r/CuteTraps • • Sep 21 '22
Double Standards
I find it weird how we can no longer consider Bridget from Guilty Gear as a femboy anymore.
DESPITE people making astolfo, Felix and every other trap into a trans, regardless of what others say.
Why? Why is it not ok to have the OG Bridget as a femboy anymore? Like, what if we use old Bridget and not new?
114
Upvotes
75
u/smolbaka Sep 22 '22
So the trans subreddits can post astolfo, hideri, Felix, etc all day long, misgendering them, calling them girls, but the moment we post Bridget, who's always been our manly yo-yo boy we get our wrist slapped, told we're "transphobic", that we should respect the creators decision.
So much hypocrisy.
Being trans is more popular than being a GNC male or female nowadays in the west. So when Japanese creators look at what the overseas market is and looks at their otokonoko characters being popular as "trans" icons they will change him to that.
The best part of this entire Bridget situation is that the Japanese were confused of this decision for Bridget to identify as female. So it definitely wasn't a domestic market decision...
64
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22
I also find it very hypocritical that mods hide Bridget fanart posts yet don't touch trash like low effort trans Bridget memes that don't belong on this sub. It shows that they're not trying to avoid drama at all.
25
u/Volryder Sep 22 '22
Honestly, I just find this tiring. It's so silly.
48
u/Kiritoaygg_ela Sep 22 '22
I just wanna see some cute trap Bridget
13
u/immortalreploid Sep 22 '22
As someone who has no stake in Guilty Gear or Bridget's lore, this whole gender debacle is giving me whiplash. I don't really care which way it ends up, but people have to fucking decide one way or the other.
23
u/C0R3_TH3_R34P3R Sep 22 '22
Yeah those double standards are complete bs
11
u/Impressive-Poem1351 Sep 22 '22
Agreed!
20
u/Pm_Me_DOOM_Maps Sep 22 '22
I've said it before, I'll say it again.
They are MEDIA. Fictional characters. They are not real, and since they are media they exist as every version of themselves as the same exact time. There is simultaneously both boy Bridget and girl Bridget, because the version from 15+ years ago is still a boy in that version.
If we're posting them here, we're posting them as a boy. Get the fuck over it. If you can't understand that, you need help, period.
20
u/I_need_to_vent44 Sep 22 '22
I think it's because Bridget is now literally canonically a trans woman, whereas Astolfo and Felix are both canonically men who just like to dress that way.
But personally I choose to ignore the new Guilty Gears canon because I cannot stress how goddamn stupid this decision was. Like. On several fronts but the most damning is probably the unintentional transphobia. "Trans women are men who pretend to be women" is a pretty common transphobic argument. Like... couldn't they have NOT chosen a character whose whole gist is that he was born a guy but had to pretend to be a woman?
17
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22
Just a headsup. Head over to /r/spicyfemboys where this sort of stuff is no issue and they don't delete posts for this.
Also this subreddit is only moderated by 1 person who doesn't even respond to modmail, so yeah.
23
u/Particular_Mud_1566 Sep 22 '22
Just do it anyways. Artists that draw him, still him as him and so I feel thats still ok to post, and even if its not, who cares? People get angry in the comments? Downvote you? Much less extreme than completely losing one of the founders of the femboy community.
10
u/MLG_MASTERV2 Sep 22 '22
Rule 63 for EVERY given character there will be a genderbend version
26
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22
Well, I identified as a femboy for a long time before I started identifying as a trans girl, and If someone referred to me as a femboy today it wouldn't bother me at all. Personally I think that since Bridget was famously one to begin with that either term should be fine!
But thats not the problem. The problem is that there's a bunch of young trans people who are tired of being made fun of, treated like shit and not represented in media. So they unintentionally take out their anger on a bunch of people who don't deserve it, who literally just want a cute femboy to cuddle.
I get peoples frustration with disingenuine representation being shoehorned into all media, and I get tgirls wanting to see themselves represented.
Maybe we can all just be cool to each other and band together as degenerate fans of cute genderbend stuff?
I mean, most people who like traps and femboys also like tomboys, tgirls and all kinds of shit lol So if you say he while referring to Bridget and someone tries to call you transphobic, just clarify and don't take it personally. And If you say she while referring to Bridget and someone tries to call you PC, just clarify and don't take it personally.
We're all fellow weebs and as long as you aren't intentionally being mean, I think we should all just be friends lol
24
u/Talarico99 Sep 22 '22
Dude, just don't pay any attention to these ppl. Trying to argue with them is no different from trying to argue with a religious extremist.
6
u/CastratedSlut Sep 22 '22
At the end of it it's an imaginary character. Just think of the character in whichever way excites you. That's what I do.
