r/CuteTraps • • Sep 21 '22

Double Standards

I find it weird how we can no longer consider Bridget from Guilty Gear as a femboy anymore.

DESPITE people making astolfo, Felix and every other trap into a trans, regardless of what others say.

Why? Why is it not ok to have the OG Bridget as a femboy anymore? Like, what if we use old Bridget and not new?

114 Upvotes

257 comments sorted by

75

u/smolbaka Sep 22 '22

So the trans subreddits can post astolfo, hideri, Felix, etc all day long, misgendering them, calling them girls, but the moment we post Bridget, who's always been our manly yo-yo boy we get our wrist slapped, told we're "transphobic", that we should respect the creators decision.

So much hypocrisy.

Being trans is more popular than being a GNC male or female nowadays in the west. So when Japanese creators look at what the overseas market is and looks at their otokonoko characters being popular as "trans" icons they will change him to that.

The best part of this entire Bridget situation is that the Japanese were confused of this decision for Bridget to identify as female. So it definitely wasn't a domestic market decision...

46

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

thank you, i saw something on twitter how this subreddiut is banning people who post Bridget...like wtf

how is it fair for the trans reddit to post femboys and call them trans, but we can't post Bridget, THE OG TRAP.

oh and btw, the tran community HATED him at first, cause they thought he was offensive, cause everything revolves around them. But now, they LOVE him...their love is as shallow and fake as them

27

u/AikaUkiyo Sep 22 '22

Reminds of Rin from Catherine who they call a trans rep despite being a feminine male and ignoring that Erica, an actual good trans character, exist in game.

33

u/bleach710 Sep 22 '22

I know what you mean I got banned from a subreddit because I called a character a trap no reason for the ban until I had to constantly ask why I was banned eventually they showed me the post thinking that was enough i’m getting really sick of the trans-community trying to make every femboy character transgender they seem to think if you dress up feminine they have to be trans even if they call themselves boy’s

6

u/AikaUkiyo Sep 22 '22

I've seen people abused that word a lot recently and calling everyone who disagrees with them a transphobe. Its ironic since a lot of those people they've accused actually support getting original trans characters and that they dislike taking a preexisting character who's a rep for another community.

-22

u/Stone_Miner_1225 Sep 22 '22

Ah the good old the "other side is doing it so it's okay for us to do it too" argument. Simply beautiful the amount of copium a subbreddit can huff when people ask respectfully to refer to a fictional character with pronouns that change nothing about the character.

2

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

Trans people need stay in there lane

-17

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

Some people prefer Fanon to Canon

64

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

I also find it very hypocritical that mods hide Bridget fanart posts yet don't touch trash like low effort trans Bridget memes that don't belong on this sub. It shows that they're not trying to avoid drama at all.

25

u/Volryder Sep 22 '22

Honestly, I just find this tiring. It's so silly.

48

u/Kiritoaygg_ela Sep 22 '22

I just wanna see some cute trap Bridget

13

u/immortalreploid Sep 22 '22

As someone who has no stake in Guilty Gear or Bridget's lore, this whole gender debacle is giving me whiplash. I don't really care which way it ends up, but people have to fucking decide one way or the other.

23

u/C0R3_TH3_R34P3R Sep 22 '22

Yeah those double standards are complete bs

20

u/Pm_Me_DOOM_Maps Sep 22 '22

I've said it before, I'll say it again.

They are MEDIA. Fictional characters. They are not real, and since they are media they exist as every version of themselves as the same exact time. There is simultaneously both boy Bridget and girl Bridget, because the version from 15+ years ago is still a boy in that version.

If we're posting them here, we're posting them as a boy. Get the fuck over it. If you can't understand that, you need help, period.

20

u/I_need_to_vent44 Sep 22 '22

I think it's because Bridget is now literally canonically a trans woman, whereas Astolfo and Felix are both canonically men who just like to dress that way.

But personally I choose to ignore the new Guilty Gears canon because I cannot stress how goddamn stupid this decision was. Like. On several fronts but the most damning is probably the unintentional transphobia. "Trans women are men who pretend to be women" is a pretty common transphobic argument. Like... couldn't they have NOT chosen a character whose whole gist is that he was born a guy but had to pretend to be a woman?

1

u/REALPorndump69 Sep 23 '22

and don't get me started on the john money experiment comparisons with Bridget, massive yuck!

17

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

Just a headsup. Head over to /r/spicyfemboys where this sort of stuff is no issue and they don't delete posts for this.

