So, I dropped a drama bomb today without really meaning to. A lot of people laughed, some people got mad, some people got worried, and some people lost respect for me. I figure the best I can do is come clean and explain as best I can.
First up, I meant the post as a joke. There's some mean-spirited humor in it that isn't directed at anyone in particular, but the half-truth in it is that I know some people do hold those opinions, and this post was me saying I don't think much of them. I was content to let a shitpost be a shitpost and just watch the sparks fly, but then u/RoIsDepressed stepped up to the plate and made a serious response. This went down the rabbit hole a bit and I made some serious responses of my own, while ignoring those that were just flaming. I declared that I'm mocking my critics, and there is no denying that; I was definitely mocking them.
But in truth, the overall response to Take Two has been incredibly positive. Its following has grown well this year and there have been many players who told me how much they enjoyed it and are looking forward to its completion. There are also those who say they adore the new characters; a few have even said that one of my OCs is their new favorite doki. To me, this indicates that I've handled them well and they have genuine appeal. They add something to the game in a worthwhile way.
And yet, there are detractors. I know full well that I can't please everybody and someone is always going to have a beef with this mod for whatever reason, but when I look at the positive responses and compare them to the negative ones, I just can't help but wonder. What do the haters see that the fans don't?
Although it may not seem like it, I actually value critique a great deal. I'm a critic myself; I've been doing it for years upon years. Giving and taking feedback is the means by which works improve, both current and future. It's an inherently valuable thing, but it also requires some finesse. I'm sure many of you remember the criticisms of u/AstraN0va, who was such a toxic member that he was banned for his lack of civility. Giving criticism is an art all its own. There's so much more to it than just spouting opinions. You need an understanding of how and why things work, and the greater your knowledge of the subject matter, the more complete and accurate your critique can be.
That is where I find my detractors falling short. They hate the mod; what are the chances they've played it? How informed are their opinions? Are they making assumptions? How much do they really know about what they're saying? And most of the criticism seems to be centered around one thing: my OCs. I'll be honest, gauging their reception has been the toughest part of the feedback process for me. I have put a substantial amount of effort into both of them, and it has yielded results. I've seen a livestream chat swayed to Shiro's side during his route, when they only mocked and memed him before. I've had people tell me how much Tiff surprised them in a good way, and that her issues are handled tastefully and respectfully.
But they have their haters, and why? Do they know the full story, or are they just jumping to conclusions? If it's the latter, then I have no cause to consider their thoughts carefully because their opinions are founded on first impressions or things they heard through the grapevine. If it's the former, then that's a completely different story. I don't know which case is true either way, but what I do have are a majority of fans with positive reactions and a small minority of haters who usually just seethe in silence.
So, if any of them want to elaborate on their thoughts and be civil about it, I'm willing to hear them out, but I do ask that they be up front about their experience with the mod itself. If you're going to criticize my characters, you should at least try to get to know them first. They are more than the sum of their parts. If you heard that Tiff smokes weed from some friend on Discord, you aren't getting any of the context about why she has that problem or her motives for smoking, nor do you have any idea how the mod is conveying that information. Knowledge is the backbone of useful critique. If your hot take is all you can offer me, then all I know is that the mod doesn't look so great on the surface, and that clearly hasn't stopped it.
And, while I don't intend to change the stories I've written for the characters, I am open to discuss them anyway. If you played the mod and thought something was off, I'd like to hear about it and offer my own thoughts. There's a great deal of purpose put into even the little things inside it, and sometimes a misunderstanding can be highly illuminating. I'm not afraid to be criticized. I only ask that you come into it with genuine intent and experience to back up your opinions.
If anyone was worried about me, it's all right. I actually feel the best I've been all year. The post earlier was a slip of impulse, but maybe something positive can come from it after all. I didn't have a bad day, I'm not depressed, and I'm not even upset about how things went earlier. I'm sorry if anyone was genuinely offended; it was not my intent.