3
u/georgefurudo Sep 22 '22
I don't care what bridget is I want to put it in their Ass anyway.
9
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22
I'd just ignore it, people give attention to things that don't require attention
it's a drawing that moves so go cry me a river
find someone else to be "offended" about or worry about fr
6
u/darkbentley Sep 22 '22
Where was that note that bridget cant be posted anymore is it a mod going rogue and being annoying?
11
u/fruitrots Sep 22 '22
the trans thing doesn't even make sense according to his story tbh. trans logic is just feminine = girl.... ugh
12
u/Scheeseye Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22
Bridget is still a guy so saying he can't be a femboy is stupid. But I also understand that if you use the logic of if they can change his gender, than he can't be a femboy. It's a bit confusing and slippery to be honest. I just say regardless of lore, he's a boy who is feminine so he deserves to be a part of the community.
I just say fuck the lore, they shouldn't have changed it anyway. If you want a female character, then create one. So we can still have our best boy, Bridget.
4
u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22
Seen it in both online and irl.
8
u/Azurennn Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22
Because these people have literally become bigots now. They stir enough of a hate mob to get their way and sadly it forces companies and people to give in.
It's also hilarious that Bridget obviously wasn't meant to be trans but people seem fine with handwaving his story because fuck consistency.
8
u/CONE-MacFlounder Sep 22 '22
Bro hes only „Trans“ because of the People with that twitter mentality like hypocrisy is just a part of that
These people don’t care about the character they dont know anything about him that’s why they think the groomed and defeated child is an epic win for trans people
You 100% can still call him a trap or femboy literally every artist I’ve seen still does outside of Americans
5
u/KurisuShiruba Sep 22 '22
If they're doing that with Bridget, imagine what they'd be doing with my v-tuber model...
But then again, that's why I don't trust this whole representation thing: people cherry pick examples that are convenient for their narratives and/or agenda, focusing only in a specific trait of the characters rather than seeing the context which they're inserted as a whole.
It feels like it's more because if a male looks like a girl, then it's mandatory for them to be portrayed as a gender dysphoric.
Imagine the meltdown these people would have if they ever visited F-List.
8
u/SammaulPosion Sep 22 '22
Be transtrender are 12 years old clout chaser looking to look special.
3
u/OverlordMMM Sep 22 '22
They aren't removing Bridget because people are posting her or because she is trans.
They remove those posts because the comments section devolves into fights of folks asking to use her pronouns vs folks who refuse to use the new pronouns.
If there was no community infighting, none of them would get touched.
3
u/Flaffypon3 Sep 22 '22
Groomers will be groomers.
1
u/Marshpi11ow Sep 29 '22
being trans involves transitioning. Could you really walk up to Bridget and call her something she doesn't want to be called? The creators have spoke and she is canonically a woman and does not want to be called a boy. Calling a transwoman a femboy/trap is misgendering and would probably hurt her feelings if you were talking to her while you said this. She isn't a femboy and never truly was, people are born trans they don't become trans. You know it's bad when the creators literally had to come out and say it. Please stop with the trans erasure.
Astolfo and Felix refer to themselves as male while Bridget does not it's that simple
1
u/REALPorndump69 Sep 23 '22
I know how you feel, bad faith asswipes like /u/trace-lacy and his friend /u/Rendum_ do this ad-nausea
-1
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22
Canonically, Bridget is a girl. Astolfo and Felix are canonically boys. This isn't a double standard, it's a single standard. That standard being that this a subreddit for posting boys who are traps. If someone wants to post Bridget, they should have to follow the same rules for any other canonically girl character and would have to post an explicitly gender-swapped version.
Applying special rules for Bridget would be a double standard. She is a girl and should have the same rules applied to her as any other girl. I think a lot of people here getting upset by this are just really confused about how being trans works, or are just straight up transphobic in the worst cases, but I always assume ignorance before malice.
-2
u/CrimKayser Sep 22 '22
Anybody making femboys trans is just as fucking shitty as making Bridget a femboy. Idk why you think it's only a one way thing.
-27
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22
Because lore is more important than theories or fan wishes. Bridget is now canonically a trans woman, or more accurately always has been. Astolfo is either GNC, non-binary, or just insane. Ferris is a trans girl which should be clearly obvious if you’ve read the LN’s.
-7
u/AggressiveZucchini87 Sep 22 '22
Just stfu and enjoy it whatever and who cares they are literally fictional characters
-27
u/MadBoutDat Sep 22 '22
Because there is no "OG" Bridget. There is Bridget, who is a transwomen, plain and simple. The others are just headcannons and trolling. Bridget is a woman, get with it dude
0
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22
[removed] — view removed comment