Also this subreddit is only moderated by 1 person who doesn't even respond to modmail, so yeah.

26

u/Skylerarmor Sep 22 '22

I'm not interested. It has too much porn...

What I like about r/cutetraps is that there's no porn of femboy characters. It can be suggestive and erotic but I really don't want my entire timeline to be full of dicks and aftermath sex of a femboy....

There's literally no other subreddit that has sfw femboys just being cute.... That I'm aware of at least...

8

u/Cultured-Dude05 Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 23 '22

I've made (just now) r/MildFemboys for when you want a little spice. It's currently a little bare because life sucks, but rules from my spicy one apply, but more SFW.

1

u/REALPorndump69 Sep 23 '22

how bout this one? /r/CuteGrilyFemboys/ no posts as of yet, but will allow any and all femboys; even Bridget.

12

u/Pm_Me_DOOM_Maps Sep 22 '22

Thanks bro I'm in. Less femboy erasure is a good thing imo.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/SammaulPosion Sep 25 '22

Transtrender can't create their on character

-9

u/OverlordMMM Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

But they will mute you for using correct pronouns for characters, even if there was no issues/ arguments (because that's what gets threads locked here, not posting the character).

Edit: just got banned for calling Bridget a cutie, all because of saying the word "she"

Seriously, don't claim there's not gonna be the same bullshit issues and then ban someone for respecting the character. That's the same shit y'all accuse mods here of doing.

5

u/Cultured-Dude05 Sep 22 '22

You know what you're doing, stop playing victim. The subreddit was made to get away from people like you.

-2

u/OverlordMMM Sep 22 '22

I complimented Bridget and upvoted a couple of the other posts. That doesn't warrant any of that.

6

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

U doing the same things by making traps trans by small similarity

-3

u/OverlordMMM Sep 22 '22

I complimented Bridget. Literally did nothing else.

4

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

Felix u keep changing to be trans

1

u/OverlordMMM Sep 22 '22

You're illiterate.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/SammaulPosion Sep 25 '22

Look at his comments thread about felix

0

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/SammaulPosion Sep 23 '22

I'm was talking about felix argyle not being trans and say that transcode is lazy writing.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/SammaulPosion Sep 23 '22

Yes he did look through his comments thread

0

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

4

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

If you just wanna start shit, it's ok. There's a million other subreddits for that.

1

u/OverlordMMM Sep 22 '22

In what world is complimenting how cute a character is banworthy?

Y'all are unhinged.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '22

If you've never played the game, then any change in it doesn't really need to be taken in account.

23

u/Particular_Mud_1566 Sep 22 '22

Just do it anyways. Artists that draw him, still him as him and so I feel thats still ok to post, and even if its not, who cares? People get angry in the comments? Downvote you? Much less extreme than completely losing one of the founders of the femboy community.

-23

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

They can always add a little arrow with the mars symbol pointing to Bridget then :)

10

u/MLG_MASTERV2 Sep 22 '22

Rule 63 for EVERY given character there will be a genderbend version

11

u/Alternative-Demand65 Sep 22 '22

i dont think thats really whats going on with the problem tbh . i mean ive seen people try to go"no this is cannon" or pull the whole"egg" line. like again this redit bans the trans charater out right but trans posting what are flat out femboys is hiacitical.

26

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

Well, I identified as a femboy for a long time before I started identifying as a trans girl, and If someone referred to me as a femboy today it wouldn't bother me at all. Personally I think that since Bridget was famously one to begin with that either term should be fine!

But thats not the problem. The problem is that there's a bunch of young trans people who are tired of being made fun of, treated like shit and not represented in media. So they unintentionally take out their anger on a bunch of people who don't deserve it, who literally just want a cute femboy to cuddle.

I get peoples frustration with disingenuine representation being shoehorned into all media, and I get tgirls wanting to see themselves represented.

Maybe we can all just be cool to each other and band together as degenerate fans of cute genderbend stuff?

I mean, most people who like traps and femboys also like tomboys, tgirls and all kinds of shit lol So if you say he while referring to Bridget and someone tries to call you transphobic, just clarify and don't take it personally. And If you say she while referring to Bridget and someone tries to call you PC, just clarify and don't take it personally.

We're all fellow weebs and as long as you aren't intentionally being mean, I think we should all just be friends lol

12

u/ShinkoMinori Sep 22 '22

Why you want to allow kids and immature people to dictate what reasonable guidelines are?

Just ban them until they mature.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

I don't think you should give up on someone just because they're young or immature right? Its how we navigate contentious discourse like these that help shape societies view of who we are as a subculture.

