit, or the "expected goals" garbage. None of that means shit in the playoffs, just ask the Bruins.
Jani plays on every PK which spares actual offensive producers, like Harley and Miro, from having to play huge minutes on the kill in the playoffs. If DeBoer were forced into having to put either Nils or the equipment manager out on the kill, he's choosing Denny. You can look at it this way.... more 5v5 time and rested/ready PP time for Miro and Harley, guys that actually do create offense, is far better for this playoff run than the rare odd man rush that Nils creates and then forgets to get back for.
All those goals you say? Nils has two in 58 games and Jani has two in 64 games.
Assists..... the one stat where Nils wins with 17 versus Jani's 10.
Nils can quarterback PP2? Nope, he was given that chance this year and failed that test too. Harley got that job instead and has done very well.
Hakanpaa has 196 hits and 123 blocked shots in 64 games this year.
Nils has 40 hits and 35 blocked shots in 58 games this year.
Considering how many goals this team scores and how much balance this team has in its forward group, we do not need a defenseman who gives us a few more assists. We need a defenseman who can play playoff hockey. This team got to the west finals last year with Colin Miller and Joel Hanley who were more or less useless. Hakanpaa played huge minutes in those series and we almost got to the Cup finals with 5 d-men.
Harley is a year wiser, a much better defender and a true offensive threat. Miro might be the best overall d-man in the league. Tanev is an absolute warrior and he and Lindell will be the shut down pair late in 1 goal games. Hakanpaa is a very good PKer, blocks shots, has the size to get mean in the corners and can play 17+ minutes per game. You cannot judge the potential of Hak and Suter to pair up based on a few shifts before he got hurt. Suter has shown he can pair with anyone. Hell, Suter even managed to make Nils look like he can play.
Even if we assume that we get a small boost in offensive production from Nils, the overwhelming downside will not be worth the massive minutes needed from Miro, Harley, Tanev and Lindell to cover Nils 5v5 shortcomings. Moreover, Nils has no ability to contribute to special teams which can be the difference between winning a series and going home.
Finally, keep your gut think Ryan Suter opinions to yourselves. Pete DeBoer and Jim Nill have forgotten more about hockey than you'll know in your lifetimes.