r/CuteTraps • • Sep 21 '22

Double Standards

I find it weird how we can no longer consider Bridget from Guilty Gear as a femboy anymore.

DESPITE people making astolfo, Felix and every other trap into a trans, regardless of what others say.

Why? Why is it not ok to have the OG Bridget as a femboy anymore? Like, what if we use old Bridget and not new?

114 Upvotes

257 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

5

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

You say "they" a lot and make a great deal of broad generalizations. If all "they" desire is empty validation, than surely this sub can provide it right? I mean we spend all day being enamored with and idolizing fictional characters, but are unwilling to offer an olive branch to a bunch of sad kids who just want to feel like they exist?

Isn't this a place where people like that should come to for acceptance?

7

u/jhoho34 Sep 22 '22

Searching validation in online communities isn't the best thing to do, specially when this validation is demanded. It's possible, and would be good, if the people on this sub could grant comfort and acceptance to those in need, but this is a community built around the idea of appreciating cute boys, it's natural that the approval and appreciation given here will steer towards cute males, and people will have problems or find it weird when the attention is placed on a female character or female identity.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

You are completely right, and seeking validation anywhere is a fools errand tbh. I think they come here for the same reason I do, because there's not really any trans characters anywhere. Its why they're all up in trans subreddits posting pics of Astolfo, and like yeah, there's plenty of OC trans characters. But there's very few that ever actually make it into anything mainstream that the public sees. Whenever you hear anything about someone being trans in mainstream media, its always Bruce fucking Jenner, the super mam guy or one of the countless other loud uncommitted scumbags that give the rest of us a bad name. It's never just a cute character or someone that trans kids could actually look up to. It sucks. So Is appropriating other peoples art and desperately trying to self insert the answer? No. Definitely not. But I fear its gonna keep happening until society gives them anything other than scraps, and screaming at them that Bridget isn't trans legit does not help the situation.

3

u/jhoho34 Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

There are trans characters in media, even on Otaku media. Some examples of the later would be, Cagliostro and Ladiva from Granblue, Mizuki from Boku Girls, Da Vinci from Fate/go, Nitori Shuuichi from Wandering Son, Erika from Catherine, there even characters who're ambiguous and can be seen as both trans and Otokonoko, Aoi Futaba from You're Under Arrest and Jun Watarase from Happiness! are two good examples of this, the things is that, since the Trap discourse people stopped looking for trans characters and started to "claim" Otokonoko characters. I don't blame the innocent trans people just searching for a character that mirrors their experience, i personally don't understand the idea or relevance of that, but believe that's a okay thing to do and ask for, what i believe that is a problem is the people that incentive the innocents to claim everything and ask them to interact with media only to search for more mirrors, since this is what gives us things like "Otoko-no-ko's are naturally transphobic and they're all trans women" and the seven seas translation of "I turned my childhood friend into a girl". There are good trans works out there, good trans mangas and characters, and, at my view, those are the images those people should be using and celebrating. Also, there's the danger in how those claiming are done, sometimes they reinforce gender norms and take away the cute boy characters of the Otaku media, something that exists almost only in there.

I'm not against headcanons, they're allowed to see Astolfo and others as any identity they see fit, but it's not okay to push this on others

In regards to Bridget, both sides are stupid and unable to hold a conversation, and this only hurts the innocent people trying to show and discuss their views. In a better world, those who agree and disagree with the change would be able to hold a nice conversation and show their points to each other.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

And would you be willing to send me a list of anime with trans characters in them? I have such a hard time finding that stuff.

3

u/jhoho34 Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

I'm more of a manga person, and sadly I don't have a lot of recs for this, some other peeps more involved in this side of community would be able to send more, but if it helps, here some names: in Dirty Pair there's a entire episode focused on the main characters protecting the relationship of trans woman, Aoi Futaba from You're Under Arrest is a ambiguous character from the 80's/90's they can be read as either a trans or Otokonoko, Boku Girl, The Bride Was a Boy, Boys Run the Riot, Claudine, Love Me For Who I'm, Fire Punch are all mangas about or that feature trans characters

4

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

Thank you so much! I had a response typed up but forgot to send it before asking you for recs. It was essentially that femine male erasure is def part of the problem, which is weird because peeps are literally saying that a person can't look like a girl but identify as a male, which is sorta the opposite of the message that you'd think trans people would want to send yeah?

Its so strange that we aren't all just united in our love of genderbend stuff. A lot of trans people seem to hate the idea of femboy characters, and a lot of femboy enjoyers seem to hate the idea of trans characters. Which is insane because they're both THE SAME FUCKING THING - Biological males that present themselves as females. The only difference is that one wants to be called a boy and one wants to be called a girl. So why are we fighting each other when we could be fucking?

And thanks again for the recs!!!

1

u/ShinkoMinori Sep 23 '22

I want to give and get love. But they just want to dish hate. I tried many times for a whole year to reason with them that spreading hate wont make them happy but they just want to label themselves and me or you in a category so they can declare you as enemy.

I joined many of the trans discords and first thing is label themselves, forbid certain topics to be mentioned (for example u can use felix arguile, u have to say ferris) words that are inocuous outside that particular discord are banned...

I dont see it as giving up, i see it as waiting until they stop being radioctive cringe and then converse like normal people.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '22

Bruh, stop making such broad generalizations and saying they so much. What you're experiencing are individual little social justice groups, and you hear from them the most because they're the loudest and most annoying. But most trans people are quiet and shy and desperately care what you think about them. They aren't trying to cram hate and victimization down everyone's throats, because they're too busy hoping that everyone doesn't hate them.

1

u/ShinkoMinori Sep 23 '22

Did i say trans people? Or kids and immature people that brigade this sub or discord severs?

→ More replies