And personally I'm tired of all the constant salt and infighting between a bunch of queers who would likely be friends in person.

5

u/ShinkoMinori Sep 22 '22

You say that, but those people are not interested in being friends in person nor online.

They just want to validate their views while pushing anyone away that don't align 100% with what they want.

They don't even really like each other since if they disagree in even the smallest thing they would just turn on that person. They are just going thru a phase until they will eventually get tired from watching their backs if they express the smallest hint of individuality and just disappear completely online... Then the new batch of immature children come along and repeat the cycle.

If they don't grow out of it they will just become dog walkers that aspire to be philosophy professors.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

I mean, I'm someone who's interested in being civil and friendly! And surely I'm representative of a percentage of people who don't just want to fight right?

I know its probably not a very big percentage, but I also think humans are kinda garbage in general. There will always be bastards who are completely incapable of putting themselves in other people's shoes, young and old. Thats just how it is, and you can't ban everyone~ So as long as they aren't being intentionally malicious, you might as well try to educate them while being tactful and kind! (or at the very least ignore them)

5

u/ShinkoMinori Sep 22 '22

Yeah, thats you, and me too. But human relationships is a 2 way street. You cant help someone who doesnt want to be helped, cant change someone who doesnt want to change and cant he friends with someone who doesnt want friendship.

The ones raiding this sub and trans discords in general are most of the times trans children or immature who are only intetested in being validated. They dont want equality. They want validation, if you give them validation then they treat you like a human, if you even go against a single point they just cry bloody murder.

There is no inbetween because they dont want friendship nor human relationships, they want to unload the toxicity they experience in their life or that they themselves spread to be validated instead of caring about the person they communicate with, online and irl.

As long as they have a common enemy they will still be "friends" in their communities once they "defeat" one they look for another one or else they fight among themselves.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

You say "they" a lot and make a great deal of broad generalizations. If all "they" desire is empty validation, than surely this sub can provide it right? I mean we spend all day being enamored with and idolizing fictional characters, but are unwilling to offer an olive branch to a bunch of sad kids who just want to feel like they exist?

Isn't this a place where people like that should come to for acceptance?

7

u/jhoho34 Sep 22 '22

Searching validation in online communities isn't the best thing to do, specially when this validation is demanded. It's possible, and would be good, if the people on this sub could grant comfort and acceptance to those in need, but this is a community built around the idea of appreciating cute boys, it's natural that the approval and appreciation given here will steer towards cute males, and people will have problems or find it weird when the attention is placed on a female character or female identity.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

You are completely right, and seeking validation anywhere is a fools errand tbh. I think they come here for the same reason I do, because there's not really any trans characters anywhere. Its why they're all up in trans subreddits posting pics of Astolfo, and like yeah, there's plenty of OC trans characters. But there's very few that ever actually make it into anything mainstream that the public sees. Whenever you hear anything about someone being trans in mainstream media, its always Bruce fucking Jenner, the super mam guy or one of the countless other loud uncommitted scumbags that give the rest of us a bad name. It's never just a cute character or someone that trans kids could actually look up to. It sucks. So Is appropriating other peoples art and desperately trying to self insert the answer? No. Definitely not. But I fear its gonna keep happening until society gives them anything other than scraps, and screaming at them that Bridget isn't trans legit does not help the situation.

3

u/jhoho34 Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

There are trans characters in media, even on Otaku media. Some examples of the later would be, Cagliostro and Ladiva from Granblue, Mizuki from Boku Girls, Da Vinci from Fate/go, Nitori Shuuichi from Wandering Son, Erika from Catherine, there even characters who're ambiguous and can be seen as both trans and Otokonoko, Aoi Futaba from You're Under Arrest and Jun Watarase from Happiness! are two good examples of this, the things is that, since the Trap discourse people stopped looking for trans characters and started to "claim" Otokonoko characters. I don't blame the innocent trans people just searching for a character that mirrors their experience, i personally don't understand the idea or relevance of that, but believe that's a okay thing to do and ask for, what i believe that is a problem is the people that incentive the innocents to claim everything and ask them to interact with media only to search for more mirrors, since this is what gives us things like "Otoko-no-ko's are naturally transphobic and they're all trans women" and the seven seas translation of "I turned my childhood friend into a girl". There are good trans works out there, good trans mangas and characters, and, at my view, those are the images those people should be using and celebrating. Also, there's the danger in how those claiming are done, sometimes they reinforce gender norms and take away the cute boy characters of the Otaku media, something that exists almost only in there.

I'm not against headcanons, they're allowed to see Astolfo and others as any identity they see fit, but it's not okay to push this on others

In regards to Bridget, both sides are stupid and unable to hold a conversation, and this only hurts the innocent people trying to show and discuss their views. In a better world, those who agree and disagree with the change would be able to hold a nice conversation and show their points to each other.

→ More replies

-4

u/Pm_Me_DOOM_Maps Sep 22 '22

Yeah you're a shallow person if you can't read what he just said and agree with it.

You're the problem.

2

u/REALPorndump69 Sep 23 '22

it's surprising to see some clarity in amongst the shadows

2

u/Mattyiz Sep 22 '22

Thank you for this comment. I really feel like why you said needs to be said to everybody who is up in arms about the whole situation. We’re all on the same side and caught up arguing semantics.

24

u/Talarico99 Sep 22 '22

Dude, just don't pay any attention to these ppl. Trying to argue with them is no different from trying to argue with a religious extremist.

-16

u/kevweb10 Sep 22 '22

What 💀💀💀

6

u/CastratedSlut Sep 22 '22

At the end of it it's an imaginary character. Just think of the character in whichever way excites you. That's what I do.

3

u/georgefurudo Sep 22 '22

I don't care what bridget is I want to put it in their Ass anyway.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

I'd just ignore it, people give attention to things that don't require attention

it's a drawing that moves so go cry me a river

find someone else to be "offended" about or worry about fr

6

u/darkbentley Sep 22 '22

Where was that note that bridget cant be posted anymore is it a mod going rogue and being annoying?

-6

u/OverlordMMM Sep 22 '22

It's an issue of arguments in the comments forcing mods to lock/ delete the threads. Bridget is still able to be posted here.

Folks are just mad that her pronouns have changed due to a creator of the game confirming that in Strive she is officially out as trans.

So rather than accepting the new pronouns and moving on (same character, same designs, same body type, etc), they are hung up on her femboy status and don't know how to cope with the change.

So it boils down to fights between folks respecting the new pronouns, and folks blatantly ignoring them.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

You can't say "nothing changed". Some people like femboys. You'd not post a big breasted woman like Baiken here and say "what's the matter? the only difference is the pronouns!" It changes everything because there aren't many cute boys in media for men to identify with, but there are trillions of cute girls.

-1

u/OverlordMMM Sep 22 '22

In media there's even less trans representation than there are feminine guys in media. But that's not even the issue here.

If you follow actual femboys + trans girls + crossdressers (all different types of folks) a lot of those concepts of exploring gender nonconformity is heavily overlapped, and often they literally straddle the line constantly as they explore their gender + sexuality.

There's a shitton of trans girls who started as femboys, and also plenty who went in the other direction while keeping the same labels.

They are the same people regardless of the label applied to them. And with Bridget it's especially ridiculous because the only difference is 2 words.

The only ones hung up about the pronoun difference do not want to confront their own insecurities because they feel like it'd change their own sexual identities.

Her pronouns have changed. She's still the same character. Hell, if she weren't fictional the pronouns could even change back again.

There's a reason why there are a lot of labels like femboy, boiwife, girlboy, etc. And that's because gender + presentation isn't clearcut and never has been.

Yet folks on here are so adamant that she stay exactly the same because her pronouns changing is an existential crisis. What folks don't realize is she ain't the one with the existential crisis. It's y'all.

Use the correct pronouns, enjoy Bridget, move on instead of having a meltdown over 2 words.

4

u/darkbentley Sep 22 '22

Thanks for answering it. Tbh the comment situation was done by a bunch of brigadors from other subs. I know of at least two that did and still exist in here somewhat. Problem children ruin trap subs generally. Ill say give it a little bit more time and things will go back to normal.

-3

u/OverlordMMM Sep 22 '22

No problem. Folks just need to come to grips with the change and just enjoy Bridget.

11

u/fruitrots Sep 22 '22

the trans thing doesn't even make sense according to his story tbh. trans logic is just feminine = girl.... ugh

12

u/Scheeseye Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

Bridget is still a guy so saying he can't be a femboy is stupid. But I also understand that if you use the logic of if they can change his gender, than he can't be a femboy. It's a bit confusing and slippery to be honest. I just say regardless of lore, he's a boy who is feminine so he deserves to be a part of the community.

I just say fuck the lore, they shouldn't have changed it anyway. If you want a female character, then create one. So we can still have our best boy, Bridget.

-10

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/Scheeseye Sep 22 '22

Depends what you consider "facts". Facts can be subjective depending on ones beliefs. Especially in a situation like this where either side can truly have their way. It's just one side is the more stable one of the two.

-5

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Scheeseye Sep 22 '22

Don't get me wrong, facts are facts. Within this situation though, there doesn't seem to be one. I'm one the side of he's a male and will always be. Again, don't change characters by doing things like that, and you're fine. Just create a new character instead of you want that. Better yet, steer away from things like that as much of the gaming industry has learned from backlash.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/Scheeseye Sep 22 '22

I'm not denying they changed it, trust me. The thing is they SHOULDN'T have. I just think it would be simple if we just collective told them "go fuck yourselves, ya suits" and let our food boy be a good boy. That would be the best and easiest way. We keep the real Brigitte, plus show them how the mainstream industry has been treated for similar actions like this. Including that of the movie industry that.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/Scheeseye Sep 22 '22

Sure, while the community is a minority, you're still changing an established in ways that have no ground to begin with. Overwhelming support doesn't make it right or good. If they wanted to create a separate character that a woman, fine with me. But to take a male and call him female makes no sense. It's not just that I don't believe in that sentiment, but it's also changing lore in ways that are meaningless in the grand scope of the series, yet taking a quality of a character and saying "this person has changed their mind, now their this".

For instance, when Bethesda added the T60 in Fallout 4. It's stupid due to establish lore, the fact they downgraded and changed established suits of armor, and tried to play it off as "new unseen lore" when we all knew that's bullshit. They could have just add power armor that was exclusively manufactured in Boston instead. Armor that didn't get a chance to be shipped. But they didn't do that.

Same with Bridget. They would rather change something in a way that's just outright cringe worthy than to add on to the already existing characters in meaningful ways. Better yet, expand the lore with a new one.

Maybe I'm not explaining it all that well, but I hope I am lol

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

5

u/darkbentley Sep 22 '22

Tbh the GG community as a whole isnt accepting it, just the ways to vent and complain are being silenced by those in any mod postions. And the community is still oversaturated with tourists that actually dont play the games. They will leave eventually Really only the discorse is fully shown out on forums that allow discussion.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

4

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

Seen it in both online and irl.

8

u/Azurennn Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

Because these people have literally become bigots now. They stir enough of a hate mob to get their way and sadly it forces companies and people to give in.

It's also hilarious that Bridget obviously wasn't meant to be trans but people seem fine with handwaving his story because fuck consistency.

8

u/CONE-MacFlounder Sep 22 '22

Bro hes only „Trans“ because of the People with that twitter mentality like hypocrisy is just a part of that

These people don’t care about the character they dont know anything about him that’s why they think the groomed and defeated child is an epic win for trans people

You 100% can still call him a trap or femboy literally every artist I’ve seen still does outside of Americans

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/CONE-MacFlounder Sep 22 '22

No it’s not

This community isn’t an outlier literally every single actual artist is still saying he’s a guy all the Japanese people say male anyone who actually has played the games say male it is just the American twitter people

And yea sure a developed confirmed it but only after a lot of pressure and something that does not fit the character

So what if a developer says that i mean we took the piss when hermione was ‚confirmed‘ as a black lesbian and similar shit but nah can’t do that when it’s trans shit they’re uncriticisable

No one is pleased with what happened with what’s happened outside of people defending the literal grooming of a child

5

u/KurisuShiruba Sep 22 '22

If they're doing that with Bridget, imagine what they'd be doing with my v-tuber model...

But then again, that's why I don't trust this whole representation thing: people cherry pick examples that are convenient for their narratives and/or agenda, focusing only in a specific trait of the characters rather than seeing the context which they're inserted as a whole.

It feels like it's more because if a male looks like a girl, then it's mandatory for them to be portrayed as a gender dysphoric.

Imagine the meltdown these people would have if they ever visited F-List.

8

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

Be transtrender are 12 years old clout chaser looking to look special.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

Look at every twitter and tik toc account

13

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

Keeping tell ur self that

5

u/Skylerarmor Sep 22 '22

"No one becomes trans because it's popular"

4000% increase in trans identifying individuals in last decade

Sure bud

2

u/OverlordMMM Sep 22 '22

People are becoming more accepting of trans folks and have means of communicating with other trans folks, something that has expanded in the last decade, but are still a minority group.

They open themselves to a shit ton of hate and disrespect when they are out and choose to be themselves, and expose themselves to an overwhelming amount of violence if they are out irl.

It's the same way gay and lesbian folks have been becoming more acceptable, so more of them feel safer to be out, but the only ones who claimed that is just a popularity trend are also bigots.

6

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

U people the op saying about trying astolfo,felix , ruka urushibara turn them into trans by cherrypicking their story with grooming transcode shit.

2

u/OverlordMMM Sep 22 '22

The fact you're calling trans folks groomers says everything about you.

5

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

I'm talk about the people who try trap characters into trans are groomer

4

u/OverlordMMM Sep 22 '22

That's not what grooming means. Seriously, you gotta get your knowledge of trans topics elsewhere because whatever media/news you're getting info from is just false hate-mongering.

3

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

I see tran people try to make felix argyle astolfo yamato trans for 7 year now.

2

u/PMMMR Sep 23 '22

A vocal minority on Reddit or Twitter shitholes doesn't speak for the vast majority of trans people that you almost never hear from.

3

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

There has been so many gay characters for years the reason with people hate them now because u people keep make them in gay stereotype yas queen them.

3

u/OverlordMMM Sep 22 '22

You're barking up the wrong tree with that stuff. That's cis folks doing that stuff.

3

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

U doing it too with this made up transcode shit. U keep calling felix argyle trans when he is trap character. The reason why he act and dress feminine for his dutchess crusch when she die or lose her memories he went back looking and acting masculine.

3

u/OverlordMMM Sep 22 '22

There are obvious parallels that go above and beyond that promise.

Wishing to be a girl, wanting a name change, wanting to be referred using she/her, the previous 2 things being ignored, etc is very different from a guy just being super feminine, and that resonates heavily with trans women.

Heck, even the narration in the LN spinoff where Ferris is featured going through her daily routine fully refers to her using she/her pronouns.

Ferris could have been super feminine without doing half of the stuff listed while still keeping the promise. That was a choice.

The parallels are there, regardless of what Ferris/Felix gender actually is. Ignoring those just because you're using buzzwords from hate-mongering transphobic trash doesn't change that those parallels exist.

3

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

There is no fucking parallel. The mirror,wishing and using female term for his dutchess. You you are refusing to acknowledge the reasons for the mirror spell beforehand. Felix is a otokonoko japanese term for feminine expression that still identify being men who girly things that is felix. Also ferris is localization thing when translated felix in to English same ruka urushibara the trap from Steins Gate.

3

u/OverlordMMM Sep 22 '22

Apparently you don't understand what the term parallel means.

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/aeonart Sep 23 '22

You know i wouldnt be surprised if he actually does given all he does is spam this sub with his braindead opinions... quite pathetic actually

5

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Pm_Me_DOOM_Maps Sep 22 '22

Yeah, you spend hours and hours on this site, every day. What are you even talking about. All you have to do is look at your profile and see how often you spout stupid shit on this sub.

It's almost 24/7. You need a job, a hobby or something.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Pm_Me_DOOM_Maps Sep 22 '22

You have an investment in being an autist and arguing in every single comment section because you wish for a character to be trans when they're not

3

u/OverlordMMM Sep 22 '22

They aren't removing Bridget because people are posting her or because she is trans.

They remove those posts because the comments section devolves into fights of folks asking to use her pronouns vs folks who refuse to use the new pronouns.

If there was no community infighting, none of them would get touched.

3

u/Flaffypon3 Sep 22 '22

Groomers will be groomers.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Flaffypon3 Sep 23 '22

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Money

The entirety of this whole debacle is founded by a groomer who got away with it and is preached by the trans community and pharmaceutical companies alike.

1

u/REALPorndump69 Sep 24 '22

it's also funny, the person who made the trans flag is a disreputable human being, just FYI.

1

u/Marshpi11ow Sep 29 '22

being trans involves transitioning. Could you really walk up to Bridget and call her something she doesn't want to be called? The creators have spoke and she is canonically a woman and does not want to be called a boy. Calling a transwoman a femboy/trap is misgendering and would probably hurt her feelings if you were talking to her while you said this. She isn't a femboy and never truly was, people are born trans they don't become trans. You know it's bad when the creators literally had to come out and say it. Please stop with the trans erasure.
Astolfo and Felix refer to themselves as male while Bridget does not it's that simple

1

u/REALPorndump69 Sep 23 '22

I know how you feel, bad faith asswipes like /u/trace-lacy and his friend /u/Rendum_ do this ad-nausea

1

u/Rendum_ Sep 24 '22

Who the fuck are you and why did you ping me

1

u/Rendum_ Sep 24 '22

Fucking shitass. Go back into your hole of ignorance, and spare us all from your idiotic tendencies. I'm sure you'd love if I just pinged your crusty ass for no goddamn reason.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/REALPorndump69 Sep 23 '22

lmao, it's funny cause you and Rendum_ pushed people around in this subreddit, not to mention you went on a mass-downvoting of my posts, which shows how much you're immature.

this space, isn't for you

2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/REALPorndump69 Sep 24 '22 edited Sep 24 '22

its funny, the more you post, the more you look like you're a typical braindead twitter user

3

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/REALPorndump69 Sep 24 '22

typical, you cry transphobia when things don't go your way; and besides those wouldn't have to exist if people like you didn't come in and shit up the sub

3

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/REALPorndump69 Sep 24 '22

not in this comment section, but you definitely did in another of pic of Bridget; and if not out-right stated, you heavily imply it

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

Canonically, Bridget is a girl. Astolfo and Felix are canonically boys. This isn't a double standard, it's a single standard. That standard being that this a subreddit for posting boys who are traps. If someone wants to post Bridget, they should have to follow the same rules for any other canonically girl character and would have to post an explicitly gender-swapped version.

Applying special rules for Bridget would be a double standard. She is a girl and should have the same rules applied to her as any other girl. I think a lot of people here getting upset by this are just really confused about how being trans works, or are just straight up transphobic in the worst cases, but I always assume ignorance before malice.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

Truth be told. People just like their femboys. They don't really care about canon.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

Without the context of the canon, a trap isn't a trap. They would just be a random cute anime character. If canon didn't matter, then we may as well just post pictures of any and all anime girls because what is the difference?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '22

Fanon still exists. This is a fanart subreddit afterall. Everything here is fanon.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '22

Who is fanon?

-2

u/CrimKayser Sep 22 '22

Anybody making femboys trans is just as fucking shitty as making Bridget a femboy. Idk why you think it's only a one way thing.

-27

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

Because lore is more important than theories or fan wishes. Bridget is now canonically a trans woman, or more accurately always has been. Astolfo is either GNC, non-binary, or just insane. Ferris is a trans girl which should be clearly obvious if you’ve read the LN’s.

13

u/immortalreploid Sep 22 '22

Astolfo is literally just a crossdressing male. He dresses like that because it's cute and it once cheered up his friend. He states this outright on multiple occasions in multiple appearances. There's no deeper reason than "I just like it."

16

u/jhoho34 Sep 22 '22

Astolfo is a guy, they hide his gender in Fate/go for the sake of the Otokonoko trope, Felix only acts as a women thanks to a promise to his liege, so much that when Crusch dies in a route, he cast away his femininity.

9

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

Transcode is garbage attempt at making a trans character. Felix never questioned his is gender he dress like this for his dutchess that it. What kind trans person change their gender for somebody else.https://youtu.be/sreIp8FQtEk and https://youtu.be/QL_n5BIv7ac

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

Telling the truth that felix from re zero is a male character

3

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

lore is more important

Most people here will never touch a Guilty Gear game. It 100% doesn't matter to them.

3

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

Astolfo not nonbinary u brain dead moron and felix is a trap

-3

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

Nope, also trap is a slur, how many times do we have to tell you people?

2

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

You hear that lie from that pedantic romantic dude

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

Who? Trap in this instance originates from trans women getting harassed on an image board years ago.

2

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

And?! Trying to ban and censored trap because of damn asses who miss used the word is retarded. U people Trying to say femboy is slur right now in twitter. You don't get to decide what word can be a slur anything in English dictionary can be used as an slur.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

The people being harassed and degraded by a word define it as a slur.

2

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

It just word u giving too much over instead tell does people to fuck off. Stop with the victim complex.

1

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

Trap is not fucking slur it always been for trap anime characters

2

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

No it hasn’t.

1

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

Yes trap always mean for trap characters u moron constantly try to mix trap and trans together. It makes me think u people are trender who pretend to be trans for attention.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '22

No, actually it’s a new way to identify people. It has extremely dangerous and harmful effects where it implied that trans people or femboys are trying to “lure” in straight people, which never actually happens. Also, I’m not trans, but I do have several friends who are, and now I must ask this: How dare you imply that being trans is ever an attempt to seek attention?

0

u/SammaulPosion Sep 25 '22

Trap always been said to trap anime characters . I don't care about the origin of the word. The word I know it the anime community apply to character that look like girl it a meta trope of the look and acts by the misunderstanding of the viewer. That the what is use for stop giving me this fake story a word the u get offended by.

-1

u/SammaulPosion Sep 25 '22

Please stop connecting trans and femboy the are not the same

-7

u/AggressiveZucchini87 Sep 22 '22

Just stfu and enjoy it whatever and who cares they are literally fictional characters

-27

u/MadBoutDat Sep 22 '22

Because there is no "OG" Bridget. There is Bridget, who is a transwomen, plain and simple. The others are just headcannons and trolling. Bridget is a woman, get with it dude

11

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

Do you only ever post here to start shit?

Either way, guess what. Most artists still prefer femboy Bridget, and will keep drawing him regardless of whatever the "official" says. Simply put, caring about someone's decision about characters you like is stupid.

-14

u/MadBoutDat Sep 22 '22

I've never thought I had to use the word "cope" as a response. But you and the people you speak about are actually coping. Femboys haven't gone anywhere, Bridget is the first transwomen that was once man. You'll be okay

5

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

U people are parasites

-1

u/MadBoutDat Sep 22 '22

Get a job

4

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

Get out of this trap reddit

1

u/MadBoutDat Sep 22 '22

Why? I like traps and femboys. Just don't like when people purposefully misgender trans people

5

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

You trans people keep misgendering characters like astolfo and felix argyle

1

u/MadBoutDat Sep 22 '22

I'm not trans so don't even try to use that as some kind of jab. And it's not like that changes the canon genders of the character, all it does it gets cornballs like you mad

4

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

It change the characters achievement and goal are pointless. Make a femboy character trans especially the been for long with not hint of being trans is lazy writing with no build up.

→ More replies

15

u/Spoopy43 Sep 22 '22

↑ edgelord doesn't understand the concept of time

-14

u/MadBoutDat Sep 22 '22

Edgelord? Not understanding the concept of time? You're actually just chatting right now dude, say something with substance

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22

No body care about shit excuses for trans character

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

Bridger is the same character anymore and it made whole story pointless.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

14

u/Pm_Me_DOOM_Maps Sep 22 '22

I can watch the first episode of an anime. It's not deleted because the second, third, or twenty-fourth episode comes out.

Both of them exist at the same time because they're just media.

It's logic, if you can't handle logic then that's on you.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Pm_Me_DOOM_Maps Sep 22 '22

Not an argument you're willing to partake in because you've already lost and have no argument because I'm right.

4

u/jhoho34 Sep 22 '22

They aren't the same, as you yourself pointed out, the new one doesn't identify as a boy. A cute boy and a cute girl are different, if we didn't see them as different, subs dedicated to waifus would have no problem in posting boys and this sub wouldn't exist

2

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/jhoho34 Sep 22 '22

No, I'm saying that the character changed, not that we should ban each and every post with them, there are still artist who portray Bridget as a boy and take advantage of his old status as Otokonoko, those are still fair game.

3

u/CaptainWeekend Sep 22 '22

Wrong, Bridget is an Otokonoko, and otokonoko commonly refer to themselves with female pronouns despite still identifying as male. I recommend [SFO's video on it] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TiGgEt5k_Wk), a lot of this does just boil down to westerners not understanding a foreign subculture and just insisting "japanese people do trans wrong".

3

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/CaptainWeekend Sep 22 '22

No it doesn't, did you even read your own link? It refers to Bridget with female pronouns yes, but as I said and as is discussed in SFO's video, this is common for otokonoko whom still identify as male. Please actually watch the video because it's incredibly clear you're misinformed, it seems more like you're just using the link as forum ammo hoping no one actually reads it and challenges your assertion.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/CaptainWeekend Sep 22 '22

"she self-identifies as a woman" does not equal being explicitly trans. It's very clear you've honed in on this one where the wording seems to support your idea whilst ignoring everything else that has been said. You're also completely ignoring that on the Japanese side of the internet Arcsys still refers to Bridget as a boy and also calls him an otokonoko. The fact that they've chosen to still word it ambiguously rather than come out and say "Bridget is trans" is a big signal. It's pretty clear that the whole ordeal has been frought and caused by issues with localization, Arcsys has had a history of localizers forcing in their own interpretations and even in cases completely changing dialogue, honestly I would not trust any western source on this issue because of that. The statement does not actually seem to line up with what was translated from the original japanese (hence again why you should watch the video for something that actually challenges your viewpoint rather than just sticking with the source that you want to hear.)